logo
Patients call on Queensland government to step in and save embattled Toowong Private Hospital

Patients call on Queensland government to step in and save embattled Toowong Private Hospital

The Queensland government is facing desperate pleas to make an 11th-hour bid to save Toowong Private Hospital, with patients describing the mental health facility as life-changing.
Eliza Johnston, 34, said the hospital had saved her life "on numerous occasions".
"Without it, there's nowhere else to go — the public system just doesn't cover it," she said.
"The public system will discharge you unless you're a danger to somebody else. Under the public system I was going to die, and this hospital saved me.
"I think anything should be done to save the beds."
The former Toowong Private patient was among about 40 people who stood outside the 58-bed hospital on Monday afternoon to protest its impending closure.
Another patient, who gave his name as Ryan, said he had been going to the facility for 25 years.
"I just don't want to see this hospital close down, because there's so many loving and caring people that look after us," he said.
Asked to give a message to the Queensland government about the closure, he said: "You can't close down the hospital."
"Too many people need the care and support, and they've got nowhere else to go. It's just a horrible situation for everyone," he said.
The Queensland Greens MP for the Brisbane-based seat of Maiwar, Michael Berkman, also attended the rally, repeating impassioned calls for the Crisafulli government to step in and buy the hospital — which would have turned 50 next year.
"We have a mental health crisis here in Queensland and across the country," Mr Berkman said.
"The last thing we can afford to see is these kinds of acute mental health beds being lost to the system.
"We need to be building the state's capacity."
Mr Berkman said he had been "astounded" by the number of people who had contacted his office to express dismay at the collapse of Toowong Private, which is expected to close its doors for the last time later this week.
"It seems like just about everyone in this community knows someone or has some connection with a patient in the hospital previously," he said.
Psychiatrist Brett Emmerson, Queensland branch chair of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, said the sunshine state was about 300 to 350 mental health beds short of what it needed.
"Access is getting worse," he said.
"It's dire. We're in trouble. They don't ever seem to find enough money for mental health."
At the same time, Professor Emmerson said psychiatry was experiencing "a workforce crisis".
"We actually are not graduating enough people to fill the needs now and into the future," he said.
"There was a survey of private practitioners — a lot of them are burnt out, and a lot of them are overwhelmed with work."
Professor James Scott, the medical superintendent of Ramsay Health's New Farm psychiatric clinic in Brisbane's inner north, said it was becoming increasingly hard to recruit psychiatrists willing to admit patients into private hospitals.
"Most psychiatrists have outpatient practices," he said.
"The psychiatrists who are treating patients in hospital, they're getting paid sometimes as little as a third of what they'd earn if they were looking after outpatients … for looking after much more complex people.
"It's not a sustainable workforce model."
Professor Scott called for more public-private partnerships in mental health to increase capacity.
He said Toowong Private Hospital had "some of the best psychiatrists in Australia" practising there.
"They were providing excellent care, and the state government could have utilised some of that facility to take the burden off," Professor Scott said.
A spokesperson for Queensland Health Minister Tim Nicholls said his department continued to work with Toowong Private to determine what impact its closure may have on public mental health services, and to "support continuity of care, if required".
"Queensland Health understands that all inpatients at Toowong hospital will be transferred to other private mental health facilities in Brisbane," the spokesperson said.
Last week, the minister told ABC Radio Brisbane that Toowong Private tended to treat "lower acuity patients", a statement that was condemned by the protesters.
"It was terribly disappointing to hear Tim Nicholls's comment that patients that come to Toowong Private Hospital are not acutely unwell. It's just not true," Eliza Johnston said.
"I'm a former patient, and the patients here are as unwell as they get.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Mailbag: More complexity in prostate cancer testing
Mailbag: More complexity in prostate cancer testing

ABC News

time43 minutes ago

  • ABC News

Mailbag: More complexity in prostate cancer testing

Norman Swan: So let's go to the mailbag now. Preeya Alexander: Yes, so I was not here, I was off gallivanting last week, but you've done a story… Norman Swan: Feel free to criticise what we did. We wouldn't have been so crap if you'd been there. Preeya Alexander: That's not at all what I was suggesting. Norman Swan: Olivia was fantastic… Preeya Alexander: She's always fantastic. Norman Swan: So a GP has written in about our story on prostate cancer diagnosis and screening, although we didn't use that word. We had Jeremy Grummet on the show talking about the guidelines, because he took umbrage, because…this did involve you, because when you and I were talking about these guidelines that came out when they first came out, I was quite forceful in saying that the PSA blood test was crap. And Jeremy, who's been on the Health Report several times before, took umbrage at this and saying it's not crap with the new guidelines. So anyway, he came on to talk about the prostate cancer guidelines and to correct my image that the PSA was crap. And this GP who's written in says, 'I found Jeremy's comments to be the untypical, unrealistic comments that urban centric, non-GP specialists are prone to make.' And our correspondent is in fact a general practitioner. So he says, 'It takes a few seconds to tick the PSA request on a form, and that's the easy bit. The Herculean task is then to obtain access to a urologist and a prostate magnetic resonance imaging machine for a rural or regional patient. And let's not forget city dwellers without private insurance who are facing exactly the same problem.' Preeya Alexander: That's the thing. The blood test, the PSA, is often the easy part, I have to agree with this, and I work in a metropolitan region, but often it's the next steps, it's what do you do with the result, how likely is it to actually cause a problem, and how does the patient access the ongoing either urology input or scanning that they need, because it can be very costly. Norman Swan: And to be fair to Jeremy, he did talk about this disparity between city and country and this evidence. And Paul also writes in, 'I know this is anecdote, and I've no idea if it's evidence based,' but when he was a GP…we've obviously got more GPs listening to the program now that you're on because they want to check you out here, whether you're sullying the profession. 'I've had a few isolated patients with an extremely low PSA (in other words, under one) which slowly rose to be around about four.' And just to put this in perspective, I don't know if you know this, Preeya, but the original studies that were done I think it was at Stanford University by a urologist there, on PSA, he was suggesting you had a high risk of cancer at a PSA of 25. Preeya Alexander: I remember you saying this when we did the show several weeks ago… Norman Swan: And it's crept down. And what Paul's talking about is that this change in PSAs are really important, even at a low level. Preeya Alexander: Paul's saying the idea of having a baseline, perhaps. But I have to say, are you potentially detecting cancers which were never going to cause any problems? Because that's the whole debate with prostate cancer, isn't it; you might detect cancers that someone might live with and die with the cancer, as opposed to die of it. And so this attaining a baseline and routine testing, gosh, it's filled with conundrums, and you need to have a big chat to the patient beforehand. Norman Swan: And some people can have prostate cancer with a normal PSA. But what Jeremy would say, if I was channelling Jeremy Grummet here, is that that's what MRI is for, is to sort this out for you. And if there's nothing much there, then you can relax. Preeya Alexander: But it's not always easy to access, either the MRI or the urologist. As we've just said, it's a little bit of a conundrum I think still. Norman Swan: It is. Preeya Alexander: Yep, but we love hearing from you. So if you want to write in with any topic suggestions or comments or questions, it's healthreport@ Norman Swan: And you don't have to be a GP to write in. Preeya Alexander: No, you don't, please, ideally everybody, all community dwellers. Norman Swan: And don't forget our companion podcast, What's That Rash? , and this week we're going to be talking about concurrent workout regimes. Should you combine cardio with strength exercises? Interesting question, I'm sure it's dominated your life for a long time. Tune in to What's That Rash? to find out. We'll see you next week. Preeya Alexander: We will.

NZ Minister Casey Costello: Australia's tobacco and vape law ‘failure'
NZ Minister Casey Costello: Australia's tobacco and vape law ‘failure'

Daily Telegraph

time2 hours ago

  • Daily Telegraph

NZ Minister Casey Costello: Australia's tobacco and vape law ‘failure'

Don't miss out on the headlines from NSW. Followed categories will be added to My News. A leading New Zealand Government politician has attributed her nation's 'massive decline' in daily cigarette smokers to the regulation of vaping products. As the political blame game continues over how Australia should combat the spiralling tobacco wars, Minister of Customs and Associate Health Minister Casey Costello told The Daily Telegraph her government had taken an approach of 'consent, rather than coercion'. Unlike Australia, New Zealand has allowed nicotine vapes to be legally sold, but with strict guardrails applied to retailers. The products are regularly tested by health officials, single-use vapes are banned and there are also restrictions on flavours. 'The message really simply is 'if you don't smoke, don't vape'. If you smoke … vaping may help,' Ms Costello told this masthead. 'At no point are we saying vaping is without harm, what we're saying is that it is less harmful.' The Minister said regulated vaping products are also exempt from the crippling government tax applied to cigarettes, a policy deliberately designed to encourage people to quit smoking. 'We had reached a point with the long-term addicted smokers that increasing the excise wasn't going to make a difference. There are cases of people who will go without food or electricity in order to smoke. You could've made cigarettes $100 a pack. All we were doing was reducing people to poverty' Ms Costello said. When asked to comment on the ongoing debate over the involvement of police on tobacco enforcement, Ms Costello said 'it's a health issue'. 'This is about day-to-day health compliance. As an ex-cop, there are some big issues that police are already dealing with,' she said. She also confirmed New Zealand had moved to ban retailers from luring children into their businesses. 'The vaping stores here are like candy wonderlands. They are brightly coloured, shiny lights, designed to look attractive to young people. As of June 17 they won't be able to display this way, so young kids won't be attracted to the bright, shiny lights,' Minister Costello said. Casey Costello, New Zealand's Minister of Customs and Associate Minister of Health, says Australia's approach to illicit tobacco had been an 'appalling failure.' Source: Facebook In separate comments discovered by this masthead, Ms Costello on Thursday told a New Zealand podcast she thought Australia's response to illicit tobacco had been an 'appalling failure' after a recent trip to our country. 'If you see a young person smoking in New Zealand, it's like a unicorn. But Darling Harbour, across the waterfront, there were young people smoking. We don't have that and we need to be proud of that,' Ms Costello told Taxpayer Talk. New Zealand's smoking rate has declined from more than 14 per cent in 2019 to just 6.9 per cent in 2023. In the same period the number of daily smokers in Australia fell from 11 per cent to 8.3 per cent. Responding to the criticism from across the ditch, Federal Health Minister Mark Butler insisted 'Australia's world-leading smoking and vaping legislations are working.' 'Making sure young people didn't get addicted to vapes was always our focus. They were told vapes were a safe alternative to smoking, but that was all a ruse from Big Tobacco. We know vaping has become a gateway to cigarette smoking,' Mr Butler said. Health Minister Mark Butler insists Australia has the right approach towards vaping and smoking. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman 'Traders selling illicit tobacco might think this is a relatively harmless, innocuous trade, but it's undermining public health. Every time they sell a packet of these illegal cigarettes, they are bankrolling the criminal activities of some of the vilest, worst organised criminal gangs in this country.' Australia has roughly 700,000 people vaping, according to the Institute of Health and Welfare. Currently vapes can only be purchased through a pharmacy - with the government aware of 40,000 patients using this service between October 2024 and May 2025 – meaning the majority of vapers continue to purchase illicit products. Do you have a story for The Daily Telegraph? Message 0481 056 618 or email tips@

Paediatric cardiologist under 'intense pressure' in Far North Queensland
Paediatric cardiologist under 'intense pressure' in Far North Queensland

ABC News

time2 hours ago

  • ABC News

Paediatric cardiologist under 'intense pressure' in Far North Queensland

Medical advocacy groups and a national charity are backing a call from parents for a second paediatric cardiologist to be appointed in Queensland's vast far north. Some patients are waiting almost a year to see a paediatric cardiologist in the region, where the rate of rheumatic heart disease in children under 14 is about 30 times higher than the state average. Doctors' groups say the far north's sole paediatric cardiologist, Ben Reeves, is under "intense pressure and stress" to provide care to children across a region that stretches more than 1,000 kilometres to Cape York and the Torres Strait. HeartKids chief executive Marcus Sandmann said his organisation was supporting hundreds of families in north Queensland, many of whom were travelling more than 200km for an appointment. "We've had some families that we've worked very closely with over the years that have had to relocate to Brisbane just based on the need to have better levels of care for their child," he said. "That's obviously quite daunting and confronting for families to have to do that." Cairns and Hinterland Hospital and Health Service chief executive Leena Singh said the far north needed an additional paediatric cardiologist to meet demand. The hospital service has been developing a business case to secure the funding needed to bolster its paediatric cardiology care with an extra specialist and more allied health workers and nurses. "I believe the paediatric cardiologist, as a sole practitioner there, must be under intense pressure and stress," Queensland paediatrician Nitin Kapur said. Professor Kapur, who until recently was president of the Royal Australasian College of Physicians' (RACP) paediatric and child health division, said many children had chronic care needs. He said long wait times led to poorer health outcomes, particularly as GP care was also increasingly hard to access. The lack of adequate paediatric cardiology services in Cairns, one of the largest centres in northern Australia, has led to calls for more incentives to lure specialists to the regions. Professor Kapur said more accommodation support, childcare, and the ability to work part-time could help address the situation, as well as a streamlined pathway for overseas doctors to take up positions. "A lot of our paediatric workforce nowadays is female … and it's difficult for part-time work," he said. Professor Kapur said the RACP's advanced paediatric training was the only college pathway that mandated time in a regional area. He said the college would accredit any funded training positions in regional hospitals but a decision to employ a full-time consultant specialist was entirely up to each individual public hospital service. The Australian Medical Association Queensland (AMAQ) branch has also called for more state government investment in attraction and retention incentives. AMAQ president Nick Yim said a workforce plan was needed to identify which regions had specialist shortages, and where the health system was losing professionals. "We know that burnout unfortunately leads to doctors leaving the profession, so we do need to ensure they have sustainable workloads," Dr Yim said. Professor Kapur said paediatricians "have let ourselves down in not strongly advocating for more support as well". "Probably the government doesn't see this as a priority because outpatient-based, subspecialty medicine-based medicine doesn't grab attention," he said. Professor Kapur said two new consultant paediatric cardiology positions had been created in Townsville in recent months. In February, the Queensland government scrapped the Workforce Attraction Incentive Scheme, which offered health workers up to $70,000 to take critical roles in regional areas. In a statement, a spokeswoman for Health and Ambulance Minister Tim Nicholls said the government was committed to delivering 34,200 extra clinicians by 2032, labelling the former government's scheme as "ineffective". "The Crisafulli government is undertaking significant local, national and international recruitment activities to attract key medical professionals to help address short, medium and long-term workforce needs across the hospital and health system," she said. "Our hospital rescue plan is investing in health infrastructure across the state, including building new staff accommodation which will go a long way in attracting skilled workers to the regions that need it most."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store