Are We Choosing Which Lives Deserve To Be Born? The Quiet Genocide
Advancements in prenatal screening have enabled early detection of genetic conditions like Down syndrome. But in some parts of the world, this progress has quietly led to the near-eradication of individuals with the condition — long before birth.
In Iceland, around 85% of expectant mothers undergo first-trimester genetic screening. Nearly 100% of those who receive a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome choose to terminate the pregnancy. Only two or three babies with the condition are born there each year.
Denmark reports a termination rate of over 95%. In France, it's around 77%. These numbers have sparked concern among ethicists and disability advocates, who warn of a troubling cultural shift: one that frames the existence of disability as undesirable — and preventable.
The American Context
In the United States, where prenatal screening is optional and unstandardized, the termination rate after a Down syndrome diagnosis ranges from 60% to 90%, depending on geography, access to care, and socioeconomic status.
Despite these figures, advocacy groups like the National Down Syndrome Society (NDSS) offer a different perspective. According to their 2022 Fact Sheet, life expectancy for individuals with Down syndrome has risen from 25 years in 1983 to more than 60 years today. People with the condition increasingly live independent lives, attend school, hold jobs, and contribute meaningfully to their communities.
'Contemporary Eugenics' and the Role of NIPT
The AMA Journal of Ethics has raised a pressing question: Are today's prenatal screening practices — particularly non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT) — a modern form of eugenics?
Unlike the coercive eugenics of the 20th century, contemporary eugenics doesn't require state enforcement. It operates subtly through individual decisions, medical norms, and cultural assumptions about what kinds of lives are 'worth living.' NIPT, which detects chromosomal conditions like Down syndrome as early as 10 weeks, may give the illusion of 'informed choice' while implicitly devaluing disability.
'Even making screening available for Down syndrome… is already, by definition, suggesting that they are not valued reproductive outcomes,' the article states.
The concern, as the authors put it, is that society may be shrinking the definition of 'normal' while expanding the definition of 'abnormal' — a shift driven not by malice, but by medicine, convenience, and silence.
Frank Stephens: A Voice for the Valued
That silence was broken in a viral speech by disability advocate Frank Stephens, who has Down syndrome and testified before Congress:
'I would like to make three points. First, we are a medical gift to society — a blueprint for medical research into cancer, Alzheimer's, and immune system disorders.
'Second, we are an unusually powerful source of happiness. A Harvard-based study found that people with Down syndrome, as well as their parents and siblings, are happier than society at large. Surely happiness is worth something.
'Finally, we are the canary in the eugenics coal mine. We are giving the world a chance to think about the ethics of choosing which humans get a chance at life.'
His testimony reframes the conversation: not just about disability, but about who gets counted as human — and what it means when entire categories of people begin to disappear.
A Local Voice of Compassion
Monty Bennett, a Dallas-based hotelier and philanthropist, is also the Publisher of The Dallas Express. But for Bennett, advocacy on behalf of children with disabilities is not just professional — it's personal.
As the father of a special needs child, Bennett has witnessed both the challenges and the beauty of raising a child the world doesn't always understand. His experience has shaped his lifelong commitment to supporting and defending the value of every human life.
'Every life has a divine purpose, regardless of what chromosomes they carry,' Bennett told The Dallas Express. 'As the father of a special needs child, I've seen the challenges — and the incredible joy — that come with raising someone the world often overlooks. It breaks my heart to think of how many lives — full of love, dignity and joy — are quietly erased before they ever get a chance.
'Our son is an incredible blessing,' he added. 'If society measured value not by perfection but by compassion, children like him would be at the top of every list.'
Bennett has long supported the development of early childhood programs that serve children with Down syndrome and other developmental disabilities. His philanthropy reflects a broader conviction — that children born with special needs deserve not just protection, but opportunities to thrive in a world that too often doubts their worth.
Reframing the Future
Disability rights advocates say the real danger isn't just the test — it's the unspoken cultural script that surrounds it. Campaigns like 'Don't Screen Us Out' warn that prenatal screening, especially when not accompanied by balanced counseling, becomes a method of informal eugenics.
Choice, they argue, is only meaningful when society embraces the full spectrum of life — and supports parents, no matter the diagnosis.
As prenatal technology advances, we're forced to reckon with what it reveals about us: Are we simply diagnosing? Or are we deciding who gets to be born?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
9 Foods You Should Never Store on the Bottom Shelf of Your Fridge
The bottom shelf of the fridge is best reserved for raw meats and poultry, as it's the coldest area and prevents juices from contaminating other foods. Ready-to-eat items like leftovers, cooked grains, hard-boiled eggs, and prepared foods should never go on the bottom shelf, where they're more likely to be exposed to harmful bacteria. Delicate foods such as herbs, berries, baked goods, and condiments also don't belong on the bottom shelf, as the extra cold can damage texture and flavor, and increase spoilage refrigerator is more than just a wide vessel to keep food cold. Sure, it's a chilly storage unit for everything from sticks of butter to home-cooked leftovers, but not all parts of the fridge are equal. 'The fridge is one of the most important food safety storage areas that we often use incorrectly as a society,' says Rachel Gargano, MS, RD, CSSD, CBS. 'There is such nuance in how we place items in the fridge, and most people aren't aware of the methods that will help keep food the safest.' Related: We Asked a Beef Expert to Name the Best Cut of Steak—Here's What They Said A fridge is divided into distinct sections with unique purposes: The fridge door and its designated shelving is convenient, but fluctuates in temperature thanks to all the opening, the crisper is designed to keep produce crisp, and the shelves in the fridge should also be organized with function in mind. Because heat rises, the top shelf of the refrigerator is warmer than the lower portions. 'This shelf should be reserved for foods that are pre-cooked or ready-to-eat, or that do not need to be reheated at high temperatures,' explains Gargano. Read on for the items that you should never store on the bottom shelf of your fridge, because they're more suited for a spot up Nicole Bianchini, MS, RD, IFNCP, RYT, a functional dietitian and founder of Body to Soul Health Rachel Gargano, MS, RD, CSSD, CBS, a California-based registered dietitian with almost 20 years of experience'The top shelf is the safest area in the fridge since nothing can leak from above, so anything that has already been cooked should be kept there, such as leftovers,' says Jennifer Nicole Bianchini, RDN. 'Additionally, since the top shelf is usually the most visible spot, you will be less likely to forget to eat your prepped meals and leftovers.' Hard-boiled eggs shouldn't be stored with raw eggs, as the shells can cross-contaminate the cooked eggs. Peeled and unpeeled eggs stay fresh for up to a week on the top shelf of the fridge (as opposed to the bottom) and are an easy grab-and-go snack. If you batch cook grains for meal prep, or just have a side of rice or pasta leftover, place it on the top shelf instead of the bottom. 'Foods that are already cooked or meal prepped have a higher risk of becoming contaminated, so when you store them on the top shelf of the fridge, they are protected from raw juices or bacteria that can leak from items such as raw meats,' says Bianchini. 'Fully cooked meats, such as bacon or sausage, can be stored on the top,' Gargano says. Keep the uncooked meats lower down. 'Raw meats and poultry should be kept cold and away from other foods, on the bottom shelf. We don't want raw meat juices dripping into foods we won't be cooking,' she adds. Related: This Cheese Won Trader Joe's Customer Choice Awards 2 Years in a Row—and It's Totally Worth the Hype Arrange fresh herbs like a bouquet in a small glass or jar of water, Bianchini suggests. These will keep well on the top shelf of the fridge. Just refresh the water every other day and trim the stems of the herbs, if needed. 'Baked goods that need refrigeration, like pies or tortillas, belong on the top shelf,' Gargano says. Again, this prevents any cross-contamination, and these treats don't need to be as cold as other items. Berries shouldn't be in the coldest area of the fridge! Ideally, they'll be on the middle or top shelf, in a breathable container with a paper towel or thin cloth to catch any extra moisture at the bottom. Salad kits, snack packs, supermarket sushi, and other ready-to-eat prepared foods belong on the top shelf along with the leftovers. Related: The 10 Healthiest Superfoods Right Now, According to Over 870 Registered Dietitians Any condiments that don't fit on the fridge door can be on the top shelf of the fridge, particularly items that don't necessarily require refrigeration but you prefer to store them in the cold. These items can include nut and seed butters, tahini, vinegars, and more. Read the original article on Real Simple
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
PFAS exposure before birth could put your teen at risk for high blood pressure, study finds
Get inspired by a weekly roundup on living well, made simple. Sign up for CNN's Life, But Better newsletter for information and tools designed to improve your well-being. Prenatal exposure to a class of dangerous, widely used chemicals could be linked to your child having high blood pressure as a teen, according to a new study. Perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS — sometimes called 'forever chemicals' because they don't fully break down in the environment — are a class of about 15,000 human-made chemicals linked to cancers, endocrine-related conditions and developmental problems in children. New data shows the synthetic compounds could also be linked to a teen's risk of developing cardiovascular disease later in life, according to the study published Thursday in the Journal of the American Heart Association. Researchers looked at data from 1,094 children over an average of 12 years. The study team compared measurements of eight types of PFAS chemicals in maternal plasma samples 24 to 72 hours after birth and the children's blood pressure from medical records, according to the study. The kids who were exposed to higher levels of PFAS chemicals in utero were more likely to have higher blood pressure in childhood and adolescence, the research found. The connection was particularly strong in adolescents, male children and Black children, said senior study author Dr. Mingyu Zhang, assistant professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. The study is observational, meaning that while it shows associations, it cannot prove that PFAS exposure is the cause of the elevated blood pressure, Zhang said. While researchers did adjust for other factors that could be at play, there could be other elements driving the connection between PFAS and blood pressure, he added. That said, the results are strong because this study is one of the largest and most diverse while also using rigorous methods, said Dr. Carmen Marsit, Rollins Distinguished Professor of Research at Emory University's Rollins School of Public Health in Atlanta. He was not involved in the research. The topic is important to investigate because if a child has high blood pressure, they are more likely to also have higher blood pressure later on, Zhang said. And that is a risk factor for cardiovascular disease, the No. 1 cause of death in the United States. The largest effects were shown in adolescents who were exposed to a mixture of different PFAS chemicals during pregnancy compared with those who were not, which implies that there may be a synergistic impact on cardiometabolic health, Marsit said. 'Most children will be exposed to multiple different PFAS chemicals, so this is worrisome,' he said. The fact that adolescence is the age when prenatal exposure to PFAS is most linked with higher blood pressure suggests that some of the PFAS chemicals could take a long period of time to show their impacts, Marsit said. A long latency of the effects would mean that people don't just need to worry about reducing exposures, but interventions also need to be developed to prevent the health outcomes in people who were exposed earlier, he added. Not only are PFAS forever chemicals –– they also are everywhere chemicals. Data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey shows that this class of chemicals can be found in nearly every person in the United States, Marsit said in a previous CNN story. There are things you can do to reduce your exposure, however, he added. Major sources of exposure include food, water, and waterproof or stain-resistant items, Marsit said. Helpful steps include drinking filtered water –– using filters like those listed by the Environmental Working Group –– out of metal or glass containers, he said. Plastics contain PFAS and other toxic chemicals, Marsit said. A focus on fresh food can also help, as packaging for foods are often coated in PFAS chemicals, he added. And avoid using nonstick cookware, opting instead for metal, cast-iron or ceramic pots and pans, he said. Dusting, vacuuming, and washing your hands before eating or drinking can also reduce PFAS exposure, Marsit said. Healthy lifestyle choices can reduce the risk of high blood pressure for children who have been exposed to PFAS, Zhang said. 'These include maintaining a healthy weight, eating a balanced diet, reducing salt intake, and encouraging physical activity,' he added. But ultimately, an individual cannot solve PFAS exposure alone, Zhang said. 'We also need policy-level actions to limit and phase out PFAS use in products and industry, and to strengthen monitoring and regulation of PFAS in water systems,' he added.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Ex-Harvard professor fired after refusing COVID shot named to CDC vaccine panel
A former Harvard University professor who said he was fired over his refusal to be vaccinated against COVID-19 has been named to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention advisory panel on vaccines. Martin Kulldorff, a biostatistician and epidemiologist, published an opinion piece last year detailing how he was let go by Mass General Brigham, and then consequently from his Harvard faculty position, after he 'objected both publicly and privately to the COVID vaccine mandates.' Kulldorff is among eight new members named by U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, after Kennedy this week abruptly purged all 17 members appointed during the Biden administration. Kennedy characterized the decision to start over with new members as one that would restore public trust in vaccines. The new appointees include individuals who have criticized vaccines and spread misinformation, according to the Associated Press. 'Without removing the current members, the current Trump administration would not have been able to appoint a majority of new members until 2028,' he wrote in a Wall Street Journal opinion piece published Monday. 'A clean sweep is needed to reestablish public confidence in vaccine science.' Read more: Mass. doctor ousted by RFK Jr. as part of purge to CDC vaccine advisory committee Before he announced his new panel picks this week, Kennedy said he would appoint credentialed scientists, 'not anti-vaxxers.' Doctors' groups and public health organizations have largely decried the move to oust 17 members ahead of their term ends. The list of all eight new appointees can be found here. Kulldorff co-authored the controversial Great Barrington Declaration in 2020, an open letter penned with two other public health experts in response to the COVID pandemic that advocated for lifting lockdowns for young and healthy people so heard immunity could develop. In 2021, Kulldorff posted on X that 'thinking that everyone must be vaccinated is as scientifically flawed as thinking that nobody should.' 'COVID vaccines are important for older high-risk people and their care-takers,' he wrote. 'Those with prior natural infection do not need it. Nor children.' The second Trump administration in its vaccine planning has mirrored Kulldorff's opinions: Last month, the FDA announced new COVID shots would no longer be approved for healthy pregnant adults and healthy children. According to his biography, Kulldorff is currently a senior scholar at the Brownstone Institute and a fellow at the Academy for Science and Freedom. He has previously served on scientific advisory committees to the Food and Drug Administration and CDC. Kulldorff did not immediately return a request for comment. Mass. doctor ousted by RFK Jr. as part of purge to CDC vaccine advisory committee Trump cuts threaten 'irreplaceable' Harvard stockpile of human feces, urine A Mass. man bought an illegal depressant online and took his life. The seller will go to prison Boston OD deaths plummeted by 38% last year, lowest in a decade Read the original article on MassLive.
