'Bring back the winter fuel payment': Starmer faces pressure to u-turn on winter fuel cut at PMQs
Sir Keir Starmer faced calls to reverse the controversial cut in winter fuel payments at Prime Minister's Questions, as pressure on the government mounts to change course after the local elections.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch urged the prime minister to "admit he was wrong to remove the winter fuel payment from millions of pensioners".
"His mayor in Doncaster says it's wrong, his first minister in Wales says it's wrong, even his own MPs say it's wrong... Will he at least listen to his own party and change course?" Badenoch asked in the first PMQs since the local elections.
Starmer insisted he was putting the public finances "back in order, after the last government lost control".
A group of Starmer's own MPs from the 'Red Wall' have called on the government to act, writing in a letter that: 'Responding to the issues raised by our constituents, including on winter fuel, isn't weak, it takes us to a position of strength'.
The group called on the government to 'break away from Treasury orthodoxy otherwise we will never get the investment we desperately need.'
Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey told the Commons: "Among the messages voters sent ministers last week, one stood out - bring back the winter fuel payment for millions of struggling pensioners."
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds told ITV's Good Morning Britain that 'you can't do everything at the same time', and ministers "want to go faster" in implementing changes.
Downing Street insist "there will not be a change to the government's policy" on winter fuel, despite ministers accepting the issue hurt the party in the local elections.
The government insists there are other ways they're supporting pensioners, pointing to an expected £1,900 increase in the state pension over the course of the Parliament and an extension to the household support fund.
Reports suggested changes were being considered to restore the winter fuel payments to some who lost the handouts worth up to £300.
Cabinet minister Wes Streeting admitted to ITV News the policy was a "big issue" at the ballot box last week but said there was no formal review taking place.
Wales' First Minister Baroness Eluned Morgan on Tuesday became the latest senior Labour figure to call for a government u-turn, saying "it's something that comes up time and again".
Her call followed that of newly re-elected Labour Mayor of Doncaster Ros Jones, who said it was "wrong" to cut winter fuel, and called on the government to listen to the public.
Former Transport Secretary Louise Haigh also said the loss of winter fuel payments along with welfare cuts were "totemic" for many voters, calling on Starmer to consider a wealth tax.
She told the BBC: 'We just cannot continue down this path that means... we keep coming and raiding those people that can least afford it.'
The decision last July to restrict the winter fuel payment to the poorest pensioners was intended to save around £1.5 billion a year, with more than nine million people who would have previously been eligible losing out.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
31 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Scots ‘voted for change', says Starmer after Labour's surprise by-election win
The Prime Minister congratulated Labour's new MSP Davy Russell and looked ahead to next year's Scottish Parliament election, saying it is a chance to 'turbo-charge delivery'. Mr Russell took the seat vacated by the death of Scottish Government minister and SNP MSP Christina McKelvie. Posting on social media on Friday morning, Sir Keir said: 'People in Scotland have once again voted for change. 'Next year there is a chance to turbo-charge delivery by putting Labour in power on both sides of the border. 'I look forward to working with you.' Labour's candidate, who is the deputy lord lieutenant of Lanarkshire, beat the SNP's Katy Loudon – who fell to her third defeat since 2023. The win comes against the backdrop of national polls which place Scottish Labour in third place behind the SNP and Reform UK – and will undoubtedly give a boost to Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar's bid to become first minister in next year's election. Mr Sarwar told BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme he is confident Labour can win that contest. When asked if his party can defeat the SNP, which has been in power in Scotland since 2007, Mr Sarwar declared: 'Absolutely. 'I believed it before this by-election and I continue to believe it now. 'Next year the choice is simple – a third decade of the SNP with John Swinney as first minister or a new direction for Scotland with me as first minister. 'That is the choice facing the people of Scotland, that is the campaign over the next year, and that is a campaign I am confident we can win. 'I think what the people of Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse did yesterday was lead the way to that change of government next year and a Scottish Labour government next year.' He also said he will 'continue to challenge the poison of Reform', making clear he is 'talking about the people who lead Reform' and not those who 'may be tempted' to vote for them. Mach of the Hamilton campaign had been dominated by a Reform UK advert – branded 'racist' by Labour and others – which had alleged Mr Sarwar would 'prioritise' the Pakistani community. A surge in support for Nigel Farage's party saw it come in third place in Hamilton, just 800 votes behind the SNP – although there had been speculation Reform could come second or possibly even win the seat. Reform UK deputy leader Richard Tice insisted the party is 'delighted' with the result. Richard Tice said he was delighted with Reform UK's result (Jane Barlow/PA) Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme, he said: 'It's truly remarkable. 'We've come from nowhere to being in a three-way marginal, and we're within 750 votes of winning that by-election and just a few hundred votes of defeating the SNP, so it's an incredible result.' At the election count earlier, Mr Tice told the PA news agency he was 'thrilled to bits' with the result. When the votes were counted, Mr Russell polled 8,559, Ms Loudon took 7,957 votes, and Reform's Ross Lambie secured 7,088. Congratulations to @DavyRussell4HLS and the team on a fantastic victory. People in Scotland have once again voted for change. Next year there is a chance to turbo charge delivery by putting Labour in power on both sides of the border. I look forward to working with you. — Keir Starmer (@Keir_Starmer) June 6, 2025 Speaking to PA after the declaration, Mr Sarwar said: 'I think people need to change the script, because we've proven the pollsters wrong. 'We've proven the commentators wrong, we've proven the bookies wrong. 'We've proven John Swinney wrong and so many others wrong too.' In the final days of the campaign, the First Minister had said it was a 'two-horse race' between the SNP and Reform, and Mr Sarwar asked what it says about a Government that has been in power for 18 years when 'all it has to offer in a campaign is vote SNP to stop Farage'. Mr Russell had faced criticism for his perceived lack of media appearances, but Mr Sarwar said such arguments were borne of 'an element of classism and elitism'. Davy Russell took the win on Thursday (Jane Barlow/PA) Speaking from the stage after his win, Mr Russell said: 'Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse has voted tonight to take a new direction with Scottish Labour. 'Like the people here in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse, and right across Scotland, we all feel we have been let down by the SNP.' The newly-minted MSP also hit out at Reform, saying the win 'sent a message to Farage and his mob tonight – the poison of Reform isn't us, it isn't Scotland and we don't want your division here'. Mr Swinney said Ms Loudon had 'fought a superb SNP campaign' and that he was 'clearly disappointed' his party was unable to win. 'Labour won by an absolute landslide in this area less than a year ago – we came much closer tonight, but the people of Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse have made clear that we still have work to do,' he added. 'Over the next few days, we will take time to consider the result fully.'
STV News
36 minutes ago
- STV News
Labour win shows how far SNP still has to go to rebuild trust with voters
The result from Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse is a big surprise. Great for Labour, grim for the SNP, good enough for Reform. Hamilton is the home of big by-election shocks. Last night might not be in the same league as Winnie Ewing's historic Hamilton by-election win in 1967 but it is still a surprise. Almost everyone I spoke to expected the SNP to win. The pollsters predicted that the SNP were ahead across Scotland, the bookies made the SNP odds on favourite, but the voters in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse backed Labour. And at elections, it is the voters that count. So how did they pull it off? Labour's candidate, Davy Russell, made a point of spending his time chapping doors, talking to voters rather than talking to the media. His opponents accused him of dodging debates and avoiding scrutiny. To give him his due he did an interview with me and it was a robust interview. He would probably have got an easier time in studio debating his opponents. Labour won on the back of what they reckon is the biggest ground campaign they have ever mounted in a Scottish election. They spent weeks knocking on doors. Hundreds of activists, MSPs, MPs, councillors and staff canvassed support and listened to voters concerns. All that led to data on how people intended to vote, it helped the party know where its voters live. Yesterday more than 250 Labour campaigners knocked on the doors of 8,000 voters, sometimes there or four times cajoling them, pestering them out to the polling stations. In the end they got 8,559 votes. That's quite a return – they knocked up 8,000 voters and got 8,559 votes. That is an incredible Get Out the Vote campaign. Davy Russell's knuckles must be red raw after chapping that many doors. And what of the others? The SNP will be hurting today. Not only did they lose a close colleague, the much loved Christina McKelvie, whose death led to this by-election. But they also lost the a close contest by just 602 votes. Politically they had momentum going in to this by-election. STV News Hamilton by-election result. Opinion polls, council by-election wins, Labour Government difficulties over pensioners winter fuel payments and more. First Minister John Swinney has spent almost as much time on the campaign trail as Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar in the last few weeks. This result is a big block to SNP momentum and a big boost to Scottish Labour. It shows just how far the SNP still has to go to rebuild trust with voters. Reform will be buoyed that they came close enough to make it a three-way contest, but they will inevitably be a bit disappointed they didn't match their recent victories from Runcorn and English council elections. 26% shows that they are a serious player in Scottish politics going in to next year's Holyrood election. The Conservatives set out to save their deposit, aiming for 1,500 votes. They managed that with a few votes to spare, but it was a low bar to set and the final result shows just how much they are being squeezed by Reform. And amid all the analysis of where the votes went don't forget the scunner factor. That has been a big part of this election campaign: just how annoyed and angry people are with politics and politicians. I heard it time and again on the streets talking to voters. And that comes through in the result too – more than half of voters stayed at home. And that is not to play down the turnout. 44% is not bad in a by-election. The scunner factor played in to the hands of Reform to some extent, but it is something all the political parties must face up to and address. Reconnecting with voters and re-engaging is crucial ahead of the Scottish Parliament election next May. And this result shows that it really is game on for next May. And finally for everyone who asked during this by-election 'Where's Davy?' Now you know, he was chapping doors, thousands of them all over Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse. And next week he'll be chapping on the door of Holyrood as the newest Member of the Scottish Parliament. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Daily Record
44 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Former SNP Health Secretary calls for John Swinney to resign after Hamilton by-election loss
Alex Neil said the current SNP leadership needs to be "replaced urgently". A former SNP Health Secretary has called for John Swinney to resign after the SNP's by-election loss. Alex Neil said the current SNP leadership needs to be "replaced urgently". Labour's Davy Russell won the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election despite some polls suggesting they could finish third. First Minister Swinney had said that it was a "two-horse race" between the SNP and Reform. Neil posted on X shortly after the result was announced: "Poor by election result for the SNP despite having the best candidate. "It shows that the opinion polls appear wide of the mark. "Most importantly it shows the current SNP leadership needs to be replaced urgently." Neil served as Health Secretary between 2012 and 2014, later serving as Social Justice Secretary. He has been a critic of the SNP leadership since standing down as an MSP in 2021. Russell beat the Nationalists' Katy Loudon - who has now lost three elections since late 2023 - by 602 votes, with Reform's Ross Lambie another 869 behind. His surprise victory came after some bookies had put Labour at 11/1. The SNP had been expected to win, with some in the Labour ranks fearing they could fall into third behind Reform. Despite Labour winning two thirds of Scottish seats at last year's general election, the party has fallen back in the polls since then. This had led to the expectation that the SNP would win next year's Holyrood election. But last night's result was hailed by Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar, who said voters "have laid the first stone in the pathway to a Scottish Labour Government next year." He continued: "It's absolutely game on for next year. We've proven the pundits wrong, we've proven the pollsters wrong, we've proven the political commentators wrong, we've proven the bookies wrong." Russell took the seat vacated by the death of Scottish Government minister and SNP MSP Christina McKelvie.
