Patients call on Queensland government to step in and save embattled Toowong Private Hospital
The Queensland government is facing desperate pleas to make an 11th-hour bid to save Toowong Private Hospital, with patients describing the mental health facility as life-changing.
Eliza Johnston, 34, said the hospital had saved her life "on numerous occasions".
"Without it, there's nowhere else to go — the public system just doesn't cover it," she said.
"The public system will discharge you unless you're a danger to somebody else. Under the public system I was going to die, and this hospital saved me.
"I think anything should be done to save the beds."
The former Toowong Private patient was among about 40 people who stood outside the 58-bed hospital on Monday afternoon to protest its impending closure.
Another patient, who gave his name as Ryan, said he had been going to the facility for 25 years.
"I just don't want to see this hospital close down, because there's so many loving and caring people that look after us," he said.
Asked to give a message to the Queensland government about the closure, he said: "You can't close down the hospital."
"Too many people need the care and support, and they've got nowhere else to go. It's just a horrible situation for everyone," he said.
The Queensland Greens MP for the Brisbane-based seat of Maiwar, Michael Berkman, also attended the rally, repeating impassioned calls for the Crisafulli government to step in and buy the hospital — which would have turned 50 next year.
"We have a mental health crisis here in Queensland and across the country," Mr Berkman said.
"The last thing we can afford to see is these kinds of acute mental health beds being lost to the system.
"We need to be building the state's capacity."
Mr Berkman said he had been "astounded" by the number of people who had contacted his office to express dismay at the collapse of Toowong Private, which is expected to close its doors for the last time later this week.
"It seems like just about everyone in this community knows someone or has some connection with a patient in the hospital previously," he said.
Psychiatrist Brett Emmerson, Queensland branch chair of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, said the sunshine state was about 300 to 350 mental health beds short of what it needed.
"Access is getting worse," he said.
"It's dire. We're in trouble. They don't ever seem to find enough money for mental health."
At the same time, Professor Emmerson said psychiatry was experiencing "a workforce crisis".
"We actually are not graduating enough people to fill the needs now and into the future," he said.
"There was a survey of private practitioners — a lot of them are burnt out, and a lot of them are overwhelmed with work."
Professor James Scott, the medical superintendent of Ramsay Health's New Farm psychiatric clinic in Brisbane's inner north, said it was becoming increasingly hard to recruit psychiatrists willing to admit patients into private hospitals.
"Most psychiatrists have outpatient practices," he said.
"The psychiatrists who are treating patients in hospital, they're getting paid sometimes as little as a third of what they'd earn if they were looking after outpatients … for looking after much more complex people.
"It's not a sustainable workforce model."
Professor Scott called for more public-private partnerships in mental health to increase capacity.
He said Toowong Private Hospital had "some of the best psychiatrists in Australia" practising there.
"They were providing excellent care, and the state government could have utilised some of that facility to take the burden off," Professor Scott said.
A spokesperson for Queensland Health Minister Tim Nicholls said his department continued to work with Toowong Private to determine what impact its closure may have on public mental health services, and to "support continuity of care, if required".
"Queensland Health understands that all inpatients at Toowong hospital will be transferred to other private mental health facilities in Brisbane," the spokesperson said.
Last week, the minister told ABC Radio Brisbane that Toowong Private tended to treat "lower acuity patients", a statement that was condemned by the protesters.
"It was terribly disappointing to hear Tim Nicholls's comment that patients that come to Toowong Private Hospital are not acutely unwell. It's just not true," Eliza Johnston said.
"I'm a former patient, and the patients here are as unwell as they get.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Daily Telegraph
an hour ago
- Daily Telegraph
'I got told that I had zero sperm - I felt like I wasn't a man'
Don't miss out on the headlines from Parenting. Followed categories will be added to My News. Sam Hargraves had been moments away from going on air when a phone call changed everything. Suddenly, the Melbourne sport broadcaster was faced with a battle he could never have anticipated. One that made him question the very essence of what it means to be a man. 'I got told that I had zero sperm," Sam told Kidspot. 'I remember straight away feeling like, oh, then that means I'm not a man.' Want to join the family? Sign up to our Kidspot newsletter for more stories like this. RELATED: 'Why dad alone, when we can dad together?' "I've got a hunch and I might have a problem and I want to go get it tested" This week, during Men's Mental Health Week, Sam is using his platform to amplify the conversation around male infertility. He wants to make one thing critically clear: 'What defines you as a man is what's in your heart. Not in your testicles.' It's a perspective he's gained through a journey that many men might shy away from. Sam, and his partner Evie, had been trying to conceive naturally for a while before turning to a fertility specialist. While Evie had her own infertility struggles, Sam had a feeling that the issue could equally be on his end. 'I think I just bit the bullet and said, 'I've got a hunch, I might have a problem and I want to go get it tested,'' Sam explained. The test itself was a piece of cake. 'I've said to a few men and a few mates, without being crass, this is something you've been practicing for your whole life. This is the easiest thing you'll ever do,' he said. 'I thought I was prepared for the worst. I really still wasn't." Sam was told by doctors that he had zero sperm. Not a single one. 'All at once I felt embarrassed. I felt ashamed. I felt less than. Like I'm not a man,' he revealed. He also felt as if he'd let his partner down, who he knew wanted so badly to be a mum. His mental health took a hit from the news. One of his first calls was to his dad. 'I burst into tears and even said to him, 'I'm not a real man.' He just said, 'Well, you know, that's not true,'' Sam recalled. This week, during Men's Mental Health Week, Sam is using his platform to amplify the conversation around male infertility. Image: Supplied RELATED: Toddler's heartbreaking plea to dad after welcoming newborn sibling 'I don't think anyone grows up wanting to be the face of men's infertility" Sam is far from alone in experiencing male infertility. 'Sperm problems are more common than people realise. Male factors contribute to around 30-40% of infertility cases,' Doctor Chandrika Parmar told Kidspot. The Director and fertility specialist, at Genea in Melbourne, says the concern arises from two main causes: obstructive azoospermia (due to a physical blockage in the reproductive tract, caused by past infections, surgeries or injury) or non-obstructive (when the testicles don't produce sperm properly due to hormone imbalances, genetic conditions or damage from treatments). But the good news: testing is straightforward and there are many options for men who face sperm difficulties. 'For men with low sperm count, lifestyle changes like quitting smoking, reducing alcohol, improving diet, and managing stress can help,' Doctor Parmar said. 'Even in cases of azoospermia, there are still options, including surgical sperm retrieval or donor sperm.' Sam credits his support network, specifically his partner Evie, as what got him through the difficult times. 'She was amazing. She was incredible and still is to this day. She's a superhero,' Sam boasted. Despite heartbreaking setbacks along the way, they didn't stop fighting for a second, and were able to achieve their dream family thanks to the common and successful approach of IVF with ICSI (Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection). 'We now have not one, but two miracles and we're incredibly lucky,' Sam shared. "I would love more men to be able to have these conversations" Now, through his story, Sam wants other men to know that one of the most powerful things they can do in the face of infertility is to talk about it. 'I don't think anyone grows up wanting to be the face of men's infertility, but I would love more men to be able to have these conversations,' Sam said. 'If you were asked to list the best qualities about yourself or the best qualities about a man you admire, at no stage would you ever say that one of the things you admire most about that person or yourself is a high sperm count.' In fact, the process has shown Sam exactly what he admires about himself. 'I reckon I've become a better man since I found out that I was shooting blanks,' he explained. 'Because what I went about doing to help with that process with exercise, diet, my relationship with alcohol. I've actually because of it become a better man and therefore I've become a better father off the back of infertility.' Originally published as 'I got told that I had zero sperm - I felt like I wasn't a man'

ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
Push for national reform of fertility sector
Another major IVF bungle has reignited calls for national reform of the sector. Monash IVF says there was an incident at a Melbourne lab last week, which saw a patient's own embryo being incorrectly transferred to them, instead of their partner's embryo. Health ministers from across the country will now discuss the issue of regulation at a meeting on Friday.

ABC News
5 hours ago
- ABC News
GoodSam app volunteer Ashlin Fisher saves neighbour in cardiac arrest
When Geoff Percival collapsed in cardiac arrest and his partner called triple-0, it was not a paramedic who was the first responder; it was neighbour Ashlin Fisher. A few months earlier, the young mum from Broulee on the New South Wales south coast had downloaded NSW Ambulance's GoodSam responder application to her phone. The time had come to put it to the test. "It's a very loud, alarming alert … and I realised what it was and I had to run out the door," Ms Fisher said. When she arrived that fateful day in March last year, the 63-year-old was unconscious, and his partner was performing cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). "I explained as best I could who I was and what I was … I asked her to put the phone on loudspeaker … and very quickly I didn't have to make any real decisions, triple-0 was just giving me instructions on what to do," she said. The frantic triple-0 call recorded the moment Ms Fisher arrived, with the operator responding: "We've got a GoodSam here? OK, alright … we're up to 300 compressions, I need you to keep going until that ambulance arrives." As Ms Fisher counted the compression alongside the operator, ambulance sirens blared in the background, and within two minutes a paramedic was in the room. Then the operator said, "Is that the paramedic on scene with you? OK, I'll leave you with them, you've all done a really good job, all the best now." Mr Percival recently got the chance to thank his good Samaritan. "I just think it was so lucky that she was able to respond. [My partner] was doing CPR on me … and Ashlin came along and I think you said, 'Can I take over?' and she said, 'Yes, please,'" he said. "It was good to have a third person come in and have some idea what to do until the paramedics arrived. According to NSW Ambulance, it takes a paramedic an average of nine to 10 minutes to reach a heart attack case. The GoodSam app aims to bridge that gap and is available to anyone 18 or older and able to perform CPR. When needed, an alarm on the responder's phone rings, and the person is asked if they can help. If they can, they receive the patient's address along with the location of any nearby defibrillator. GoodSam began in NSW in 2023, and so far about 9,600 volunteers have registered. NSW Ambulance GoodSam project officer Monika Sitkowski said volunteers had given CPR to 54 patients who had survived. "They're not getting oxygen into their vital organs, especially their brain, so we need to get volunteers who are nearby to start that CPR process and keep them alive until paramedics arrive. "[GoodSam] is about saving your neighbours. It's about saving your friends and family. There's a huge increase in survival when you've got early CPR to that person in need." NSW Ambulance said it was aiming for 50,000 registered volunteers across the state. "That would probably mean that there's a GoodSam responder nearby to every person who goes into cardiac arrest," Ms Sitkowski said. Versions of the GoodSam app are also used in South Australia and Victoria, while Western Australia's St John Ambulance has a similar app.