CM office, Raj Bhawan submit separate stands to J&K High Court on Gulmarg lease issue
The Division Bench, comprising J&K Chief Justice Arun Palli and justice Rajnesh Oswal, was informed by Senior Additional Advocate General Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri that there were two separate replies from the Chief Minister's office and the Lieutenant Governor's office. These were produced before the court in a sealed cover.
The court was hearing the PIL on environmental concerns of Gulmarg and the recent eviction of owners of the Nedou's Hotel in Gulmarg after 137 years of possession. Justice Palli and Justice Oswal, while taking note of the two separate replies, decided to hear the case again on August 28, 2025.
However, J&K Chief Minister Omar Abdullah expressed displeasure over the Raj Bhawan's move. Talking to The Hindu, Mr. Abdullah said, 'Until recently the L-G has continued to maintain that he only has responsibility for security and Law and Order. Now suddenly he's got involved in this. It's unfortunate that the elected government is sought to be undermined by the unelected government'.
Around 55 hotels out of 59 could go under the hammer because of the lack of lease extensions in Gulmarg. The J&K Land Grant Rules-2022, which replaced the J&K Land Grants Rules-1960, introduced by the L-G in 2022 barred extension in case of lease expiry. The L-G administration had asked the outgoing lease holders to evict properties or else face evictions under the new rules. However, the current land holders termed these rules 'exclusive to J&K where the first right to lease-holders has not been granted and revised rates negotiated'.
Many leaseholders have already challenged the new rules before the court. During the L-G rule, it was decided that an expert committee will enlist all properties where lease had ended and will be e-auctioned afresh. For the first time, the earlier bar that only locals could apply for lease of land has been done away with. The new rules instead open bidding to 'any person legally competent under Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.' In the past, no land in Gulmarg was granted on lease to any person who was not a permanent resident of the erstwhile state of J&K.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
3 hours ago
- The Print
Ladakh L-G leads ‘Har Ghar' Tiranga rally in Leh; terms it movement to boost patriotism
Addressing the gathering, the L-G underlined that the rally was more than just a symbolic march. 'It is a national movement to strengthen the spirit of unity and patriotism,' he said. The event, a part of the nationwide campaign ahead of India's 79th Independence Day and an effort to honour its heroes, saw an overwhelming response from citizens, local leaders, youth groups, and cultural troupes. Leh, Aug 13 (PTI) Ladakh Lieutenant Governor Kavinder Gupta on Wednesday led a 'Har Ghar Tiranga' rally through the bustling main market here and termed the march a 'national movement to strengthen the spirit of unity and patriotism'. Paying glowing tributes to legendary freedom fighter Chandra Shekhar Azad and revered local hero Abdul Sattar, Gupta lauded their courage and sacrifices that paved the way for a free and self-reliant India. 'Their legacy is the bedrock of our nation's strength,' he said. The L-G also reaffirmed his commitment to fulfilling Prime Minister Narendra Modi's dream of seeing the tricolour flying proudly atop every home, symbolising the strength of India's unity and the vibrancy of its democracy. PTI TAS TAS NSD NSD This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Hindustan Times
6 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Security beefed up ahead of Independence Day events in Kashmir
Security has been enhanced ahead of the Independence Day celebrations in Kashmir as a full dress rehearsal was conducted by the forces and authorities in Srinagar and other district headquarters of the valley. In Srinagar, the full dress rehearsal was held at Bakhshi Stadium where the Independence Day function will be held on August 15.(HT Photo) In summer capital, the full dress rehearsal was held at Bakhshi Stadium where the Independence Day function will be held on August 15. 'In all the districts, the full dress rehearsal of the August 15 functions was held. It was held effectively with the participation of all the contingents,' said inspector general of police VK Birdi at Bakshi Stadium. He said that the forces also reviewed security arrangements for the Independence day functions to be held across the valley. 'In Srinagar, we have the main program in which VVIPs take salute. Keeping that in mind, multi-tier security arrangements have been made which will be provided by a contingent of J&K Police and central arms police force,' Birdi said. 'There will also be spotters on high rise (structures) and also those in muftis(police personnel in plain clothes) so that all the security arrangements are complete,' he said. Police, CRPF and also other security agencies, in full battle gear, have been deployed on the streets in capital and other district headquarters. There has been enhanced checking of vehicles and pedestrians to ensure tight arrangements are in place for the upcoming function. CCTVs and drones will ensure an eagle's eye view on the movement of people. Divisional commissioner Vijay Kumar Bidhuri hoisted the National Flag and took salute at the march past as he inspected the parade at Bakhshi Stadium. 'Security and peace is prerequisite for development. Earlier law and order situation had a negative role (owing to the Pahalgam attack) on development. But now we are moving ahead owing to the sacrifices of security forces,' he said. Bidhuri said that all the people have an open invitation just like last year on I-day celebrations. 'All are invited. There is no restriction. It is just like a festival. I request everyone to come with their ID cards,' he said. Army & BSF on high alert Jammu Ahead of Independence Day celebrations on August 15, the army and the Border Security Force (BSF) have been put on a high alert along the 744 km long LoC and 200 km long Indo-Pak international border. To catch a glimpse of army's preparedness, media persons were taken to the LoC in Sunderbani on Tuesday. The visit highlighted the formidable challenges faced by soldiers stationed at the border, who steadfastly defend the nation with determination and selflessness, said a defence spokesperson. Amid the breathtaking yet unforgiving landscapes, the soldiers displayed an indomitable spirit as they tackled adversities with unwavering commitment and an assuring smile, he added. Despite extreme weather conditions, isolation and the constant demand for vigilance, these soldiers embody remarkable resilience, he said. Technological advancements were also on display, such as the smart fence system that enhances border security and surveillance. Newly introduced equipment—including quadcopters, advanced surveillance tools, bulletproof vehicles, all terrain vehicles, modern weapons and night vision eights were also displayed, he said. 'These soldiers exemplify the values of honour, duty and sacrifice that form the bedrock of their service. Their unity and shared purpose in safeguarding the country, serves as an inspiration to all citizens,' he said. The BSF has also upped its surveillance and border domination drill along the 200 km long Indo-Pak international border and has put almost entire border under technological surveillance including smart fence, said officials. They informed that the anti-drone systems have also been inducted all along the Jammu border. The BSF has also intensified boat patrolling in rivers that flow from Jammu region into Pakistan. 'Our border patrols and troops in the mounds besides watch towers are alert and alive to the situation,' they said. With inputs from HTC Jammu
The Hindu
10 hours ago
- The Hindu
Aid and advice: on Jammu and Kashmir, LG's Assembly member nominations
The Union Ministry of Home Affairs' assertion to the J&K High Court that the Lieutenant Governor (LG) can nominate five Assembly members without the 'aid and advice' of the elected government overrides democratic accountability. Consequential decisions such as nominating members who have voting rights in an elected assembly must flow from democratic mandate, not administrative discretion. The High Court's constitutional question could not be more direct: do the 2023 amendments to the J&K Reorganisation Act, allowing the LG to nominate five Assembly members 'which have the potential of converting the minority government into a majority government and vice-versa,' violate the Constitution's basic structure? Rather than addressing this, the Ministry delves into legal technicalities. Its submission argues that nominations fall outside the elected government's remit, seemingly invoking the K. Lakshminarayanan vs The Union of India precedent from Puducherry while claiming the 'sanctioned strength' includes elected and nominated members. It even references Section 12 of the 1963 Union Territories Act (voting procedures) as justification for bypassing democratic consultation. When five nominated members could determine government stability in a 119-member Assembly, the issue transcends statutory definitions of 'sanctioned strength'. The real question is whether any legal framework allowing appointed officials to potentially overturn the people's electoral verdict violates the democratic essence of the Constitution. The amendments inserted Sections 15A and 15B into the 2019 Act, allowing the LG to nominate two Kashmiri migrants (including one woman) and one from the Pakistan-occupied J&K community, besides the existing power to nominate two women, if inadequately represented in the elected Assembly. This effectively creates five nominated seats. The High Court's framing of this issue acknowledges the stakes involved: this could 'convert minority government into majority government and vice-versa', potentially subverting the electoral process. This concern is not unsubstantiated — in 2021, three years after Lakshminarayanan, Puducherry saw nominated members and defecting elected MLAs contributing to the collapse of the Congress-led government. Also, J&K's trajectory to Union Territory, without consultation with elected representatives, makes democratic accountability even more crucial. The unfulfilled promise of Statehood restoration, acknowledged by the Supreme Court and despite overwhelming support in J&K, reinforces that current arrangements should strengthen democratic governance. The Ministry's argument that nominations exist 'outside the realm of the business of the elected government' also contradicts evolving Supreme Court jurisprudence. In the Delhi services cases of 2018 and 2023, it ruled that the LG should act on elected governments' aid and advice, with discretionary powers treated as exceptions. Seen in this light, the Ministry's arguments do not hold water.
