logo
Court grants leave for Australian women to sue Qatar Airways over alleged invasive physical examinations

Court grants leave for Australian women to sue Qatar Airways over alleged invasive physical examinations

The Guardian24-07-2025
Five Australian women who allege they were forced off a Qatar Airways plane by armed guards before some were intimately examined at Doha airport will be able to sue the airline directly, the federal court has ruled.
The women launched an appeal in April last year hoping to overturn a ruling that the airline could not face trial for the October 2020 incident, when they were among more than a dozen women forcibly led from a Sydney-bound plane and escorted into ambulances.
Four of the women underwent bodily examinations – three of which were invasive – without consent as part of a local investigation to find the mother of a newborn baby found abandoned in a bathroom in Hamad international airport. The infant survived.
The episode sparked international outrage, with the women suing Qatar Airways Group, Qatar Civil Aviation Authority (QCAA) and Matar, the Qatari company responsible for airports operation and management, for negligence, assault, false imprisonment and battery.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
But the case against the airline, in which they sought damages over alleged 'unlawful physical contact', was dismissed, with Justice John Halley finding that Qatar Airways should not have to go to trial because its employees could not have influenced the actions of Qatari police, who boarded the planes to remove the women.
Halley also found that the QCAA was immune from the court's jurisdiction and determined that the five women could instead refile their claims for damages against Matar.
The women lodged an appeal against the judgment, hoping to pursue Qatar Airways and the QCAA directly.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
On Thursday morning the federal chief justice, Angus Stewart, said the court found that Halley had 'erred' when he summarily dismissed the airline's claims that the invasive examinations had not taken place in 'the course of any of the operations of embarking or disembarking' the aircraft.
'There is no sufficiently high degree of certainty that what happened to the appellants in the ambulance could not ultimately be found to have been in 'the course of any of the operations of embarking or disembarking',' Stewart told the court. The issue could 'only be decided at trial and not on a summary basis'.
He also found that Matar's application to set aside service should have been dismissed – and that its claim a nurse who had who performed the bodily examinations was not its employee was arguable.
It was an 'error to conclude at this stage of the proceeding that Matar's duty of care cannot possibly extend to the circumstances in and around the ambulance', he ruled.
He ordered Qatar Airways and Matar to pay the costs of the appeal.
But the judge dismissed the women's appeal against the QCAA, telling the court the evidence showed management activities of the government-run authority 'were in pursuit of public functions of the State of Qatar'.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Freedom Flotilla activists say they were ‘brutalised psychologically' by Israeli military after aid boat boarded
Freedom Flotilla activists say they were ‘brutalised psychologically' by Israeli military after aid boat boarded

The Independent

time33 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Freedom Flotilla activists say they were ‘brutalised psychologically' by Israeli military after aid boat boarded

Two Australian activists have claimed they were 'brutalised psychologically' by the Israeli military, strip-searched and shackled, after their Freedom Flotilla boat was intercepted. Journalist Tania Safi and activist Robert Martin were detained while onboard the Handala, which was seeking to deliver aid to Gaza as part of the Freedom Flotilla Coalition. After their arrest alongside 19 other activists on Sunday, the pair were transported to Israel and spent days in Israeli custody, where they allege they were manhandled and treated like criminals. The Handala was carrying 21 civilians representing 12 countries - including the UK - with parliamentarians, lawyers, journalists, environmentalists, and other human rights defenders among them. It was carrying aid including baby formula, nappies, food, and medicine for the Gaza strip, where a starvation crisis has prompted international outcry after dozens of Palestinians died from hunger-related causes in recent weeks. Experts, the UN, and other countries say Israeli blockades caused the crisis. The Israeli government says Hamas is at fault and has accused the Palestinian militants of stealing food from aid trucks. The two Australian activists landed back in Sydney on Friday morning, where they spoke to reporters about their ordeal. Ms Safi said at least 30 IDF members boarded Handala when it was intercepted, and claimed all were armed, some with four guns. 'They knocked me in the leg with one of their machine guns,' Ms Safi said of the moment around 30 IDF soldiers boarded the Handala after it was intercepted, speaking to The Guardian. After being taken to the port of Ashdod south of Tel Aviv, the group was taken to interrogation rooms. Ms Safi supported earlier allegations by the group that Chris Smalls, the former president of the Amazon Labour Union who was onboard the Handala, was physically assaulted by IDF troops. 'Chris was pinned down by seven or eight men,' she told the outlet. 'When I asked about him they came into the room and dragged me out by my arms, I'm still bruised from it. 'They pulled me out and threw me down on the floor, they made me take off all my clothes, they strip-searched me right there, made me squat up and down … they treated us like we were criminals.' Ms Safi, who said she witnessed 'the soullessness and the cruelty and brutality' of Israeli detention, added that soldiers would 'handcuff me and grab the handcuffs and just throw me against the wall'. She said the military tried to get the Handala activists to sign documents which said they had entered Israel illegally, which Ms Safi says is 'not true… we were taken completely against our will and brutalised psychologically in every way'. Mr Martin alleged he was not allowed any of the medication that he required, nor was he allowed to make any phone calls to loved ones and 'anybody else' - despite the Australian government demanding to Israel that they were allowed to do so. They were eventually transported to Jordan, where they were assisted by the Australian embassy and taken to hospital, he added. The Handala incident came nearly two months after the Madleen, a Freedom Flotilla with Swedish activist Greta Thunberg on board, was intercepted by the Israeli army on 9 June. The IDF has been contacted for comment. In a statement on X after the boat was seized, the Israeli Foreign Ministry said the military had prevented the boat from 'illegally entering the maritime zone of the coast of Gaza'. It added: 'The vessel is safely making its way to the shores of Israel. All passengers are safe. Unauthorized attempts to breach the blockade are dangerous, unlawful, and undermine ongoing humanitarian efforts.' Regarding the alleged assault on Mr Smalls, the Israeli foreign ministry told The Guardian on Thursday: 'Contrary to the claims made, the passenger violently resisted. This was a planned provocation intended to create media attention.'

Underworld figure's two-word taunt before being gunned down - as his prophetic tattoos are revealed
Underworld figure's two-word taunt before being gunned down - as his prophetic tattoos are revealed

Daily Mail​

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mail​

Underworld figure's two-word taunt before being gunned down - as his prophetic tattoos are revealed

A man who was gunned down in a daylight shooting near his family home taunted his killer in his final moments. Athan Boursinos, 21, was shot dead in a 'targeted' shooting near a kindergarten as he left his family home in Wollert, in Melbourne 's outer north, at 9am on Thursday. Several neighbours claimed to have heard Mr Boursinos engaged in a verbal argument with his killer in the moments before he was peppered with bullets. It's understood Mr Boursinos taunted his killer, urging him to 'do it' before he was shot dead, witnesses told The Herald Sun. It comes as new photos emerged of Mr Boursinos showing the eerily prophetic tattoo he had etched on his neck. 'The souls I have taken will never haunt me. Only the ones I haven't,' the tattoo on the left side of his neck read. The quote was also tattooed on the chest of murdered Sydney gangster Hamad 'the Executioner' Assaad. His body was also covered in symbols and slogans associated with criminal organisations from around the world. Wedged between a large cross on his chest and a blade on his torso, Mr Boursinos had the word 'Omerta' tattooed. Omerta is a word used to describe the code of silence, particularly associated with the Mafia in Southern Italy. In another photograph, a tattoo of an outlined teardrop can be seen underneath one of Mr Boursinos' eyes. The teardrop symbol is common among American gang and prison culture and can represent several things, including acts of violence, loss of life, the taking of a life or even time served in jail. Mr Boursinos also had the name of his fiancée, Sanaria Rofael, tattooed on his upper right arm in red capital letters. Ms Rofael was seen sobbing at the scene, wearing a maroon tracksuit and holding a Fendi handbag while detectives began their investigation into the shooting. In a heartbreaking tribute to her fiancé, Ms Rofael shared a carousel of images to Instagram just hours after his death. 'I miss you,' she captioned the post. 'I would do anything in this world to feel this with you again. I will never stop loving you, you showed me what love was. I love you so much. I will see you soon. 'You're the best person I have ever met with the best soul. I can't wait to see you and hold you again.' Mr Boursinos was due to face court later that day regarding several lingering drug, weapon, theft and driving charges he had been facing. The 21-year-old is also believed to have been an associate of underworld kingpin and exiled crime boss Kazem 'Kaz' Hamad. It's understood Mr Boursinos was leaving his home to appear in court when he was ambushed near his BMW. His body was found lying beside a grey BMW with the driver door open and the engine apparently still running. A neighbour said her brother heard eight shots ring out and ran to see the man's last breaths before he died. Prior to his execution, his killers reportedly planted a getaway car near his home at 4am on Thursday - just five hours before he was shot dead. Homicide squad Detective Inspector Dean Thomas said police believed the gunman shot and killed Mr Boursinos in Game Lane before fleeing the scene in another vehicle. 'We also have reports of a vehicle being found burnt out in Amery Street in Reservoir,' Det Insp Thomas told reporters. The getaway vehicle had been parked just in front of where the Nissan, which had been driven to Mr Boursinos' house, was torched. Two hooded figures in black clothing were seen fleeing the scene immediately after setting the vehicle alight. Homicide squad detectives have remained in the area and several crime scenes have been established. Another vehicle was found with extensive fire damage three kilometres away but detectives have no reason to believe it is linked to the killing. Any trace of evidence or fingerprints was unrecoverable from either car. Mr Boursinos is suspected of being linked to the execution of underworld figure Sam 'The Punisher' Abdulrahim on January 28. Detectives admitted Mr Boursinos' murder appeared to be 'very deliberate and obviously targeted' and that he had been 'known' to police before his death. Independent journalist Ryan Naumenko's website Outlaw Media - which charts Melbourne's underworld crime news - labelled Thursday's murder a gangland hit. 'If the information I have is right... this will be bigger than World War 3,' he wrote. Mr Boursinos' killers remain on the run.

‘What's wrong with you?' – Legendary jockey stood down with immediate effect over allegedly ‘racist' videos
‘What's wrong with you?' – Legendary jockey stood down with immediate effect over allegedly ‘racist' videos

The Sun

time4 hours ago

  • The Sun

‘What's wrong with you?' – Legendary jockey stood down with immediate effect over allegedly ‘racist' videos

A LEGENDARY jockey has been stood down with immediate effect over two allegedly 'racist' videos. Iconic Australian rider Noel Callow, 50, faces his career ending in tatters after two clips were leaked. 2 2 In both videos he appears to hurl allegedly racist insults at Indigenous people. In the first Callow appears to ridicule a man while holding a slice of pizza and says 'you stink' while demanding he take a shower. In the other, a man believed to be Callow is cycling down the street. He deliberately rides through a group of people before shouting disgusting racial slurs in their direction. An investigation was launched after the videos were leaked online and charges have now been brought against the multiple Group 1 winner. He has been stood down from racing and had his riding licence suspended in full, pending the outcome of the stewards' enquiry. A statement read: "The Queensland Racing Integrity Commission (QRIC) has today convened a Stewards' Inquiry and issued two charges under Australian Rule of Racing AR 228(a) against licensed jockey Mr Noel Callow. "The charges relate to conduct alleged to have occurred approximately one year ago while Mr Callow was not riding at, or attending, a race meeting and was not at any racecourse. "It is alleged Mr Callow engaged in conduct prejudicial to the image of racing. "Acting under AR 23(a), the Stewards have suspended Mr Callow's jockey licence in full, pending the outcome of the inquiry. "Mr Callow has been informed of his right of appeal in respect of this decision. "QRIC takes matters concerning conduct, welfare, and integrity seriously and will continue to ensure all participants are held to the highest professional and behavioural standards." Famed jockey Callow was recently in trouble with stewards after getting knocked out in a fight he started with a rival jockey.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store