Diego Maradona death trial suspended as judge's impartiality questioned
(From left) Judges Veronica Di Tommaso, Maximiliano Savarino and Julieta Makintach are seen during the trial for the death of Diego Maradona. PHOTO: AFP
SAN ISIDRO – The Argentinian court trying the medical team of late football legend Diego Maradona over his death suspended the trial on May 20 for a week, over questions about a judge's impartiality.
The court ordered the suspension after defence lawyers said that the judge's involvement in a documentary about the case constituted a possible breach of her duty of impartiality, as well as possible influence peddling and even bribery.
Prosecutor Patricio Ferrari said the pause was ordered 'to resolve an issue... of institutional gravity'.
Two defence lawyers asked for the judge, Julieta Makintach, to be recused from the two-month-old trial.
At issue is the alleged use of cameras in the courtroom in violation of a ban on filming the trial.
The prosecutor's office will investigate whether the rule was broken and what part, if any, Makintach played in the transgression.
Makintach told the court on May 20 that she could 'understand the concerns of all'.
'But I am convinced of my impartiality,' she said, adding that she would consider recusing herself from the case if there were doubts over the matter.
'I understand everyone's anxiety. I will give the explanations of the case. To denounce a judge, you have to have well-founded reasons.'
The presiding judge, Maximiliano Savarino, said the trial would resume on May 27.
Maradona died on Nov 25, 2020 at age 60, while recovering at home from brain surgery for a blood clot, after decades battling cocaine and alcohol addictions.
He died of heart failure and acute pulmonary edema two weeks after going under the knife. He was found dead in bed by his day nurse.
His seven-person medical team is on trial in the Buenos Aires suburb of San Isidro over the conditions of his convalescence at a private home in the nearby suburb of Tigre.
Prosecutors have described the football icon's care in his last days as grossly negligent.
The defendants risk prison terms between eight and 25 years if convicted of 'homicide with possible intent' – pursuing a course of action despite knowing it could lead to death.
The case so far has focused on the decision by Maradona's doctors to allow him recuperate at home, with minimal supervision and with minimal medical equipment, instead of in a medical facility.
Testifying in court last week, Maradona's daughter Gianinna accused her father's carers of keeping him in 'a dark, ugly and lonely' place and said that they seemed more interested in money than his welfare.
So far only one of the defendants, Maradona's psychiatrist, has been called to the stand.
The passing of the star of the 1986 World Cup plunged Argentina into mourning in the midst of the Covid-19 pandemic.
Tens of thousands of people queued to bid farewell to the former Boca Juniors and Napoli striker, as his body lay in state at the presidential palace. AFP
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Ex-Ubisoft executive on trial denies seeing office harassment
[BOBIGNY, France] A former executive at French video game giant Ubisoft, on trial with two others for alleged sexual and psychological harassment of employees, denied on Tuesday witnessing any abuse in the office. Serge Hascoet, the company's former chief creative officer, said that he had been unaware of incidents that prompted several employees to complain of regular public humiliation and hazing. He said he never heard any sexist or homophobic remarks or insults, but after hours of questioning admitted making some 'misplaced' comments with sexual connotations to women employees. Overall, the atmosphere in Ubisoft's open-plan offices in the eastern Paris suburb of Montreuil was 'studious and focused on work', Hascoet insisted, although he said that 'water fights' did break out 'when it got hot'. Hascoet, in his 60s, is on trial with the company's former vice-president of editorial and creative services, Thomas Francois, and former game director Guillaume Patrux. All three were dismissed for serious misconduct following an internal inquiry in 2020, and all three deny the claims made against them. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Francois is the focus of the most damning claims of systematic psychological and sexual harassment over years, including watching pornographic films in the office and commented on women employees' appearance. He allegedly forced one skirt-wearing employee to do a headstand and drew on her face with a felt-tip pen before forcing her to attend a meeting. Francois is additionally being prosecuted for an attempted sexual assault. Hascoet is accused of lewd behaviour and posing intrusive questions of a sexual nature, as well as racist comments and behaviour. Asked about the felt-pen allegation involving Francois, Hascoet said: 'I don't remember that episode at all.' When the court's judge asked about another incident, in which Hascet's company male assistant - known for selling drugs - brandished a knife to a woman employee, the ex-chief creative officer said 'I don't know' how the victim took the armed threat against her. In Monday's hearing, several women who worked under Hascoet testified that he made them run personal errands for him, including picking up his daughter from school. Hascoet said he was forced to give such orders because of lengthy meetings, and because his wife was suffering from incurable cancer. AFP
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
Putin eyes a bigger prize than Ukraine
Russian President Vladimir Putin never veered from his refusal to consider a cessation of hostilities, says the writer. PHOTO: AFP Ukraine's June 1 drone strike deep inside Russian territory has left Russian officials humiliated. A nation that remains a significant global power has suddenly discovered that some of its most prized military assets – its long-range bombers capable of carrying nuclear weapons – can be destroyed on the ground. And despite being pounded by the full might of Russia's armed forces for more than three years, Ukraine still had both the audacity and ingenuity to mount such an attack. All these are unpleasant news for Russian President Vladimir Putin, so it was not surprising that, when Ukrainian and Russian mediators met in the Turkish city of Istanbul on June 2 to discuss options for a ceasefire in their war, the talks failed in just one hour. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Online Citizen
14 hours ago
- Online Citizen
SMRT to be fined S$3 million over maintenance and system lapses in 2024 East-West Line disruption
SMRT will be fined S$3 million following a six-day disruption on the East-West Line in September 2024. The Land Transport Authority (LTA) announced the penalty on 3 June 2025, citing serious lapses in maintenance practices and system response. On 25 September 2024, a key component known as an axle box dropped from a train travelling between Dover and Clementi MRT stations. This dislodgement caused the bogie—an undercarriage structure with wheels—to come off the rail, damaging the tracks and forcing a major service disruption. Nine stations between Boon Lay and Queenstown were affected, with normal service only resuming six days later on 1 October 2024. About 500,000 of the 2.8 million daily journeys were disrupted each day. Ageing fleet and delayed replacement The train involved was part of SMRT's first-generation KHI fleet, in operation since the late 1980s. These trains were due to be replaced by newer Movia models, with full handover originally scheduled by March 2024. However, due to delays from the COVID-19 pandemic, the first Movia train was only delivered in May 2023, over a year behind schedule. As a result, SMRT continued to operate some older trains, including the one involved in the incident. LTA found that the failed train had not undergone a scheduled overhaul despite being overdue. While overhauls are required every 500,000km, SMRT extended this interval twice—first to 575,000km in August 2022, then to 750,000km in August 2024. At the time of the incident, the train had clocked 690,000km since its last overhaul in 2018. By then, only 18 of the 66 KHI trains had been overhauled. The train involved was not among them. SMRT extended these intervals based on internal analyses and fleet performance data. However, LTA said no detailed engineering risk assessment was carried out regarding the axle box overhaul interval. Axle box damage and root cause analysis Investigators could not determine the precise cause of the axle box failure as the components were too severely burnt and damaged. These included the axle box itself, axle bearings, and chevron springs—critical parts within the bogie assembly. Nonetheless, LTA concluded that the likely cause was degraded grease inside the axle box. Grease degradation increases friction, which in turn accelerates wear and tear on components, potentially causing overheating. High heat and burnt materials found along tracks Burnt rubber and metal fragments from the chevron springs were discovered along the train's travel path. This suggests the axle box had overheated to the point of igniting surrounding rubber components. The degraded grease likely contributed to the axle box becoming dislodged, said LTA. The train's third carriage bogie came off the tracks, damaging a 2.55km stretch and causing 46 rail breaks. Warning system failure contributed to delay in response On the morning of the incident, SMRT's Hot Axle Box Detection system recorded a temperature spike—118 degrees Celsius compared to the usual 30–65 degrees Celsius range. This system uses infrared sensors to detect axle box heat and RFID tags to identify affected trains. However, due to a system error, the train's ID was not detected. Instead, a 'Null ID' appeared. The controller overseeing the system mistook the alert for a false warning and did not act on it. The Transport Safety Investigation Bureau (TSIB) said this issue had occurred previously but was not resolved. Lapses in procedures and response protocols TSIB noted that SMRT's operational procedures regarding the Hotbox system were 'not robust enough'. There was no escalation protocol for unidentified warnings, leading to possible staff desensitisation to repeated false alerts. Had the warning been addressed, the train could have been withdrawn before the axle box dislodged. Both LTA and TSIB concluded that the incident could likely have been prevented with proper maintenance and a timely response to the warning. Cost and consequences of disruption The six-day disruption required extensive repair and recovery efforts. SMRT provided free travel for affected passengers, including bridging buses, shuttle train services, and waived fares at Jurong East and Buona Vista stations. The total cost of SMRT's service recovery exceeded S$10 million. Despite the high costs already incurred by SMRT, LTA determined the fine was warranted given the serious operational lapses. The S$3 million fine will be channelled to the Public Transport Fund, which supports lower-income households with transport costs. LTA noted that SMRT will have the opportunity to appeal the fine to the Minister for Transport. The authority said its enforcement action considered both the operational failures and SMRT's efforts at service recovery. TSIB and LTA both emphasised the need for stricter adherence to maintenance schedules and more resilient fault detection procedures to prevent future incidents. SMRT: Pandemic-related delays and ageing assets posed challenges to overhaul and train replacement efforts SMRT acknowledged LTA's findings in a Facebook post on Tuesday, affirming its commitment to safety and operational excellence. The operator emphasised that safety remains its top priority, alongside balancing service reliability and cost-effectiveness. SMRT cited the COVID-19 pandemic as a major factor in disrupting train and spare part deliveries, which affected overhaul timelines. Despite continued regular maintenance, these delays hindered the overhaul of first-generation trains post-2018. SMRT stated it is working closely with LTA to renew assets, improve maintenance, and expedite new train commissioning, aiming to retire all first-generation trains by end-September 2025. The operator added it remains committed to continuous improvement, guided by Kaizen principles, to strengthen system resilience.
