EXCLUSIVE Real estate agents getting rich on Australia's housing crisis is a 'kick in the guts' for struggling households
According to property comparison site, bRight Agent, a Perth home worth $1million in 2020 would be worth roughly $1.7million today.
This means a real estate agent charging a two per cent commission would today earn $35,200 compared to $20,000 five years ago.
While Perth's property market is an outlier, all major Australian cities have seen significant growth in the past five years.
Aaron Scott, who co-founded the comparison service, said homeowners shouldn't be expected to pay agents so much more for the same amount of work.
He told Daily Mail Australia that while agents deserved to be well-paid, the flashy wealth of the top earners is a 'kick in the guts' amid a worsening housing crisis.
'Let's face it - the extravagance often seen in the real estate industry, whether it be designer clothes, cars, or partying on yachts, is done on the backs of Australian families who are trying to keep up with their repayments and keep a roof over their heads,' he said.
'We don't think that Aussies should be forking out an extra $10,000, $15,000 or $20,000 in costs to sell their home, just because the property value has increased.
'Aussies work really hard for the equity that they put into their homes over the years, so it really doesn't make sense that selling costs increase at the same rate.'
Mr Scott said it was worth asking whether commissions should be regulated at an industry level, in the same way the states restrict the movement of rent and bills.
'If we're good enough to regulate the rate of increase of rents... shouldn't we be good enough to regulate the increase of selling costs?'
State and territory governments have previously capped the commission an agent could charge for residential property transactions.
Queensland was the last state to deregulate, having only done away with its cap of 2.5 per cent of the purchase price in 2014.
While it is difficult to calculate the impact of deregulation on commissions, the Real Estate Institute of Australia insists it has allowed agents to lower their fees.
'Commission rates in Australia have been deregulated for many years, and this has created strong competition in the industry, which has helped bring fees down rather than push them up,' a REIA spokesperson told Daily Mail Australia.
'Agents now work in a highly competitive environment where many charge well under 2 per cent, and in some metro markets, even below 1 per cent.
'While some regional areas still see rates around 3 per cent, those cases are the exception rather than the norm.'
But others tell a different story, including former agent Neil Jenman who claims commissions soared as agents were left to negotiate their own fees.
'When real estate commissions were fixed in the early 90s, the real estate industry convinced governments across Australia to deregulate the commissions on the basis that they would fall,' he told Daily Mail Australia.
'Of course they all giggled when the governments fell for it, because real estate commissions soared.'
Mr Jenman claimed commissions in certain parts of western Sydney had surged by roughly ten times since he practised there about 30 years ago.
'When I was an agent, my average fee per sale was $3,500 (in 1995). Today, in the same area, the average fee is $35,000,' he said.
The spoils are not evenly spread among real estate agents, with the millions raked in by top earners well outpacing the average salary of between $75,000 to $95,000.
Neither is it clear whether increasing saturation in the job market has reduced the number of sales agents are securing, as suggested by a CoreLogic spokesperson.
But many, like Mr Jenman, think the fees charged by agents should be more closely tied to the work they put in, rather than simply the value of the sale.
'Some agents in Australia who are selling one house a month (a pitiful performance - less than eight hours 'work') are earning a million dollars a year,' he said.
'There's an agent in the eastern suburbs who boasts that he doesn't get out of bed for less than $100,000 commission per house.
'There is more money in real estate than in drug dealing.'
Simon Murphy, a former real estate agent and founder of Melbourne Property Advocate, agreed, saying the commission system is 'broken'.
'The problem's not just how much agents charge. It's what they actually do for that money,' he told Daily Mail Australia.
'Agents throw the property online, run a couple of open homes, pass on some feedback, and somehow walk away with twenty grand or more.
'They're not really selling. They're just listing. That's not strategy. That's admin in a suit.'
Mr Murphy acknowledged negotiating is a valuable skill but said too often agents were refusing to do the heavy lifting, relying on Australia's strong housing market.
'Most (agents) are just middlemen cashing in on a system that hasn't changed in years,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
42 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Gaudy lifestyle of controversial real estate agent who drives a $300,000 luxury car and boasts a $15million property empire - as three-year probe into alleged underquoting draws near
High-flying real estate agent Josh Tesolin may be under investigation by NSW Fair Trading, but he hasn't let that put a dampener on his lavish lifestyle. Despite the official scrutiny, Tesolin remains one of Australia's highest-performing agents, reportedly raking in $9million in commissions over the past financial year. Tesolin isn't just a top-selling real estate agent – he and his wife, Sophia, have amassed a property portfolio estimated at more than $15million. This includes a four-bedroom home in Bella Vista, purchased for $2.3million in July 2021, and a five-bedroom house in Rozelle, which sold for $2.2million in 2024. Tesolin also owns two investment properties on the outskirts of Brisbane, acquired for a combined $789,000. He drives a Bentley Bentayga, which start at around $395,800, and has a penchant for Gucci and Louis Vuitton loafers, which retail for $1,600 and $1,700 respectively. Tesolin is also known for his flashy custom suits, including a jacket lined with images of homes he seemingly had a hand in selling, worn at a conference in New Zealand. And on the agent's wrist? A Rolex Day-Date, known as the 'President' model thanks to its association with global power players, which start at around $62,000. The Rolex was made famous by US Presidents like Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, and Donald Trump, as well as cultural icons Michael Jordan, Jay-Z, and Warren Buffett. Tesolin is also known for gifting luxury timepieces to his staff to mark milestones. One post on social media shows the agent gifting a sales agent a rose gold Rolex, estimated to be valued at over $50,000. In another, a watch worth an estimated $35,000 was handed out. Tesolin, who regularly wears colourful socks, has previously joked that the cartoon patterns help him stay 'relatable' to his clients. 'Vendors often judge agents from the outside - assuming we're arrogant or overly serious - but when I show up in Gucci shoes, a custom suit, and socks with flying pigs, it breaks the ice, makes me more approachable, and shows I don't take myself too seriously,' he told the One Life Club podcast in January, 2024. In 2021, Tesolin was awarded the Number 1 Agent in Australia by RateMyAgent, a title he secured four years in a row, from 2020 to 2023. His wife is listed as the office manager at Ray White Quakers Hill in Sydney's northwest, where Josh is the owner and principal. Daily Mail Australia in April revealed Tesolin and his agency were at the centre of a NSW Fair Trading investigation into underquoting and complaints. The agent publicly acknowledged the investigation for the first time in a podcast interview with disgraced agent Adrian Bo. 'What are we being investigated for? Fair Trading came in, asked for files, we complied with the regulator,' Tesolin said. 'Anything the regulator has asked, whether it be 500 files... three files... we have completely complied with the regulator at every single stage.' A Fair Trading spokesperson last week confirmed the investigation was ongoing. 'The Strata and Property Services Taskforce within NSW Fair Trading is investigating Quakers Hill Ray White Real Estate and Josh Tesolin following proactive compliance blitzes into underquoting and complaints,' they said. 'As this investigation is ongoing, no further comment is available at this time.' The inquiry is expected to wrap up in the coming weeks. Daily Mail Australia does not suggest Tesolin has engaged in underquoting, only that his agency is the subject of an active investigation.
Daily Mail
42 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Property asking prices fall AGAIN as Rightmove records worst seasonal dip in more than 20 years
Property asking prices fell by £4,531 on average this month, according to latest figures from Rightmove. It revealed the average price of property coming to the market for sale dropped by 1.2 per cent in July. It means the average newly listed home is now £373,709, down from a record high of £379,517 in May. While there's usually a seasonal dip in prices in July, according to Rightmove, this is the largest monthly price drop at this time of year recorded for more than 20 years of data. As a result, Britain's biggest property portal has cut its price forecasts for the year in half, downgrading its property price predictions for 2025 from 4 per cent growth to just 2 per cent. Dipping: Newly listed asking prices were almost £6,000 lower in July than they were in May A glut of homes on the market is predominantly the cause, according to Rightmove. It says the number of homes for sale remains at a 10 year high with an over-supply keeping a lid on prices, compounded by the start of the traditional summer holiday season. Separate figures from Zoopla showed there were 37 homes for sale per estate agent branch in June on average across the country. That number is up from 31 at the start of 2025 with the number of homes per estate agent rising every month so far this year. It also is a massive increase compared to previous years. For example in June 2023 there was an average of 27 homes for sale per estate agent office while in June 2021 and 2022 there were 18 homes for sale per agent. Rightmove says that pricing is key, and sellers who are over-optimistic on their initial asking price are increasingly at risk of getting lost among the competition. 'What's most important to remember in this market is that the price is key to selling,' said Colleen Babcock, property expert at Rightmove. 'The decade-high level of buyer choice means that discerning buyers can quickly spot when a home looks over-priced compared to the many others that may be available in their area. 'It appears that more new sellers are conscious of this and are responding to this high-supply market with stand-out pricing to entice buyers and get their home sold.' What are asking prices doing in different areas? Beneath the headline national monthly price fall this July, the picture isn't the same across the whole of Great Britain. In the South East, average newly listed asking prices fell by 1.2 per cent this month while in the East Midlands they were flat. London has seen the biggest regional monthly price fall, dropping 1.5 per cent, driven especially by Inner London. Certain parts of London have seen significant falls this month. Newly listed asking prices in Camden were 2.7 per cent lower than in June, while Westminster recorded a 2.9 per cent decline. Asking prices in Hammersmith and Fulham fell 2.5 per cent while in Southwark they dropped 2.7 per cent. Rightmove says April's increase in residential stamp duty in England has had a greater impact in London where property prices are higher, while last year's increase in stamp duty for investment and second homes will also be having an effect. A landlord or second home buyer purchasing a £1million property in the capital can now expect to pay £93,750 in stamp duty. Additionally, changes to non-dom tax rules and uncertainty around future tax changes may be affecting investment into the central London market. Jeremy Leaf, north London estate agent and a former RICS residential chairman, says the figures confirm what 'he's been seeing on the ground' recently. 'Asking prices are not of course values but invariably an owner's aspirational starting point to determine if genuine buyers are attracted,' said Leaf. 'Sales are still being agreed but nearly always with sellers who have recognised the importance of setting a realistic initial figure to differentiate themselves from so much other, often similar, property. 'Otherwise, buyers will take even more time waiting for the 'right' property and perhaps worrying about the possibility of autumn tax rises despite improving affordability – including the likelihood of imminent mortgage rate cuts.' However, while London asking prices fell, there are regions where asking prices rose in July. The North East, which is the least expensive region of the UK, has seen a 1.2 per cent increase in prices this month, continuing the trend of cheaper areas seeing faster price growth. Will prices go up from here? With mortgage rates falling and two more interest rate cuts still expected in 2025, the overall outlook for the second half of the year remains positive, albeit from Rightmove's perspective. For some people, property may seem more affordable than it has done in recent years. The average newly listed asking price for a UK home is now just 0.1 per cent higher than a year ago, while average earnings are up by over 5 per cent. Meanwhile, average two-year fixed mortgage rate is now 4.53 per cent, according to Rightmove, compared with 5.34 per cent at this time last year. For someone purchasing a home at the average asking price, this equates to a saving of nearly £150 per month on a new mortgage over 30 years and with a 20 per cent deposit. Experts at the property portal are expecting the annual rate of growth to increase from its current 0.1 per cent, as they say the number of buyers out house hunting is encouraging. 'It's been a promising first half of the year for activity levels, particularly when you consider that some will have brought their plans forward to try to avoid added stamp duty from April,' added Babcock. 'Even after the stamp duty deadline, we're seeing more sales being agreed and more new potential buyers entering the market than at the same time last year. 'Looking ahead to the second half of 2025, there will still very likely be the usual quieter seasonal periods around the summer holidays and Christmas, but we expect market activity to continue to be resilient. 'Crucially, buyer affordability is heading in the right direction, and another two Bank Rate cuts before 2026 would be a big boost to this.' How to find a new mortgage Borrowers who need a mortgage because their current fixed rate deal is ending, or they are buying a home, should explore their options as soon as possible. Buy-to-let landlords should also act as soon as they can. Quick mortgage finder links with This is Money's partner L&C > Mortgage rates calculator > Find the right mortgage for you What if I need to remortgage? Borrowers should compare rates, speak to a mortgage broker and be prepared to act. Homeowners can lock in to a new deal six to nine months in advance, often with no obligation to take it. Most mortgage deals allow fees to be added to the loan and only be charged when it is taken out. This means borrowers can secure a rate without paying expensive arrangement fees. Keep in mind that by doing this and not clearing the fee on completion, interest will be paid on the fee amount over the entire term of the loan, so this may not be the best option for everyone. What if I am buying a home? Those with home purchases agreed should also aim to secure rates as soon as possible, so they know exactly what their monthly payments will be. Buyers should avoid overstretching and be aware that house prices may fall, as higher mortgage rates limit people's borrowing ability and buying power. What about buy-to-let landlords Buy-to-let landlords with interest-only mortgages will see a greater jump in monthly costs than homeowners on residential mortgages. This makes remortgaging in plenty of time essential and our partner L&C can help with buy-to-let mortgages too. How to compare mortgage costs The best way to compare mortgage costs and find the right deal for you is to speak to a broker. This is Money has a long-standing partnership with fee-free broker L&C, to provide you with fee-free expert mortgage advice. Interested in seeing today's best mortgage rates? Use This is Money and L&Cs best mortgage rates calculator to show deals matching your home value, mortgage size, term and fixed rate needs. If you're ready to find your next mortgage, why not use L&C's online Mortgage Finder. It will search 1,000's of deals from more than 90 different lenders to discover the best deal for you. > Find your best mortgage deal with This is Money and L&C Be aware that rates can change quickly, however, and so if you need a mortgage or want to compare rates, speak to L&C as soon as possible, so they can help you find the right mortgage for you.
Daily Mail
42 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
How Australia will be 'begging for migrants' as the nation's birth rate crashes to new low
Australia is hurtling towards a population crisis, with birth rates plummeting so fast experts warn the country will soon be begging for migrants just to keep the economy afloat. The nation's birth rate is at an all-time low, according the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), with the number of babies born not high enough to sustain the population. Renowned Queensland-based evolutionary psychologist Dr Bill von Hippel has warned the global decline in babies 'raises alarms' that humanity could begin to shrink without urgent intervention. In Australia, the trend is already well underway, with the birth rate plunging from 3.55 children per woman in 1960 to just 1.5 today - well below the level of 2.1 births per woman needed to sustain the nation's population of 27million. Dr von Hippel said low birth rates would inevitably drive governments to 'fight to let migrants in, not keep them out' to support an ageing population, workforce needs, and public services. 'If you look at the current population of the globe, it's meant to peak somewhere between 2070 and 2090, probably around eight billion and some change,' he told the Diary of a CEO podcast. 'And then it starts to go down, and then it may continue to go down forever.' Dr von Hippel said many Asian countries and half of western Europe had populations shrinking 'crazy fast' with Japan demolishing homes because there was nobody to buy them. That declining birth rate trend across rich, industrialised nations will propel them to outbid each other to lure migrant workers to live there. 'In 50 years, that argument is going to be how can we convince people of country X to come into our country because we're going to shrink and disappear,' he said. 'There are a lot of countries that are going to be literally half their size by the year 2100 because they're shrinking so fast.' Dr von Hippel said humans may start to have more children if robots take over some of the hard slog of parenting. Futurologist Rocky Scopelliti said in the future, nations won't fight wars over oil, they'll compete over nurses, engineers, and coders. 'Australia's fertility rate has dropped to 1.5, well below the replacement level of 2.1,' he said. 'This means fewer taxpayers, fewer workers, and a growing burden on a shrinking younger population to support an ageing one. 'By 2060, there will be just 2.7 working-age Australians for every person over 65, down from 7.4 in the 1970s. 'That spells serious strain on our healthcare, pensions, housing, and productivity.' Mr Scopelliti said as birth rates fell, a global talent war was brewing, with skilled migrants poised to become the world's most coveted asset. 'Australia can't assume it will stay on top,' he said. 'Canada has already outpaced us in attracting young, skilled migrants with streamlined visa processes and family-friendly resettlement policies. 'Australia must modernise its migration strategy, making it easier for workers, families, and students to stay long-term and integrate. 'If we hesitate, we'll lose out to more nimble nations.' Mr Scopelliti said countries such as Japan and South Korea were examples of what happens when demographic inertia sets in with fewer births, lower economic growth, and a struggle to fund basic services. 'Australia is not immune,' he said. 'We're at a pivotal crossroads. While slower population growth may benefit the planet in environmental terms, without strategic foresight, it could also lead to economic stagnation and declining innovation.' He said Australia has a unique opportunity with world-class education, political stability, lifestyle, and proximity to Asia. 'But we must improve liveability, housing affordability, and pathways to permanent residency,' he said. 'We need a bold migration brand strategy. 'If migrants are the gold of the 21st century, Australia must become the vault everyone wants to be in.' Outspoken billionaire Elon Musk has warned the world about declining birth and fertility rates. Musk, a father of 12, said the trend poses a significant risk to humanity. 'Population collapse due to low birth rates is a much bigger risk to civilisation than global warming,' he said in 2022. Musk said: 'A lot of people are under the impression that the current number of humans is unsustainable on the planet. 'That is totally untrue. The population density is actually quite low.' Emeritus Professor of Demography Peter McDonald from the Australian National University in Canberra stated that there are several reasons why young Australian women are delaying having children, or not at all. 'Establishing themselves in career, younger people have been putting off life and settling down, by staying in education longer, by travelling and all of those things lead to things occurring later,' he said. The professor said governments could pull two policy levers to increase fertility rates. 'One is affordable housing, and the other is affordable childcare,' he said.
