‘Misplaced concerns', ‘misconceptions': In paper countering Project Cheetah criticism, officials say animals are now well-adapted
Amid continuing criticism of various aspects of Project Cheetah, wildlife officials and field scientists from the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) have authored a paper seeking to counter what they termed 'persistent criticism' and 'sensationalised media narratives' against the project, and defended its progress.
The officials and scientists said some of the criticism against the project was 'rooted in ideological biases'.
Published in Frontiers in Conservation Science journal, the paper said that cheetahs imported to India have adapted ecologically and that the project had demonstrated significant progress in 2.5 years.
It added that the project was on a promising trajectory, even as cheetah reintroduction was a 'gradual and risky process, with inevitable and adaptive learning'. NTCA's assistant veterinary officer Sanath Krishna Muliya is the paper's lead author, and Project Tiger head Gobind Sagar Bharadwaj is among the co-authors.
Project Cheetah was launched in September 2022 and introduced African cheetahs into India from Namibia and South Africa. Initially, 20 cheetahs were imported from the two countries.
The paper delved into issues such as the project's scientific merits, 'misplaced concerns about cheetahs in captivity', 'misinformed ethical and justice concerns', and 'misconceptions about veterinary capabilities and field interventions.'
It sought to rebut criticism that the cheetahs were held in enclosures for a long duration, as well as questions raised on what criteria were followed for the same.
The government officials said in the paper that the cheetahs were held in 'soft-release bomas' or large enclosures, where they hunted locally available prey, and no prey was provided. They added that the soft-release practice was internationally recognised for carnivore reintroductions.
The cheetahs, the paper said, are now well adapted to the landscape after the phased release process resumed in early 2025 after setbacks such as deaths during May-June 2023 due to what it called 'unforeseen challenges' of tick infestations due to unseasonal winter coats. As per the paper, six introduced cheetahs and 18 cubs are currently free-ranging in Kuno's wilderness and others await release. The government is also negotiating with the governments of Namibia, Botswana, and South Africa, for more cheetah translocations, the paper said.
However, the paper did not touch upon the death of male cheetah Pawan, who died due to drowning in August 2024, as per the Madhya Pradesh forest department.
The paper also cited the birth of 25 cubs in 2.5 years as a sign of a stress-free environment. On criticism regarding the project's social impacts, the paper claimed that there was no unjustified displacement or coerced relocation of local communities, and much of the relocation had happened long before.
On the stress faced by the wild cats due to recurring immobilisation, the paper said that zero deaths were recorded due to immobilisation. Since the project began, there have been 90 immobilisations of over 20 cheetahs in a span of 2.5 years, for preventive care, medical treatment, and radio-collar deployment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
4 hours ago
- Indian Express
‘Misplaced concerns', ‘misconceptions': In paper countering Project Cheetah criticism, officials say animals are now well-adapted
Amid continuing criticism of various aspects of Project Cheetah, wildlife officials and field scientists from the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) have authored a paper seeking to counter what they termed 'persistent criticism' and 'sensationalised media narratives' against the project, and defended its progress. The officials and scientists said some of the criticism against the project was 'rooted in ideological biases'. Published in Frontiers in Conservation Science journal, the paper said that cheetahs imported to India have adapted ecologically and that the project had demonstrated significant progress in 2.5 years. It added that the project was on a promising trajectory, even as cheetah reintroduction was a 'gradual and risky process, with inevitable and adaptive learning'. NTCA's assistant veterinary officer Sanath Krishna Muliya is the paper's lead author, and Project Tiger head Gobind Sagar Bharadwaj is among the co-authors. Project Cheetah was launched in September 2022 and introduced African cheetahs into India from Namibia and South Africa. Initially, 20 cheetahs were imported from the two countries. The paper delved into issues such as the project's scientific merits, 'misplaced concerns about cheetahs in captivity', 'misinformed ethical and justice concerns', and 'misconceptions about veterinary capabilities and field interventions.' It sought to rebut criticism that the cheetahs were held in enclosures for a long duration, as well as questions raised on what criteria were followed for the same. The government officials said in the paper that the cheetahs were held in 'soft-release bomas' or large enclosures, where they hunted locally available prey, and no prey was provided. They added that the soft-release practice was internationally recognised for carnivore reintroductions. The cheetahs, the paper said, are now well adapted to the landscape after the phased release process resumed in early 2025 after setbacks such as deaths during May-June 2023 due to what it called 'unforeseen challenges' of tick infestations due to unseasonal winter coats. As per the paper, six introduced cheetahs and 18 cubs are currently free-ranging in Kuno's wilderness and others await release. The government is also negotiating with the governments of Namibia, Botswana, and South Africa, for more cheetah translocations, the paper said. However, the paper did not touch upon the death of male cheetah Pawan, who died due to drowning in August 2024, as per the Madhya Pradesh forest department. The paper also cited the birth of 25 cubs in 2.5 years as a sign of a stress-free environment. On criticism regarding the project's social impacts, the paper claimed that there was no unjustified displacement or coerced relocation of local communities, and much of the relocation had happened long before. On the stress faced by the wild cats due to recurring immobilisation, the paper said that zero deaths were recorded due to immobilisation. Since the project began, there have been 90 immobilisations of over 20 cheetahs in a span of 2.5 years, for preventive care, medical treatment, and radio-collar deployment.
Hindustan Times
a day ago
- Hindustan Times
Decline in tiger prey due to civil unrest, deforestation, poaching: New report
Guwahati: A recent report by the Wildlife Institute of India (WII) has raised concerns over the declining population of ungulates — hoofed mammals such as deer, antelopes, and wild boars — in over a quarter of India's tiger habitats, citing rising civil unrest and human-wildlife conflict as major causes. 'Ungulates play a key role in sustaining large carnivores like tigers and leopards and medium ones like hyenas and jackals. A thriving ungulate population sustains these carnivores, which in turn play a vital role in regulating the predator-prey dynamic essential for maintaining ecological balance,' the report uploaded on the WII website last week said. The report, based on the first-ever study on the status of ungulates conducted by the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) and the Dehradun-based WII, using data from the 2022 tiger census, highlights multiple threats faced by these hoofed mammals. These include habitat loss due to deforestation, urbanisation, and agricultural expansion, as well as poaching and the decline of livestock. Human-wildlife conflict, particularly crop raiding by certain ungulate species, often leads to retaliatory killings, further contributing to their population decline. A total of 39 species of ungulates are reported in India. Chital, sambar, wild pig, nilgai, barking deer, and gaur are the most abundant herbivorous ungulate species and are widely distributed across India, unlike other ungulate species which have much smaller and specialised fundamental niches. The report mentioned that densities of 30 or more prey per square kilometre can support over four tigers per 100 square kilometres, and this tiger density scales with increasing prey availability. Also Read: 272 km fencing to curb man-animal conflict in UP: Govt 'In Odisha, both prey and tiger densities are low. High bushmeat consumption and civil unrest in the region negatively impact wildlife presence, leading to low ungulate densities,' the report read. Similarly, 'Palamau (tiger reserve in Jharkhand), an important part of the Central Indian corridor, faces challenges such as left-wing extremism, which affects wildlife presence. The area has very low ungulate and leopard densities and has not had a resident tiger population for more than a decade,' it added. Maharashtra tiger reserves, particularly Tadoba, and in Ratapani of Madhya Pradesh, carnivore presence is high, whereas prey density remains low. As a result, these areas experience high rates of livestock depredation, leading to increased human-wildlife conflict. Similarly, tiger reserves like Nagarjun Sagar (Andhra Pradesh) and Amarabad (Telangana) show a rapidly increasing tiger population but low prey density. Without prey recovery and supplementation, human-wildlife conflict in this region is also expected to rise rapidly, the report said. The report also mentioned that the Valmiki-Sohagibarwa landscape (in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh respectively) has a high human population density alongside an increasing tiger population. 'Without a proper ungulate population recovery plan, this landscape may experience heightened conflict between carnivores, livestock, and humans,' the report added. Also Read: Human-wildlife conflicts: Karnataka, Kerala ink pact The study found a decline in populations of chital, sambar, and gaur in 28, 27, and 28 percent of the tiger habitats in India between 2014 and 2022. The populations of the three species were found either stable or showed an increase in the rest of the tiger habitats during the same period. Chital, sambar, and gaur are key prey species in the tiger's diet. 'Chital, sambar, and gaur exhibit similar population trends with approximately 27% of sites showing a decline. This correlates to an increased probability of livestock depredation in these areas,' the report said. Areas with high densities of these ungulates often support higher tiger densities. When preferred prey is not available, tigers shift to smaller prey such as wild pigs or barking deer, the report added. 'As prey densities increase, tiger densities rise sharply, reflecting the critical role of prey abundance in supporting predator populations. However, beyond 75 prey per square kilometre, the curve plateaus, indicating diminishing returns where additional prey no longer correlates with higher tiger densities,' the report said.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
'Run for Nature 3.0': Environmental education needed for all says environmentalist; 10,000 mango saplings distributed
HUBBALLI: The number of educated individuals has increased enormously, but educated people are weak in environmental education, regretted environmentalist and writer Shivanand Kalave. Addressing Run For Nature 3.0, organised by Green Karnataka Association, We Care Foundation, and Vasundhara Foundation, here on Sunday, Kalave said that there is a need for environmental education for educated people, whereas less educated and illiterate people are living in an eco-friendly way. 'There are trees over 5,000 years old in African countries, and their saplings are being grown in Karnataka. However, human beings, with a lifespan of about 100 years, are killing trees for their greed. If we don't go back to trees, the end of mankind is in the near future,' he warned. Natural farming expert Kavita Mishra pressed for the plantation of carbon credit trees to combat increasing carbon in the environment. 'A myth is spread that agriculture is not a profitable occupation. If we do it with heart, Mother Earth will definitely hold our hands, and I am an instance of these words. I have grown about 8,000 trees on 8.10 acres of land and earn in lakhs a month,' she claimed. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Keep Your Home Efficient with This Plug-In elecTrick - Save upto 80% on Power Bill Learn More Undo MLA Prasad Abbayya narrated that the celebration of World Environment Day started in 1973, but there is still a need for awareness. 'God has given us good nature, but human beings are spoiling it. Because of pollution, we are all consuming poisonous food. Protecting the environment is not only the duty of the govt or organisations, but everyone should join hands at an individual level,' he asserted. Kshamata Seva Samsthe convenor Govind Joshi said that Indians have been worshipping the environment in the form of trees, water, air, and all other components of the ecology. 'However, these components are being destroyed in the name of modernisation,' he analysed. Organiser Channu Hosamani said that they are distributing 10,000 mango Alphonso saplings to citizens so that they can grow them in their home gardens and eat chemical-free mangoes in the coming years. MLA Mahesh Tenginkai and others inaugurated the run.
