England vs India: Cricket laws broken in Old Trafford Test controversy
There are 42 laws in every cricket match and the law book also contains a special preamble on the spirit of cricket which includes more laws to which players are held fully accountable.
It is placed in the front of the book because it is considered the most important entry.
And England, self-appointed standard setters for the game's moral compass, pushed those laws beyond breaking point on a day when they taunted and mocked Indian batsmen Ravi Jadeja. and Washington Sundar after they refused an invitation from English captain Ben Stokes to declare the game drawn before they had their centuries.
Here are three examples.
THE LAW: It is against the spirit of the game to direct abusive language towards an opponent or umpire.
THE INCIDENT: 'F------ hell Washy get on with it,'' said Harry Brook to Sundar when he was 95 chasing his century.
OUR VERDICT: Normally players caught swearing over the stump mike get fined. Brook appears to have escaped. That's surprising. Not the worst sledge we've heard but the angry tone in which it was delivered went down badly with the Indian team, especially as Sundar had every right to go on and get his century. Guilty.
THE LAW: The captains are responsible for ensuring play is conducted within the spirit of the game.
THE INCIDENT: Stokes was the key architect in making a mockery of the final hour of the Test. He had every right to ask the Indian batsmen if they wanted to finish up but they had every right to reject him. From that point he turned into Captain Salty and his decision to gift them centuries via some 'joke'' bowling from Harry Brook was a demeaning act as far away from the spirit of the game as you could imagine.
OUR VERDICT: Stokes effectively tossed this law out the window had one of his worst days as captain by setting a dreadful example. Guilty.
THE LAW: It is against the spirit of the game to seek to distract an opponent either verbally or by harassment with persistent clapping or unnecessary noise under the guise of enthusiasm and motivation of one's own side.
THE INCIDENT: Where do we start? The English were as rowdy as a flock of gallahs all day with the stump mike running hot with random observations and needling taunts. On and on it went then, when Sundar and Jadeja approached their tons, the volume level soared again.
OUR VERDICT: Guilty but India can't whinge too loudly because they babbled on all day when they were in the field as well. Robert Craddock Senior sports journalist
Robert 'Crash' Craddock is regarded as one of Queensland's best authorities on sport. 'Crash' is a senior sport journalist and columnist for The Courier-Mail and CODE Sports, and can be seen on Fox Cricket. Cricket
State cricket authorities have discussed moving Sydney's iconic New Year's Test as a new report calls for a radical shake-up to the summer schedule to allow more stars to feature in the BBL. Cricket
The new tough-talking, pot-stirring English cricket team is suffering from a baffling identity crisis on the eve of the Ashes tour, going into meltdown after two Indian batters had the audacity to tell them 'no'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
19 minutes ago
- West Australian
The Ashes: What Australia learned from epic contest between our two rivals England and India
England's epic series against India finished in some of the most dramatic scenes cricket has ever seen on Monday evening. A one-handed Chris Woakes came agonisingly close to helping the Poms to a famous series win at the Oval, but Australia's villain Mohammad Siraj crashed the party. Here are three things we learnt from the two-all series. Joe Root is as good as he ever has been. Root tried to reinvent himself around the time of the 2023 Ashes, but has now settled down again and truly found his groove. He scored another 537 runs this series at an and has now passed Ricky Ponting as the second-leading run-scorer in Test cricket history. The knock on Root is that he has never scored a ton in Australia. But good luck stopping him this time. He has better players around him than he has since he was fresh to the side and this will be his fourth tour Down Under. He's had enough time to figure it out. As David Warner pointed out this week – he is susceptible to the ball that nips back into his pads – but right now he is the form batter in the world. England have gone all in on this Ashes series by building genuine depth in their pace stocks. They want to meet Australia with fire this week and will bring rapid-quick trio Jofra Archer, Mark Wood and Brydon Carse if they can all stay fit. But Gus Atkinson and Josh Tongue have now strung some good Test cricket together. Jamie Overton was picked at the Oval, but their big quicks should push him and Woakes out of the side. If Australia is gettable, they're gettable at the top of the order. Mohammed Siraj is now more than just Jasprit Bumrah's understudy. It would be fair enough for Aussie fans to remember him as a bit of a fake tough guy who battled during our home summer. But Siraj genuinely broke out in this series. He was brilliant across the final two days of the fifth Test and was comfortably the best bowler in the series. He took nine wickets at the Oval to be named player of the match, including a monster 30-over effort to win the match.
The Australian
3 hours ago
- The Australian
England captain Ben Stokes on the Ashes availability of seamer Chris Woakes
A specialist will determine the Ashes availability of wounded Englishman Chris Woakes after his brave attempt to secure victory against India. Woakes dislocated his shoulder early in the fifth Test at the Oval but courageously walked to the crease with his arm in a sling on day five. He didn't face a ball but was prepared to counter the Mohammed Siraj-inspired Indian attack left handed. Despite struggling in Australia – averaging 51 with the ball Down Under – Woakes would still be one of England's first-choice quicks for the upcoming Ashes. England captain Ben Stokes said Woakes was yet to see a specialist as he remained intent on seeing out the fifth Test. But that specialist would decide whether the 36-year-old pushed a case for the first Test in November at Perth Stadium. 'You obviously don't get that chance (to see a specialist) with a game going on, so that (availability for the Ashes) won't be known until later,' Stokes said. Chris Woakes leaves the field after attempting to bat one handed. Picture:)\ Woakes did not bat in the first innings but walked to the middle when England needed 17 to win the Test match. He followed the courageous efforts of Graeme Smith, Nathan Lyon, Dean Jones and Rick McCosker who have all batted under extreme duress. Stokes said he had no doubt Woakes would bat if required and claimed it emblematic of the unrelenting series. 'Unbelievable, but it was never going to be a question for him to be out there, he was in a lot of discomfort running between the wickets there,' Stokes said. Ben Stokes (right) commiserates with Gus Atkinson and Chris Woakes. Picture:'We've had guys go out, Rishabh (Pant) going out and batting with a broken foot, Bash (Bashir) bowling and fielding with a broken finger. 'Then Chris going out there today trying to get the team over the line with a recently dislocated shoulder. 'It just goes back to how much energy and effort has been put into the series by both teams, everyone has left a lot out on the grounds for their country this series. 'I didn't give him a chance to give him a tap on the back and say, 'Go well', but coming off there it was pretty obvious what was said. '(I said) 'Good effort' and unbelievable, he just shrugged his shoulder and said, 'I wouldn't do anything else'.' Tyler Lewis Sports reporter Tyler Lewis is a sports reporter based in Melbourne's south east. @tmlew_ Tyler Lewis
Sydney Morning Herald
4 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Seven's heaven: Heavy ground a godsend for resuming gelding
One of Sydney's leading stables is out to put down a spring marker when it resumes an imported gelding at Wednesday's Canterbury meeting. Seven's, a UK-bred and lightly raced five-year-old in the Annabel and Rob Archibald camp at Warwick Farm, hasn't raced since failing on firm ground in a BM 78 at Wyong in mid-March. That was the third and final run for Seven's across a disappointing seven-week campaign since arriving from Europe. Earmarked behind consecutive weight-for-age wins in Europe around 2000m last year, Seven's didn't adjust to the tighter tracks in Australia, twice going under as a short-priced favourite at Warwick Farm and then on the Central Coast. He was then spelled before returning with two solid trials up to 1200m, the latter in open class where he settled off speed before working home strongly despite laying in, all in readiness for a first-up BM 72 assignment over 1550m at Canterbury. Seemingly looking stronger and more at home, Seven's returns to his preferred rain-affected ground, with both those wins 12 months ago coming on very soft ground. He is by high-class British staying stallion Bated Breath out of a Galileo mare, and the longer the distances get, the better placed he will be. Seven's drew to find a handy trail back in the pack, yet around this circuit from a tricky starting point, there'll be little or no room for error. Bat Out Of Hell, from the Bjorn Baker yard, is knocking on the door for a fifth career win after placing in his last couple.
