Dundee care boss says Keir Starmer is playing politics with vulnerable people
The prime minister unveiled plans on Monday to ban recruitment of care workers from overseas.
It prompted outcry from social care sector leaders who say they are reliant on foreign labour.
Dr Robert Kilgour, chairman of Renaissance Care, which operates care homes in Blairgowrie and Dundee, says he has been 'shocked' by the UK Government's treatment of the sector.
He accused the Labour administration of a 'knee jerk' reaction to the success of Nigel Farage's anti-immigration Reform UK.
'It should be about people not politics, and vulnerable people at that,' he said.
'I don't think they've thought it through.'
Instead of a visa scheme for carers, firms will have to hire British nationals or extend existing visas. Sir Keir says his changes will 'reduce immigration significantly'.
His government promises a new fair pay agreement for care staff to encourage British nationals to take roles in social care, but Home Secretary Yvette Cooper seemed unable to say how this would be funded when pressed.
Dr Kilgour says providers will have to reduce the number of council-funded places to meet the government's demand of increasing wages to make caring more attractive to UK workers.
He says around 70% of residents in his homes are state-funded, though he is exploring ways of decreasing that.
He said: 'It's fairly two faced of the prime minister and the government to say this.
'On the one hand they're saying we need to recruit more in the UK and we need to pay our staff more – both of those statements I'd be 100% in agreement with, I'd love to pay our staff more – but when your main customer won't pay the true cost of care and pay you more, then what options do you have?
'I'm working on a few initiatives to reduce our dependency on local authority funding by bringing that percentage down.'
He says will look to eventually increase the number of privately funded residents to 50%.
If other providers adopted a similar approach to increase their income then it would inevitably make finding care harder for those who cannot afford to pay.
Dr Kilgour says operators may also be forced to announce further closures due to this latest 'attack'.
'I know loads of operators are looking at closing homes. I closed one last month due to the National Insurance changes. I know of others with this latest attack by the government on the care sector.'
The care chief also says the changes will also make fixing problems in the NHS even more challenging.
He added: 'It's a fact that you cannot fix the NHS without first fixing social care.
'But at every turn, they seem to be determined to make social care worse.'
Sir Keir accused industries of being 'almost addicted to importing cheap labour' over investing in the skills of British workers.
'Every area of the immigration system, including work, family and study, will be tightened up so we have more control,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
23 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Oregon city that tried to ban homeless encampments agrees to ensure 150 camping spaces
The Oregon city at the heart of a major US supreme court homelessness ruling has agreed to ensure camping spaces for at least 150 people as part of a settlement reached with a disability rights group that sued the city over its camping rules. Disability Rights Oregon, which sued Grants Pass in January, said on Friday that it had reached a settlement agreement. The advocacy group accused the city of discriminating against people with disabilities and violating a state law requiring cities' camping regulations to be 'objectively reasonable'. Grants Pass has received national attention for its efforts to ticket and prosecute unhoused people sleeping outside. The city's legal battle resulted in a supreme court ruling dictating that local governments across the US can criminalize camping even when there is no shelter available for the homeless population. 'This settlement represents a significant step forward in ensuring people with disabilities experiencing homelessness have places to rest, basic necessities like drinking water, and real opportunity to stabilize their lives,' Jake Cornett, executive director and CEO of Disability Rights Oregon, said in a statement. Grants Pass mayor, Clint Scherf, said in an email on Tuesday that the city appreciates having reached an agreement and will 'continue to work toward effective measures to benefit all members of our community'. A copy of the settlement agreement showed the city signed off on it earlier this month. Josephine county circuit court judge Sarah McGlaughlin issued a preliminary injunction in March blocking the city from enforcing its camping rules unless it increased capacity at city-approved sites for camping and ensured they are physically accessible to people with disabilities. City ordinances prohibit sleeping or leaving personal property in a park overnight in most cases. Those found in violation can be fined up to $50. The city said Friday on Facebook that law enforcement 'will begin noticing the parks, and occupants will have 72 hours to remove their belongings'. The city's website shows three 'designated resting locations' in the downtown area, near City Hall and the police station, where people can stay for four days before having to relocate. The time limit can be enforced unless disability accommodations are necessary, the city said on Facebook. At resting sites, individuals are limited to spaces that are 8ft by 8ft (2.4 metres by 2.4 metres), with buffers of 3ft (0.9 metres) between spaces, as outlined in city code. Under the settlement, Grants Pass must ensure that at least 150 camping spaces are available in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act for the next 12 months. Drinking water and hand washing stations must be available on-site. The city must also provide $60,000 in grant funding to a non-profit for homeless services. Sign up to Headlines US Get the most important US headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion Grants Pass, a small city of about 40,000 along the Rogue River in the mountains of southern Oregon, has struggled for years to address the homelessness crisis and become emblematic of the national debate over how to deal with it. Its parks in particular became a flashpoint, with many of them becoming the site of encampments blighted by drug use and litter. Last June, in a case brought by the city, the US supreme court ruled communities can ban sleeping outside and fine people for doing so, even when there are not enough shelter beds. After the high court ruling, Grants Pass banned camping on all city property except locations designated by the city council, which established sites for the town's hundreds of homeless people in a bid to move them from the parks. Upon taking office in January, the new mayor and new council members moved to close the larger of the two sites, which housed roughly 120 tents, according to Disability Rights Oregon's complaint, which said the sites were frequently crowded with poor conditions and inaccessible to people with disabilities because of loose gravel. After the lawsuit was filed, the city reopened a second, smaller site. McGlaughin's order in March said the city had to increase capacity to what it had been before the larger site was closed. Elsewhere, the California city of San Jose is similarly planning to open sanctioned camping sites in addition to the 'safe parking' it offers for people who live in vehicles such as RVs. The city of San Rafael, also in the San Francisco Bay Area, also has a sanctioned camping program. Homelessness increased 18% last year nationwide, driven mostly by a lack of affordable housing as well as devastating natural disasters and an increase in migrants in some areas.
The Courier
an hour ago
- The Courier
EXCLUSIVE: Fife Reform defector was 'passionate' anti-Brexit voter
A Fife councillor who defected to Nigel Farage's Reform UK campaigned fiercely against Brexit – and won backing from Labour's most pro-EU wing. Councillor Julie MacDougall quit Labour in 2024 after being blocked from standing as a General Election candidate. She is now in Reform, which evolved from the anti-EU Brexit Party. The Courier can reveal Ms MacDougall had publicly supported EU membership and been endorsed as an MP hopeful by Labour Movement for Europe, a pro-EU faction. 'You don't get an endorsement from them without pledging true allegiance to the EU,' a source explained. Ms MacDougall also superimposed the stars of the EU flag over her Facebook profile picture in 2020. One former party colleague described the councillor as a 'passionate' EU supporter who 'despised' Brexit. A Labour source added: 'Julie MacDougall's desperate search for relevance continues. 'Having been rejected as a Labour candidate multiple times, she is now abandoning what she previously said she believed in to try to get herself a seat with any party in any parliament that might have her. 'She has previously been strident in her pro-EU views, as a member of the Labour Movement for Europe, and even displaying an EU flag around her face in social media profile pictures. 'She needs to explain to people in her council ward why she has suddenly abandoned these views in favour of Reform, who were previously called the Brexit Party.' Ms MacDougall told The Courier she had backed Remain during the EU Referendum in 2016, and says she does not know how she would vote if the ballot was re-run. She said: 'I've always been pro-European. It's more about the fact the country has voted to leave. That's what the people of the country decided, and that's democracy. 'I accept that decision by the people that voted.' Asked how she would vote now, the councillor added: 'I haven't thought about a vote at the moment, because I don't think that's something on the table.' Ms MacDougall, whose late father John was a Labour MP in Fife, also denied accusations of careerism. 'Everyone can have their own opinion. Labour was where my heart was. Sadly, things have changed,' she added. 'Had I really wanted to progress my career, I would have joined another party years ago when other parties approached me. It's taken me till now to make my decision.' A Reform UK spokesman said: 'Unlike Labour, who continue relitigating Brexit and driving us ever closer to the EU, Councillor MacDougall is committed to a free, sovereign country that is governed by its citizens. 'We welcome anyone who shares our values of slashing immigration, cutting taxation, and building a better Britain.'
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
'Alarm' over exclusion of child sexual exploitation from strategy to tackle violence against women and girls
The shadow minister for safeguarding has written to the government demanding action on child sexual exploitation after being "alarmed" by a Sky News story revealing plans to exclude it from their Violence Against Women and Girls strategy. which stated that child sexual abuse and exploitation was not "explicitly within the scope" of their upcoming strategy to tackle Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG). Shadow minister for safeguarding, Alicia Kearns, has written to safeguarding minister, Jess Phillips, saying that "survivors of sexual violence have been left bereft" by the decision. The government insists that its strategy, due to be published next month, will include action to tackle child sexual abuse, but that a distinctive programme will also be announced to address the specifics of the crime. In her letter "demanding answers," Ms Kearns urged the minister to "be transparent and explain why sexual violence has been purposefully excluded" and to "set out when a separate strategy on tackling sexual violence will be published". Poppy Eyre was sexually abused and raped by her grandfather when she was four. Her grandfather was later convicted and died in prison. She told Sky News on Friday: "VAWG is violence against women and girls. If you take child sexual abuse out of it, where are the girls?" 2:58 The Centre of Expertise on Child Sexual Abuse, which is funded by the Home Office, estimates that 500,000 children will experience some form of sexual abuse every year in England and Wales, Rape Crisis told Sky News ministers have failed victims of abuse if they don't consider the "scale of child sexual abuse and exploitation" within their strategy. The campaign group said, "for any strategy to be effective," that the plans "must include all forms of gender-based violence against all women and girls", suggesting there is a "danger" in having a separate plan for child sexual abuse. A Home Office spokesperson said the department was "working tirelessly to tackle the scourges of violence against women and girls and child sexual abuse". In a statement, the spokeperson said: "These issues are complex and run deep within the fabric of society. "The government wholly recognises that they overlap. "But it also recognises that concerted action is needed to tackle child sexual abuse, which is why we have set out a range of actions... and why we are launching a national inquiry into grooming gangs."
