St. Johns County mother sentenced to prison for 2018 house fire that killed son
A St. Johns County woman accused of burning down her home in a 2018 fire that also killed her son has been sentenced to 3 years in prison followed by 5 years of probation.
Michelle Taylor was charged with second-degree manslaughter and faced up to 13 years behind bars after her 11-year-old son died in the fire.
On October 18th, 2018, Michelle Taylor, her son David, and 18-year-old daughter Bailey were at their home on Lee Street in St. Augustine when their house caught on fire.
Taylor and her 18-year-old daughter made it out of the house safely, but her 11-year-old ran back into the home to save their family dog, according to the State Attorney's Office. He died from smoke inhalation and severe burns.
Nearly three years later, in August 2021, Taylor was arrested and charged with first-degree murder and felony arson.
>>> STREAM ACTION NEWS JAX LIVE <<<
[DOWNLOAD: Free Action News Jax app for alerts as news breaks]
Investigators say she was trying to get insurance money from the house and later received a $90,000 check from her homeowner's insurance company.
According to our previous reporting, fire investigators with the State Fire Marshal determined several areas inside the house tested positive for gasoline.
On April 2nd, 2025, Taylor entered a no-contest plea for second-degree manslaughter in exchange for the murder charge being dropped. The arson charges were dropped at the sentencing as part of the plea agreement.
During the hearing, the defense called upon seven witnesses, including Taylor's husband, daughter, and mother.
Taylor herself took to the podium and delivered a very emotional testimony about how much she loved her son David.
'The day that he died, I died,' said Taylor.
The State Attorney's Office called several witnesses as well.
Taylor will only have to serve two and a half months in Florida State Prison, as she already served 33 months in the St. Johns County Jail.
[SIGN UP: Action News Jax Daily Headlines Newsletter]
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The Glynn County Board of Commissioners selects new Assistant County Manager
The Glynn County Board of Commissioners selected County Manager William Fallon's appointment of Danny Smith as the new Assistant County Manager, effective June 29, 2025. Smith replaces Assistant County Manager John Gentry, who took a new position as Assistant County Administrator in Hall County, GA. >>> STREAM ACTION NEWS JAX LIVE <<< 'Danny Smith is the kind of steady, experienced leader Glynn County needs as we continue to grow and modernize our operations. His proven track record as Public Works Director, improving government efficiency, and serving with integrity made him the clear choice. We are excited to welcome him to this new position and we look forward to benefitting from his vision and leadership,' said Glynn County Board of Commissioners Chairman Walter Rafolski. [DOWNLOAD: Free Action News Jax app for alerts as news breaks] Before joining Glynn County, Smith served in leadership positions in public works and environmental services in Florida and Colorado, including roles in Manatee County and the Town of Parker. He graduated from the University of Florida with a Bachelor of Science. [SIGN UP: Action News Jax Daily Headlines Newsletter] 'We are fortunate to have had several qualified internal candidates that were considered for this position. Danny's experience, education, accountability and numerous certifications in the areas of responsibility for this position made him the right choice for this selection,' said County Manager William Fallon. Smith will manage storms and play an important role in the oversight of capital projects. Click here to download the free Action News Jax news and weather apps, click here to download the Action News Jax Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Action News Jax live.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
FIRST ALERT WEATHER DAY: Building humidity, rain & storms
The Action News Jax First Alert Weather Team is tracking another beautiful day to end the weekend. Notes from the meteorologist: It's another really nice day for the second half of the weekend There's still a haze to the sky this afternoon & evening Smoke from Canadian wildfires will linger through the day Monday, with no impact to our air quality Tonight will be mild again, and Monday will be mostly sunny & very warm again Onshore winds breeze up Tuesday, increasing the humidity There may be an isolated shower moving inland through the day too Wednesday & Thursday look wet with mostly cloudy skies & scattered showers Rain coverage backs off Friday thru the weekend, but I still expect some storms each day WATCH THE FORECAST | DOWNLOAD THE APPS TROPICS There are no active storms and no development is expected in the next 5-7 days Saharan dust will be working its way across the Atlantic and over Florida later this week LISTEN: Mike Buresh 'All the Weather, All the Time' Podcast First Alert 7-Day Forecast: TONIGHT: Mostly Clear & Mild. Low: 66 TOMORROW: Mostly to Partly Sunny. High: 92 TUE: Partly Sunny, Isolated Shower. 68/89 WED: Mostly Cloudy, Scattered Showers. 72/86 THU: Mostly Cloudy, Scattered Showers. 70/87 FRI: Partly Cloudy, A Few Storms. 72/91 SAT: Partly Sunny, Isolated Storms. 71/90 SUN: Partly Cloudy, Isolated Storms. 72/91 Follow Action News Jax Meteorologists on Twitter for updates: Mike Buresh | Garrett Bedenbaugh | Corey Simma | Trevor Gibbs INTERACTIVE RADAR: Keep track of the rain as it moves through your neighborhood SHARE WITH US: Send us photos of the weather you're seeing in your area ⬇️
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Sharks get the job done in a hurry as they make it two from two in Blast
Sussex claimed a swift and comfortable T20 Vitality Blast home victory over last year's champions Gloucestershire, winning by 80 runs as Tom Alsop and James Coles set up a commanding total, with skipper Tymal Mills claiming three wickets. After being put in to bat, Sussex started brightly, with opener Daniel Hughes twice finding the boundary in the first over. Advertisement Fellow opener Harrison Ward fell for one in the second over, clean bowled by the off-spin of Ollie Price after going back and trying to cut a straight delivery which wasn't that short. Hughes kept his foot on the gas, hitting powerfully down the ground and square of the wicket, before tamely chipping a short delivery from Price into the hands of James Taylor at mid-off for 35 from 19. Hammond took a wonderful diving catch in the sixth over to dismiss John Simpson for eight off the bowling of Taylor, and the Sharks finished the powerplay on 53-3. James Coles started slowly, but Alsop hit both of his first two balls for four and didn't look back, thumping Tom Smith back over his head for the first six of the innings in the 11th over, and managing to hit the clock face above the scoreboard with another huge blow shortly after. Advertisement Coles got in on the act too, twice hitting Taylor over the square leg boundary in the 13th, almost striking the clock himself. Alsop reached his 50 from 30 in the 14th over, and the pair brought up their 100 partnership in the 15th. Sussex were well on top by this point, but David Payne seemed to have swung momentum back in Gloucestershire's favour when he dismissed Alsop (58 off 35) and then Coles (43 off 27) in the 16th over - Alsop stretching for a wide slower ball and looping it to short third man, Coles pulling a shortish delivery straight to mid wicket, leaving the Sharks 149-5. No subsequent batter could add more than ten runs to the total in the remaining four overs. Advertisement Smith took an amazing caught and bowled after Tom Clark smashed one back towards his face for two, and Jack Carson holed out at long on off Aman Rao's bowling, just after hitting an impressive pull shot over square leg for six. Nathan McAndrew was also caught on the boundary, becoming Payne's third wicket in an outstanding spell of 4-24 in his four overs. Tom Alsop adds to his tally (Image: Simon Dack) Ollie Robinson tried a few scoops, but eventually lobbed one straight to the keeper for six, and skipper Tymal Mills was out off the final ball of the innings, caught for one off the bowling of Taylor, with Sussex setting Gloucestershire a target of 174 to win. That seemed at the halfway point just above a par score, on a good wicket with a lightning outfield. Advertisement However, it became apparent quite quickly that Sussex's total would be far out of Gloucestershire's reach. Robinson showed his class with a high quality opening spell, clean bowling Australian opener Bancroft for seven in the third over with a world class delivery that kissed the top of off stump. He was very unfortunate not to have Price in the third over with lbw and, by the time Robinson had completed his third over, Gloucestershire were 29-2, with Currie having removed D'arcy Short for a duck. Hammond looked good for 24, but when he fell to Mills in the final over of the powerplay, Gloucestershire looked in trouble at 34-3. Advertisement Bracey looked in decent nick but also couldn't get past 24, joint top-scoring with Hammond. Mills bamboozled the lower order with his slower deliveries, finishing with 3-13, but everyone chipped in with Coles and Carson picking up two wickets each, and McAndrew claiming another. Gloucestershire were dismissed for 93 in the 14th over, with Sussex winning by a huge 80 runs.
