Major update in Bruce Lehrmann's legal battle to have rape trial halted
Lehrmann's Sydney-based solicitor Zali Burrows on Friday took aim at Queensland Police after withdrawing a bid to prove officers had illegally recorded two conversations between Lehrmann and his previous legal team.
Ms Burrows had also been seeking a court injunction to prevent Queensland Police from recording any future conversations with any of Lehrmann's legal representatives.
Lehrmann, 30, appeared by phone on Friday when the matter was heard at Toowoomba District Court.
Judge Benedict Power dismissed the application after the claims were withdrawn by Ms Burrows, who conceded her entire case would depend on proving officers had broken the law in Queensland.
Outside court, Ms Burrows told reporters she would never again speak to a Queensland Police officer on the phone.
'All I can say is that it's another world in the state of Queensland,' she said.
Ms Burrows' application was part of a wider bid to seek a permanent stay on proceedings, which, if granted, would halt a pending trial against Lehrmann on two counts of rape.
Lehrmann, who is on bail, is accused of raping a woman twice during the morning of October 10, 2021, after they met at a strip club the previous night in Toowoomba, west of Brisbane.
The former ministerial staffer to Liberal senator Linda Reynolds was charged in January 2023 and is yet to formally enter a plea.
But his former solicitor had previously told a magistrate he intended to contest the charges.
Ms Burrows on Friday agreed with Judge Power's contention that the officers might have followed proper procedure for keeping accurate notes during the early stages of an investigation.
'You need to establish as a matter of law that what (the investigating detective) did was unlawful,' Judge Power said.
Ms Burrows said police would have an 'unfair tactical advantage' if they had a recording of any conversation where a lawyer accidentally disclosed legally confidential material.
Judge Power said that would not be the fault of police and any of Lehrmann's solicitors could make a separate claim if there was confidential material.
Crown prosecutor Caroline Marco was not required to argue in court against Ms Burrows except to agree with Judge Power's proposed order to dismiss.
She told Judge Power the application to halt the trial could only be heard once all other applications were dealt with.
Judge Power told the lawyers they needed to be in a position by July 31 to nominate a date for when the trial might begin.
Ms Burrows told Judge Power that while Lehrmann's previous solicitor had indicated he would make an application for a judge-only trial, her client no longer had a position on whether any trial should be heard by a jury.
The matter will return to court for an August 28 hearing concerning Ms Burrows' efforts to subpoena the Commissioner of Queensland Police for access to all materials involved in the case.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
31 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Homeless at Sydney's Central station have belongings removed with advocates condemning ‘heavy-handed' tactics
Kylie Emery returned from a shower on Thursday morning to find her shopping trolley full of belongings was gone. It contained everything she has to her name: a sleeping bag, warm clothes, her credit card. Emery is among about two dozen people who have been sleeping rough at Sydney's Central station, some for several years, in a sheltered spot near the light rail stop. The majority are women, who find the site safe because of its CCTV cameras and public location. On Thursday, at around 5am, the homeless sleepers were awoken by police and told to move on for two hours, as happens most mornings. They have been told by police this is to avoid disruption for passengers during peak hour. When they returned, they found all their items had been covered in caution tape – and, for the first time, posters had been erected. 'Please remove all your belongings by 12pm today 31/07/2025,' the laminated signs, which were not attributed, read, 'or your items will be disposed afterwards.' Sign up: AU Breaking News email Emery's trolley was eventually returned by a cleaner, who had taken it downstairs, but she said her items had been moved and sorted through. Another man who also had his items taken, including his sleeping bag, was told by a cleaner that they had been thrown away. While Emery's belongings had been returned, she did not know what would happen in the coming hours. She had nowhere else to go, and it was pouring with rain. 'There's women who live here,' she said, adding that many of them, including her, have been through complex trauma and struggle with PTSD. 'It's unsafe for everyone [on the streets], but it's extremely unsafe for us.' Emery says she has been on a priority list for housing for seven months, after experiencing a home invasion in Port Macquarie last year, where she says her housemate was robbed at gunpoint and shot, and then spent months in hospital. 'There's no way I could go back there [to Port Macquarie], it's not safe,' she said. 'I'm just left with nowhere. I ring up [housing services] and they're like, 'Sorry, we can't help you'. 'It's horrible seeing ladies out here on the street. There are mothers and grandmothers here … we haven't done anything wrong.' According to the NSW street count, the number of rough sleepers counted across the state has almost doubled in five years, from 1,314 in 2020 to 2,192 in 2025. Systems are struggling to cope with demand. A report released by Mission Australia on Thursday found demand for its tenancy support services had surged to an all-time high, with a 52% increase in people seeking assistance between 2023 and 2024. The fastest-growing groups of people seeking support were employed people, young people and those escaping family and domestic violence. Homelessness NSW's CEO, Dominique Rowe, said Sydney's housing crisis was forcing more people, including women and children, to seek shelter in stations, parks and other public places. 'People forced to sleep rough need suitable homes and trauma-informed support services, not heavy-handed move-on instructions from authorities,' Rowe said. 'The government must urgently increase funding for stretched homelessness services so they can help more people in need.' Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Amanda, who did not want to use her surname, has been living at Central station for two-and-a-half years, except for a few brief stays in temporary accommodation. She had a doctor's appointment on Thursday, but had to cancel it to guard her belongings. She said the warnings belongings would be removed was the 'harshest response' she had seen by authorities during her time sleeping at the station – particularly as they were targeting the entire group, not just individuals. 'They're saying we're inhibiting passengers, but everyone's getting on board [the light rail],' she said. If we were standing in front of trains of stopping the trains from moving, I would probably say that's appropriate [to ask us to leave], but we aren't.' Amanda said police had given the group warnings in the past, including to keep their belongings tidy and clean, and to make sure benches were made available for passengers. 'But when they moved us on this morning, they said if people didn't take their belongings with them, they'd dispose of them,' she said. 'They've never done that before. 'And every time I put a complaint in to NSW police, I don't get a response.' In most cases, police require a court warrant to lawfully remove property from public land. NSW councils can remove belongings or tell people to move on under certain circumstances, including those that threaten public health or safety. Alexia Smith has been staying at Central station for around five months, and has been periodically homeless since arriving in Australia from the Philippines in 2004. Two weeks ago, she said the group had been advised to move their belongings from inside the station to the undercover concourse. But nobody had been offered them a long-term solution – a home. 'They just create more problems on top of problems,' she said. 'Australia shouldn't treat people like this.' NSW police declined to comment and said the matter was best referred to the City of Sydney council. The City of Sydney council also declined to comment and referred Guardian Australia to Transport NSW. Transport NSW was approached for comment.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Joe Schmidt hits out at ‘online abuse' of Carlo Tizzano as Wallabies flanker stood down after Jac Morgan incident
Australia head coach Joe Schmidt has hit out at the 'online abuse' of Carlo Tizzano that followed the flanker's involvement in a contentious incident at the end of the second British and Irish Lions Test. Tizzano was cleared out in a controversial fashion by Jac Morgan in the lead-up to Hugo Keenan's match-winning try in Melbourne, with the officials concluding that there had been no foul play from the Welshman after an extended review of the footage. The 25-year-old Wallabies back row was subsequently accused of simulation by some, with a suggestion that that he had made more of an incident than it merited. Issuing a staunch defence of his player, Schmidt however revealed that the force registered by Tizzano's instrumented mouthguard indicated that he could have suffered injury in the collision, with contact made to the top of his back or back of his neck. Though he was fit to feature and did not suffer a concussion, Tizzano has been left out of the Wallabies' squad for the third Test in Sydney as Schmidt takes care of the player. 'He's had a really tough week,' Schmidt explained. 'He's copped a lot of online abuse. The only thing I'd say in defence of Carlo is that there were just over 54 Gs of force that went directly through the neck, which is enough to cause serious injury - not to a rugby player who is as well conditioned as Carlo. He's probably best left to take a deep breath. 'I think we are all aware of Newton's third law: For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. When that force hits him, and the speed of his head collapsing down, he recoiled out the back of the ruck. I don't think he wanted to recoil like that, but that's the nature of fore. There is an equal and opposite reaction. For Carlo, it's better that he sits this one out.' Tizzano's absence sees Schmidt revert to a five forwards to three backs bench split, with Langi Gleeson providing back row cover and Tom Hooper replacing Rob Valetini in the starting side. The debate over the decisive incident has raged since the conclusion of the second Test - World Rugby chief executive Alan Gilpin criticised comments made by Schmidt in the immediacy of Australia's defeat. The Wallabies boss praised referee Andrea Piardi on Thursday, suggesting he felt the Italian had a good game, despite his disagreement over the Morgan decision. The matter of online abuse on social media has been raised previously on this tour, with Lions fly half Owen Farrell describing both positive and negative commentary as 'poison'. Schmidt has told Tizzano, normally an active social media user, to avoid any of the commentary surrounding him. 'We weren't sure about him on Tuesday,' Schmidt said. 'He was still pretty sore. He was great today. He was right back to the irrepressible character he is. 'It's more come from other players. I've advised Carlo to stay away from the media full stop, and the opinions that are out there. We've tried to just deal in the facts, the facts of what is law and what forces occur, and to let him know that we know what caused the equal and opposite reaction. We have faith in him and that will continue.'
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
After-school carer charged with producing child abuse material at six facilities across northern Sydney
A male before- and after-school care staffer who was previously a New South Wales police officer has been charged with producing abuse material of children in his care, with authorities releasing a list of almost 60 facilities where he worked. The Australian federal police allege 26-year-old David James produced child abuse material of 10 children, aged between five and six, during his employment at six out-of-school hours (OOSH) care services in the northern suburbs of Sydney over three years, from April 2021 to May 2024. The AFP said there was no evidence to suggest alleged offending took place at any of the facilities James worked at beyond the six identified by authorities. 'It is important to note that all of the impacted families have been contacted by the AFP and NSW Health,' the AFP said. James was remanded in custody in October 2024; however, the accusations against him were only made public on Thursday after a court-ordered non-publication order was lifted. He has been charged with 13 offences, including nine counts of aggravated use of a child under 14 to make child abuse material; one count of using a child under 14 to make child abuse material; two counts of possessing child abuse material; and one count of contravening a warrant. James was initially arrested and charged with refusing to provide police with passcodes to his devices. After police gained access, officers located child abuse material and he was again arrested, the AFP alleged on Thursday. James worked with children as far back as 2018 across 58 different after-school and vacation care services across Sydney, according to police. 'AFP investigators have carefully scrutinised the available evidence to identify the scale and scope of the alleged offending,' the AFP acting sssistant Commissioner Brett James said. 'There is no evidence to suggest the man's alleged offending took place in out-of-school-hours facilities or other care providers which have not yet been contacted by law enforcement.' James worked at Knox Grammar high school from March 2018 to July 2020 and the YMCA in Bankstown in July 2018. His work history also shows he worked at OOSHs services in Stanmore, Ultimo, Erskineville, St Ives and Fort Street. The AFP said the families of all alleged victims had been contacted. 'This process resulted in letters being sent on 18 June 2025 to parents and carers of children who attended six Sydney-based care services where the man had been employed and where evidence of offending was identified by the AFP,' the police said in a statement on Thursday. NSW police confirmed on Thursday that James was a former officer. The force said he was employed as a probationary constable from December 2021 to September 2022. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion After failing to complete his probation, he stayed employed with the force in a civilian capacity until his resignation in May 2023. NSW police said that during his employment, James failed to seek the required approval to engage in secondary employment, therefore the 'police were unaware of his concurrent role in the childcare sector'. 'We acknowledge the seriousness of the allegations and condemn any behaviour that places our community's most vulnerable members at risk,' NSW police said in a statement. 'The NSWPF will continue to assist the AFP in its investigation and to ensure the safety and wellbeing of all affected individuals. As this remains an ongoing investigation, it would be inappropriate to comment further at this time.' Brett James said police were 'committed to supporting those families whose children's innocence was allegedly violated by a man trusted to take care of them'. 'Any form of child sexual abuse is confronting. Even more so when the alleged perpetrator is an individual trusted with the care of our youth,' he said. 'If parents are concerned, please visit the website dedicated to supporting families and the community seeking further information about the AFP investigation.'
