Visual errors in China paragliding accident clip suggest AI use
"Yesterday, a paraglider named Liu Ge set a new world record for the altitude of a conscious human flight in the #Qilian Mountains," reads a Douyin post on May 25, 2025 written in simplified Chinese, referring to the cluster of peaks in northern China.
Footage in the post supposedly shows three clips from the accident -- an aerial view of the man followed by a closer angle apparently from a sports camera and finally visuals of the paraglider covered with ice and flying over clouds.
Similar visuals surfaced on X and Facebook after Chinese media reported a paraglider named Peng Yujiang was carried away by a sudden updraft to an altitude of over 8,500 kilometres (5,200 miles) while training in the Qilian Mountains in Gansu Province on May 24.
Peng lost consciousness for a short time before he regained awareness and operated the paraglider back to the ground, according to an article from state-run broadcaster CCTV (archived link).
According to an incident report issued by the Gansu Province Aviation Sports Association, Peng was banned from flying for six months although authorities said his ground training did not require prior approval (archived link).
Multiple paragliding experts told AFP there have been previous cases of paragliders being carried up to dangerous heights.
"It is possible to get carried up to extreme altitudes, but it also happens to be very easily avoidable. This can only happen in cumulonimbus clouds, aka thunderstorms," said Emil Kaminski, safety officer at the Hong Kong Paragliding Association.
"Pilots who have been lifted to such dangerous heights have either intentionally flown into them OR inadvertently flown into them because not paying attention to weather OR due to poor training, poor understanding of the weather."
"This is very rare (to be accidentally carried to such an altitude) but it is possible," Geoff Davison, a paragliding instructor at Fly Koh Larn in Thailand, separately said.
However, the circulating footage is not an accurate depiction of the incident.
A reverse image search using a keyframe found the first five seconds in the compilation matches a clip posted May 26 on Facebook that bears the watermark of Doubao AI, a ChatGPT-like conversational bot created by TikTok owner ByteDance (archived link).
The subsequent clips have inconsistent visuals, an AFP analysis found. The colour of the paraglider's helmet and the straps of the equipment are initially white but inexplicably turn black.
The man's legs are also depicted hanging out of the paraglider at first but is later shown as covered by an insulating cocoon.
Despite the meteoric progress in Generative AI, errors still show up in AI-generated content. These defects are the best way to recognise a fabricated image.
Multiple news organisations including Reuters, NBC News and ABC News said they took down footage of the incident from CCTV after they found signs of AI (archived here, here and here).
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Bricks from Malaysia and New Jersey misrepresented amid LA unrest
"Soros funded organizations have ordered countless pallets of bricks to be placed near ICE facilities to be used by Democrat militants against ICE," says a June 7, 2025 Facebook post from David Harris Jr, a commentator supportive of US President Donald Trump whom AFP has previously fact-checked for spreading misinformation. The post references George Soros, a billionaire Democratic megadonor commonly targeted by right-wing and anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. In another post shared June 8 on X, American actor James Woods, who has also repeatedly peddled misinformation, shared a photo of a different stack of masonry. "It's not like these 'protests' are organized though…," he wrote. Similar claims citing either of the two images of bricks rocketed across social media platforms amid protests in Los Angeles that broke out June 6, triggered by immigration raids and arrests of what federal authorities say are undocumented migrants and gang members. Los Angeles officials have said the demonstrations were in large part peaceful but punctuated by scattered violence, including moments during which participants torched cars and law enforcement fired tear gas. The unrest continued to escalate over several days, with Trump clashing with California leaders as he bypassed the governor to deploy the state's National Guard to the city -- and active-duty US Marines. Other protests have also spread elsewhere in the country. Local news outlets have reported that some of the protesters in Los Angeles have thrown objects at officers and police cruisers, including rocks and fireworks. But the two widely shared photos showing stacks of bricks are unrelated. Reverse image searches traced the first image to a Malaysian hardware and construction dealer's page on Building Materials Online, a Malaysian online marketplace (archived here and here). The distributor, Ng Lian Seng Hardware Trading, is based in the town of Jinjang, northwest of Malaysia's capital, Kuala Lumpur. Reached by AFP, a worker at the dealer said the store took the picture and uploaded it to Build Materials Online more than eight years ago. Google Street View imagery appears to show matching pallets of bricks piled up at the location (archived here). The second photo can be geolocated using Google Street View to West New York, New Jersey (archived here). A journalist with the fact-checking website Lead Stories visited the location June 9 and photographed additional construction equipment they found stationed beside the same heap of bricks (archived here). They also observed scaffolding set up along a nearby building, where contractors appeared to be working on the exterior. Fearmongering narratives about piles of bricks have become a common trope among accounts that traffic in misinformation since the nationwide protests that followed the police killing of George Floyd in 2020, when images from construction sites were misrepresented in posts claiming authorities or left-wing groups were stashing bricks near planned demonstrations to foment violence. Similar claims have resurfaced around prominent court trials, trucker convoys and the 2024 Democratic National Convention, where protesters demonstrated against Israel's war with Hamas in Gaza. "These days, it feels like every time there's a protest, the old clickbaity 'pallets of bricks' hoax shows up right on cue," said the Social Media Lab, a research center at Toronto Metropolitan University, in a June 9 post on Bluesky (archived here and here). "You know the one, photos or videos of bricks supposedly left out to encourage rioting. It's catnip for right-wing agitators and grifters," it added. AFP has debunked other misinformation about the Los Angeles protests here, here and here.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Aspen Police Department Warns Kids Having Fun Is a Crime
"When you see this, do you think it's just fun? Or do you think that it's illegal? It is definitely the latter. Whether it's fun or not." This is the beginning of a Facebook post by Colorado's Aspen Police Department (APD). What is this possibly fun but definitely illegal activity? The post includes a photo that shows two children on a bike—one child sitting on the seat and the other on the first rider's lap—riding on a sidewalk. "Colorado law says that two-up riding on a single seat bike is against the law, and of course, bikes are not allowed on sidewalks," the post continues. "These 'Sidewalk Sallys' could potentially hurt themselves or others." (If you had to Google "Sidewalk Sally" you are not alone, as it's not a real term. A daytime talk show seems to have coined and used it once, unrelated to riding a bike on a sidewalk.) The APD post goes on to inform Aspen's citizens that this behavior could result in a "ticket or a trip to the emergency room," both of which seem like rather dramatic consequences for an activity that has been popular since the invention of bikes. The tone-deaf post is signed "The Aspen Police Department—protecting the Wild West on two wheels since the 1880s," which seems to inadvertently imply that APD officers get around exclusively on bikes. The post has garnered over 300 comments—far more than the department's other posts—most of which are not thankful for the Department's caution and concern: "Tell me you don't have real crimes in Aspen without telling me you don't have real crimes." "'Kids never go outside anymore!' Proceeds to police every single thing kids do." "Lol yes. Our children should really be playing IN the traffic. Not away from it. Got it." (That one really resonated. My mom made me ride on the sidewalks, so it's not obvious to all of us that biking on the sidewalk is a crime.) Many of the comments were very libertarian-toned, naturally: "So basically every kid since the bicycle was invented has broken the law!" "Find a crime to deal with or reduce your force." "The more laws you make, the more police you have to hire to enforce new laws, the more police you hire to enforce those new laws, the more criminals you make. This pattern doesn't stop one day. It keeps growing." Several commenters asked if the page was satire, while one dealt a devastating blow: "Colorado used to be cool." Despite this, in 2022, Colorado Gov. Jared Polis signed the Reasonable Independence for Children law, clarifying that "a child is not neglected when allowed to participate in certain independent activities that a reasonable and prudent parent, guardian, or legal custodian would consider safe given the child's maturity, condition, and abilities." Utah passed the first such law in 2018 and has since been joined by Oklahoma, Texas, Colorado, Virginia, Illinois, Connecticut, and Montana. This year alone, Georgia and Missouri also passed similar legislation, with Florida expected to follow soon. Let Grow, the nonprofit I run, supported all of these laws and continues to work with broad coalitions to see legislative protections for childhood independence enacted. No child should be treated like a criminal for riding a bike with a friend. And no police department should be proud of doing so. Facebook commenters know this. Hopefully, the APD will catch up soon. The post Aspen Police Department Warns Kids Having Fun Is a Crime appeared first on
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Police assault arrest as dozens involved in disorder
A teenage girl has been arrested on suspicion of assaulting a police officer after dozens of people joined disorder that saw cars set on fire and bricks being hurled in Salford. About 50 to 60 people gathered during the disturbance in the city's Lower Broughton Road at about 13:30 BST, Greater Manchester Police said. Cars were stolen and set on fire, motorbikes were being ridden erratically and bricks thrown at officers, while wheelie bins and cars were used to block off the road, the force said. A 16-year-old girl was arrested on suspicion of assaulting an officer. The windscreen of a police vehicle was smashed during the disruption. A video shared on social media appeared to show a Fiat 500 reversing at speed along the road with its boot open, as another car followed it. Supt Marcus Noden said: "We are aware of speculation online that this incident is linked to immigration. This is categorically incorrect. "This sort of behaviour will not be tolerated and we took robust and appropriate action. "A large number of officers will be remaining in the area over night as a precaution. "There are currently no ongoing incidents in the area, however, tensions remain heightened, and we have robust plans in place, should we need to respond to any further incidents." A dispersal order would remain in place until 14:00 BST on Thursday, police said. Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230. Salford Police
