Maintaining the policy rate
The average CPI for the year 2024-25 was calculated by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) at 4.61 percent — lower than the projected increase next fiscal year.
Core inflation declined to 7.3 percent last month (May), the lowest since May 2024. But in April 2025 core inflation was 0.1 percent higher than in May — at 7.4 percent — that may have been the basis for the MPS to refer to 'persistence in core inflation' though this so-called persistence was not evident in data from January to March 2025: 7.8 percent in January, 7.8 percent in February and 8.2 percent in March.
The MPS noted that real interest rate remains adequately positive to stabilise inflation; however, if CPI had been used as a yardstick to adjust the discount rate (as it was during 2019 to 2022) then it should have been raised by 25 to 50 basis points and if core inflation was used as a yardstick then it could have been reduced by 25 basis points.
This lends credence to the widely-held belief that the International Monetary Fund (IMF) did not approve any adjustment in the policy rate at this time — a decision that is inexplicable, given that the MPC met on 16 June (Monday) while a hike in domestic prices of oil and products was announced a day earlier (effective Monday) due to the rise in the international oil prices as a consequence of the ongoing Israel-Iran conflict and yet the MPS reads 'energy prices continued to remain lower than last year, mainly reflecting the impact of moderation in global oil prices' — an observation that does not justify the policy rate remaining unchanged from 16 June onwards.
The influence of the IMF on the MPS is evident from its contention that 'economic growth is picking up gradually and is projected to gain further traction next year, supported by the still unfolding impact of earlier policy rate cuts,' which mirrors the IMF statement in the first review documents uploaded a month ago notably, 'the MPC's decision to hold the policy rate in their March 10 meeting was appropriate, allowing time for past rate cuts to feed through to the economy.'
This growth of 2.7 percent in the outgoing year belies two macroeconomic indicators: (i) the negativity suffered by the large-scale manufacturing sector rose from negative 0.22 percent July-March 2023-24 to negative 1.47 percent in the corresponding period 2024-25 as per data uploaded by the Finance Division; and (ii) agriculture crops underperformed; however, PBS upped the livestock growth which faces challenges in terms of collecting accurate data (comprising a little over 14 percent of agriculture's total 24 percent contribution to GDP) and services again not credibly accounted for, given that it constitutes mainly wholesale and retail trade which mainly operates outside the legal economy.
The MPS further notes that growth accelerated to 3.9 percent during the second half of 2024-25 compared to 1.4 percent in the first half, which was as per MPC expectations. However, there is little evidence of this growth spurt in the second half of this year.
Keeping the policy rate unchanged may have repercussions on yet to be approved by parliament budget 2025-26, given that the 738.677 billion-rupee lower mark-up budgeted for next fiscal year from the revised estimates of the outgoing year (in spite of a massive rise in bank borrowing to the tune of 3.438 trillion rupees) may adversely impact the budget balance sheet.
The MPS rightly noted two major positive macroeconomic outcomes: the completion of the first IMF review which led to a disbursement of one billion dollars that strengthened foreign exchange reserves (which remain largely sourced to debt); and primary surplus of 2.2 percent of GDP in the current year (a Fund condition that has led to an increased reliance on incurring debt/debt equity) budgeted at 2.4 percent in 2025-26, which will have to be reassessed if the discount rate is not lowered during the year though here the MPS has noted that this would reflect 'the evolving geopolitical situation in the Middle East and some ease in the US-China trade relations.'
The SBP is tasked by the IMF to achieve what the Fund has noted in the first review: 'changes to central bank communication, particularly greater clarity on the MPC's assessment of the current and desired policy stance, have been welcome and should continue to help the public better understand the MPC's reaction function to incoming data, and guide expectations between meetings'. This can only be described as work in progress at this point in time.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
36 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
Business confidence: Fragile faith
'...inflation expectations increased slightly for consumers but declined for businesses in the latest sentiment surveys…' reads an excerpt from the central bank's July 30, 2025, Monetary Policy Statement. 'Supported by easing financial conditions, positive business sentiments and a gradually strengthening macroeconomic environment, real GDP growth is projected to rise to 3.25 – 4.25 percent this year….', reads another. It would have been good — if it were true. SBP's own Business Confidence Survey shows inflation expectations among businesses hitting two of their highest readings in recent years in the last two survey rounds. Yet this is precisely where the central bank saw a 'decline' worth highlighting. And it's not as if the SBP was teeing up a rate cut to make the framing at least politically convenient — it wasn't. July 2025 Business Confidence Index (BCI) slipped to its lowest since December 2024. Calling business sentiment 'positive' is technically accurate — in a diffusion index, anything above 50 counts — but the trend is hardly reassuring. The BCI has fallen for two consecutive months, only the third such losing streak in the past 30 months, and the direction of travel is unmistakably downward. The Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI), a key sub-component of the BCI — saw its steepest-ever month-on-month drop, plunging 4.8 percentage points. At a six-month low in July 2025, the PMI reflects weakening across the board: past six months' production, headcount, order books, and raw material purchases all lost ground. Industry capacity utilization has barely budged over the past year, which is still more than 600 basis points below where it stood at the start of 2024. The lackluster LSM growth numbers tell the same story, matching the subdued tone of business sentiment. Looking ahead, there isn't much for businesses to cheer. Expected demand for credit over the next six months is at a six-month low, while hiring plans aren't exactly inspiring. In manufacturing, sentiment on the rupee-dollar parity has slumped to its weakest since September 2023. Yes, the macro indicators have improved, and some high-frequency data suggest a modest recovery. But that has yet to translate into a sustained lift in business sentiment — something official communication would do well to acknowledge.
Business Recorder
36 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
S&P 500, Nasdaq at record highs as inflation rises moderately
NEW YORK: Wall Street's main indexes rose on Tuesday, with the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq at record highs after data showed inflation rose broadly in line with expectations in July, bolstering expectations that the Federal Reserve could lower interest rates next month. A Labor Department report showed that the Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose by an expected 0.2% on a monthly basis in July, while annual inflation came in slightly below forecasts, drawing calls from President Donald Trump to lower interest rates. However, there was also some caution, as the data suggested that underlying inflation rose by its fastest pace in six months in July as markets look for signs that tariffs and trade uncertainty were filtering into prices. Yields on shorter-dated Treasury bonds - a reflection of interest rate expectations - slipped and interest rate futures showed traders are giving an 88.8% chance that the Fed could lower interest rates by about 25 basis points in September. 'This is still early innings of this process and just as the Fed will be beginning to cut rates in the autumn, that's when the inflation data will probably start to be registering some of these more direct tariff price increases and it's going to complicate the rate-cutting decision,' said John Velis, a macro strategist at BNY. The data also comes at a time when there are growing concerns over the quality of economic data, weeks after Trump fired the head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics following downward revisions to previous months' nonfarm payrolls counts. At 12:00 p.m. ET, the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 465.62 points, or 1.06%, to 44,440.71, the S&P 500 gained 55.29 points, or 0.87%, to 6,428.74 and the Nasdaq Composite advanced 212.21 points, or 0.99%, to 21,597.61. Nine of the 11 S&P 500 sectors were higher, with communication services in the lead after a 1.7% rise. Alphabet rose 1.2% as Perplexity made a $34.5 billion cash offer to buy the company's Chrome browser. Further providing some relief, US and China extended their tariff truce until November 10, staving off triple-digit duties on each other's goods. US stocks have rallied in recent weeks, putting the benchmark S&P 500 on track for its first record high close in nearly two weeks on the back of strong tech earnings, easing trade tensions and rate cut expectations. Reflecting the confidence, data from BofA Global Research showed that inflows into US stocks last week were the largest in two years. Markets are monitoring developments around Trump's nominee E.J. Antoni to the Bureau of Labor Statistics commissioner post and potential candidates for the Fed's top job. Meanwhile, the Russell 2000 index, tracking small-cap companies, also advanced 2.1% to hit a two-week high. An index tracking airline stocks surged 7.9%, putting it on track for its biggest one-day rise in over a month after data showed air fares rose 4% in July. Cardinal Health dropped 7% after the drug distributor said it will buy healthcare management firm Solaris for $1.9 billion. Advancing issues outnumbered decliners by a 3.31-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and by a 2.3-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 20 new 52-week highs and 11 new lows, while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 70 new highs and 75 new lows.
Business Recorder
36 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
India's stock benchmarks inch lower
MUMBAI: Indian equity benchmarks inched lower on Tuesday as a drop in financials weighed ahead of key US and domestic inflation readings. The Nifty 50 fell 0.4% to 24,487.4 points and the BSE Sensex shed 0.46% to 80,235.59. Investors await US CPI data due later in the day which will guide the Federal Reserve's rate-cut path. Lower US rates typically boost the appeal of emerging market equities, including India, as yields on US Treasuries fall. Eight of the 16 major sectors logged gains. The broader small-caps were flat, while mid-caps slipped 0.3%. Financials, which gained 0.9% in the previous session, reversed course and fell 1% on Tuesday. IT rose 0.4%, on the back of a US-China tariff truce extension that averts triple-digit duties that is expected to shield US growth, curb inflation risks, and support corporate discretionary spending, including on technology. Pharma advanced 0.7%, buoyed by strong results from Abbott India and Alkem Laboratories. The sector, like IT, counts the US as a key market. Investors also await India's July retail inflation data, due after market hours, with a Reuters poll forecasting an eight-year low of 1.76% on cooling food prices. The modest sized drop in benchmark indexes 'reflects reluctance among investors to make significant moves ahead of key inflation data, while uncertainty also lingers with a second round of tariff hikes scheduled later this month,' said Devarsh Vakil, head of prime research at HDFC Securities. Among stocks, Marksans Pharma and Astral fell 11.1% and 8.1% after reporting weaker quarterly profits.
