CCP's Appellate Tribunal upholds penalty against telecom operators for non-competitive practices
The commission noted that while incoming call volumes fell by 70% after anti-competitive International Clearing House (ICH) agreement of telecom operators — from 1.9 billion minutes in September 2012 to 579 million in February 2013 — LDI revenues jumped 308%, from $8.37 million to $59 million.
The tribunal upheld the CCP's findings but reduced the penalty to 2% of turnover generated from the ICH arrangement. It ruled that if the operators fail to pay within 30 days, the original 7.5% penalty will be reinstated.
The CAT, however, has conditionally cut the fine to more than half of what the CCP had imposed. The CCP had imposed penalties of 7.5% of annual turnover on each LDI operator including the PTCL for entering into an anti-competitive ICH agreement.
In 2012, the LDI operators including PTCL entered into an agreement wherein all incoming international calls were routed through a single gateway operated by PTCL as head of an LDI consortium. The arrangement fixed a uniform termination rate of around 8.8 US cents per minute — up from about 2 cents previously — and allocated revenue shares and traffic quotas among LDI operators. Competing networks were closed, and prices for overseas callers increased.
The CCP declared the ICH a cartel arrangement involving price-fixing and market-sharing. In April 2013, it imposed penalties of 7.5% of annual turnover on each LDI operator and directed the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) to restore pre-ICH competition.
The order rejected claims of 'state compulsion' or Ministry of Information Technology directives, stating that records showed LDI operators themselves sought and secured the policy directive for ICH.
The tribunal affirmed that the Competition Act, 2010, applies to government bodies and regulators, noting that even PTA could be held liable for restricting competition. It dismissed arguments that the CCP lacked jurisdiction because the calls were incoming and free to local consumers, stressing that the agreement restricted market entry and competition.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Uncertainty persists despite EU-US trade deal: Lagarde
BERLIN: The US-EU trade deal has eased but 'certainly not eliminated' global uncertainty, European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde said Wednesday. Speaking at a panel at the World Economic Forum in Geneva, Lagarde said the deal had left the effective US tariff rate for EU goods at between 12 and 16 percent. The tariff rate was 'somewhat higher' than the ECB had forecast, she said, adding that President Donald Trump's plans for sector-specific levies on pharmaceutical goods and semiconductors remain unclear. The ECB expects eurozone activity to slow in the third quarter of 2025 after a strong start to the year. Lagarde said that 'global growth has remained broadly steady so far' but cautioned that 'this resilience has been mainly driven by tariff-induced distortions of economic activity'. EU push to protect digital rules holds up trade statement with US, FT reports She noted that, in the first quarter of the year, 'importers boosted their inventories in anticipation of higher tariffs'. Trump has imposed painful import tariffs on countries around the world in an attempt to boost US manufacturing and reduce his country's colossal trade deficit. He had initially threatened steep 30 percent tariffs on EU imports but late last month Brussels and Washington reached a deal which lowered that to 15 percent, with the bloc trying to secure exemptions for certain sectors. However, in recent weeks Trump has raised the possibility of additional tariffs hitting certain sectors such as pharmaceuticals, which account for 20 percent of the the EU's exports to the United States. The EU-US deal was struck a few days after a meeting of the ECB's governing council at which it decided to hold interest rates steady after consecutive cuts. That was seen as a sign of caution as policymakers waited to see what effects the US tariffs would have. In its last macroeconomic projections in June, the ECB lowered its inflation forecast to two percent for 2025 due to lower energy prices and a strengthening euro. At the same time it lowered its forecast for GDP growth in 2026 slightly to 1.1 percent. Lagarde said that new forecasts set to published in mid-September will take into account 'the implications of the EU-US trade deal for the euro area economy'.
Business Recorder
8 hours ago
- Business Recorder
‘Strong and growing' interest among American firms in Pakistan's energy sector, says US diplomat
US Charge d'Affaires to Pakistan, Natalie A. Baker, highlighted strong American interest in Pakistan's energy sector. The US official gave her remarks during a high-level meeting with Federal Minister for Petroleum Ali Pervaiz Malik on Wednesday. The meeting focused on strengthening bilateral cooperation between the United States and Pakistan in the energy sector, with particular emphasis on the oil, gas, and minerals sectors, read a statement. Last month, the US administration imposed a 19% reciprocal tariff on a wide range of Pakistani goods, significantly lower than the initially proposed 29%, under an executive order signed by US President Donald Trump. Pakistan, US vow to advance new trade agreement, boost trade & investment Pakistan's revised tariff rate of 19% is lower than that of several regional economies, including India (50%), Bangladesh (20%), Vietnam (20%), and Sri Lanka (20%). During Wednesday's meeting, Baker highlighted significant opportunities for American investment in Pakistan's energy landscape. 'There is a strong and growing interest from US companies in Pakistan's oil, gas, and minerals sector, in line with the vision of President Trump,' she said. 'The US is committed to working with Pakistan. The US Embassy will actively facilitate direct linkages between American companies and their Pakistani counterparts in the Exploration & Production (E&P) sector,' she said. Meanwhile, Federal Minister Ali Pervaiz Malik welcomed the keen interest from US investors and detailed the upcoming opportunities. 'The government is undertaking a bidding round for offshore and onshore oil and gas exploration blocks, which presents a tremendous opportunity for international partners,' Malik said. 'Pakistan possesses huge untapped potential, especially shale oil & gas, and converting these indigenous resources into tangible reserves is a target of our government. We are already engaged in a positive information exchange with US companies,' he added. Charge d'Affaires Baker reinforced that the US-Pakistan had the counter terrorism dialogue, 'now we would like to drive this partnership forward in the economic realm'. The meeting concluded with a shared commitment to deepen the energy partnership, leveraging US technology and investment to support mutual economic and energy growth.
Business Recorder
10 hours ago
- Business Recorder
NZ central bank cuts rates to 3-year low, flags more easing; kiwi tumbles
WELLINGTON: New Zealand's central bank cut its policy rate by 25 basis points to a three-year low of 3.00% on Wednesday, and flagged further reductions in coming months as policymakers warned of domestic and global headwinds to growth. The central bank's dovish tone caught markets offguard and sent the New Zealand dollar tumbling 1.2% to a 4-month low at $0.5819, while two-year swap rates slumped as deep as 2.93% – their lowest level since early 2022. The Reserve Bank of New Zealand said the economy had stalled in the second quarter, and lowered its projected floor for the cash rate to 2.55%, from 2.85% forecast in May. Two members of the six-strong policy committee even voted to cut by 50 basis points on Wednesday. Addressing a press conference, RBNZ Governor Christian Hawkesby said the outlook is data-dependent, but if businesses and consumers remain cautious 'and need more support that might be something that prompts more action.' The quarter point cut in the official cash rate was in line with a large majority of economists in a Reuters poll, but the central bank's broadly bearish tone around economic risks and rates jolted markets. The central bank has slashed rates by 250 basis points since August 2024 to underpin a fragile recovery, but it said 'consumption and investment demand appear to have weakened in the second quarter of 2025, partly in response to heightened trade policy uncertainty' after a shakeup in U.S. tariff policy in April this year. 'The fact that members gave serious consideration to an outsized 50bp cut is quite telling,' said Abhijit Surya, a senior APAC economist at Capital economics. The central bank forecast in its Monetary Policy Statement that the cash rate will be at 2.71% in the fourth quarter, below a forecast of 2.92% in May. In the first quarter of 2026 it expects it to average 2.55%, from the previously forecast 2.85%. 'It is possible that pessimistic sentiment, together with the initial negative effects of the global tariff shock, have dampened the effects of the reduction in the OCR since last August,' RBNZ said in its meeting minutes. Two more rate cuts? Markets quickly moved to narrow the odds on two more cuts, implying a 50% chance of a move in October and over 100% for November. The bottom is now implied around 2.57%, compared to 2.76% before the RBNZ announcement. A snap Reuters poll showed 10 of 12 economists picking the cash rate to bottom at 2.5%, compared with 2.75% in a broader pre-RBNZ poll last week. Bank of New Zealand head of research Stephen Toplis said that given the central bank's dovish tone, the BNZ is now forecasting 25-basis-point cuts in both October and November. ANZ bank is also now expecting two quarter point cuts in October and November, from previous expectations for easings in November and February, saying the RBNZ was 'much more dovish than expected.' New Zealand's annual inflation remains within the RBNZ's 1%-3% target band at 2.7%, giving the central bank leeway to cut rates further. The bank is forecasting inflation to rise to 3% in the third quarter, and then ease to around 2% by the middle of next year. A global front-runner in withdrawing pandemic-era stimulus, the RBNZ lifted rates 525 basis points between October 2021 and September 2023 to curb inflation in the most aggressive tightening since the official cash rate was introduced in 1999. The punishing borrowing costs tipped the South Pacific nation's economy into recession last year, and the recovery has been hampered by tariff risks, slowing global growth and the government's tight fiscal policy. ANZ chief economist Sharon Zollner said the economic weakness has prompted the central bank to act forcefully. 'The RBNZ has come around to our big-picture view more quickly than we anticipated.'
