‘That's not how AFL footy's supposed to look': Why Richmond versus Essendon didn't deserve a winner
For just over three minutes in the last quarter, scores were level. It would have been apt if it had remained that way. In many respects, this was a game that did not deserve a winner.
For all the criticism the AFL has copped for not having Saturday night football on free to air TV, it's just as well Richmond and Essendon played behind a paywall. This was a match league chief Andrew Dillon would not have wanted to be exposed to the masses.
Tomorrow's history buffs will look at the scoreline and wonder whether a game that produced a total of 10 goals, 23 behinds was played in teeming rain, only to be shocked it was played on close to a perfect winter's night.
In between Jayden Short's goal late in the first quarter and Tim Taranto's early in the last, just one goal was scored in close to an hour of football. On the previous night across town, Ryan Reynolds' Wrexham AFC put three goals past Melbourne Victory in 35 minutes.
Often, games dubbed 'the worst of the season' come about because the coaches are locked in a tactical game of chess and a battle of defensive strategies. Think 'the Shame Game' between Hawthorn and St Kilda in 2007, or last year's equivalent between St Kilda and Gold Coast.
But this one couldn't be blamed on Ross Lyon, or even the coaches involved.
Two injury-depleted and low-scoring sides who came into this game with five- and seven-game losing streaks played accordingly. They struggled to perform the basics of the game. Kicks went over teammates' heads, ground balls were fumbled, and chest marks grassed.
Even Zach Merrett, one of the best ball-users in the competition, had trouble. Twelve of his 18 kicks were ineffective or clangers. Kamdyn McIntosh, a dual premiership winner who has played more than 200 games, managed to turn an attempted drop punt into a torpedo that landed in row K.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
an hour ago
- 7NEWS
Clayton Oliver's home broken into by thieves ahead of AFL milestone
Melbourne midfielder Clayton Oliver will play in his 200th AFL game on Saturday despite having his home broken into by thieves. Late on Friday, the Demons confirmed exclusively to 7NEWS that the home invasion happened earlier this week. The club says the 27-year-old is OK and and will take the field for his milestone game against Carlton tomorrow night. Oliver trained freely today, showing no signs of any stress from the incident. Melbourne could not say if anything was stolen or if Oliver was home at the time. It's the latest chapter — albeit not one that was his fault — in what has been a turbulent couple of years for the three-time All-Australian. Oliver had a desire to be traded to Geelong at the end of last year, but Melbourne held firm, holding him to his lucrative and long-term contract. The denied attempt at a move came after a string of off-field and personal issues which saw him take time away from the club. Since fighting back from those challenges, Oliver has returned to the fold but is still working to rediscover his best form. Trade speculation is expected to resurface at the end of this season, when it now appears Oliver's premiership teammate Bailey Fritsch could also be on the move, despite coach Simon Goodwin's dismissal of the suggestion. Out of finals contention, the Demons (6-11) insist there is plenty left to play for over the last six rounds of a disappointing campaign. Fritsch's name has been floated this week as a possible trade candidate, the 2021 grand-final hero having had an inconsistent season up forward. But Goodwin declared Melbourne's focus is firmly on adding to their list in pursuit of success, rather than paring it back for a full-scale rebuild. It comes after the club held onto Christian Petracca and Oliver last year during a rocky trade period, when the contracted midfield stars both explored their options. 'We're in a mindset of getting better and at the end of the year we'll sit down and work through what all that looks like,' Goodwin told reporters on Thursday. 'We feel as a footy club we're very stable, both off the field and now on the field, from 12 months ago. 'So we feel like we're in a really, really strong position to make some really strong and good decisions moving forward about how we get to where we want to as quick as we can.'
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
We've got your back: Eagles vow to protect Harley Reid
Richmond beware - West Coast players will have Harley Reid's back if the Tigers attempt to go after the young Eagles star in Saturday night's cellar-dweller clash at Optus Stadium. Reid produced his best display of the season in last week's 26-point loss to Port Adelaide, tallying a team-high 27 disposals and six clearances to go with a goal. But the performance didn't come without controversy, with Reid fined $6250 for a kick-trip on Travis Boak that Essendon legend James Hird said deserved to be a three or four-week suspension. Reid's heated battle with Port star Jason Horne-Francis was also a big talking point. The young Eagle reportedly sledged the Port star with words to the effect of "go back to mummy, you left after one year", in reference to Horne-Francis lasting just one season at North Melbourne before seeking a trade back to his home state of South Australia. It came a week after Reid was physically targeted by GWS players during his heated battle with star Giants midfielder Tom Green. Young Eagles midfielder Clay Hall said he and his teammates would have Reid's back in Saturday's clash with Richmond. "That's something I'd love to do for someone who is a fellow draftee of mine," Hall said. "We're the same age, and to watch how much he cops it on the field and then off the field as well in terms of media, it's a little bit unfair at times. "So we'll support him as much as we can. He's one of my best mates around the club." Reid has given away a whopping 52 free kicks across 17 games this season, and he has now been fined 13 times so far in his 37-game career, as well as copping a two-week ban for a dangerous tackle last year. West Coast coach Andrew McQualter is doing his best to encourage Reid to maintain his intense competitiveness while playing within the rules. "Me and his coaches and his teammates, we all talk to him and we're all working really hard behind closed doors," McQualter said. "We're not playing everything out publicly with Harley. "I know there have been some things that have been a bit of a distraction and take away a little bit from his game, and we acknowledge that, and he acknowledged that last week. "But he's actually playing some pretty strong football at the moment." If West Coast (1-16) are any hope to avoid the wooden spoon, they simply must defeat 17th-placed Richmond (4-13). The Eagles have recalled midfielder Tim Kelly following his one-week stint in the WAFL, while Liam Ryan and Jack Petruccelle are the other inclusions, with Elijah Hewett rested. Richmond beware - West Coast players will have Harley Reid's back if the Tigers attempt to go after the young Eagles star in Saturday night's cellar-dweller clash at Optus Stadium. Reid produced his best display of the season in last week's 26-point loss to Port Adelaide, tallying a team-high 27 disposals and six clearances to go with a goal. But the performance didn't come without controversy, with Reid fined $6250 for a kick-trip on Travis Boak that Essendon legend James Hird said deserved to be a three or four-week suspension. Reid's heated battle with Port star Jason Horne-Francis was also a big talking point. The young Eagle reportedly sledged the Port star with words to the effect of "go back to mummy, you left after one year", in reference to Horne-Francis lasting just one season at North Melbourne before seeking a trade back to his home state of South Australia. It came a week after Reid was physically targeted by GWS players during his heated battle with star Giants midfielder Tom Green. Young Eagles midfielder Clay Hall said he and his teammates would have Reid's back in Saturday's clash with Richmond. "That's something I'd love to do for someone who is a fellow draftee of mine," Hall said. "We're the same age, and to watch how much he cops it on the field and then off the field as well in terms of media, it's a little bit unfair at times. "So we'll support him as much as we can. He's one of my best mates around the club." Reid has given away a whopping 52 free kicks across 17 games this season, and he has now been fined 13 times so far in his 37-game career, as well as copping a two-week ban for a dangerous tackle last year. West Coast coach Andrew McQualter is doing his best to encourage Reid to maintain his intense competitiveness while playing within the rules. "Me and his coaches and his teammates, we all talk to him and we're all working really hard behind closed doors," McQualter said. "We're not playing everything out publicly with Harley. "I know there have been some things that have been a bit of a distraction and take away a little bit from his game, and we acknowledge that, and he acknowledged that last week. "But he's actually playing some pretty strong football at the moment." If West Coast (1-16) are any hope to avoid the wooden spoon, they simply must defeat 17th-placed Richmond (4-13). The Eagles have recalled midfielder Tim Kelly following his one-week stint in the WAFL, while Liam Ryan and Jack Petruccelle are the other inclusions, with Elijah Hewett rested. Richmond beware - West Coast players will have Harley Reid's back if the Tigers attempt to go after the young Eagles star in Saturday night's cellar-dweller clash at Optus Stadium. Reid produced his best display of the season in last week's 26-point loss to Port Adelaide, tallying a team-high 27 disposals and six clearances to go with a goal. But the performance didn't come without controversy, with Reid fined $6250 for a kick-trip on Travis Boak that Essendon legend James Hird said deserved to be a three or four-week suspension. Reid's heated battle with Port star Jason Horne-Francis was also a big talking point. The young Eagle reportedly sledged the Port star with words to the effect of "go back to mummy, you left after one year", in reference to Horne-Francis lasting just one season at North Melbourne before seeking a trade back to his home state of South Australia. It came a week after Reid was physically targeted by GWS players during his heated battle with star Giants midfielder Tom Green. Young Eagles midfielder Clay Hall said he and his teammates would have Reid's back in Saturday's clash with Richmond. "That's something I'd love to do for someone who is a fellow draftee of mine," Hall said. "We're the same age, and to watch how much he cops it on the field and then off the field as well in terms of media, it's a little bit unfair at times. "So we'll support him as much as we can. He's one of my best mates around the club." Reid has given away a whopping 52 free kicks across 17 games this season, and he has now been fined 13 times so far in his 37-game career, as well as copping a two-week ban for a dangerous tackle last year. West Coast coach Andrew McQualter is doing his best to encourage Reid to maintain his intense competitiveness while playing within the rules. "Me and his coaches and his teammates, we all talk to him and we're all working really hard behind closed doors," McQualter said. "We're not playing everything out publicly with Harley. "I know there have been some things that have been a bit of a distraction and take away a little bit from his game, and we acknowledge that, and he acknowledged that last week. "But he's actually playing some pretty strong football at the moment." If West Coast (1-16) are any hope to avoid the wooden spoon, they simply must defeat 17th-placed Richmond (4-13). The Eagles have recalled midfielder Tim Kelly following his one-week stint in the WAFL, while Liam Ryan and Jack Petruccelle are the other inclusions, with Elijah Hewett rested.
The Australian
3 hours ago
- The Australian
AFL: Ross Lyon slams ‘disgusting' attacks on Saints star Wanganeen-Milera
St Kilda coach Ross Lyon has called out the 'disgusting' attacks on star Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera, declaring the messages he received were 'more than racism'. Wanganeen-Milera and Port Adelaide wingman Jase Burgoyne are considering legal action after they were both targeted online following their respective matches last weekend. Lyon launched to his player's defence on Friday morning, calling for more pointed language when describing the nature of the incident. 'Is that what you call it? Can you be stronger with it? It was hate. It was vehement. It was disgusting,' he said. 'We don't stand for it as a club, the AFL doesn't and the community shouldn't. 'It's more than racism, it's hate. You know what? The standards you walk past are the standards you accept. 'We'll call it out, we'll move on and play our footy – even that – 'racial', it's a bit more than that, it's a bit more than that.' Ross Lyon says the attacks on Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera are 'more than racism'. Picture:Wanganeen-Milera has played a career-best season, shrugging off attention around his future as well as an on-field tag. Lyon said Wanganeen-Milera was in a good space despite the incident but doubled down on how it should be treated. 'Nothing fazes 'Naz', it's got nothing to do with 'Naz',' he said. ''Naz' is a great person, becoming a great player, if anything, the power is in how you respond. 'He's got nothing to shy away from, deep down, would it be really hurtful and uncomfortable? Yeah, but guess what? That's out there. 'I think if we, you guys (the media, need to) use strong language. Racism? It was hate, it was vehement, it was disgusting, we don't stand for it and want to stamp it out.' St Kilda travels down the highway to take on Geelong this weekend in reliable defender Callum Wilkie's 150th game. Tyler Lewis Sports reporter Tyler Lewis is a sports reporter based in Melbourne's south east. @tmlew_ Tyler Lewis
