Patients call on Queensland government to step in and save embattled Toowong Private Hospital
The Queensland government is facing desperate pleas to make an 11th-hour bid to save Toowong Private Hospital, with patients describing the mental health facility as life-changing.
Eliza Johnston, 34, said the hospital had saved her life "on numerous occasions".
"Without it, there's nowhere else to go — the public system just doesn't cover it," she said.
"The public system will discharge you unless you're a danger to somebody else. Under the public system I was going to die, and this hospital saved me.
"I think anything should be done to save the beds."
The former Toowong Private patient was among about 40 people who stood outside the 58-bed hospital on Monday afternoon to protest its impending closure.
Another patient, who gave his name as Ryan, said he had been going to the facility for 25 years.
"I just don't want to see this hospital close down, because there's so many loving and caring people that look after us," he said.
Asked to give a message to the Queensland government about the closure, he said: "You can't close down the hospital."
"Too many people need the care and support, and they've got nowhere else to go. It's just a horrible situation for everyone," he said.
The Queensland Greens MP for the Brisbane-based seat of Maiwar, Michael Berkman, also attended the rally, repeating impassioned calls for the Crisafulli government to step in and buy the hospital — which would have turned 50 next year.
"We have a mental health crisis here in Queensland and across the country," Mr Berkman said.
"The last thing we can afford to see is these kinds of acute mental health beds being lost to the system.
"We need to be building the state's capacity."
Mr Berkman said he had been "astounded" by the number of people who had contacted his office to express dismay at the collapse of Toowong Private, which is expected to close its doors for the last time later this week.
"It seems like just about everyone in this community knows someone or has some connection with a patient in the hospital previously," he said.
Psychiatrist Brett Emmerson, Queensland branch chair of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, said the sunshine state was about 300 to 350 mental health beds short of what it needed.
"Access is getting worse," he said.
"It's dire. We're in trouble. They don't ever seem to find enough money for mental health."
At the same time, Professor Emmerson said psychiatry was experiencing "a workforce crisis".
"We actually are not graduating enough people to fill the needs now and into the future," he said.
"There was a survey of private practitioners — a lot of them are burnt out, and a lot of them are overwhelmed with work."
Professor James Scott, the medical superintendent of Ramsay Health's New Farm psychiatric clinic in Brisbane's inner north, said it was becoming increasingly hard to recruit psychiatrists willing to admit patients into private hospitals.
"Most psychiatrists have outpatient practices," he said.
"The psychiatrists who are treating patients in hospital, they're getting paid sometimes as little as a third of what they'd earn if they were looking after outpatients … for looking after much more complex people.
"It's not a sustainable workforce model."
Professor Scott called for more public-private partnerships in mental health to increase capacity.
He said Toowong Private Hospital had "some of the best psychiatrists in Australia" practising there.
"They were providing excellent care, and the state government could have utilised some of that facility to take the burden off," Professor Scott said.
A spokesperson for Queensland Health Minister Tim Nicholls said his department continued to work with Toowong Private to determine what impact its closure may have on public mental health services, and to "support continuity of care, if required".
"Queensland Health understands that all inpatients at Toowong hospital will be transferred to other private mental health facilities in Brisbane," the spokesperson said.
Last week, the minister told ABC Radio Brisbane that Toowong Private tended to treat "lower acuity patients", a statement that was condemned by the protesters.
"It was terribly disappointing to hear Tim Nicholls's comment that patients that come to Toowong Private Hospital are not acutely unwell. It's just not true," Eliza Johnston said.
"I'm a former patient, and the patients here are as unwell as they get.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
National aged care and disability provider Annecto announces shock closure
National aged care and disability services provider Annecto will close in July, putting the care of more than 3000 patients in limbo. The business announced the shock closure on Wednesday, citing 'service model shifts and financial challenges' for the breakdown. 'This difficult decisions follows careful deliberation and extensive stakeholder consultation which considered the service model shifts and financial challenges facing the organisation into the future,' the company said in a statement. The provider supports more than 3000 people with disabilities, members of the veteran community and older adults across Victoria, NSW, Queensland and the ACT. 'Our focus now is working to transition our customers and services to other trusted providers who can continue delivering the support and assistance our customers expect and deserve.' The company said it was working with the Department of Health, the NDIS and the Department of Veterans' Affairs and 'other key stakeholders' to ensure 'the seamless transition' of its customers and staff to 'trusted and quality accredited providers'. The business ran for some 70 years. Annecto chair Colleen Furnaletto OAM said the decision to shut down the enterprise 'was not made lightly'. 'We deeply appreciate the support of our community over all these years and the dedication of our staff and partners to high quality of support standards,' she said.

ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Monash IVF CEO Michael Knapp steps down after second embryo bungle
Monash IVF chief executive officer Michael Knapp has resigned following the reveal of a second embryo bungle. In a statement to the ASX, Monash IVF said its board had accepted Mr Knaap's resignation and "respects his decision". "Since his appointment in 2019, Michael has led the organisation through a period of significant growth and transformation, and we thank him for his years of dedicated service," the statement said. Monash IVF revealed on Tuesday that it had incorrectly transferred the wrong embryo to a patient — the second incident the company has apologised for in recent months. It comes two months after the company revealed a Brisbane patient was mistakenly implanted with another patient's embryo. The woman gave birth to a baby who had no genetic link to her later that year, which the ABC understands happened in 2023. Mr Knapp was also the managing the director of Monash IVF Group and had led the organisation since 2013. Chief financial officer and company secretary Malik Jainudeen has been appointed as acting CEO.

News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Consumer group finds most sunscreens do not meet SPF claims
Major sunscreen brands are not living up to their SPF claims, according to a new test from consumer group Choice. Choice tested 20 popular SPF50 and SPF50+ sunscreens and found that only four lived up to the standard they claimed, with 16 falling short. SPF stands for 'sun protection factor' and is the measure of how well the sunscreen protects from the sun's UV rays. An SPF 50 sunscreen is meant to block about 98 per cent of the rays, meaning it will take 50 times longer to get burnt than with unprotected skin. The consumer group tested the products with experts in an accredited sunscreen lab, with four products returning SPF results in the 40s, four in the 30s, and seven in the 20s. Choice chief executive Ashley de Silva said the tests showed that products were not meeting consumer expectations. 'Consumers expect sunscreen to protect them in line with the SPF rating on the product, but as our testing has shown, the SPF label doesn't always match what's in the bottle,' he said. One sunscreen, Ultra Violette's lean screen SPF 50+ mattifying zinc skinscreen, astoundingly returned a result of just SPF4. 'We were really shocked to see the results for Ultra Violette's lean screen SPF 50+ product, so much so that we actually decided to test a different batch at a completely different lab in Germany to confirm the results,' Mr de Silva said. 'Those tests found the product had an SPF of 5 – an almost identical result to our initial testing.' The consumer group was, however, quick to remind people that while a sunscreen may have ranked lower than claimed in its tests, that does not mean that products do not work. A sunscreen with an SPF of 30 or 20 can still give significant sun protection and is much better than using no sunscreen at all. Choice have told the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) and Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) about the results of the tests and asked the TGA to conduct their own tests. 'Choice is calling on the TGA to urgently carry out its own sunscreen compliance testing and on the ACCC to investigate if any SPF claims are misleading,' Mr de Silva said. 'Currently, the TGA relies on reports provided by manufacturers to ensure the safety, quality and efficacy of sunscreen products. 'Unfortunately, these reports may not be providing the accurate information consumers need when choosing sunscreens for themselves and their families.'