With the pvt sector indifferent to R&D, India risks missing the deep-tech bus, or getting locked out
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com .)
In the 2000s, China recognised that technological dependence was a strategic liability because it relied on US chips, Western operating systems and telecom infra. This triggered a strategy rooted in constructive paranoia, and the launch of mission-driven policies:This aimed to make China an 'innovation-oriented nation'.It targeted dominance in 10 hi-tech sectors.This programme was launched to reverse brain drain, and attract global researchers. It has received massive state support through guidance funds, industrial subsidies and tech-focused SOEs.China also doubled down on patenting, domestic standards and end-to-end industrial ecosystems, from semiconductors to green energy. R&D investment surged past 2.5% of GDP, with a rapidly rising share from the private sector. Today, China leads the world in AI patents, EV production, solar capacity and quantum publications.Meanwhile, India faces similar vulnerabilities China faced 25 years ago: imported chips, weak indigenous IP, low- tech exports and a fragmented research base. And the response has been uneven.GoI has launched Anusandhan National Research Foundation (ANRF), a ₹1 lakh cr R&D fund, expanded PLI schemes, and invested in semiconductors, space tech, clean energy and quantum. For the first time, the government is adopting a full-spectrum approach to funding research and innovation across all technology readiness levels (TRLs).While ANRF will focus on early-stage discovery (TRLs 1-3) and improve ease of doing science with DST, a soon-to-be-finalised ₹1 lakh cr R&D fund should drive private investment in mid-to-late-stage innovation (TRLs 4-9) through long-term, near-zero-interest loans. This fund shifts focus from grants to outcome-linked support for developing commercially viable tech. While the need for greater funding in basic research is acknowledged, GoI is laying the essential groundwork to build a self-sustaining R&D ecosystem.Yet, the private sector remains risk-averse, contributing barely a third of national R&D. India's R&D-to-GDP ratio remains stuck below 0.7%, with little traction in patenting or deep-tech commercialisation. The innovation pipeline is still thin.Ex-Intel CEO Andrew Grove made the line, 'Let's be paranoid' - with its philosophy of the importance of proactive preparedness for unexpected changes and strategic inflection points - famous. And, yet, even Intel wasn't paranoid enough. It missed the AI inflection point, and today Nvidia has overtaken it in valuation, strategic relevance and tech leadership.A similar inversion is unfolding between China and the US, driven by who innovates faster and scales deeper. Unfortunately, while GoI is paranoid, India's private sector isn't.In 2024, Foundation for Advancing Science & Technology (FAST) published a comparative study, 'State of Industry R&D in India', of 59 Indian and 60 global firms across six key sectors: pharma, software, defence, chemicals, automobiles, and energy. The study, conducted between FY16 and FY23, reveals a persistent input-output gap. Global firms, on average, reported 2.9x R&D intensity (spend as % of revenue), 3.7x share of PhD-qualified employees, and 2.9x R&D spending as share of profits than Indian firms.On output indicators, the disparity is starker. Global firms generated 13.1x patents and 1.3x scientific publications per billion dollars of revenue compared to their Indian counterparts.The European Commission recently released the EU Industrial R&D Investment Scoreboard 2024. It presents data on the top global 2,000 companies investing in R&D. They invested ₹1,257.7 bn in R&D in 2023. Indian firms accounted for ₹5.5 bn, or about 0.4%, of global industrial R&D investment, with only 15 companies featuring among the world's top 2,000 R&D spenders.This places India behind not only advanced economies like the US (₹531.8 bn, 681 firms) and China (₹215.8 bn, 524 firms), but also innovation-intensive small economies such as South Korea (₹42.5 bn, 40 firms), Taiwan (₹24.7 bn, 55 firms), and Ireland (₹10.4 bn, 24 firms).Sustained long-term economic growth is driven by investments in knowledge and innovation. India's failure to internalise this principle within its industrial ecosystem suggests presence of constraints: low absorptive capacity, weak industry-academia linkages, and limited interest from the private sector in high-risk R&D.Persistent underrepresentation of Indian firms in global innovation rankings reflects a missing industrial policy focus on Schumpeterian creative destruction, without which India risks being confined to low-value segments of GVCs.In Liu Cixin's 2008 science fiction novel, The Three-Body Problem, the world gets paralysed by the sudden collapse of scientific progress. Stagnation is the real nightmare. It's not fiction any more. For India, the risk isn't that we fail. It's that we're too comfortable even to try. Innovation can't be outsourced.If there's a gap between what scientists are doing and what businesses need, then companies must invest in R&D, collaborate with academia, and shape research. If the private sector stays disengaged, we'll keep watching others lead. We just aren't paranoid enough.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Capricorn Horoscope Today, June 11th, 2025
Written By : Chirag Daruwalla GaneshaGrace Last Updated: June 11, 2025, 06:55 IST Capricorn Horoscope Today: Astrological predictions by Chirag Daruwalla for makara rashi on June 11th 2025. Capricorn Daily Horoscope Today, 11th June 2025: Ganesha says maintain courage and communication. Improve your routine. Maintain continuity in work and business. Move forward by following the discretion rules and policies. Maintain discipline. Get results with patience and confidence. Present important matters with ease. Maintain harmony. Discussions will be simple and dignified. Avoid superstitions. Be polite. Give up stubbornness. Health will remain normal. Check out your daily horoscope for June 11, 2025 here. Positive: Ganesha says there will be celebrations regarding the achievement of a family member. An incident will happen to you that you would have never imagined. You will feel the presence of some divine power. Negative: Capricorn, it is better not to do any kind of financial transaction today. There may be a mild quarrel due to the issue of ancestral property. Work with discretion and wisdom. Check the land-related documents thoroughly. Business: There will be an improvement in business activities. Most of the work will be done properly. Employed people will remain dedicated to their work. There will be sweetness in relations with officers as well. Love: Ignore small negative things in the house. This will keep the arrangement of the house proper. There will also be sweetness in relations. Health: Health will be excellent. Pain and fatigue can be felt in the legs only due to the pressure of too much work. Swipe Left For Next Video View all Lucky Colour: White Lucky Number: 5 (The author Chirag Daruwalla is the son of Astrologer Bejan Daruwalla). Chirag Daruwalla Chirag Daruwalla, a renowned Indian astrologer with 18+ years of experience, provides expert guidance in career, health, finance, business, and more. He combines Vedic and Western astrology, I-Ching, Tarot, Num... Read More Chirag Daruwalla, a renowned Indian astrologer with 18+ years of experience, provides expert guidance in career, health, finance, business, and more. He combines Vedic and Western astrology, I-Ching, Tarot, Num... Read More News astrology Capricorn Horoscope Today, June 11th, 2025
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Taiwan thinks the unthinkable: resisting China without America
IF TAIWAN CAN resist Chinese invasion forces for a month, then Communist Party leaders in Beijing can be deterred. That calculation has long guided war planners and politicians in Taiwan. The democratically ruled island would need to survive weeks of bombardment, blockade or even amphibious landings by the People's Liberation Army, to give America time to turn up and save the day. Alas, Taiwanese confidence that America will arrive at all is growing weaker by the day. That is reshaping the plans that the island's sitting government, which is determined to resist Chinese aggression, must make for its defence. For years, the island has had to live with a degree of doubt. When President Donald Trump declines to say whether he would risk war with China to save Taiwan, he is following the precedent set by most modern presidents, who used 'strategic ambiguity' to deter rash moves by either side to change the status quo. Under the terms of that uneasy stand-off, China calls Taiwan a province that must one day return to the motherland. The island's leaders deny being part of the People's Republic of China, but stop short of declaring Taiwan a separate country. American ambiguity leaves China's supreme leader, Xi Jinping, wrestling with uncertainties. If Mr Xi wants to avoid conflict with America, he needs to be sure of a quick victory, or must stay his hand. As for leading Taiwanese opposition politicians, they have long seized on that same ambiguity to portray America as an unreliable friend, and counselled accommodation of China to buy peace. What is new is the alarm engendered in Taiwan by Mr Trump's treatment of Ukraine. When Mr Trump scorns Ukraine as a small country that foolishly imagines it can defy a larger neighbour, Taiwanese hear echoes of their own plight. It does not help that Mr Trump has long scoffed at Taiwan's prospects in a fight with China. And if America stays aloof, no other power will take up arms in Taiwan's defence. True, Chinese hopes of a quick victory were shaken by the failure of Russia's own attempt at a lightning conquest of Ukraine in February 2022: a debacle that China has studied minutely. But now Ukraine's long war is forcing Taiwan and friendly governments, including in Europe, to make unprecedented public efforts to prepare the island's 23m people for a crisis lasting far longer than a month, such as a naval blockade. In June The Telegram travelled to Berlin for the Taiwan Trilateral Forum, a meeting of diplomats and analysts from America, Europe and Taiwan. Asked for lessons from Ukraine, a Taiwanese participant replied that his island needs 'to prove to the rest of the world that Taiwan is able to fight for an extended period'. This is as much a political as a military imperative. Taiwan's plan is 'to hold on as long as possible, while China's legitimacy is challenged and the international community has time to help', he added. Speakers described a flurry of studies and war-games in Western capitals, weighing Taiwan's vulnerabilities. Taiwanese firms, notably TSMC, make more than 90% of the world's cutting-edge semiconductors. Even if TSMC foundries are not blown up, the forum heard, a blockade could stop just-in-time imports of specialist gases and chemicals needed to make chips. The meeting, organised by the German Marshall Fund, a Washington-based think-tank, heard of growing seriousness in Taiwan, too. Green groups that clamoured for ageing nuclear power plants to be shut down are more open to arguments about national security and the risks of Taiwan's heavy reliance on imported fossil fuels. Trump administration views were parsed like scripture. There were accounts of reassuring meetings with the defence secretary, Pete Hegseth, and the secretary of state, Marco Rubio. Against that, there were dismaying reports of Britain and Germany being chided by other American officials for sending warships through the Taiwan Strait to uphold the freedom of navigation. Europeans should be focusing on Europe's security, was the message. The new German government risked China's wrath by allowing Jaushieh Joseph Wu, the head of Taiwan's national security council and a former foreign minister, to address the forum in Berlin. Praising Germany's 'courage', Mr Wu pledged that Taiwan will spend more on defence but will 'not be a provocateur', in remarks that German officials allowed to be made public. Speaking a stone's throw from Friedrichstrasse station, a cold war crossing point between East and West Germany, Mr Wu hailed West Berlin's survival as an island of freedom. He described Taiwan's improving civilian resilience, including the stockpiling of food, water, medicines and energy, and 'whole of society' training drills. Taiwan contemplates a harsher, lonelier world Under Tsai Ing-wen, Taiwan's president from 2016-24, such planning was kept secret to avoid alarming the public and foreign investors. The current president, Lai Ching-te, has chaired meetings about resilience and live-streamed them. His hope is to educate a society riven by partisan divisions. Promoting civilian resilience is a diplomatic play, too, allowing friendly powers to help Taiwan without arms sales that would enrage China. Israel and Finland, two countries with advanced civil-defence systems, have both welcomed Taiwanese fact-finding missions. Other Western countries want to learn from Taiwan's expertise in fighting off Chinese cyber-attacks and disinformation campaigns. One step is almost unsayable aloud. Should Taiwan rehearse how to resist occupation by China, striving to be ungovernable after a defeat? Several Taiwanese experts are sceptical. They call such planning defeatist, divisive and panic-inducing. Besides, fears of post-war unrest and resistance on Taiwan will not deter Mr Xi, sceptics argue. Other Taiwanese see no choice. They point to Ukraine's starkest lesson: survival is a long game. Get 360° coverage—from daily headlines to 100 year archives.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
2 hours ago
- First Post
UK, Canada and western allies sanction far-right Israeli ministers for ‘inciting extremist violence'
Five Western countries, including Canada, UK have sanctioned two Israeli ministers over inciting violence against Palestinians, amid growing global criticism of Israel's settlement policies and the ongoing Gaza war. read more The United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Norway have imposed sanctions on two Israeli ministers, accusing them of repeatedly inciting violence against Palestinians. The sanctions target National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, both leaders of far-right parties that support Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's fragile coalition. This move comes amid growing criticism from Israel's Western allies over its settlement policies in the West Bank and the surge in settler violence. The violence has intensified since Hamas' 7 October 2023 attack, which triggered the ongoing war in Gaza. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Support for continued war, Gaza resettlement Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, key figures in Netanyahu's government, strongly support the continuation of the war in Gaza. They have publicly backed what they call the 'voluntary' emigration of Palestinians from Gaza and the re-establishment of Jewish settlements in the territory. Sanctions include asset freezes and travel bans The sanctions could lead to asset freezes and travel bans against both ministers. In a joint statement, the foreign ministers of the five countries said Ben-Gvir and Smotrich 'have incited extremist violence and serious abuses of Palestinian human rights. Extremist rhetoric advocating the forced displacement of Palestinians and the creation of new Israeli settlements is appalling and dangerous.'
