Portuguese hospitals hang by a thread with closed A&E departments, lack of staff and long queues
Closed A&E departments, a shortage of health professionals, waiting times far above of what is acceptable and a faulty new triage system. Portugal's national health service is on the verge of collapse.
For Pedro Pita Barros, a specialist in health economics, the problem lies in the ability to organise and manage.
"To a certain extent it's management too, but to a certain extent it's competition with the private sector. It's much more capable of working well in terms of recruitment and retention, of paying more attention to people. So we have two big tension points here, pure and hard management and a human resources issue. These will perhaps be the biggest challenges over the next three years," the professor of economics at Nova School of Business and Economics explains to Euronews.
In May 2024, the government presented a Health Emergency and Transformation Plan to be implemented in 3 months to guarantee general access to healthcare.
Without much immediate progress in sight and with some hospital A&E units exceeding 30-hour waiting times, the Prime Minister said last week in a fortnightly debate in Parliament that the executive is still not satisfied with the results.
Pedro Pita Barros is hopeful that the plan will now stop being an emergency and become a programme of continuous improvement, which will also undergo adjustments itself.
"We have to get away from the idea that we're going to be able to solve the problems of the National Health Service in a month or two. The problem isn't making rules or yet another law to transform the national health service. The question isn't whether we're going to have a date when we reform the SNS, the question is how we can permanently adjust the national health service to the needs that arise," emphasises the economist.
There are many complaints from users about the SNS, namely the compulsory pre-screening via telephone before going to emergency, which delays medical interventions even more, since in hospitals, patients are still subject to long waiting times.
"Just last week, with a relative of mine who was referred to the emergency room by Saúde 24, we were there for almost 12 hours. And as far as I can tell, I don't think it was too bad. There were cases of patients who had been there since the night before. I went there at around 1pm and left at half past midnight," an SNS user told Euronews.
The Movement of Public Service Users (MUSP) has already said in a statement that the Ministry of Health knows that "the long queues are the result of a lack of professionals and conditions to retain them and attract them to the SNS".
In the MUSP's opinion, the "government responds with a bureaucratic measure, hiring a health call centre, creating yet another barrier and delaying the treatment" to a serious problem that required serious and profound measures, namely more investment in the SNS and its professionals.
Between 2020 and 2024, the level of satisfaction with public healthcare in Europe fell from 74 per cent to 56 per cent, according to a report by German pharmaceutical company Stada. Only 49 per cent of Portuguese said they were satisfied with the response of the SNS.
In the Euro Health Consumer Index, Portugal ranks 13th out of 35 European countries. Leading the ranking is Switzerland, followed by the Netherlands, Norway and Denmark.
The Minister of Health has already recognised that "it is unacceptable" to have waiting times of tens of hours in emergency services and has promised to take action soon.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
3 days ago
- Euronews
At least 12 injured after unknown powder found at German DHL centre
At least a dozen people were injured on Friday after a suspicious package was located at a DHL distribution centre in Langenzenn in southern Germany. Several mail centre employees reportedly came into contact with an unknown white powder through a suspicious package, local media reported. The mail centre staff later complained of feeling ill shortly after the package was discovered, including suffering from rashes. The substance was found on the outside of the parcel and allegedly caused irritation. At least eight people were hospitalised after touching the powder. However, a spokesperson for the regional police said this number could increase. This discovery prompted a response from several emergency departments including police, firefighters and hazardous materials specialists. Around 100 emergency personnel were deployed. A local fire department set up a decontamination site at the scene and the distribution centre was evacuated. The police spokesperson told local media that a so-called decontamination shower had been taken to the warehouse. Such a device can be used to wash off potentially hazardous substances. According to reports, 35 people have already used the shower. Dangerous goods specialists are examining the package, but for now, it is unclear what it contains. Meanwhile, the public has been asked to avoid the area until firefighters give the all-clear. Proposals to allow charging air passengers for carry-on cabin baggage were green-lit by EU transport ministers on Thursday as part of wider reforms of EU air passenger rights, despite resistance from Germany, Portugal, Slovenia and Spain. As Euronews reported, the proposal would create a new free hand luggage item, one that can be slipped under the seat, leaving other stowed cabin bags exposed to charges. The agreed proposals would mean airlines must reroute passengers at the earliest opportunity, including through other carriers or transport modes when appropriate. If rerouting isn't offered within three hours, passengers may book their own travel and claim up to 400% of the original ticket cost in reimbursement. Delays of over four hours on short and intra-EU flights (under 3,500 km) will trigger €300 in compensation. Long-haul flights (over 3,500 km) will warrant €500 after six hours of delay. Airlines would no longer be permitted to invoke "extraordinary circumstances" unless they prove all reasonable measures were taken to avoid disruption. Airlines would also be explicitly required to provide food, drinks, and accommodation during delays. If they fail to do so, passengers may arrange these themselves and claim costs back. To bolster enforcement, the rules impose stricter information requirements. Airlines must clearly inform passengers of their rights at booking and during complaints handling. New timelines are foreseen: passengers would have up to six months to submit a claim, and airlines must respond within 14 days. 'The position finally adopted today answers to an urgent call by air passengers and airlines for up-to-date, clearer and more straightforward rules. The revised rules will bring over 30 new rights to the air passengers, applicable from the moment when they buy a ticket, until they arrive at their destination, and in some cases even beyond. It is a historical milestone as an agreement couldn't have been reached in the last 12 years,' Dariusz Klimczak, Minister of Infrastructure of Poland, whose country holds the presidency of the Council, told reporters. European consumer organisation BEUC criticised the position adopted by member states, saying it 'substantially decreases several key rights'. 'Although the deal improved some rights on paper, giving consumers improved access to information in case of disruption, care and assistance, it represents a substantial rollback of other key rights. Take compensation for instance. The new eligibility thresholds will deprive the majority of passengers from their compensation rights as most delays are between two and four hours,' Agustín Reyna, BEUC's director general, said after the vote. 'Consumer groups have already pointed out that airlines should stop charging passengers for their hand luggage by lodging a complaint with the consumer protection authorities and the European Commission last May. Such practices are contrary to EU rules and EU top court case law which states that hand luggage is an essential aspect of passengers' carriage. On the contrary, the text adopted by the Council legitimises charging for reasonably sized hand luggage,' the director added. The next legislative steps Now it is the turn of the European Parliament to adopt its position on the file. If it does so, the text will enter interinstitutional negotiations with member states, the Parliament and the Commission to find a common position on the new rules. BEUC lamented the fact that the revision is being conducted through an expedited procedure that gives shorter deadlines in the Parliament, which will only need to approve the proposal by an absolute majority.
Euronews
3 days ago
- Euronews
"The green transition and competitiveness are not contradictory," says EU Environment commissioner
Jessika Roswall is convinced that water cannot be taken for granted by Europeans. "We cannot continue like that because extreme weather events have become the new normal in one way," she said in an interview with Euronews as part of a presentation of the new European Water Resilience strategy. Europe is facing a problem of quantity: drought is a problem not only in the south of the continent but also in the north. On the flipside, there have also been severe floods in Valencia and southwest France. "The water scarcity that Europe is facing, the Europe's land, is 30%. So, we have both problems with too much water sometimes, too little water, but also polluted water, so we need to act." The goal for the Commissioner is to have clean and affordable water for everybody including industry and farmers. "We need to be smarter on using water. How can we be more efficient? And then it's also about innovation and how can we use the techniques." The quality of water is another major issue facing the Commission. The presence of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), also known as 'forever chemicals,' have been accumulating across EU waters for decades, posing a serious risk to human health and the environment. The European Commission says it's preparing to support a major clean-up initiative set to begin in 2026. The Commission also says it's working towards an eventual ban on the use of PFAS when it comes to consumer products including pizza boxes, cosmetics, rain clothes or firefighting foams. But it becomes much more difficult for medical products like inhalers, surgical equipment or items where there is no suitable alternative. "We need to discuss both how industries that need it can use it safely, and how we can protect it from leaking into nature or otherwise harming people's health," Roswall said. "We are working on both, how to use it in a sustainable way if you may say but we need also at the same time work on how to clean up." The Commissioner firmly believes that the "green transition and competitiveness is not contradictory." She thinks the solution lies through dialogue, including industry, NGOs and member states. The PFAS actions are intended to complement ongoing efforts to review the EU's REACH framework, which oversees EU regulation of chemicals. The revised text could come by the end of the year, following several postponements. Roswall denies accusations from environmental and consumer groups that the Commission is prioritising the demands of industry over the environment. "When we see the chemical industry, which is an important industry for all other industries, that is true because other industries need the products and we need an industry here in Europe, that is important for all of us." Roswall said she believes it's possible to support the environment and also relieve the burden on farmers when it comes to regulations. "If we don't have nature, we don't have farming—and of course, the opposite is also true. So, I would say that we are working toward the same goal. When it comes to simplification, for me, it's really about reporting. For example, I know we're focusing on how we can make it easier for farmers to report less." When discussing the needs of tackling the collapse of biodiversity, Roswall says she is pushing for a dialogue between farmers and NGOs which she says is key in understanding each other's perspectives. She suggests nature credits - financial instruments that can be traded or used to offset biodiversity impacts - would boost private sector investment and biodiversity conservation. "I would still argue that this is something that we need to do and we know that we want to do it, but we need to be smarter when we do it," she said.
Euronews
4 days ago
- Euronews
Infant mortality in the EU: An unexpectedly bleak picture
The infant mortality rate has increased in at least eight EU countries in 2024, according to the latest figures from the countries' national statistics offices. The infant mortality rate refers to the number of deaths of children under one year of age per 1,000 live births. In 2024, both France and Romania reported infant mortality rates surpassing the EU average of 3.3 deaths per 1,000 live births from 2023. Romania experienced a significant rise in its rate, jumping from 2.1 deaths per 1,000 live births in 2023 to 6.4 in 2024. This is followed by France, which saw the rate double from 2 deaths per 1,000 live births in 2023 to 4.1 deaths per 1,000 live births. This means that one child out of 250 dies before the age of one in France, according to the French Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE). Since 2015, France's infant mortality rate has consistently been higher than the EU average. Boys are 1.2 times more likely than girls to die before the age of one and twins or triplets are five times more at risk than any other children. Between 2023 and 2024, Portugal experienced a 20% increase in infant mortality rates, a trend that deviates from the country's overall mortality rate. The causes behind this trend are not clear, but several factors may contribute, including the increasing age of mothers, an increase in multiple pregnancies and geographic inequality of access to maternal health care, according to health experts. On the other hand, Latvia and Sweden have the lowest infant mortality rate in the EU. Currently, Lithuania, Ireland, Luxembourg, Denmark and Slovenia only have estimated numbers. 2024 was a year marked by health staff shortages and the closure of some maternity hospitals in countries like Portugal, Germany and France. During the summer of 2024, 10 Portuguese maternity wards were closed or with restrictions. This followed the government's presentation of a Health Emergency and Transformation Plan to be implemented in three months to guarantee general access to healthcare. In the past decade in France, 15% of small maternity units have closed. Over the past two decades, the number of doctors and nurses per capita has increased substantially in most EU countries. However, the workforce is ageing and interest in health careers among young people is declining due to low salaries and poor working conditions.
