Pippa White's death in NSW hospital was preventable and ‘system failed her', medical experts tell inquest
Pippa Mae White died on 13 June 2022, two months before her third birthday, after doctors at the hospitals in Cowra and Orange wrongly assumed she had an acute viral illness rather than the serious bacterial infection that killed her.
Giving evidence on Wednesday at the coronial inquest into her death, a 'conclave of experts' who weren't involved in Pippa's treatment said she should have been checked and treated for potential sepsis much earlier than she was.
The NSW deputy state coroner Joan Baptie is examining whether Pippa's death was preventable and whether she received appropriate care in Cowra and Orange, and from the Newborn and Paediatric Emergency Transport Service team.
The inquest previously heard that Pippa presented to Cowra hospital about 2pm on 12 June 2022 with a fever, vomiting, and a heart rate of 171 beats per minute, considered in the 'red zone' for sepsis.
She did not have a blood test until nearly 4am on 13 June, after she was transferred to Orange, which revealed she had a serious infection.
She was administered antibiotics and given a chest X-ray, which showed she had pneumonia that had caused a 'complete whiteout' of her left lung. She suffered two cardiac arrests and died just after 1pm.
Five of the seven medical experts who submitted a joint report to the inquest gave oral evidence on Wednesday: Prof Simon Craig, Prof John Raftos, Prof Warwick Butt, Prof Adam Irwin and Associate Prof Phillip Braslins, along with GP Robert Morton.
While there was some disagreement on when the paediatric sepsis pathway should have been activated for Pippa, all the doctors agreed investigations into possible sepsis – including blood tests – should have been started much sooner than they were.
The experts agreed medical staff became 'anchored' on the wrong diagnosis of a viral illness. They stressed the importance making 'serial observations' of vital signs heart rate and oxygen saturation more frequently than was done in Pippa's case.
The inquest was previously shown a video of Pippa in the Cowra emergency department making a 'grunting' noise while breathing, which the doctors on Wednesday said would have been identifiable with a stethoscope.
Raftos said Pippa was already a 'very sick' and 'lethargic' child when she was taken to Cowra and she needed a rapid response.
He said if medical staff in Cowra didn't have the capacity to treat Pippa right away, as the inquest previously heard, they should have arranged for an ambulance to take her to Orange, or for her mother, Annah, to drive her there.
Raftos said the alternative was 'doing nothing, which is what they did'.
Craig said the 'make or break' point when 'things went absolutely wrong' was at 1am on 13 June when there were 'delays in escalation' at Orange hospital despite Pippa having become 'critically ill'.
The junior doctor in charge of looking after Pippa in Orange, Dr Christopher Morris, last year cried in the witness box as he gave evidence to the inquest and said he wished he had called a rapid response earlier in the night.
The experts on Wednesday said the senior paediatrician on-call the night Pippa was admitted, Prof Adam Buckmaster, should have assessed her that evening. The inquest previously heard he didn't attend the hospital until the morning of 13 June.
Most of the experts agreed Pippa should have had her blood tested and been administered antibiotics around 9pm on 12 June after arriving at the hospital.
'She should have been on the [sepsis pathway], she should have had an IV [intravenous drip] inserted, she should have had bloods done, and she should have had antibiotics given. I think it's very clear,' Butt said.
'I believe the death was preventable, and that means the system failed her,' Butt said.
The inquest continues, with a final block of hearings expected later this year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Fitzy & Wippa are over - but one already has a new gig: Plus, awkward moment between Sky News and the Guardian at 'journo Oscars' - and the ABC tries to bury story about 'missing' reporter: INSIDE MAIL
Insider on the outside? The ABC got shirty with us this week when we enquired about the whereabouts of Claudia Long - the young reporter who in May wrongly accused two Nationals MPs of abandoning their electorates during the floods.
The Independent
10 hours ago
- The Independent
Experts alarmed as dead turtles with bleeding eyes wash up on Australia's beaches: ‘It's very, very worrying'
More than 32 turtles, some with bleeding eyes, have been found washed up on shores across New South Wales (NSW) in Australia, prompting conservationists to launch an urgent investigation. NSW's National Parks and Wildlife Services said they investigating the deaths of at least 32 turtles that have been found dead across the Port Stephens Council area. Marine rescue group Sea Shelter said it had recorded 25 green turtle deaths at Port Stephens in the past month, including seven in the past week alone. Green turtles are listed as vulnerable under Australian conservation law. The animals have been found at several popular swimming spots, including Shoal Bay, Nelson Bay and Corlette. While the deaths appear to be concentrated around tourist beaches, wildlife experts suggested that may simply reflect the higher likelihood of sightings in well-populated areas. Multiple agencies, including NPWS, the Department of Primary Industries and the Taronga Zoo's Australian Registry of Wildlife Health, are involved in the investigation, according to the Australian Broadcasting Cooperation. 'It's definitely very, very worrying,' Lia Pereira, co-founder of Sea Shelter, told ABC. 'In my personal history of working with turtles, I have never seen this in Port Stephens.' Ryan Pereira, another founder of Sea Shelter in Anna Bay, said they witnessed an increase in the number of sick or dead turtles after recent flooding in the area. He said there were 'too many possibilities at the moment' to confirm the cause of the turtles' deaths. Conservationists said bleeding around the eyes was an unusual symptom. The Taronga Zoo registry said: "A thorough, multifaceted investigation is underway and it may take some weeks to determine the factors contributing to the event." It said they have taken two samples from two dead turtles and are also running diagnostic testing on samples from another 15 turtles from Port Stephens. Earlier this year, more than 400 endangered sea turtles were found washed ashore on India 's east coast in an event not witnessed in over two decades. The Olive Ridley turtles, which travel thousands of miles searching for ideal nesting conditions, likely died due to large fishing nets that trawl the ocean floor, experts said.
Daily Mail
11 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Bruce Lehrmann's own lawyer calls him a 'national joke', 'the most damaged man in Australia' and 'probably Australia's most hated man' in astonishing list of insults about her own client
Former Liberal staffer Bruce Lehrmann is fighting to quash a civil finding he likely raped colleague Brittany Higgins, which led him to become 'probably Australia's most hated man'. The former federal political staffer is appealing his defamation loss against Network Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson over an interview with Higgins on The Project in 2021. Justice Michael Lee found Higgins' claims she had been raped in parliament house in 2019 were substantially true in a ruling against Lehrmann in April 2024. But Lehrmann, 29, claims the judgment was rife with errors which will be ventilated during a three-day appeal hearing that got underway Wednesday. He arrived at the Sydney courthouse more than an hour before the hearing, wearing his trademark rectangular glasses and navy suit, carrying a brown briefcase. His lawyer Zali Burrows told the panel of judges that Justice Lee's serious ruling resulted in Lehrmann probably being 'the most damaged man in Australia'. Media attention, aggravated by commentary from Channel Ten and Wilkinson, had led to a flood of hateful social media comments aimed at Lehrmann, she said. 'He's pretty much become a national joke,' Ms Burrows said. 'He's probably Australia's most hated man.' The ex-Liberal staffer alleges he was denied procedural fairness because the events found by the judge were 'starkly different' from the case run by Ten. 'The primary judge found that the rape occurred in a particular way that wasn't put to Mr Lehrmann in evidence and he was taken by surprise as to the nature of the rape,' Ms Burrows said. Lehrmann was accused of committing a violent rape but Justice Lee found it was a 'non-violent' rape. 'I'm not sure that's a concept I understand,' Justice Craig Colvin said when questioning whether that had been the finding. Ms Burrows noted the judge had not been satisfied about a number of the violent elements argued by Ten, including that Lehrmann had held open Higgins' legs or pinned her to the sofa. She said there had been 'a really unfair denial of natural justice' because her client was not questioned on the details of rape found by the judge on the balance of probabilities. But Justice Michael Wigney noted Lehrmann had denied the sexual intercourse took place, so quizzing him on additional factors would have been fruitless. 'This is not a different case. This is a case where much of what was identified was found,' he said. The trial judge found Lehrmann had been so 'hell-bent' on having sex with Higgins that he was reckless as to whether or not she was consenting. But Justice Lee's definition of rape has been criticised by Lehrmann, who claims it is inconsistent with the meaning conveyed to an ordinary person. Ms Burrows asked the court to reassess the finding that Lehrmann would only be entitled to $20,000 in damages, if he was found to be defamed. She said it was inadequate and a much higher figure was needed to address the reputational damage of the very serious imputations of what she has dubbed a false charge of rape. Lehrmann continues to deny he sexually assaulted Higgins and a criminal case in 2022 was abandoned without any findings against him. 'Having escaped the lions' den, Mr Lehrmann made the mistake of going back for his hat,' Justice Lee said in his decision in 2024.
