S Shankar Faces Backlash For Comparing Velpari To Avatar And Game of Thrones
Filmmaker S Shankar faces criticism after claiming his project Velpari could match Avatar and Game of Thrones. Critics cite his recent flops, Game Changer and Indian 2.
Filmmaker S Shankar has found himself at the centre of social media criticism after making bold statements about his upcoming project titled Velpari. The director claimed that the film, an adaptation of the historical Tamil novel, has the potential to match the global scale and technological achievements of international hits like Avatar and Game of Thrones.
Speaking at a recent event, Shankar said, 'Enthiran (2010 film with superstar Rajinikanth) was my previous dream project. Now, Velpari is my dream film. It has the scope to introduce new technologies like Game of Thrones and Avatar. Velpari has the potential to become the pride of Tamil cinema and Indian cinema. It can achieve global recognition. Hope the dream comes true."
'Enthiran was my Previous Dream project, now #Velpari is my dream film🤞. It scope to introduce new technologies. Like GameOfThrones & Avatar, Velparu has all scope to become our Pride Indian-Tamil film❤️🔥. Hope Dream comes true"– #Shankar at today's event pic.twitter.com/Hr1v2TWk0h — AmuthaBharathi (@CinemaWithAB) July 11, 2025
However, the director's grand vision has sparked skepticism online, especially given the poor performance of his recent films. His last two releases, Game Changer and Indian 2, failed to meet expectations, both at the box office and among critics.
Game Changer, starring Ram Charan, was reportedly made on a massive budget of Rs 400 crore but managed to earn only Rs 186 crore worldwide. Similarly, Indian 2, produced on a budget of Rs 250 crore, grossed about Rs 150 crore globally. Both projects were widely considered commercial disappointments.
Following his comments about Velpari, several users on social media platforms expressed frustration, accusing Shankar of focusing too much on high budgets and flashy technology, while ignoring storytelling and financial accountability.
One user wrote, 'Producer will have to beg after this film… Sir, at least try to do good films in a limited budget. You waste too much money! Who spent 75 crore for a song only?" Others called for him to scale down his productions or even suggested retirement.
Shankar has yet to respond to the backlash, but with no confirmed producer yet attached to Velpari, questions remain about whether the ambitious project will move forward.
First Published:
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Pink Villa
13 minutes ago
- Pink Villa
Box Office: Sitaare Zameen Par continues with healthy trend; Aamir Khan starrer collects Rs 155 crore in 24 days
The Aamir Khan-led Sitaare Zameen Par is continuing with its healthy run at the box office in India, as the film has collected Rs 5.75 crore in its fourth weekend, taking the total nett collections to Rs 155 crore. The social dramedy scored Rs 1.00 crore on 4th Friday, followed by a jump to Rs 2.25 crore and Rs 2.50 crore respectively on 4th Saturday and 4th Sunday. The RS Prassana directorial is continuing to get numbers in the urban markets, and is now nearing te end of its run. The lifetime collections of Sitaare Zameen Par could now fall in the range of Rs 165 crore to Rs 170 crore, which is more or less in the same range as Raid 2 and Housefull 5. One must note that, given the controlled budget and a good theatrical trend, Sitaare Zameen Par has emerged a hit venture at the box office. The verdict is largely driven by the weekend-to-weekend trajectory of this Aamir Khan starrer, as the film is getting patronage from the family audience on every Saturday and Sunday since its release. The box office is in a much better shape now as mid-range films have started to do well, and cinema is no longer a medium for just the tentpole spectacles. A finish in the north of Rs 200 crore would have been sweeter for Sitaare Zameen Par, but the drop on the first Monday had more or less put curtains on the dreams of a double century in India. Nonetheless, this is a good result for the Aamir Khan starrer, and a much-needed HIT for the actor, bringing him back in the business. Sitaare Zameen Par Day Wise Box Office Collection Week One: Rs 87.50 crore Week Two: Rs 44.50 crore Week Three: Rs 17.25 crore 4th Friday: Rs 1.00 crore 4th Saturday: Rs 2.25 crore 4th Sunday: Rs 2.50 crore Total: Rs 155 crore
Mint
22 minutes ago
- Mint
Nine years after theatrical release, Emilia Clarke's ‘Me Before You' climbs Prime Video charts
'Me Before You', a romantic drama starring 'Game of Thrones' actor Emilia Clarke, which once stirred strong reactions, is now gaining newfound popularity on Amazon Prime Video. The 2016 film, which also stars Sam Claflin, has surged into Prime Video's global Top 10 rankings nearly a decade after its theatrical release. Directed by Thea Sharrock, the film was adapted from Jojo Moyes' bestselling novel. It follows Louisa Clark, a quirky caretaker who develops a complex relationship with Will Traynor, a wealthy man left paralysed after an accident. Although the movie was commercially successful during its initial run, a Screen Rant report said it drew significant backlash for its depiction of disability and portrayal of assisted suicide or euthanasia. Another report in Collider cited FlixPatrol data showing 'Me Before You' has recently climbed the Prime Video Top 10 lists in several countries, including Argentina, Egypt, Guatemala, Mexico and the United States. On July 5, the film reached its highest average international ranking, sitting at 5.4 across 13 countries. Earlier this year, it had entered the US Top 10, marking a resurgence in English-speaking markets, the Screen Rant report added. When the movie, which also stars Janet McTeer and Joanna Lumley, was released in 2016, it grossed $208.4 million worldwide against a modest $20 million budget: a 10.4x return on investment. It outperformed titles like 'Arrival', 'The BFG' and 'Bridget Jones's Baby', becoming the 42nd highest-grossing movie of the year. The Collider report stated that while audiences gave the film a 73% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, critics were less favorable, with a 54% score. Much of the criticism centered around the film's messaging and handling of sensitive themes, particularly regarding the protagonist's decision to pursue assisted suicide. Emilia Clarke's role as Daenerys Targaryen in HBO's 'Game of Thrones' catapulted her to fame. Since the series ended in 2019, Clarke has taken on a variety of roles, from the romantic holiday film 'Last Christmas' to her recent appearance in Marvel's 'Secret Invasion'. In spite of mixed reception for some projects, Clarke's role in 'Me Before You' remains one of her most emotionally resonant performances ever. Why was 'Me Before You' controversial? The film was criticised for promoting ableist ideas and for its portrayal of assisted suicide (euthanasia) as a romantic act, which drew backlash from disability rights activists. Is 'Me Before You' based on a true story? No. The film is a fictional adaptation of Jojo Moyes' 2012 bestselling novel of the same name. Where can you watch 'Me Before You' now? 'Me Before You' is currently available to stream on Prime Video.
Economic Times
35 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Housefull 5 OTT release: When and Where to watch Akshay Kumar's latest comedy movie online
Synopsis Housefull 5, the latest film in the hit comedy franchise, is set to stream on Amazon Prime Video after its successful theatrical run that began on June 6, 2025. Directed by Tarun Mansukhani, the film takes place on a luxury cruise and follows a chaotic inheritance battle involving three men claiming to be the billionaire heir, Jolly. Known for releasing in two different versions with alternate endings, the film generated buzz for its experimental storytelling and star-studded cast led by Akshay Kumar, Abhishek Bachchan, and Riteish Deshmukh. Housefull 5 Set for OTT Release After Theatrical Success Following its theatrical release on June 6, 2025, Housefull 5—the latest entry in one of Bollywood's most popular comedy franchises—is now preparing for its OTT debut. While an official streaming date has not been confirmed, reports suggest the film may arrive on Amazon Prime Video either by the last week of July or in early August, as per Times of India. The digital release is highly anticipated, given the buzz the film generated for its unique storytelling format and ensemble installment unfolds on a grand cruise liner and opens with billionaire Ranjeet Dobriyal's death from a heart attack, just before the start of his 100th birthday celebration. His passing is kept secret by his son Dev and the board to prevent market panic. Matters escalate when Ranjeet's will reveals that his £69 billion fortune is to be inherited by Jolly, his son from a previous marriage. Complications arise when three different men—Julius (Akshay Kumar), Jalbhushan (Abhishek Bachchan), and Jalabuddin (Riteish Deshmukh)—each claim to be Jolly. All three possess matching birthmarks, making the situation increasingly absurd. What follows is a blend of romantic confusion, mistaken identities, and over-the-top investigations—all layered in the franchise's trademark comedic an unusual move for a mainstream Hindi film, Housefull 5 was released in two separate versions—titled Housefull 5A and Housefull 5B—each with its own climax. This bold narrative experiment was met with enthusiasm, with audiences intrigued by the idea of alternate endings. It added replay value and set the film apart from previous entries in the by Tarun Mansukhani and co-written with Farhad Samji, the film features an extensive cast. Alongside the lead trio, the ensemble includes Jacqueline Fernandez, Sonam Bajwa, Nargis Fakhri, Sanjay Dutt, Jackie Shroff, Nana Patekar, Mithun Chakraborty, Chitrangda Singh, Fardeen Khan, Johnny Lever, Shreyas Talpade, Archana Puran Singh, Chunky Panday, Dino Morea, and others, all contributing to the film's chaotic its theatrical release, Housefull 5 had already secured Rs 135 crore from non-theatrical deals, including Rs 75 crore for its digital rights. Its global box office collection of Rs 288.58 crore ensured the film not only recovered costs but emerged as a commercial hit. With the film now gearing up for its OTT release, Amazon Prime Video is set to host this comedy spectacle, offering viewers another chance to board the cruise of 5 has been produced by Sajid Nadiadwala, Firuzi Khan, and Warda Nadiadwala under the Nadiadwala Grandson Entertainment banner.
