The UK supreme court and the definition of a woman
On paper it does not sound like something that would spark nationwide interest. Last week the UK supreme court gave its judgment on a case brought by a women's group against the Scottish government over the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018.
But its judgment – that the word 'woman' in equality law refers only to biological sex – has upended years of legal interpretation. And the news of the ruling led to celebrations, protest and an outpouring of emotion.
For some, such as the Guardian Weekly deputy editor, Isobel Montgomery, who is a trustee of the domestic violence charity Rise, the court's decision is reassuring. The Brighton charity offers women-only services based on biological sex, as well as separate LGBTQ services.
This, she says, is essential for women who have been subject to male violence and only feel safe if they are in a space with other cis women. 'You are dealing with a cohort of people who are in great distress and deserve to be met where their trauma is,' she says.
But for others, such as Ellie Gomersall, an activist for the Scottish Greens who campaigns for trans rights, the judgment is heartbreaking.
'I think this ruling means that, as trans people, it's now completely impossible for us to ever be able to just put our trans-ness behind us and go about our normal day-to-day lives. It's always going to be a question for us – are we going to be told: 'Actually, no, you can't come in here'?'
The Guardian's Scotland correspondent, Libby Brooks, explains how the ruling came about and what it could mean. She tells Helen Pidd that some legal experts have explained that this legal ruling means organisations can exclude trans women from women-only facilities – but they're not obliged to do so.
Read More Firm loses appeal over under-settlement amputation claim
Yet with the head of the Equalities and Human Rights Commission saying trans people must use toilets that fit their biological sex at birth, and that changing rooms and hospital wards should use the same criteria, it marks a serious change in public life.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
World Pride Attendance Plummets As Trump's Shadow Looms Over D.C.
The glitter-caked gatherings at World Pride have taken a more somber tone amid the Trump administration's crackdown on LGBTQ+ rights. World Pride comes to a close this weekend in Washington, D.C., after a month-long celebration. D.C. had anticipated some 3 million people to mark the 50th anniversary of Pride celebrations in the Capitol. But attendance has plummeted, hotel bookings were down, and the estimated $800 million expected to be generated in the local economy failed to materialize. The BBC reports that a massive two-thirds of expected attendees stayed away. 'It is a risk to now come over [the border] and especially as a trans woman,' one Canadian who decided not to attend told the BBC. The drop is sharp, though not unexpected. Nations around the world have issued travel warnings to their non-binary, trans, and LGBTQ+ citizens, cautioning them that America under Trump is not a safe place. World Pride organizers themselves even considered advising trans attendees not to come. The African Human Rights Coalition explicitly called out the event, warning 'LGBTQI+ people worldwide to refrain from attending' because 'the event is being held in a venue ... governed now by an antagonistic fascist regime which presents distinct dangers to foreign LGBTQI+ attendees.' The last World Pride, held in Sydney in 2023, served as a touchpoint for the Australian government to announce record funding for LGBTQ+ organizations. 'It couldn't be a starker contrast,' an Australian human rights law professor who attended both events told ABC. 'Sydney was a celebration ... This is a call to action. This is a realization of how quickly our rights can be wound back.' Government policy has been notably hostile since the new administration took office. On his very first day, President Donald Trump directed government agencies to recognize only two sexes on official documents. Bans on diversity, equity, and inclusion policies; curtailing anti-discrimination efforts; and suspending trans people from military service quickly followed. The Trump administration has refused to recognize World Pride, in contrast to the administration of former President Joe Biden. The crackdown has spread to corporate America, previously a stalwart supporter of LGBTQ+ rights. A recent survey found that more than a third of Fortune 1000 companies surveyed planned to decrease their support for Pride events in 2025. Booz Allen Hamilton, a leading federal contractor, pulled its support for World Pride this year, while others did not renew previous funding commitments. Ryan Bos, executive director of the group that organizes D.C. Pride events, told The New York Times that corporate fundraising reached about half its target. Some companies sponsoring the event asked for their logos not to be displayed, he said. Still, some attendees saw their attendance as a necessary act of defiance—a return to Pride's more traditional protest, rather than celebratory, history. 'For the first time in many, many years, I'm not parading; I'm marching,' one attendee told NPR. 'It's a very different approach for the first time in a long time. Everything's under threat right now.'
Washington Post
4 hours ago
- Washington Post
'Not just a party:' World Pride celebrations end with defiant politics on display
Washington — After the raucous rainbow-hued festivities of Saturday's parade, the final day of World Pride 2025 in the nation's capital kicked off on a more downbeat note. More than a thousand people gathered under grey skies Sunday morning at the Lincoln Memorial for a rally that will lead into a protest march, as the community gathers its strength for a looming fight under President Donald Trump's second administration.
Associated Press
4 hours ago
- Associated Press
'Not just a party:' World Pride celebrations end with defiant politics on display
Washington (AP) — After the raucous rainbow-hued festivities of Saturday's parade, the final day of World Pride 2025 in the nation's capital kicked off on a more downbeat note. More than a thousand people gathered under grey skies Sunday morning at the Lincoln Memorial for a rally that will lead into a protest march, as the community gathers its strength for a looming fight under President Donald Trump's second administration. 'This is not just a party,' Ashley Smith, board president of Capital Pride Alliance. 'This is a rally for our lives.' Smith acknowledged that international attendance numbers for the bi-annual World Pride were measurably down, with many potential attendees avoiding travel to the U.S. due to either fear of harassment or in protest of Trump's policies. 'That should disturb us and mobilize us,' Smith said. Over a thousand people cheered on LGBTQ+ activists taking the stage while waving both traditional Pride flags and flags representing transgender, bisexual, intersex and other communities. Many had rainbow glitter and rhinestones adorning their faces. They held signs declaring 'Fight back,' 'Gay is good,' 'Ban bombs not bathrooms' and 'We will not be erased.' Trump's campaign against transgender protections and oft-stated antipathy for drag shows have set the community on edge, with some hoping to see a renewed wave of street politics in response. 'Trans people just want to be loved. Everybody wants to live their own lives and I don't understand the problem with it all,' said Tyler Cargill, who came wearing an elaborate costume with a hat topped by a replica of the U.S. Capitol building. Wes Kincaid drove roughly 6 hours from Charlotte, North Carolina to attend this year. Sitting on a park bench near the reflecting pond, Kincaid said he made a point of attending this year, 'because it's more important than ever to show up for our community.' Reminders of the cuts to federal government programs were on full display, Sunday. One attendee waved a massive rainbow flag affixed on the same staff as a large USAID flag; another held a 'Proud gay federal worker' sign; and a third held an umbrella with the logos of various federal program facing cuts — including the PBS logo. Trump's anti-trans rhetoric had fueled fears of violence or protests targeting World Pride participants; at one point earlier this spring, rumors circulated that the Proud Boys were planning to disrupt this weekend's celebrations. Those concerns prompted organizers to install security fencing around the entire two-day street party on a multi-block stretch of Pennsylvania Avenue. But so far, the only clear act of aggression has been the vandalizing of a queer bar last week. Late Saturday night, there was a pair of violent incidents near Dupont Circle — one of the epicenters of the World Pride celebrations. Two juveniles were stabbed and a man was shot in the foot in separate incidents. The Metropolitan Police Department says it is not clear if either incident was directly related to World Pride.
