logo
In relationships, have we placed too much importance on attachment styles?

In relationships, have we placed too much importance on attachment styles?

Independent05-03-2025

W ouldn't it be nice if relationships were simple? Imagine. We could just look at someone and immediately slap a label on them that would give us insight into their character, communication style, and the extent of their childhood trauma. On top of this, we'd be able to predict how a relationship with that person would pan out: the things we'd agree on, the ways we'd align, and all the ways we would not. It's an appealing prospect. And it's one that's at the root of our obsession with attachment theory.
The concept first came to prominence in 2010 courtesy of the bestselling book, Attached: Are you Anxious, Avoidant or Secure? How the science of adult attachment can help you find – and keep – love, written by Amir Levine and Rachel Heller. But it took a few economic crises, some serious political disasters, and a fatal pandemic that saw millions locked in their homes for several months to convince us we needed this guidance in matters of the heart. During Covid, the book shot back up the bestseller list and has lingered there ever since.
Now, attachment theory is a heavily saturated TikTok trend, where it's regularly discussed, analysed, and scrutinised in videos that garner millions of views. As the discourse has increased, so has the scepticism. While interesting and somewhat helpful, Attached has been criticised for its litany of strange arguments, from calling co-dependency – the harmful root of addictions and a very real result of trauma – a myth, to advising people to avoid those with avoidant tendencies entirely. Some members of the psychological community have warned we're relying too heavily on attachment types, diagnosing people as avoidants or anxious attachers based on exceedingly little information, such as their texting style or what they've put on their Hinge profile. The trouble is that nowadays, the evidence doesn't really matter. Because once we've prescribed someone with a label, we're off: catastrophising, spiralling, and overanalysing, often at the expense of ourselves and whoever we happen to be dating.
But let's go back a little: what actually are attachment styles? And how are they influencing the way we understand and behave in relationships? 'Shaped by childhood experiences and past connections, attachment theory helps us recognise our emotional patterns, strengths, and challenges when it comes to intimacy, trust, and communication,' explains Paul Brunson, Tinder's global relationship insight expert. 'Conversations around attachment styles have brought a huge shift in how we approach dating, bringing self-awareness and emotional intelligence to the forefront.'
There are four different attachment styles: secure, anxious, avoidant and disorganised. 'Secure means being comfortable with intimacy and independence, trusting others, having good communication skills and the ability to navigate conflicts without fear of abandonment,' explains dating coach Sophie Personne. Anxious attachers are defined as 'craving closeness but fearing rejection at the same time', adds Personne. They're likely to be in need of constant reassurance and highly sensitive to changes in a partner's behaviour. Avoidants are hyper-independent and feel uncomfortable with intimacy; they may also suppress emotions and keep people at arm's length. And disorganised attachers tend to carry a mix of both anxious and avoidant traits, exhibiting a desire and fear of intimacy that, according to Personne, can lead to unpredictable relationship behaviours.
If you believe what you read on TikTok, the idea is that each of us falls into one of these categories, depending on how much our parents screwed us up. Anxious people might've grown up in a broken home and subsequently feel drawn to people who, like their parents, make them feel abandoned. So they cling on a little tighter in order to redress the balance that was set for them as children. Avoidants can come from homes where one parent made them feel smothered or pressured, hence a fear of intimacy that will continue to plague them and their partners for their entire adult lives. And as for secure people, well, they are the unicorns of the dating world, existing exclusively in dreams and tomes on romantic mythology.
While it can obviously be helpful to think about our behaviour according to attachment theory, it's important not to get caught up with the binary definitions we see all over social media. Yes, someone who doesn't reply to your texts might be avoidant. They also might be busy. And sure, the person asking you to make a little effort might be anxious. But you also might not be making much of an effort. It's not hard to see how this could lead you into muddy waters.
'I've noticed a troubling trend in how we discuss attachment styles,' says psychologist Barbara Santini. 'While the theory offers a valuable framework for understanding relationship dynamics, we've morphed it into a rigid system of categorisation, almost like astrological signs for relationships.' This approach is doing us more harm than good, encouraging us to quickly label ourselves and others while negating the fundamental fluidity that makes us all human.
'I've seen clients prematurely end promising relationships because they've decided someone they've classed as 'avoidant', failing to recognise that behaviours can shift depending on context and emotional state,' adds Santini. 'A bad day doesn't necessarily signify a deeply ingrained attachment style.' Taken too far, this way of thinking can create lasting pain in current and future relationships. 'From a trauma perspective, these labels can also be weaponised,' says Chris Meaden, a leading trauma expert who runs The Meaden Clinic in Tunbridge Wells. 'I've seen partners use attachment styles to blame or shame. For example, saying things like, 'You're so anxious, stop being needy,' or 'You're just avoidant, you don't care.' This isn't helpful. Instead, we should be asking: What created this response in you? How can we help your nervous system feel safe in relationships? That's the real work.'
Social media is not exactly known for nuance, which is why it's not surprising that the attachment styles have also become increasingly gendered. You're far more likely to see people talking about avoidant men than avoidant women, just as you'll struggle to find videos about anxiously attached men and avoidant women. It's subtle messaging that feeds into archaic stereotypes surrounding heterosexuality: women are desperate to be loved so they can find someone to have children with, whereas men are terrified of commitment and want to avoid the trap of 'settling down' for as long as possible. 'It's a simplification that also carries a kernel of truth,' says Santini. 'Societal pressures can shape emotional expression. Women, often encouraged to nurture, might internalise relational stress as anxiety. On the other hand, men pushed toward stoicism might default to avoidance.' But the clinical reality is more complex than this. 'I've worked with anxious men and avoidant women and determined that while these labels seem helpful, they can obscure the individual's unique emotional experience.'
Barbara Santini, psychologist
Of course, our attachment style can – and probably will – also change. You might have seen people online say things like 'I thought I was anxiously attached but I was just with someone treating me badly.' If you do identify with one of these labels, it's far from the death sentence we've been made to think it is. 'Attachment styles are plastic and dynamic, not static,' confirms Dr Venetia Leonidaki, clinical psychologist at Spiral Psychology. 'They develop and evolve over time. If a couple manages to overcome attachment struggles and develop a relationship of mutual respect and trust, then their relationship itself may help each partner grow a more secure attachment style.' In other words: don't believe all the TikTok videos telling you that anxious people can never have successful relationships with avoidant ones. They can and do; in some cases, it might even be the thing they need to develop a more secure attachment style.
With this in mind, what's especially concerning about attachment theory is the label we prescribe to ourselves – and how quickly we do so. 'In my practice, I've witnessed clients who misdiagnose themselves based on a single relationship experience, leading to a self-fulfilling prophecy that keeps them from genuine connection,' says psychologist Ieva Kubiliute. This hinders personal growth, often leading us to make poor decisions in our love lives. 'If you constantly identify as 'anxious', you might unconsciously gravitate towards partners who reinforce that narrative, perpetuating a cycle of insecurity.' The same is said of those who call themselves 'avoidant'. 'It can become an excuse to evade intimacy, hindering your capacity for genuine connection.'
The reality is that while attachment theory can help us understand our romantic responses and triggers, it is nothing more than guidance. Because nobody is meant to move through the world with an anxious or avoidant attachment style; the idea is that through some self-reflection, personal growth, and possibly a little therapy, we all become secure. But we're never going to do that if we're so fixated on diagnosing ourselves and everyone around us. 'It's important to challenge these narratives and explore the underlying fears and beliefs that influence our behaviour,' says Kubilate. 'Individuals who do that can break free from the confines of attachment theory and engage more authentically in their relationships. Because true growth isn't about recognising if you're avoidant or anxious. It lies in the ability to transcend labels and embrace the complexity of our emotional selves.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'Covid left me in a blacked out room, then I was put in a mental health unit'
'Covid left me in a blacked out room, then I was put in a mental health unit'

Daily Mirror

time32 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

'Covid left me in a blacked out room, then I was put in a mental health unit'

Brandon says the initial Covid virus wasn't too bad - but the symptoms after were 'terrifying' A man was locked in a psychiatric ward and accused of being delusional after developing a terrifying condition he believes was triggered by Covid. Brandon Green's symptoms included extreme sensitivity to light, hives and a range of allergies; he was eventually forced to spend 20 months living in a blacked-out room. The 37-year-old contracted Covid in 2020 and says that he was not particularly ill - but the experience was strange. 'The virus itself wasn't too bad' Brandon says, 'but it was weird. I could feel something in my brain. For weeks afterwards, my tongue would go numb, my foot would drop for a whole week, I couldn't speak for hours. I'd blank out mid-conversation. It was like I couldn't access my brain.' ‌ The next sign that something was wrong was when he used a supermarket sunscreen on his face and had an unusual reaction. 'By the end of the day, I was burnt all over,' he says. 'And the following days and weeks, every time I would go out in the sun, I would feel intense burning.' ‌ As time passed, Brandon's symptoms worsened. He developed extreme sensitivity to sunlight that felt like being burned by a blowtorch, hives on his skin and a bizarre sensitivity to metal. 'I couldn't sleep on a mattress because the springs would burn me, so I just moved to the floor,' he explains. He also developed an allergy to mould that left him struggling to breathe and severe sensitivity to electromagnetic radiation, which got worse week by week. By April 2022 he was forced to spend his days in a blacked out room with the curtains taped shut to ensure no light crept in. He was only able to venture out at night and jokes he lived for late night shopping on Thursdays. Brandon was terrified but trips to the doctors left him feeling hopeless. 'Doctors didn't know what to do and kept saying I was making it up,' he said. 'I once had a doctor laugh at me because I said I got relief from acupuncture.' He was ill, exhausted and incredibly frustrated when events took a turn for the worse. Worried friends had contacted a psychiatrist who appeared at his door in 2023 to talk to him. Later that night he had a phone call from the doctor, explaining that he thought he was suffering delusions and that a mental health team was on the way to assess him who then took him to a psychiatric ward. ‌ 'As soon as I arrived at the facility, I went out to the basketball court for fresh air, and saw a young guy trying to choke himself with his jumper, wrapping it around his neck and pulling on each end of it,' Brandon said. 'I ran and told the nurse and security. By the time they arrived he'd stopped what he was doing, seen me dob on him and the nurse and security weren't impressed with me - explaining that he was fine. I later got a mouthful from the guy.' Staff wanted to medicate him, but Brandon refused. 'They told me I was delusional, that I had schizophrenia. They wanted to pump me full of benzodiazepines and antipsychotics. I was scared,' he said. ‌ Locked up with patients with severe mental illness, his condition worsened and he was plagued with asthma attacks. 'I kept thinking, this is a place for people with mental illness, but I'm here because they think I'm crazy when really I'm sick.' After two days, he was allowed home, exhausted and bewildered - and with no answers about what was really wrong with him. A few months later there was finally progress. Brandon's doctor told him he had Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS), a condition where immune cells overreact and release excessive chemical mediators. He was prescribed Mast Cell Stabilising drugs. There have been multiple reports of people developed MCAS after having Covid and a number of specialists believe that the condition can be triggered by the virus. ‌ Over the next few weeks Brandon noticed gradual improvement and by December 2023 - after 20 months of living in the dark - he was finally able to tolerate more light. 'By Christmas Day I was fully out,' he says. 'A true Christmas miracle.' But despite significant improvements, he still struggles with debilitating symptoms that doctors are unable to explain. I want to get better. I want people to understand what I've been through,' he says. 'I've forgiven my friends and family; they were only trying to help. But I would hope the medical establishment would reflect on themselves and improve. We should be able to expect better from doctors and experts.'

'I ended up in a psychiatric ward after Covid triggered condition'
'I ended up in a psychiatric ward after Covid triggered condition'

Wales Online

timean hour ago

  • Wales Online

'I ended up in a psychiatric ward after Covid triggered condition'

'I ended up in a psychiatric ward after Covid triggered condition' Brandon had to spend 20 months in a blacked out room Brandon Green's symptoms included extreme sensitivity to light, hives and a range of allergies; he was eventually forced to spend 20 months living in a blacked-out room A man was locked in a psychiatric ward and accused of being delusional after developing a terrifying condition he believes was triggered by Covid. Brandon Green's symptoms included extreme sensitivity to light, hives and a range of allergies; he was eventually forced to spend 20 months living in a blacked-out room. The 37-year-old contracted Covid in 2020 and says that he was not particularly ill - but the experience was strange. 'The virus itself wasn't too bad' Brandon says, 'but it was weird. I could feel something in my brain. For weeks afterwards, my tongue would go numb, my foot would drop for a whole week, I couldn't speak for hours. I'd blank out mid-conversation. It was like I couldn't access my brain.' ‌ The next sign that something was wrong was when he used a supermarket sunscreen on his face and had an unusual reaction. 'By the end of the day, I was burnt all over,' he says. 'And the following days and weeks, every time I would go out in the sun, I would feel intense burning.' ‌ As time passed, Brandon's symptoms worsened. He developed extreme sensitivity to sunlight that felt like being burned by a blowtorch, hives on his skin and a bizarre sensitivity to metal. 'I couldn't sleep on a mattress because the springs would burn me, so I just moved to the floor,' he explains. He also developed an allergy to mould that left him struggling to breathe and severe sensitivity to electromagnetic radiation, which got worse week by week. By April 2022 he was forced to spend his days in a blacked out room with the curtains taped shut to ensure no light crept in. He was only able to venture out at night and jokes he lived for late night shopping on Thursdays. Doctors did not believe Brandon was physically ill Article continues below Brandon was terrified but trips to the doctors left him feeling hopeless. 'Doctors didn't know what to do and kept saying I was making it up,' he said. 'I once had a doctor laugh at me because I said I got relief from acupuncture.' He was ill, exhausted and incredibly frustrated when events took a turn for the worse. Worried friends had contacted a psychiatrist who appeared at his door in 2023 to talk to him. Later that night he had a phone call from the doctor, explaining that he thought he was suffering delusions and that a mental health team was on the way to assess him who then took him to a psychiatric ward. ‌ 'As soon as I arrived at the facility, I went out to the basketball court for fresh air, and saw a young guy trying to choke himself with his jumper, wrapping it around his neck and pulling on each end of it,' Brandon said. 'I ran and told the nurse and security. By the time they arrived he'd stopped what he was doing, seen me dob on him and the nurse and security weren't impressed with me - explaining that he was fine. I later got a mouthful from the guy.' Staff wanted to medicate him, but Brandon refused. 'They told me I was delusional, that I had schizophrenia. They wanted to pump me full of benzodiazepines and antipsychotics. I was scared,' he said. Brandon finally got his diagnosis ‌ Locked up with patients with severe mental illness, his condition worsened and he was plagued with asthma attacks. 'I kept thinking, this is a place for people with mental illness, but I'm here because they think I'm crazy when really I'm sick.' After two days, he was allowed home, exhausted and bewildered - and with no answers about what was really wrong with him. A few months later there was finally progress. Brandon's doctor told him he had Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS), a condition where immune cells overreact and release excessive chemical mediators. He was prescribed Mast Cell Stabilising drugs. There have been multiple reports of people developed MCAS after having Covid and a number of specialists believe that the condition can be triggered by the virus. Article continues below Over the next few weeks Brandon noticed gradual improvement and by December 2023 - after 20 months of living in the dark - he was finally able to tolerate more light. 'By Christmas Day I was fully out,' he says. 'A true Christmas miracle.' But despite significant improvements, he still struggles with debilitating symptoms that doctors are unable to explain. I want to get better. I want people to understand what I've been through,' he says. 'I've forgiven my friends and family; they were only trying to help. But I would hope the medical establishment would reflect on themselves and improve. We should be able to expect better from doctors and experts.'

Kate Garraway
Kate Garraway

Daily Mirror

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mirror

Kate Garraway

Kate Garraway has revealed the scary moment she feared she was having a heart attack as Good Morning Britain staff rushed her to hospital. The 58-year-old presenter has confessed Dr Hilary urged producers on the ITV show to get her immediate medical care as she suffered an episode in November 2022. The incident occurred in 2022 when Kate was caring for her husband Derek Draper, who was suffering from COVID implications. She has candidly opened up on how much her own health suffered as she dealt with her husband's health woes. Describing the "searing chest pain" she felt on the morning when she woke, Kate explained she forced herself to make her way to the studios for the morning show. However, things quickly got worse. Speaking to the Sun, Kate revealed: "I could barely move, but I forced myself into the car. On the way in, I threw up. "By the time I arrived at the studio, something was clearly wrong. Dr Hilary told the producers to call an ambulance. Instead of going on air, I was in hospital, wired to machines, with doctors fearing a heart attack." Thankfully, Kate's health issue wasn't an attack, but was described as a 'heart event'. She continued: "The stress of fighting for Derek to get the support he needed along with the physical demands of being a primary carer 24 hours a day was such a strain that my body was feeling the effect." She revealed she had also had other signs of her own issues, but had no time to rest. Conditions such her autoimmune thyroid condition has "worsened significantly" she confessed, revealed surgery had looked likely. Kate has regularly shared the struggle she felt while trying to care for her husband Derek, who died in January 2024 following a cardiac arrest. And she admitted she still has a the "tsunami of sadness" as she often wakes in the middle of night panicking she hasn't given her husband his medicine. Kate, who had two children with Derek, held his hands until the very end, she said in a previous interview. She explained at the time that while he was sitting in the ambulance with an oxygen mask on before being rushed to hospital, he spoke to his family one last time. She revealed his one final selfless request. According to Kate, proud dad Derek told Darcey and Billy: "You're the best children anyone could ask for. Look after mum, be good for her." This was the last time Derek saw his two children before going into a coma. Kate praised her children for the way they dealt with their dad's sad passing in a chat with Good Morning Britain in February 2024. Kate recalled: "It was one of those stop-the-clock moments, where you want the world to stop. It swamps you. We now have 24 hours, [which] turned out to be more of a month, of fighting on and fighting on, following the prognosis that he won't make it through. For the children when they heard he won't make it through, they've heard it so many times. "They were so beautiful, the children, about that. They individually had time with him on his own and Darcey said, 'If, dad, you can't do this, it's okay. Don't worry about us'. And I had similar conversations, a chance to hold his hand and smell his skin and hold him all the way through, and some people don't get that.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store