
Ireland's forgotten ‘Hell on Earth' Alcatraz WON'T reopen despite Trump's US slammer plot for ‘most ruthless offenders'
Last week, the
Advertisement
4
Spike Island in Cork was once the world's largest jail housing over 2,300 inmates during the famine
Credit: Alamy
4
Cork Lord Mayor Councillor Kieran McCarthy said it will not reopen
He said the country's 'most ruthless and violent offenders' will be housed in the long-shuttered slammer just off San Francisco,
Spike Island in
Known as 'Hell on Earth', like Alcatraz, it has become an award-winning attraction.
Local historian and Cork Lord Mayor Councillor Kieran McCarthy said there was no chance the Irish
Advertisement
READ MORE IN IRISH NEWS
He said millions have been poured into transforming the island and Fort Mitchel into a place visited by thousands of visitors annually.
He told the Irish Sun: 'Spike Island is part of a historical trail in Cork Harbour which also includes Fort Camden and Fort Meagher.
'It has been closed as a prison for decades and it now plays an important part in the
He also says he does not believe
Advertisement
Most read in the Irish Sun
Exclusive
Latest
Cllr McCarthy thinks it is an impossible ask, as Alcatraz had been crumbling before it was decommissioned and is now a
He said: 'My gut is that this is a political plot by the President aimed at getting at the Democratic Governor of California, Gavin Newsom, who has been somewhat of a thorn in his side.
'STIRRING THE POT'
'San Francisco is twinned with Cork City and there are good relationships between the two cities.
'I do think Trump is stirring the pot. His plan would cost more than millions and it is something people wouldn't want for the Rock.'
Advertisement
Spike Island is famously known as Ireland's Alcatraz.
It was the first of four
An enormous fortress arrived in 1804, its 24-acre footprint so large it could fit
Built to defend an empire and repel an all-conquering Napoleon, it was the fort's conversion to a prison in 1847 that drew the eyes of the world and fostered its dark reputation.
Advertisement
CONDITIONS DETERIORATING
The explosion in crime during the Great Hunger led the prison population to swell to more than 2,300, making it the largest formal prison yet seen in Ireland or
With such severe overcrowding, conditions quickly deteriorated.
More than 1,000 convicts died in the first seven years of operation, each now buried in an unmarked mass grave to the island's east in a forgotten penal tragedy.
No women were held on the island but men and boys as young as 12.
Advertisement
An especially converted 'children's prison' held up to 100 boys in a former ammunition storehouse, the youngsters sleeping in hammocks suspended from chains in the roof.
It reopened in 1921, holding more than 1,200 republican prisoners as the Irish War of Independence raged.
NOTORIOUS INMATE
The
A final prison operated from 1985 to 2004, cementing the island's legendary status in the penal system.
Advertisement
Its most notorious inmate was Martin 'The General' Cahill, who was sent out of harm's way when serving time for breaching the peace.
Cork County Council became the owners and, along with tourism interests, developed it into a modern tourism facility with a 100 seater cafe, two gift shops, and interactive units which allow visitors to go back in time and explore the long history of the island.
4
Donald Trump plans to reopen Alcatraz
Credit: AP:Associated Press
4
Martin 'The General' Cahill was an inmate in the jail
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
Advertisement
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

The Journal
6 hours ago
- The Journal
Trump says that homeless people need to be moved 'far' from Washington 'immediately'
US PRESIDENT DONALD Trump said today that homeless people must be moved 'far' from Washington, after days of musing about taking federal control of the US capital where he has falsely suggested crime is rising. The Republican billionaire has announced a press conference for tomorrow in which he is expected to reveal his plans for Washington – which is run by the locally elected government of the District of Columbia under congressional oversight. It is an arrangement Trump has long publicly chafed at. He has threatened to federalise the city and give the White House the final say in how it is run. 'I'm going to make our Capital safer and more beautiful than it ever was before,' the president posted on his Truth Social platform today. 'The Homeless have to move out, IMMEDIATELY. We will give you places to stay, but FAR from the Capital,' he continued, adding that criminals in the city would be swiftly imprisoned. 'It's all going to happen very fast,' he said. He followed the post on Truth Social with a post of a YouTube short showing an Australian man grappling with a shark. Advertisement Washington is ranked 15th on a list of major US cities by homeless population, according to government statistics from last year. While thousands of people spend each night in shelters or on the streets, the figure are down from pre-pandemic levels. Earlier this week Trump also threatened to deploy the National Guard as part of a crackdown on what he falsely says is rising crime in Washington. Violent crime in the capital fell in the first half of 2025 by 26% compared with a year earlier, police statistics show. The city's crime rates in 2024 were already their lowest in three decades, according to figures produced by the Justice Department before Trump took office. 'We are not experiencing a crime spike,' Washington Mayor Muriel Bowser said today on MSNBC. While the mayor, a Democrat, was not critical of Trump in her remarks, she said 'any comparison to a war torn country is hyperbolic and false.' Trump's threat to send in the National Guard comes weeks after he deployed California's military reserve force into Los Angeles to quell protests over immigration raids, despite objections from local leaders and law enforcement. The president has frequently mused about using the military to control America's cities, many of which are under Democratic control and hostile to his nationalist impulses.


Sunday World
7 hours ago
- Sunday World
Donald Trump says homeless people must leave Washington DC ‘immediately'
The president is planning to hold a press conference on Monday to "stop violent crime' in the city President Donald Trump pledged on Sunday to evict homeless people from the nation's capital and jail criminals, despite Washington's mayor arguing there is no current spike in crime. "The Homeless have to move out, IMMEDIATELY. We will give you places to stay, but FAR from the Capital. The Criminals, you don't have to move out. We're going to put you in jail where you belong," Trump posted on the Truth Social platform. The White House declined to explain what legal authority Trump would use to evict people from Washington. The Republican president controls only federal land and buildings in the city. Trump is planning to hold a press conference on Monday to "stop violent crime in Washington DC." It was not clear whether he would announce more details about his eviction plan then. US President Donald Trump. Photo: Win McNamee/Getty. News in 90 seconds - 10th August 2025 Trump's Truth Social post included pictures of tents and DC streets with some garbage on them. "I'm going to make our Capital safer and more beautiful than it ever was before," he said. According to the Community Partnership, an organization working to reduce homelessness in DC, on any given night there are 3,782 single persons experiencing homelessness in the city of about 700,000 people. Most of the homeless individuals are in emergency shelters or transitional housing. About 800 are considered unsheltered or "on the street," the organisation says. A White House official said on Friday that more federal law enforcement officers were being deployed in the city following a violent attack on a young Trump administration staffer that angered the president. The Democratic mayor of Washington, DC, Muriel Bowser, said on Sunday the capital was "not experiencing a crime spike." "It is true that we had a terrible spike in crime in 2023, but this is not 2023," Bowser said on MSNBC's The Weekend. "We have spent over the last two years driving down violent crime in this city, driving it down to a 30-year low." The city's police department reports that violent crime in the first seven months of 2025 was down by 26pc in DC compared with last year while overall crime was down about 7pc. Bowser said Trump is "very aware" of the city's work with federal law enforcement after meeting with Trump several weeks ago in the Oval Office. The US Congress has control of DC's budget after the district was established in 1790 with land from neighbouring Virginia and Maryland, but resident voters elect a mayor and city council. For Trump to take over the city, Congress likely would have to pass a law revoking the law that established local elected leadership, which Trump would have to sign. Bowser on Sunday noted the president's ability to call up the National Guard if he wanted, a tactic the administration used recently in Los Angeles after immigration protests over the objections of local officials.


Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the Trump/Putin meeting: Ukraine must be at the table
The symbolism of the planned Trump-Putin meeting this week in Alaska is striking. Alaska, after all, was bought from Russia for $7.2 million in 1867, much as Donald Trump hopes to buy Greenland. Nothing wrong with trading land ,Trump appears to be telling Russia's president, whether you own it or not. If the price is right. The US president has set the scene for his encounter with Vladimir Putin with the promise that land concessions of forcibly conquered land are on the cards . 'We're going to get some back, and we're going to get some switched,' Trump said on Friday. 'There'll be some swapping of territories to the betterment of both.' The owner of that land, Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskiy, has not been invited . But a deal without Ukraine being present would not be a deal at all. Calls from EU countries over the weekend for the Ukrainian president to be present should be heeded. While Trump appeared to have patched up his relationship with Zelenskiy after the Oval Office blow-up, his resulting public coolness towards Putin over the latter's stonewalling over a ceasefire has all but dissolved in his enthusiasm to set up a meeting entirely on the Russian's terms, and without any previously demanded ceasefire commitment. Talk of deadlines and secondary sanctions against those buying Russian oil are now, apparently, on hold. And for what? READ MORE Bringing Putin in from diplomatic isolation is in itself a win for the Russian president. An agreement to the permanent consolidation of territorial gains, whether formally or informally acknowledged, would represent an explicit concession of Russia's war aims, a massive reward for an illegal war. Also on Putin's agenda, a Nato commitment not to take in Ukraine is already US policy, and both the ending of US engagement in Ukraine and the splitting of the Europeans off from the US appear feasible objectives for Moscow. At the same time, tensions between Washington and Kyiv have reappeared. Zelenskiy's rapid repudiation of 'constitutionally prohibited' territorial concessions is certain to anger Trump, whose promise that the meeting will be followed by one including Zelenskiy has also been repudiated by Moscow. Putin has made clear all along that he is not interested in a preliminary ceasefire to allow comprehensive peace talks to be arranged. He wants a deal now that will effectively disarm Kyiv and put as much distance between it and allies safely confined to their own territories. No question of international peacekeeping or monitoring. In effect, permanent vulnerability. The prize this week for Putin would be a deal with Trump that Ukraine cannot accept, with the US then walking away and washing its hands of the conflict. Trump's promise of land for peace appears to make that a possible outcome .But a deal without Ukraine being present is not a deal at all.