logo
The Barcelona effect on Spain: The pros and cons of a club dominating the national side

The Barcelona effect on Spain: The pros and cons of a club dominating the national side

New York Times16-07-2025
When you watch Spain you get the feeling this is a team that play alongside each other every weekend, as if it were club football rather than a group thrown together on the international stage.
The reason? In large part, it is because so many players come from one club, to a far greater extent than is usually the case with national teams.
Advertisement
Following Spain's 6-2 win over Belgium, The Athletic's Michael Cox wrote that 'it is not unfair to suggest that football this cohesive and sophisticated would have been almost unthinkable a decade ago in the women's game'.
Given the influence and volume of Barcelona players on Montse Tome's team, it comes as no surprise the reigning world champions have been one of the standout sides at the Women's Euros so far, winning all three of their group games, scoring 14 goals (no team has more) and setting up a quarter-final against hosts Switzerland on Friday.
In the 5-0 victory against Portugal, there were five Barcelona players in the starting line-up: Ona Batlle, Patri Guijarro, Vicky Lopez, Alexia Putellas and Claudia Pina. That's without adding Laia Aleixandri, who spent her formative years with Barca and has just re-signed for the Catalan club from Manchester City, or Mariona Caldentey, who played there for 10 years before leaving last summer.
That list of five might have been seven had Irene Paredes not been suspended and Cata Coll not had tonsillitis. Two-time Ballon d'Or winner Aitana Bonmati was only a substitute for the opening game because she was in the final stages of recovery from viral meningitis, which she contracted shortly before the start of the tournament. She was replaced in the starting line-up by another Barca player: Lopez. Two of their club team-mates were also brought on as substitutes: Salma Paralluelo and Jana Fernandez.
That makes eight of the 16 players who featured in the match.
In the thrashing of Belgium, the starting line-up was the same as against Portugal, with the addition of Paredes, and against Italy (3-1) changes were made but the side still featured six Barca players.
Fernandez replaced Batlle, Bonmati came in for Lopez and Pina did not play, but Paralluelo did. Leila Ouahabi, from Manchester City, has spent a huge part of her career at Barca. Eight of the 11 players selected for that match either play or have played for them. And that is even though Coll, who is expected to be the starting goalkeeper for the rest of the competition, has not yet made her first appearance at these Euros.
Advertisement
In a Nations League match on April 8 against Portugal (7-1), Tome fielded a starting XI of players who all either play for Barcelona now or had done at some point in their careers.
There were eight active Barca players (Coll, Fernandez, Paredes, Bonmati, Guijarro, Putellas, Pina, Paralluelo) along with Caldentey, Aleixandri and Ouahabi.
Of the 23 called up for Euro 2025, 10 are current Barcelona players — 11 if you count Aleixandri. Thirteen either are or have been Barcelona players.
But why is it like this?
Obviously, this dominance is not a coincidence — it is the result of years of strategic development, local talent cultivation and a footballing philosophy deeply rooted in the identity of both club and country.
The women's side of the Catalan club has never been stronger. They have played in the past five Champions League finals, winning three and losing two. In La Liga, they have been champions for six consecutive seasons.
While Barca do have overseas stars — their team that started the Champions League final in May included Denmark's Caroline Graham Hansen, Poland's Ewa Pajor and Sweden's Fridolina Rolfo — they have a strategy that prioritises local talent first. They consider Catalonia and Spain in general to be one of the best breeding grounds for footballers.
This is especially true for finding those who fit Barca's style of play — a game of touch, possession and attack that they believe is naturally understood by players who have grown up in the region.
Their plan is to build a solid core of Spaniards in the first team, complemented by international talent to make the team more complete and competitive.
This is true for both the women's and men's teams.
However, this has not always been the case. The turning point came in 2015, when Barcelona's women's side turned professional. Since then, they have become the best team in Spain, light years ahead of the rest — even Real Madrid.
Advertisement
This has also meant a better academy has been built and that players are being developed with a clear understanding of the Barca DNA. Lopez is a prime example — one of the first products to come out of La Masia, to have lived there and the 18-year-old is part of a generation that is already much better prepared for the first team than those players who came before her.
By focusing on local talent first, the club has become a breeding ground for players who are eligible to play for Spain. And if the team is at such a high level and has brought together one of its best generations, the answer is quite simple.
There is a stylistic synergy between club and the national team. Both sides emphasise possession-based football, positional play, and quick passing — hallmarks of the famed 'tiki-taka' approach that Barcelona helped define over the past two decades.
Tome — and Jorge Vilda before her — is aware of the advantage of fielding players accustomed to this system, so naturally leans on Barca's core group. These players do not just fit the style — they have lived and breathed it since they were young.
Choosing players who already have strong on-field relationships — like those built at club level — provides an invaluable advantage. And you can tell that while watching Spain games.
'The fact the national team has so many Barca players tells me that my club is doing a great job and that's why it's producing so many international players,' Putellas said in an interview with Diario Sport. 'Not just for Spain, but for other national teams as well. And it speaks highly of us, of the competitive team we have, all capable of playing in big games.'
That is why the best teams in Spain, which have won major titles, coincide with great generations of Barcelona players. The 2010 men's World Cup was won during Barca's 'Guardiola era', just one year after they won the club's first treble.
Advertisement
The same is true for the women's team, which is starting to win tournaments after previously always falling in the first knockout stage. Since 2023, they have won a World Cup and a Nations League, and they are clear favourites for the Euros. This is a period in which Barca have won consecutive Champions Leagues and reached a final, which they lost to Arsenal.
That is not to say there is no downside. Barca's dominance of the women's football landscape in Spain is self-perpetuating — the more successful they are, the more they attract the best young talent and the harder it is for other teams to compete. They have won the Liga F title by eight, 15, 10, 24 and 25 points respectively over the past five seasons. No other Spanish team has yet reached a Women's Champions League semi-final.
In the long run, this might not be healthy for Barcelona either because it means a less competitive league that does not help them prepare for European competitions.
Historically, Spain has nurtured and taken advantage of Barcelona's happy years, translating them into historic success for the national team. And seeing how the club are increasingly taking care of its football academy, it does not seem this dynamic is going to change.
Spain has its magic formula for success and the hope is they will capitalise on it this summer.
(Andrea Amato/NurPhoto via Getty Images).
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ashley Young officially signs for Championship club
Ashley Young officially signs for Championship club

Yahoo

time17 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Ashley Young officially signs for Championship club

Former Manchester United fullback Ashley Young has extended his remarkable professional career by signing with a Championship club. Long United career Young spent nine seasons at Old Trafford, playing 261 games and scoring 19 goals. The 40-year-old then moved to Inter Milan in 2019, winning a Serie A title before returning to England to play for Aston Villa. Young joined Everton two seasons ago and managed to play 70 games despite being in his late thirties. Rumours of Watford return The England international was released by Everton at the start of the summer but he spoke of his desire to keep on playing at the highest level he could. There were reports last week that Young was on the verge of returning to his former club Watford, but a deal never came to pass. He will be playing in the Championship next year though, as he has officially signed for recently relegated Ipswich Town. New adventure The Tractor Boys' official website states that, 'Ipswich Town is delighted to announce the signing of Ashley Young.' He has signed a one-year deal at the club, as they aim to make a rapid return to the Premier League. Commenting on the transfer Ipswich's manager Kieran McKenna claimed, 'Ashley has had a fantastic career and his achievements speak for themselves.' The Northern Irishman also added, 'he has maintained an extremely high level of professionalism and competitiveness through his career and he is still playing at a very good level. We feel his leadership and experience will be valuable to the group this season and he is very hungry to contribute on and off the pitch.' Mckenna pull Young gave his own thoughts on the move whilst speaking to the club's website and claimed that the manager was a big reason why he decided to join the Tractor Boys. McKenna was an assistant coach at United whilst Young was at the club and he spoke in glowing terms about his new manager. He stated, 'he's a winner and you see that on the training pitch and on the sidelines in the games. I got to see that day in day out. I have worked with him previously, so he was a massive pull.' Feature image Jan Kruger via Getty Images Follow us on Bluesky: @

Indian football 'hurt, scared' as domestic game hits fresh low
Indian football 'hurt, scared' as domestic game hits fresh low

Yahoo

time17 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Indian football 'hurt, scared' as domestic game hits fresh low

Former FIFA president Sepp Blatter once called India a "sleeping giant" of football, but the sport is mired in fresh crisis in the country and faces problems from the top down to grassroots. The men's national team are without a coach and the Indian Super League (ISL) -- India's top competition -- is in danger of collapsing over a dispute between the federation and its commercial partner. "Everybody in the Indian football ecosystem is worried, hurt, scared about the uncertainty we are faced with," Sunil Chhetri, the celebrated veteran striker, wrote on X about the fate of the ISL. The former national skipper unwittingly summed up one of the issues facing Indian football when he came out of international retirement in March aged 40. The striker has 95 goals for his country and is only behind Cristiano Ronaldo (138), Lionel Messi (112) and Ali Daei (108) in the all-time international scoring charts. His best days are well behind him, but with no younger replacements coming through he returned to the national side. India's men are 133rd in the FIFA rankings -- their lowest placing in nearly a decade -- and have won just one of their last 16 matches. They have never reached the World Cup and Spaniard Manolo Marquez stepped down this month as head coach after just one year and one win in eight games. His last act was to oversee a 1-0 defeat in Asian Cup qualifying to Hong Kong, population 7.5 million to India's 1.4 billion. - Disarray - The ISL is usually played between September and April. But a rights agreement between the All India Football Federation (AIFF) and Football Sports Development Limited (FSDL), the company which runs the ISL, ends on December 8 and is yet to be renewed. The league is now paralysed ahead of the new campaign and the uncertainty has affected over 5,000 players, coaches, staff and others. National football team director and former captain Subrata Paul is confident the sport in India -- a country obsessed with cricket -- will come out stronger. "Indian football, like any growing ecosystem, will face its share of challenges and transitions," Paul, regarded as one of India's best-ever goalkeepers, told AFP. "I see this as a time to pause, reflect and refocus. Yes, the recent results and the uncertainty around the ISL are difficult for all of us who love the game, but I see a silver lining as well. "It's an opportunity to strengthen our foundation by investing in youth development, infrastructure and quality coaching." The franchise-based ISL started in 2014 as a league that brought global stars including Italy's Alessandro Del Piero to India, and aimed to promote the game in a new avatar. Bur rather than boom, the ISL has seen dwindling TV ratings and falling sponsor interest. - Wenger help and hope - Football's global bosses have long been keen to tap the potential that India has as the world's most populous country. Arsene Wenger, the former Arsenal manager and now FIFA's chief of global football development, visited in 2023 to inaugurate an academy. AIFF president Kalyan Chaubey -- who is also a politician with the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party -- last month met Wenger, who has backed India's football development, particularly at grassroots level. Chaubey said Wenger believes starting football at 13 years of age, as is the norm in India, is too late. Players should start by eight, he said. While India have never reached the World Cup and again will be absent in North America next year, there has been modest success in the distant past. India qualified for the Olympics four times between 1948 and 1960. At the 1956 Melbourne Games India came fourth after losing the bronze-medal match to Bulgaria. Blatter in 2007 called India a "sleeping giant" -- but it remains in a deep slumber. - 'Own benefit' - Football is a distant third in popularity in India after cricket and hockey, with the eastern city of Kolkata and the southern state of Kerala hotspots for the sport. Compounding that, there has long been mismanagement by Indian football chiefs, said veteran sports journalist Jaydeep Basu. "The fact that the team which was ranked 99 in September 2023 has come down to 133 basically shows poor management," Basu told AFP. "There is a caucus working in the AIFF of two or three people who are running the show for their own benefit," added Basu, who recently authored a book, "Who stole my football?". AFP has contacted the AIFF for comment. fk/abh/pst

Euro 2025 semifinals: Aitana Bonmatí's game-winner in extra time lifts Spain over Germany
Euro 2025 semifinals: Aitana Bonmatí's game-winner in extra time lifts Spain over Germany

Yahoo

time36 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Euro 2025 semifinals: Aitana Bonmatí's game-winner in extra time lifts Spain over Germany

A rematch of the 2023 FIFA Women's World Cup final is on the way. Aitana Bonmatí beat Germany's Ann-Katrin Berger near post with an angled shot to the bottom right-corner in the 113th minute at Stadion Letzigrund in Zurich, Switzerland, to break a scoreless tie in extra time and send Spain to its first-ever UEFA Women's Euro final. Berger appeared to expect a cross, making an uncharacteristic error in judgement near the end of an otherwise fantastic outing. Germany, which won six straight Euros from the mid-'90s to the early 2010s, had never lost to Spain in a major tournament. In the nations' third such meeting, Spain prevailed. Spain will meet England on Sunday (Noon ET, Fox), which is coming off a shocking, and controversial, win over Italy on Tuesday. Spain dominated possession in the first half Wednesday, so much so that by the time it had completed 219 passes, Germany had completed only 39 passes. When intermission rolled around, Spain went into the break with 12 shot attempts, 10 more than Germany. [Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2025 NFL season] Germany opened the match with great physicality and never really relented, an impressive feat, especially after playing with 10 players throughout most of regulation, and then extra time, during its dramatic quarterfinal win in penalties over France. Germany mounted a trio of fouls in the first 12 minutes of action, but the whistles were worth it. Manager Christian Wück's squad seemed to rattle the usually clinical offensive operation of Spain, which entered the semifinal having scored 16 total goals in the tournament. That said, Spain created serious momentum toward the end of the first half. Esther González — who came into the day as the Golden Boot frontrunner with four goals — was at the heart of the surge. In the 41st minute, she won a corner kick, which led to a threatening Irene Paredes header that hit the right post. González tried a bicycle rebound, except it sailed high and wide. Minutes later, González made a run downfield. Patricia Guijarro found her, and González split Germany's Sophia Kleinherne and Carlotta Wamser. That time, though, her left-footed shot from the center of the box was saved by her NWSL Gotham FC teammate. Berger, the hero of Germany's quarterfinal win — and of the 2024 Olympics — recorded five first-half stops and eight total saves, the first of which saw her rise up and use her right hand to deflect a beamer from González over the bar. Berger's final save of the opening frame came in its waning seconds, as she secured a Clàudia Pina shot that didn't have the power necessary to find twine. The halftime whistle halted Spain's push and gave Germany a chance to reset. Germany came out swinging in the second half, matching its first-half shot total in just four minutes. Still, Germany didn't record a shot on goal until the 63rd minute when Klara Bühl's attempt from the left side of the box was saved by Spain's Cata Coll. Giovanna Hoffmann played Bühl into the shot, but Hoffman previously missed some critical chances of her own midway through the first half. First, after Jule Brand sent a cross into the middle, Hoffman swung and missed, affording Spain an opportunity to clear. Then, just three minutes later, Hoffman was barely offsides at the time of a brilliant throughball from Carlotta Wamser. Even if Hoffman wasn't offsides, though, it's worth noting that her 1-on-1 shot dragged wide of the cage. Spain manager Montserrat Tomé subbed out González at the 68th minute, making way for Salma Paralluelo. To break the tie in regulation, Spain needed scoring from two-time Ballon d'Or winners Alexia Putellas and Bonmatí or anyone else in its lineup. Paralluelo had her chances in the late stages of the second half, but she couldn't come through, either. Germany dared to end the match in added time with two of its three shots on net in regulation, in succession. Coll, showing she can go toe-to-toe with Berger on the other end, made a double save, first going off her line to track a deflection and then using her legs to stop a follow-up shot. In what was the fourth of six knockout games in this year's Euros to reach extra time, Germany and Spain traded opportunities. Germany's Wamser rifled a shot over the bar. Spain's Paralluelo threatened before Kleinherne cut her path to goal short with a challenge that came at a cost — she became the latest German player to suffer an injury in the tournament. Despite Germany's fight, however, Spain proved too much to overcome in the second period of extra time. That's when Bonmatí scored her game-winner. Here's how the thrilling semifinal match unfolded:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store