'You've put on weight' — Woman asks if it's normal in Singapore to openly comment on someone's weight
SINGAPORE: Irritated at the freedom with which two people recently commented on her weight, a woman took to Reddit to ask if this is normal in Singapore.
In a Wednesday (June 11) post on r/askSingapore, u/slcreation101 wrote that prior to getting pregnant, she weighed 48kg. She now weighs 52kg, 16 months after giving birth. The heaviest she got during her pregnancy was 60kg, which means she has already lost a fair amount of weight, and she added that she is still breastfeeding.
Nevertheless, her Filipino helper and the admin staff at her baby's infant care have openly told her she's put on weight.
When she called the helper out, the helper explained that 'in Filipino culture, commenting on someone's weight is often seen as a neutral or even positive observation, like saying someone is eating well.'
And when the post author asked the helper if she wanted her to lose weight, the helper finally understood and stopped making these types of comments. See also Singaporeans Share Their Most Embarrassing Moments At Work
'I s this kind of comment socially acceptable in Singapore? Is it seen as normal or harmless in some cultures or communities here? I'd love to understand different perspectives on this, especially around cultural norms and personal boundaries,' the post author added.
Some commenters on her post confirmed what her Filipino helper had told her, that in their culture, people do comment on weight openly, with some even complimenting people when they've gained weight.
Others agreed that it may be part of some Asian cultures in general, especially with older generations.
'In the Anglo countries, people generally don't comment about each other's weight in front of their face. My parents grew up in a smaller Asian town where boundaries don't mean much. It might depend on how blunt a culture generally is. Not sure how it is in Germany, for example, but Japan would probably be more on the more polite side,' one wrote.
'Unfortunately, it's part of our culture, though they mean no harm. Everyone wants to talk to me about my weight, even if it's my body and none of their business. Just one ear goes in, one ear goes out la,' chimed in another.
Some reassured the post author that at her height of 1.6m, 52 kg is 'far from obese.'
Another endeavoured to explain that 'Asian folks love to comment on weight because the love language for a majority of seniors brought up in struggle times is to feed their family. If they see you've lost weight, they worry you're not eating enough and/or they're afraid they're not doing a good enough job. If you're fat, they'll worry about your health. Either way, they'll still force you to finish all the dishes on the table. Or else.'
They added, however, that focusing on weight is not just annoying but downright rude.
Others echoed this sentiment, adding that too much of a focus on body size can do real damage to people, especially to women, in the sense of leading to eating disorders. /TISG See also Can the Lions really 'roar' in Asean Suzuki Cup?
Read also: Woman who gained 20kg due to working stress in Singapore asks if she should quit her job 'to lose weight'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vogue Arabia
9 hours ago
- Vogue Arabia
The Japanese Habit That Helps Me Reduce Daily Stress
A few days ago, a friend of mine was telling me that her way of reducing the time she spent on social media (specifically Instagram) consisted of installing the application only once per day—only for the time reserved for browsing—and uninstalling it right after. At first, this seemed like an impractical solution, but when she explained it to me I understood everything. "Social media generates a certain addiction in me, and the way to control it is to only browse them at that moment. I waste less time by installing and uninstalling applications rather than leaving the application visible on my mobile, because in the latter case I'll waste hours by scrolling" he said. He convinced me, after all, that this was his particular strategy to eliminate obstacles that were taking up time and adding stress. Added stress is the stress that results from the feeling that you have spent your free time watching a sequence of unreal lives. It all reminded me of an atomic habit that the originator of this concept, James Clear, explains in his well-known book about those small habits that generate big changes in our lives. Clear always insists that the key to fulfilling resolutions without stress is to make it easy and beautiful (among other things). And that's precisely why he refers to a methodology that originated in Japan in the late 1940s, as explained in an article published in the New Yorker titled Better All the Time . It is known as 'lean' or streamlined production and began when Japanese companies completely overhauled their assembly lines to detect errors before they happened (and not after), carrying out lean production in which waste of all kinds that could worsen both the process and result were eliminated. And by waste they also meant redesigning the workspace so as not to waste time or generate 'movement waste' going from one place to another in search of tools, for example. With this strategy of eliminating barriers of any kind (not only physical, but also what Clear calls 'stress or resistance points') they managed to be much more productive, generate higher quality products and save time and money. And this can also involve eliminating distractions, as was the case with the friend I spoke about at the beginning of this article. The essence of lean This process optimisation methodology is not only applied in business, but also domestically in a much more mundane way to make our lives easier. Just google 'lean productivity techniques' to find several experts who explain how to put these strategies into practice to reduce daily stress caused by certain everyday situations that can be simplified if the process is optimised. For example, Brion Hurley, an expert in the field, confirms that in this way you can reduce frustration, prevent procrastination and save time. And he gives very simple examples that can summarise the essence of the benefits of eliminating barriers or stress points: something as obvious as removing objects from the floor that are obstacles when vacuuming or classifying work tools when cleaning the house, by categories, eliminating the unnecessary and designating a place for each thing—so that every task is not tedious but rather quick and practical. Reduce the stress points of daily activities to live better Clear stresses the importance of not forcing motivation when it comes to maintaining habits, but making things easier and simplifying. And instead of trying to overcome the resistance to stick to that habit, reduce it. "For example, when deciding where to practice a new habit, it's best to choose a place that is on the way when performing your daily routine. It's easier to build habits when they fit into the flow of your daily life. It's easier for you to go to the gym if it's on your way to work, because stopping there isn't going to add much stress to your lifestyle. Conversely, if the gym is off the road you normally follow - even if it's just a few blocks - you'll have to make a detour to get there," he explains. All of this is also about order and cleanliness, which facilitate the process—and even designing environments that facilitate those tasks and eliminate the resistance Clear talks about. In addition, by eliminating those points of tension that take time and energy away from us, "we can achieve more with less effort" and, as the expert points out, we also lighten the cognitive load involved. In short, it is a matter of making the road easier to meet the objectives and thus reduce daily stress. Some ways of eliminating stress points in everyday life Only turn to a fridge with healthy food when hungry. In fact, the Harvard School of Health states that according to a study conducted by Cornell University, people who stored sweets and fizzy drinks on their kitchen counter put on 9 to 11 kilos compared to those who kept them out of sight. Turn off your phone or put it on airplane mode when you need to concentrate at work. Neuroscience expert Ana Ibáñez calls it creating "concentration bubbles' and consists of working without interruptions by creating the environment for it, without a cell phone and even with music and lighting a candle. It all adds up. Practicing sports when getting up (to eliminate any obstacle or resistance during the day) and leaving your clothes ready the night before. Leave your phone in another room during lunch and dinner so that you can eat consciously, without having the impulse to look at your phone. If you want to drink more water during the workday, fill up a bottle and put it on your desk. This avoids the wasted motion of having to fetch it, which generates some resistance. When you start your facial care routine each morning, you can place your outfit of the day on your bathroom counter, so you don't have to rummage through the closet and avoid the stress of not finding something. It's all about making it easy to enjoy it. Article originally published on Vogue Spain
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Eyewitness recounts rescuing the injured after deadly Air India crash
Indian eyewitnesses recounted the moment an Air India plane bound for London crashed shortly after takeoff on Thursday. (AP Video: Piyush Nagpal and Shonal Ganguly)
Independent Singapore
19 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
'You've put on weight' — Woman asks if it's normal in Singapore to openly comment on someone's weight
SINGAPORE: Irritated at the freedom with which two people recently commented on her weight, a woman took to Reddit to ask if this is normal in Singapore. In a Wednesday (June 11) post on r/askSingapore, u/slcreation101 wrote that prior to getting pregnant, she weighed 48kg. She now weighs 52kg, 16 months after giving birth. The heaviest she got during her pregnancy was 60kg, which means she has already lost a fair amount of weight, and she added that she is still breastfeeding. Nevertheless, her Filipino helper and the admin staff at her baby's infant care have openly told her she's put on weight. When she called the helper out, the helper explained that 'in Filipino culture, commenting on someone's weight is often seen as a neutral or even positive observation, like saying someone is eating well.' And when the post author asked the helper if she wanted her to lose weight, the helper finally understood and stopped making these types of comments. See also Singaporeans Share Their Most Embarrassing Moments At Work 'I s this kind of comment socially acceptable in Singapore? Is it seen as normal or harmless in some cultures or communities here? I'd love to understand different perspectives on this, especially around cultural norms and personal boundaries,' the post author added. Some commenters on her post confirmed what her Filipino helper had told her, that in their culture, people do comment on weight openly, with some even complimenting people when they've gained weight. Others agreed that it may be part of some Asian cultures in general, especially with older generations. 'In the Anglo countries, people generally don't comment about each other's weight in front of their face. My parents grew up in a smaller Asian town where boundaries don't mean much. It might depend on how blunt a culture generally is. Not sure how it is in Germany, for example, but Japan would probably be more on the more polite side,' one wrote. 'Unfortunately, it's part of our culture, though they mean no harm. Everyone wants to talk to me about my weight, even if it's my body and none of their business. Just one ear goes in, one ear goes out la,' chimed in another. Some reassured the post author that at her height of 1.6m, 52 kg is 'far from obese.' Another endeavoured to explain that 'Asian folks love to comment on weight because the love language for a majority of seniors brought up in struggle times is to feed their family. If they see you've lost weight, they worry you're not eating enough and/or they're afraid they're not doing a good enough job. If you're fat, they'll worry about your health. Either way, they'll still force you to finish all the dishes on the table. Or else.' They added, however, that focusing on weight is not just annoying but downright rude. Others echoed this sentiment, adding that too much of a focus on body size can do real damage to people, especially to women, in the sense of leading to eating disorders. /TISG See also Can the Lions really 'roar' in Asean Suzuki Cup? Read also: Woman who gained 20kg due to working stress in Singapore asks if she should quit her job 'to lose weight'
