Rethinking graduate wages
The recent narrative, as featured in a news article, paints a dismal picture of graduate earnings. However, key national statistics suggest a more nuanced and, in some cases, more optimistic reality.
A BROADER LOOK AT GRADUATE EARNINGS
Contrary to claims that most degree holders earn below RM3,000, the Department of Statistics Malaysia (DOSM) reports a median salary of RM4,409 and a mean salary of RM4,933 for graduates in 2023.
These figures reflect a more accurate average of what degree holders are earning across industries, rather than the narrower lens of entry-level salaries in specific sectors.
Furthermore, MYFutureJobs, Malaysia's national job-matching platform, shows that graduate-level jobs advertised an average salary of RM4,537 up to last month.
In alignment with DOSM's data, the Social Security Organisation's (Perkeso) 2024 Data Placement also reports that the average salary for graduates entering PMET (Professionals, Managers, Executives, and Technicians) roles is RM3,598.
These numbers show strong alignment between advertised and actual salaries, suggesting that the labour market may be more competitive and fairer than what individual employer surveys suggest.
ENTRY-LEVEL WAGES
It is true that public sector entry-level salaries, such as RM2,250 for Grade 9 (formerly Grade 41), are lower than private sector medians.
However, this figure does not capture the full compensation trajectory, as Grade 9 positions in the government can rise to RM11,110 and come with long-term benefits such as pension schemes, job security and annual increments, which are often absent in many private sector roles.
At the same time, graduates from the arts and social sciences tend to earn lower starting salaries, largely due to market oversupply, limited demand and less direct commercial applicability of their qualifications.
According to the Higher Education Ministry's 2023 data, over 150,000 graduates, or more than 50 per cent of total graduate output, came from non-science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields such as Business Administration and Law (82,288), Arts and Humanities (22,558), Education (17,933) and Social Sciences (17,539).
This oversupply has created a mismatch between graduate output and labour market needs.
Bridging this gap requires targeted upskilling in areas such as digital literacy and analytical competencies — skills critical to enhancing employability and creating pathways to higher-value career opportunities in both the public and private sectors.
MISMATCH, NOT OVERSUPPLY
One of the key issues is not necessarily an oversupply of graduates, but underemployment.
According to DOSM, 35.7 per cent of employed graduates in the first quarter of this year were in roles that did not match their qualifications — a clear sign of skill mismatch rather than graduate surplus.
Yet, the Graduate Employability Rate for last year stood at 92.5 per cent, reflecting that the vast majority of graduates are employed. The challenge lies in aligning job quality with graduate qualifications and aspirations.
This issue calls for improved industry-academia collaboration, not just wage reform.
WHAT NEEDS TO CHANGE
Rather than focusing solely on starting salaries, naturally lower as part of early career progression, the national conversation should pivot toward sustainable and impactful solutions.
Chief among them is closing the skill gap, which requires critically enhancing university curricula to ensure graduates are equipped with skills that align with evolving industry needs.
Greater emphasis on practical, industry-relevant education can bridge the disconnect between academic training and workplace expectations.
Equally important is supporting upskilling and reskilling initiatives, which empower graduates to transition into high-demand sectors such as digital technology, the green economy and advanced manufacturing.
These sectors offer not only better remuneration, but also long-term career resilience.
Data analysis has begun to explore ways to compare outcomes between reskilled/upskilled graduates and fresh graduates.
Although direct official salary comparisons are limited, existing policy frameworks and research consistently show that reskilling improves employability, job readiness and career progression, often leading to better salary outcomes than those available to fresh graduates.
Additionally, stronger industry collaboration must be encouraged. Structured partnerships between the public and private sectors can create clear, purposeful pathways from education to employment, such as internships, apprenticeships and industry-driven training programmes that ease workforce entry and raise job quality.
While there are legitimate concerns about business sustainability, especially among micro, small and medium enterprises, blanket suppression of graduate wages should not be seen as a viable solution.
Instead, a more balanced and forward-thinking approach is required: one that integrates performance-based remuneration, targeted government incentives and comprehensive labour market reforms.
Such a strategy would not only support business viability, but also ensure fair and equitable compensation for Malaysia's highly educated workforce.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
21 minutes ago
- New Straits Times
Court upholds RM1.04mil award against lift contractor over faulty work at Johor school
PUTRAJAYA: A lift contractor has failed in its bid to overturn a High Court decision ordering it to pay RM1,045,294.80 in damages to an international school over delayed and defective lift works at its Johor Baru campus. A three-member Court of Appeal bench, chaired by Datuk Supang Lian, unanimously dismissed MS Elevators Engineering Sdn Bhd's appeal, finding no merit in its challenge against the earlier decision in favour of Fairview International School Nusajaya Sdn Bhd. The other members of the bench were Datuk Azmi Ariffin and Datuk Ismail Brahim. In the judgement dated yesterday, Azmi said MS Elevators had breached its contract and failed to deliver functional and safe lifts by the stipulated deadline of Feb 28, 2015. According to court documents, the school had awarded MS Elevators a RM566,000 contract in July 2014 for the supply, installation, testing, and commissioning of three lifts at its Johor Baru campus. Under the Letter of Award (LOA), the contractor was required to complete the work within six months, with a liquidated ascertained damages (LAD) clause of RM10,000 per day for any delay. However, the lifts were only certified by the Department of Occupational Safety and Health (DOSH) on June 2, 2015 — 94 days after the deadline — and were subsequently found unsafe. Incidents included schoolchildren being trapped in a lift and dignitaries being forced to walk up seven floors during school events. The court ruled that the school was entitled to LAD amounting to RM940,000 and RM70,294.80 in rectification costs incurred when third-party contractors were hired to repair and make the lifts safe for use. The court also affirmed the lower court's decision to award a nominal sum of RM35,000 for loss of student intake due to the unavailability of the upper floors. The appellate court held that MS Elevators had no legal basis to suspend works or refuse to rectify the defects unless payments were made, noting that no valid payment certification had been issued by the project consultants. The court also dismissed the company's counterclaim for RM387,908.60 for alleged outstanding payments, citing its failure to complete works as per the contract or obtain proper certification. In affirming the High Court's findings, the Court of Appeal emphasised that MS Elevators had neither applied for a valid extension of time nor complied with the contractual procedures. "There was no written notice given by the company to seek an extension of time. "They had the contractual right to do so if they believed the school's actions or omissions had caused delays. "The company cannot now turn around and blame the school for its unwarranted delay. "The defendant must live with the consequences of its fault," the court said. The court also awarded RM25,000 in costs to the school.
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Luxury car owners skip road tax, insurance for cheap fines
KUALA LUMPUR: A senior lawyer has revealed that some owners of high-powered luxury vehicles are allegedly choosing not to renew their road tax and insurance because the fines are cheaper. Muhammad Hasif Hasan said a product founder told him it was more cost-effective to pay a maximum fine of RM3,000 for not having the required documents than to pay the thousands of ringgit needed to renew them. The lawyer was speaking on the Road Transport Department's (RTD) Ops Luxury 2025, which has so far seized 53 luxury vehicles without road tax and insurance. "When I met the individual who has become an 'orang kena saman' (OKS), I asked why they came to court, and the answer was to pay a fine on road tax and insurance," Muhammad Hasif told Berita Harian. "The person explained that it was better to pay the RM300 fine, as it was cheaper and more worthwhile compared to paying over RM5,000 for road tax and more than RM10,000 for insurance for his continental car." The individual, who does not drive the car daily but uses it for product promotions, said that to get road tax, he must first get insurance. "If he just continues driving without road tax and insurance and gets fined, the maximum is only RM300. It's more worth it," Muhammad Hasif said. The lawyer added that this attitude not only breaks the law but also endangers other people's lives. "If he were to get into an accident and hit a member of the public while having no vehicle insurance coverage, the victim or their family would not be able to make any claims," he said. "In the end, they would have to bear all court and medical costs themselves." Muhammad Hasif said that once a victim's family is involved in a serious accident or death due to a driver's negligence, they will face a complicated and costly legal process. "Legal costs can reach up to RM10,000 to RM40,000, excluding medical and other court costs," he said. "In fact, even if they win the case, there's no guarantee they will receive the compensation money." He added that if the defendant has no insurance, the plaintiff would then have to file bankruptcy proceedings to enforce the court's decision, which would also cost thousands of ringgit.
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Water tariff hike to boost infrastructure, offset rising costs
KUALA LUMPUR: The recent water tariff revision offers water operators greater flexibility to improve infrastructure, speed up the replacement of old pipes, and address non-revenue water (NRW) issues. CIMB Securities said the tariff adjustments also helped offset significant increases in electricity costs and other operational expenses faced by water treatment plant (WTP) operators. "For instance, the Negeri Sembilan government has seen the monthly water pumping expenses, especially for commercial and industrial sectors in the state, rising by RM700,000 since July 2024," it said in a note. The research house noted that several states have already detailed their plans for utilising the additional revenue from the revised water tariff structure. It added that the Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) anticipates generating an additional RM20 million in revenue in the second half of 2026 from the new tariffs, which it plans to reinvest in enhancing Penang's water supply infrastructure. "The projects in the pipeline include the construction of the Mengkuang Park Water Treatment Plant, the new Sg. Kerian WTP, and the construction of a new treated water pipeline from the Macallum area to Bukit Dumbar," it said. CIMB Securities said there is an urgent need to upgrade and rehabilitate ageing water infrastructure, noting that 98 out of 350 WTP nationwide are operating beyond their intended capacity, while another 120 WTP are grappling with operational issues. The firm emphasised that addressing these challenges is vital to securing the long-term sustainability of the country's water services. It also stated that the recent water tariff adjustments mark a significant step forward in enhancing water service quality under Malaysia's Water Sector Transformation Plan 2040 (AIR 2040). "This is crucial to support the country's water demand, which is growing at an average rate of 2 to 6 per cent per annum," it said. CIMB Securities noted that while water tariff increases are a step forward, the sector still needs alternative financing models involving private sector participation. This would help ease the federal government's financial burden in supporting the significant investments needed under the AIR 2040 plan. "For exposure to water-related plays, we reiterate our view that licensed water operators under Suruhanjaya Perkhidmatan Air Negara (SPAN) would be the immediate beneficiaries of the water tariff revisions. "Apart from Ranhill Utilities Bhd, PBA Holdings Bhd is the only other licensed water operator in the country that is listed on Bursa Malaysia. "Pending further updates on the private sector's role in Malaysia's water sector transformation, we maintain Gamuda Bhd as our preferred play for water-related infrastructure construction," it added. The firm said Gamuda is well-placed to win construction contracts valued at RM4 billion under the Ulu Padas and Northern Perak water supply projects. It noted that the Northern Perak scheme will be implemented through a privatisation model with a minimum concession period of 40 years. "As the main WTP contractor for Phase 1 of the Rasau Water Supply Scheme worth nearly RM2 billion, we also expect Gamuda to be in the running for more jobs under the second phase," CIMB Securities said.
