
It's not guns vs growth. Spending on desi defence tech can boost economy
By all accounts, Operation Sindoor has been a success. It has demonstrated the strength of India's air defence system, as well as its offensive capabilities in destroying training and logistical facilities of terror networks deep inside Pakistan. But this success was not achieved overnight. The Indian govt has been proactively investing in procurement and indigenisation of advanced weapons and surveillance capabilities in the past decade. Following the demonstration of the capabilities of indigenous technologies like Aakash, the confidence in indigenous research and development (R&D) is at its peak. This presents an opportunity to significantly increase defence spending, even if it requires loosening the fiscal deficit targets.
This might raise a few eyebrows, especially among monetary hawks and bond vigilantes, but from the Spanish conquest of the Aztecs to the use of the nuclear bomb in World War II, history is replete with examples of epochal, and yet one-sided, battles that turned the page of civilisations due to technological superiority on one side. These tech advancements are often achieved with state backing through speculative R&D investments. A prominent example is the Manhattan Project behind the first nuclear bomb.
Fiscal hawks will ask two questions when they hear suggestions of increased govt spending. First, how would this affect private investment? And second, how should this increased expenditure be financed?
Focus on firepower: It makes sense to fund defence R&D even if it means relaxing fiscal deficit target
The metric to assess the impact of the first question is called the 'fiscal multiplier'. To put it simply, fiscal multiplier tells us how much is the additional output (GDP) created by increasing govt spending by one rupee. A fiscal multiplier of greater than one means a positive spillover effect on the private sector, while less than one indicates otherwise. In her research published in 2019, Prof Valerie A Ramey of the University of California, San Diego, found that most types of govt spending have a multiplier of less than 1, i.e., they crowd out private activity entirely. A simple example would be a policy like free cash transfer to the poor. Such schemes can disincentivise some workers from going to work, thereby making labour more expensive, leading to firms cutting down their investment and production.
But what about defence expenditure? What is its fiscal multiplier? A recent paper in The American Economic Review titled 'The Long Run Effects of Government Spending' by Juan Antolin-Diaz and Paolo Surico of The London Business School argues that by shifting the composition of public spending towards R&D, military spending boosts innovation and private investment in the medium-term, and increases productivity, GDP and consumption at longer horizons. Essentially, defence expenditure is distinct from other types of govt expenditures, including public infrastructure investment, due to its ability to spur R&D in both public and private sectors. Using extremely conservative methods for estimating fiscal multiplier, they show that military spending has a fiscal multiplier of nearly 2. In other words, a rupee spent on military spending creates an additional GDP of another rupee. Most importantly, the additional rupee comes from an increase in productivity that lasts a very long time. These quantitative estimates may vary from country to country, but they are unlikely to be significantly less than 2 even in a country like India.
Moreover, while the quantitative effects may be surprising, the qualitative effects are entirely unsurprising. Increased R&D expenditure is likely to go to the most talented, productive, and ambitious people in the economy. It is entirely expected that allocating capital towards their R&D initiatives will create strong and robust second-order gains. The second question then is how to fund defence expenditure? In India's context (and even otherwise), tax would likely be the worst way to finance this increased defence expenditure. It has one of the lowest fiscal multipliers and will likely have serious repercussions on the GDP. But the govt can raise long-term money at a rate lower than 6.5% per annum. This makes the choice of funding source for defence expenditure clear: long-term govt borrowing. Given the sustainable benefits from defence spending, the govt should not have a problem repaying the debt.
However, this requires a mindset change in the govt, where a certain segment holds a dogmatic view that debt is bad. Not all debt is bad; it is the debt to finance unproductive expenditures that causes trouble. Debt to finance defence R&D expenditure should be sustainable given the strong positive spillover effects. We hope that the govt considers relaxing the fiscal deficit target by 0.5-0.7% of GDP ($20-30 billion), borrowing long-term, and using it to fund defence expenditure that is heavy in R&D. This amount would go a long way in creating deep-tech defence startups making India stronger and, thus, more prosperous. Facing external threats from two neighbours—one reckless and one highly advanced—time is not on our side.
Tantri is a faculty in finance at the Indian School of Business while Kuvalekar teaches economics at the University of Essex, UK
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email
This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
18 minutes ago
- Indian Express
26th foundation function of NCP: Ajit Pawar asks party workers to gear up for civic polls
Refraining from any direct criticism or remark on Sharad Pawar-led NCP (SP), NCP chief Ajit Pawar on Tuesday urged party workers to put in all efforts to ensure victory in the upcoming civic elections. 'Many of our leaders are founder members of the NCP. It has grown since its formation in 1999. However, the party has not got a majority in elections to form a government. Alliances had to be formed and the NCP joined the NDA,' said Pawar at the 26th foundation function of the NCP. He said the NCP joined hands with the Shiv Sena in 2019 and it indicates adjustment has to be made at times to be in power. 'Though we have joined the NDA we have not given up our ideology of secularism. There are many political parties who believe in secularism and have been part of the NDA,' Pawar said. Earlier, the NCP passed two resolutions over the success of Operation Sindoor and congratulated Prime Minister Narendra Modi for his impressive performance in the last 11 years by leading the NDA-led Centre. The NCP chief did not say anything on speculations over merger of the two NCPs nor criticised the opposition NCP (SP). 'We want to resolve public issues. The country is developing, and the state is also developing. I want to assure that there will be no compromise on the secular fabric of the party. Our ideology of secularism and creating progressive society continues. We have been against extremism and will continue to do so,' he said, justifying the party's joining the NDA on development agenda. The NCP received a setback in the Lok Sabha elections but later worked hard for the Assembly elections resulting in the 'ladki bahin' scheme, said Pawar, adding, 'I will not let the scheme to be closed.' The NCP chief said the civic polls are only a few months away. 'The BMC election will be wardwise while other municipal corporations will likely have a four-ward electoral panel system for civic polls. We should be fully prepared for it. NCP ministers will be asked to hold election rallies per week in municipal corporations to activate party workers. The pre-poll alliance for civic elections will be as per the stand of local party units,' he said. 'Real political fight coming now with elections to 28 municipal corporations, 25 zila parishad or municipal councils and 285 panchayat samiti. So work hard for civic polls,' said Pawar, urging party workers to set a target of enrolling one crore new members for the party. Ajay Jadhav is an Assistant Editor with The Indian Express, Pune. He writes on Infrastructure, Politics, Civic issues, Sustainable Development and related stuff. He is a trekker and a sports enthusiast. Ajay has written research articles on the Conservancy staff that created a nationwide impact in framing policy to improve the condition of workers handling waste. Ajay has been consistently writing on politics and infrastructure. He brought to light the lack of basic infrastructure of school and hospital in the hometown of Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde even as two private helipads were developed by the leader who mostly commutes from Mumbai to Satara in helicopter. Ajay has been reporting on sustainable development initiatives that protects the environment while ensuring infrastructure development. ... Read More


Indian Express
18 minutes ago
- Indian Express
‘Infiltration, violence, obstructed Central schemes': Union Minister Bhupendra Yadav slams Bengal government ahead of 2026 Assembly elections
Union Minister Bhupendra Yadav, addressing a press conference in a Kolkata hotel, launched a scathing attack on the West Bengal government, accusing it of perpetuating 'unchecked infiltration, pervasive violence, and obstruction of Central welfare schemes'. With the 2026 Assembly elections in mind, Yadav said a 'befitting reply' would come from the people of Bengal in a BJP victory. The Union Minister for Environment, Forest and Climate Change was part of the press conference in Kolkata on the completion of 11 years of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led Union government. He claimed that the Bengal government is responsible for 'helping infiltrators settle in the state' and 'opposing the Centre's steps to stop infiltration', while urging it to help Central forces identify and deport 'illegal' foreign nationals. 'The biggest impact of infiltration falls on the law and order of a state,' he said. Upon being asked about their strategies to tackle post-poll violence in the state, Yadav dismissed the idea that it was confined to the post-election period. 'It happens in Bengal throughout,' he stated, invoking incidents in Murshidabad and Sandeshkhali. 'The biggest sadness is violence has become part of Bengal,' he said, questioning the state's ability to function amidst 'community-based violence' fueled by 'appeasement' politics. 'It is sad that people under their own government are forced to flee their homes,' said Yadav. 'By talking about post-poll violence, we would restrict violence to two months, whereas on the ground, it is happening round the clock. People of Bengal are not ready to forgive this government. We are fighting post-poll violence democratically.' Yadav also criticised the state government's 'resistance' to Central schemes, claiming it opposed the Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana, Ayushman Bharat Yojana and the Pradhan Mantri Vishwakarma Yojana. He said, 'A large section of OBC workers are here; what is her scientific logic behind including and excluding people?' 'The Sandeshkhali and Murshidabad incidents are the poster of Mamata Banerjee's bad governance… while the Centre has proved that India will not tolerate terrorism…I don't take it in a good way that they are talking ill of Operation Sindoor. On Operation Sindoor, all political parties have been a representative of an international delegation,' Yadav said. Yadav alleged that 'not a single month passes without reports of attacks on women' in Bengal, claiming that the state did not take action during the violence in Murshidabad, which broke out on April 8. 'Instead, the responsibility of maintaining peace and security in the state was left to the Centre,' he claimed. Regarding the deployment of forces during the elections, he stated, 'The Election Commission is discussing it with all political parties and it will decide on the deployment of the forces.' Meanwhile, on the subject of climate action, Yadav highlighted Central initiatives. 'There is a beautiful name of a plan which is Project Mishti' he said, also mentioning 'Mission Life,' which focuses on seven key areas: saving water, saving food, saving energy, solid waste management, e-waste disposal, and a complete ban on single-use plastic. He stressed the importance of 'individual responsibility', stating, 'People must think about it.' Sweety Kumari reports from West Bengal for The Indian Express. She is a journalist with over a decade of experience in the media industry. Covers Crime, Defence, Health , Politics etc and writes on trending topics. With a keen eye for investigative and human-interest stories. She has honed her craft across diverse beats including aviation, health, incidents etc. Sweety delivers impactful journalism that informs and engages audiences. Sweety Kumari is a graduate of Calcutta University with an Honors degree in Journalism from Jaipuria College and a PG in Mass Communication from Jadavpur University. Originally from Bihar, she is brought up in Kolkata and completed her education from Kendriya Vidyalaya SaltLake. Multilingual, Sweety is fluent in English, Hindi, Bengali, and Maithili. She started her career as an Entertainment and lifestyle journalist with a newsportal in Kolkata. She is working with The Indian Express for 8 years now. ... Read More


Economic Times
20 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Disruption of rare earth magnet supplies beyond 30 days can impact vehicle production in India: Report
Agencies Representative image. A disruption in rare earth magnet supplies lasting beyond a month can impact production of passenger vehicles, including electric models, weighing on the domestic automobile industry's growth momentum, a report on Tuesday said. Rare earth magnets, low in cost but critical in function, could emerge as a key supply-side risk for India's automotive sector if China's export restrictions and delays in shipment clearances persist, Crisil Ratings said in a statement. "The supply squeeze comes just as the auto sector is preparing for aggressive EV rollouts. Over a dozen new electric models are planned for launch, most built on PMSM platforms," Crisil Ratings Senior Director Anuj Sethi said. While most automakers currently have 4-6 weeks of inventory, prolonged delays could start affecting vehicle production, with EV models facing deferrals or rescheduling from July 2025, he added. A broader impact on two-wheelers and ICE PVs may follow if the supply bottlenecks persist for an extended period, Sethi said. "The shortage of rare earth magnets is forcing automakers to reassess supply-chain strategies. Despite contributing less than 5 per cent of a vehicle's cost, these magnets are indispensable for EV motors and electric steering systems," said Crisil Ratings Director Poonam Upadhyay. Automakers are actively engaging with alternative suppliers in countries such as Vietnam, Indonesia, Japan, Australia, and the US, while also optimising existing inventories, she noted. "With applications across EVs and ICE vehicles, a prolonged supply squeeze could disrupt production of PVs and 2Ws, making this low-cost component a potential high-impact bottleneck for the sector," she said. Rare earth magnets are integral to Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (PMSMs) used in EVs for their high torque, energy efficiency and compact size. Hybrids also depend on them for efficient propulsion. In internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, the use of rare earth magnets is largely limited to electric power steering and other motorised systems. In April this year, China, the world's dominant exporter of rare earth magnets, imposed export restrictions on seven rare earth elements and finished magnets, mandating export licences. The revised framework demands detailed end-use disclosures and client declarations, including confirmation that the products will not be used in defence or re-exported to the US. With the clearance process taking at least 45 days, this added scrutiny has significantly delayed approvals. And the growing backlog has further slowed clearances, tightening global supply chains. India, which sourced over 80 per cent of its 540 tonnes magnet imports from China last fiscal, has started to feel the impact. By end-May 2025, nearly 30 import requests from Indian companies were endorsed by the Indian government, but none have yet been approved by the Chinese authorities, and no shipments have arrived. During the pandemic, rare earth magnet supplies remained stable, unlike semiconductors, reinforcing reliance on just-in-time inventory without building strategic buffers. However, while semiconductors have a globally diversified supply base, over 90 per cent of rare earth magnet processing is concentrated in China, with limited short-term alternatives. Recognising the risk, the government and automakers are taking action on two fronts, Crisil said. In the short term, the focus is on building strategic inventories, tapping alternative suppliers and accelerating domestic assembly under Production Linked Incentive schemes. For the long term, reducing import dependency will hinge on fast-tracking rare earth exploration, building local production capacity and investing in recycling infrastructure, Crisil stated.