logo
Winnipeg Transit redesign leaves the North End behind

Winnipeg Transit redesign leaves the North End behind

Opinion
I have fond memories of my first bus pass. The sense of freedom was unparalleled, and I'm sure my mother appreciated not having to drive me to work anymore. Here in Winnipeg, we pride ourselves on raising hardy kids. It's the kind of grit you need to survive. But even the hardiest among us shouldn't have to walk six blocks to a bus stop in the pitch dark while the wind cuts through like a knife.
If the people who designed the new Winnipeg Transit system had ever waited for a bus at Redwood and Main in January, they might have thought twice.
The new Primary Transit Network has been framed as an efficiency upgrade. For those of us living in the North End, it feels like something else entirely, something more akin to abandonment.
JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS
Transit changes that were put in place on June 29 seem to have left some neighbourhoods behind.
Transit service has been cut or reduced in many of the areas where it is most needed. The 17, 38, and 71 routes, among others, were either eliminated or significantly rerouted. Dozens of stops were removed from Main Street alone, with the FX2 and FX3 replacing frequent local service with limited-stop express buses that often bypass residential pockets entirely. Transfers are now unavoidable. For those with options, this might be inconvenient. For many of us, it's disruptive. For some, it's disabling.
In some North End neighbourhoods, over 30 per cent of households don't own a vehicle. Walking long distances to transfer points, especially in winter, isn't just difficult, it can be dangerous. The city removed approximately 1,700 bus stops during the redesign, and while officials have not released a public breakdown by neighbourhood, riders in the North End have reported a disproportionate loss of coverage. Main Street alone lost numerous stops, and key transfer points like Redwood and Main were eliminated without alternatives nearby. Riders have noted having to walk multiple blocks further, often in areas without sidewalks or shelters.
Meanwhile, the new network prioritizes high-frequency routes along major corridors, many of which run through the south and southwest. The Blue Line, Winnipeg's flagship rapid transit spine, cuts through Fort Garry and south Pembina, areas with stronger economic growth and higher rates of car ownership. The network now extends all the way to St. Norbert.
The expansion of service into new suburban areas raises a serious and uncomfortable question: how many stops were eliminated in the inner city and North End to make that possible?
What did we sacrifice to serve sprawl?
City officials point out that the network redesign was service-hour neutral, meaning the total hours of service citywide remain roughly the same.
But equity isn't measured in aggregate hours. It's not about giving everyone the same thing. It's about giving people what they need. Equality would give every neighbourhood a bus. Equity recognizes that some neighbourhoods need more buses because they have fewer cars, fewer alternatives, and more people depending on public transit to survive.
Winnipeg Transit's weekday ridership reached an average of 225,400 in early 2025, and the system recorded 47.8 million rides in 2024, nearly back to pre-pandemic levels. But that 'recovery' hides real disparity. While Rapid Transit routes in the south grow and thrive, riders in the North End are watching their service evaporate. And when ridership drops in these communities, as it inevitably does when stops vanish and routes are broken, they'll be blamed for it.
We also need to talk about the role of political leadership in all this. Mayor Scott Gillingham, during his time as chair of the finance committee under then-mayor Brian Bowman, supported multi-year budgets that effectively froze or reduced transit funding when adjusted for inflation. These budget decisions constrained Winnipeg Transit's ability to hire operators, replace aging buses, or expand service.
Fast forward a few years, and Gillingham now expresses concern over declining ridership and system gaps, as if he hadn't played a central role in underfunding the system in the first place. You can't gut a service and then act surprised when it fails to meet public need.
I keep coming back to the question, why did our city councillors allow this to move forward? Especially those representing wards like Point Douglas, Mynarski, and Elmwood-East Kildonan. Did they not see what this would do to their constituents?
The Winnipeg Transit Master Plan was approved in 2021, and revised in early 2025 after feedback. Yet many residents say they were never informed or consulted meaningfully. Public meetings were held, but largely online, and mostly attended by more affluent users. Those most affected had the least opportunity to shape the outcome.
There is currently no publicly available data showing how stop removals were distributed across neighbourhoods. If the city is confident this plan serves all of Winnipeg fairly, they should release stop-level data and let the public see for themselves.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
Until then, it falls to community members and advocates to track what was lost. A simple overlay of the old and new network maps, if allowed through GIS data, would quickly reveal where access was cut, and ultimately, who paid the price.
This isn't about nostalgia for an older system. It's about whether a public service still serves the public. The Transit Master Plan talks about building a 'resilient and equitable' system.
But in execution, the city has privileged efficiency over access, and growth corridors over existing communities. If equity was ever on the table, it didn't survive implementation.
Transit can be modern. It can be fast and efficient. But if it isn't fair, it isn't working. And right now, it's not working for the North End.
MJ Jonasson is a Winnipeg-based thinker and advocate for community-driven change. With a background in advocacy, Indigenous social innovation, and social entrepreneurship, she collaborates with communities to develop meaningful solutions that challenge systemic inequities.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Homemade
Homemade

Winnipeg Free Press

time6 hours ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Homemade

Welcome to Homemade, a Winnipeg Free Press project celebrating home cooking in Manitoba. We regularly publish recipe features that highlight the communities, traditions and flavours of this wonderfully diverse province. Submit your recipe to have your dish considered for a future story — recipes can be beloved family favourites or everyday staples. Submit a Recipe Eva Wasney 8 minute read 5:05 PM CDT Homemade is a series that celebrates home cooking in Manitoba. Find more stories, ideas and share your recipes at In today's Homemade Cooking School lesson, chef Mandy Wingert walks us through the basics of stocks and sauces — essential culinary components designed to enhance the flavour, moisture and texture of a dish. 'It's like the foundation of your house. If you don't have a good stock, you're going to be playing catch-up trying to make things taste better,' says Wingert, a culinary and baking instructor at Red River College Polytechnic. Originally from Saskatchewan, she grew up in a family of cooks and knew from an early age she wanted to pursue a career in food. We try reader-submitted Jell-O recipes Eva Wasney 8 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 8 minute read Wednesday, Jul. 9, 2025 Saturday is Eat Your Jell-O Day. In honour of this gelatinous holiday, we've done just that. Read Wednesday, Jul. 9, 2025 EVA WASNEY / FREE PRESS Clockwise from top left: Broken glass torte, spring parfait salad, orange jellied salad, tomato aspic. Salads add colour, texture, freshness and acidity to any dinner table Eva Wasney 4 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 4 minute read Wednesday, Jun. 25, 2025 Unlike most of The Simpsons clan, I'm of the opinion that you can, in fact, win friends with salad. And not because of their purported 'health benefits.' Read Wednesday, Jun. 25, 2025 MIKAELA MACKENZIE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS Alison's Roasted Sweet Potato Salad with Mango Chutney recipe in Winnipeg on Tuesday, July 19, 2022. For Eva Wasney cookbook. Winnipeg Free Press 2022. Cutting edge tips: Learn kitchen knife skills in our new monthly cooking feature Eva Wasney 7 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 7 minute read Wednesday, Jun. 11, 2025 Welcome to the first class of Homemade: Cooking School, a new Free Press series featuring in-depth cooking tutorials from professional local chefs. Read Wednesday, Jun. 11, 2025 MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS Terry Gereta demonstrates knife skills at RRC Polytech on Monday. He says a sharp knife is a safe knife, as a dull knife may move while cutting. Turn on that barbecue and get grilling: Barbecue Lean Pork, Gale's Barbecue Trout and Auntie Shirley Potatoes Eva Wasney 4 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 4 minute read Tuesday, May. 27, 2025 Make the most of grilling season with reader recipes for Barbecue Lean Pork from Anita Lee, Gale's Barbecue Trout from Gale Petreny and Auntie Shirley Potatoes from Patti Mersereau-LeBlanc. Read Tuesday, May. 27, 2025 Freepik Adding lemon to barbecued trout is never a bad idea. Spring flings: Use seasonal produce in go-to faves asparagus soup, spinach salad, rhubarb pie Eva Wasney 4 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 4 minute read Tuesday, May. 13, 2025 This week, Homemade features cream of asparagus soup from Rae Carpenter, spinach salad from Vi Scherbak and rhubarb crunch pie from Velma Scott. Read Tuesday, May. 13, 2025 RUTH BONNEVILLE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS files Rae Carpenter makes cream of asparagus soup every year when the snow is finally gone. Expand those Easter baskets Eva Wasney 7 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 7 minute read Wednesday, Apr. 16, 2025 Add some home-baked Easter treats to this weekend's cache of chocolate eggs and marshmallow chicks. This week, we have some sweet, sentimental reader recipes for Dolly's Easiest and Yummiest Sugar Cookies from Dolly Kuzyk, Babka from Shirley Kalyniuk and Daffodil Cake from Karen Stepaniuk. Want to share a recipe? Visit Homemade to fill out the submission form. Read Wednesday, Apr. 16, 2025 EVA WASNEY PHOTO Dolly Kuzyk's sugar cookie recipe can be decorated to suit the occasion. Stir things up with these creamy crowd-pleasers: Cowboy Caviar, Cucumber Chip Dip, Hot Hamburger/Bean Dip Eva Wasney 4 minute read Preview Eva Wasney 4 minute read Wednesday, Apr. 2, 2025 Due to the recent 'dip' in temperature, this week's Homemade is an homage to, you guessed it, dips. Read Wednesday, Apr. 2, 2025 RUTH BONNEVILLE / FREE PRESS files Leslie Pitchford's Cowboy Caviar recipe is home on the range.

Encampments and personal responsibilities
Encampments and personal responsibilities

Winnipeg Free Press

time2 days ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Encampments and personal responsibilities

Opinion Some parts of Winnipeg have a noxious problem on their hands. Among behaviours by the residents of homeless encampments causing consternation among other Winnipeggers near the sites, the act of burning cable and wires in order to cash in on the metallic components is, literally, a toxic one. It's a problem firefighters have had to contend with, and one local authorities seem ill-equipped to address. Wire burning poses serious short-term and long-term health risks; the burning wires release carcinogens into the atmosphere and those exposed are at a higher risk of developing cancer. BROOK JONES/FREE PRESS An encampment on the bank of the Red River along the North Winnipeg Parkway Winnipegger Howard Warren told the Free Press he has asked residents of an encampment near his home to cease burning wires, but says his requests have been rebuffed. Warren pointed out that, were he to do the same in his own yard, his neighbours would likely complain and he may face penalties under the law. He's right, and the double-standard reveals a major problem, one with which those sympathetic to the encampments will have to contend. In late June, this paper shed light on an element of encampment life which put to the test the common stereotype that residents of homeless encampments are there because they have no other choice. Some residents, the June 25 story revealed, prefer to live in encampments. 'These are the people I trust, instead of somebody I don't trust or don't know,' one encampment resident, identified as Joseph, told the Free Press. He was unimpressed by provincial plans to end homelessness by 2031. 'And why? We don't have to pay rent. Why would I pay $600 for someone to tell me how to live when I could pay nothing and live how I want to live?' It's a whimsical notion, and one easy to be sympathetic to. Modern life is fraught with high costs and irritating obligations. And some people are not well-equipped or inclined to take part in the 21st-century rat-race. So let's indulge that thought for just a moment, that encampments in the city could be treated as permanent settlements for those who are not calibrated to the 'ordinary,' way of living. And let's narrow the focus to those who do have the choice, and not those who live in encampments because mental health issues or addictions leave them little choice. What does this idealized arrangement demand of everybody involved? Wednesdays A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom. Without wanting to besmirch the character of the aforementioned Joseph, let's zoom in on one comment he made: why should he want to pay rent 'for someone to tell me how to live…?' That's the sticking point, here: for all the talk among some encampment residents and their advocates about how the encampments provide protective, tight-knit communities for their residents, there is a distinct antisocial streak within them, one which makes the encampments dangerous and antagonistic to the rest of the city around them. Even in a world without all of the expectations which come with modern living, there is still such a thing as the social contract — a set of expectations placed on the individual which, while varying between cultures, is a fact of life across human civilization. In the distant past, one might have been free to pitch one's tent wherever worked, but there remained a social requirement to behave in a way that was not burdensome or dangerous to everyone else. While encampments may be a preferred way of life for some, they cannot and should not be a way to opt out entirely from the social contract. Encampments are not going to be a sustainable reality for the people living in them if their establishment is followed by trash littering the area, unsafe and toxic fires burning through the night, and other disruptive or criminal activities. Some people may be willing to look at those choosing the encampment life and say 'live and let live,' — but it's not going to happen if encampment residents can't figure out how to be better neighbours.

Winnipeg Transit redesign leaves the North End behind
Winnipeg Transit redesign leaves the North End behind

Winnipeg Free Press

time6 days ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Winnipeg Transit redesign leaves the North End behind

Opinion I have fond memories of my first bus pass. The sense of freedom was unparalleled, and I'm sure my mother appreciated not having to drive me to work anymore. Here in Winnipeg, we pride ourselves on raising hardy kids. It's the kind of grit you need to survive. But even the hardiest among us shouldn't have to walk six blocks to a bus stop in the pitch dark while the wind cuts through like a knife. If the people who designed the new Winnipeg Transit system had ever waited for a bus at Redwood and Main in January, they might have thought twice. The new Primary Transit Network has been framed as an efficiency upgrade. For those of us living in the North End, it feels like something else entirely, something more akin to abandonment. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS Transit changes that were put in place on June 29 seem to have left some neighbourhoods behind. Transit service has been cut or reduced in many of the areas where it is most needed. The 17, 38, and 71 routes, among others, were either eliminated or significantly rerouted. Dozens of stops were removed from Main Street alone, with the FX2 and FX3 replacing frequent local service with limited-stop express buses that often bypass residential pockets entirely. Transfers are now unavoidable. For those with options, this might be inconvenient. For many of us, it's disruptive. For some, it's disabling. In some North End neighbourhoods, over 30 per cent of households don't own a vehicle. Walking long distances to transfer points, especially in winter, isn't just difficult, it can be dangerous. The city removed approximately 1,700 bus stops during the redesign, and while officials have not released a public breakdown by neighbourhood, riders in the North End have reported a disproportionate loss of coverage. Main Street alone lost numerous stops, and key transfer points like Redwood and Main were eliminated without alternatives nearby. Riders have noted having to walk multiple blocks further, often in areas without sidewalks or shelters. Meanwhile, the new network prioritizes high-frequency routes along major corridors, many of which run through the south and southwest. The Blue Line, Winnipeg's flagship rapid transit spine, cuts through Fort Garry and south Pembina, areas with stronger economic growth and higher rates of car ownership. The network now extends all the way to St. Norbert. The expansion of service into new suburban areas raises a serious and uncomfortable question: how many stops were eliminated in the inner city and North End to make that possible? What did we sacrifice to serve sprawl? City officials point out that the network redesign was service-hour neutral, meaning the total hours of service citywide remain roughly the same. But equity isn't measured in aggregate hours. It's not about giving everyone the same thing. It's about giving people what they need. Equality would give every neighbourhood a bus. Equity recognizes that some neighbourhoods need more buses because they have fewer cars, fewer alternatives, and more people depending on public transit to survive. Winnipeg Transit's weekday ridership reached an average of 225,400 in early 2025, and the system recorded 47.8 million rides in 2024, nearly back to pre-pandemic levels. But that 'recovery' hides real disparity. While Rapid Transit routes in the south grow and thrive, riders in the North End are watching their service evaporate. And when ridership drops in these communities, as it inevitably does when stops vanish and routes are broken, they'll be blamed for it. We also need to talk about the role of political leadership in all this. Mayor Scott Gillingham, during his time as chair of the finance committee under then-mayor Brian Bowman, supported multi-year budgets that effectively froze or reduced transit funding when adjusted for inflation. These budget decisions constrained Winnipeg Transit's ability to hire operators, replace aging buses, or expand service. Fast forward a few years, and Gillingham now expresses concern over declining ridership and system gaps, as if he hadn't played a central role in underfunding the system in the first place. You can't gut a service and then act surprised when it fails to meet public need. I keep coming back to the question, why did our city councillors allow this to move forward? Especially those representing wards like Point Douglas, Mynarski, and Elmwood-East Kildonan. Did they not see what this would do to their constituents? The Winnipeg Transit Master Plan was approved in 2021, and revised in early 2025 after feedback. Yet many residents say they were never informed or consulted meaningfully. Public meetings were held, but largely online, and mostly attended by more affluent users. Those most affected had the least opportunity to shape the outcome. There is currently no publicly available data showing how stop removals were distributed across neighbourhoods. If the city is confident this plan serves all of Winnipeg fairly, they should release stop-level data and let the public see for themselves. Wednesdays Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture. Until then, it falls to community members and advocates to track what was lost. A simple overlay of the old and new network maps, if allowed through GIS data, would quickly reveal where access was cut, and ultimately, who paid the price. This isn't about nostalgia for an older system. It's about whether a public service still serves the public. The Transit Master Plan talks about building a 'resilient and equitable' system. But in execution, the city has privileged efficiency over access, and growth corridors over existing communities. If equity was ever on the table, it didn't survive implementation. Transit can be modern. It can be fast and efficient. But if it isn't fair, it isn't working. And right now, it's not working for the North End. MJ Jonasson is a Winnipeg-based thinker and advocate for community-driven change. With a background in advocacy, Indigenous social innovation, and social entrepreneurship, she collaborates with communities to develop meaningful solutions that challenge systemic inequities.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store