How a quirk of wartime football led to an extra list of AP All-Americans during the 1940s
The answer is that in 1943, Todd played for a service team — a quirk of wartime football that led some NFL players back to college football. Sort of.
During World War II, military posts in the U.S. fielded football teams of their own. These weren't college teams in any traditional sense, but they were part of the college game. In addition to facing each other, they took on college programs and were included in AP team rankings.
The AP, at least in 1943 and 1944, also named a service All-America team in addition to its more traditional one for college players that began in 1925.
That's how Todd, who was on Washington's 1942 NFL championship team, became an AP military service All-American in 1943. He played for Iowa Pre-Flight, which finished that season ranked No. 2 in the AP poll — between No. 1 Notre Dame and No. 3 Michigan.
'There were some very strong teams,' said College Football Hall of Fame historian Denis Crawford, who noted that service teams also existed in World War I. That's how the 1918 Rose Bowl came to pit Camp Lewis (Army) against Mare Island (Marines).
After making the college All-America team in 1943 with Northwestern, future Hall of Famer Otto Graham was named to the service All-America team the following year with North Carolina Pre-Flight.
Bruce Smith won the 1941 Heisman Trophy as a running back for Minnesota. He later played for both Great Lakes Naval and St. Mary's Pre-Flight. The transfer portal was wild back then.
Randolph Field played Texas to a 7-7 tie in the 1944 Cotton Bowl, with former Tulsa star Glenn Dobbs throwing a touchdown pass.
Since the service teams could include ex-college stars and players with NFL experience, perhaps it's no surprise that facing them could be a challenge. Top-ranked Notre Dame was the AP's national champion in 1943 despite losing its only game to a Great Lakes (Navy) team ranked No. 6.
Crawford said he isn't aware of any major backlash to the idea of putting college players up against pros. Just keeping the sport going during the war was hard enough.
'I didn't run across a lot of articles bemoaning this,' Crawford said. 'I think people were just happy to have the distraction.'
Wartime football games were just one part of the relationship between the military and U.S. colleges. Training programs could help bring more people to campus — which schools certainly could use.
'The V-5 and V-12 programs had a direct impact on helping a lot of college football teams survive, and in the case of Notre Dame, helping the university survive,' Crawford said. 'To this day, that's why Navy and Notre Dame play every year. Notre Dame has a debt of gratitude to Navy for putting one of the V programs in South Bend, which kept that school humming.'
___
Get poll alerts and updates on the AP Top 25 throughout the season. Sign up here. AP college football: https://apnews.com/hub/ap-top-25-college-football-poll and https://apnews.com/hub/college-football
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
3 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Justin Herbert to play in his first-ever preseason game as the Chargers face the Rams
EL SEGUNDO, Calif. (AP) — Justin Herbert will play in the first preseason game of his career when the Los Angeles Chargers visit the LA Rams on Saturday. Herbert will play one or two series in the game at SoFi Stadium, coach Jim Harbaugh said Thursday. Entering his sixth season in the league, the 27-year-old quarterback has yet to throw a pass in a preseason game. When he was a rookie in 2020, the preseason was canceled because of the COVID-19 pandemic. By 2021, Herbert was coming off a stellar rookie year and then-Chargers coach Brandon Staley didn't want to risk an injury during exhibition play. Staley maintained that approached in 2023, as did Harbaugh when he took over last season. Trey Lance and Taylor Heinicke will play after Herbert. Lance threw for only 55 yards against the New Orleans Saints last weekend but he ran seven times for a team-high 48 yards, including a 5-yard TD run. Lance threw for two TDs in a win over the Detroit Lions in the Hall of Fame game. Heinicke started against the Saints and was 1 of 5 for 8 yards. Herbert and wide receiver Keenan Allen will be among the offensive starters who will play against the Rams. On defense, Khalil Mack and Derwin James Jr. won't play as Harbaugh indicated they don't need the reps. Thursdays Keep up to date on sports with Mike McIntyre's weekly newsletter. 'I know they're ready,' he said. 'I remember when K Mack got traded to the Bears and didn't practice at all and then pick-6 and a couple sacks. I know they're good and ready to go.' The Chargers, who are 2-0 in the preseason, canceled their joint practice with the Rams on Wednesday, citing a rash of injuries, including the season-ending loss of Rashawn Slater. 'We felt it was more prudent to reconfigure,' Harbaugh said, 'and that's what we did.' ___ AP NFL:
Winnipeg Free Press
3 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
The Mid-American Conference heads into the season with experienced quarterback at top teams
Quarterback Dequan Finn is returning to a very different Mid-American Conference than the one he left when he transferred to Baylor last year. His biggest challenge now comes from quarterback Parker Navarro, who led Ohio to the 2024 league crown. Finn's backup at Toledo, Tucker Gleason, is now the incumbent starter for the preseason favorite. And Finn, the 2023 MAC player of the year, is back to prove he's still the best of the bunch, this time at Miami (Ohio). Naturally, the league's three best quarterbacks also happen to be running the top three teams as each vies for a championship ring. 'When I got in the portal, that was just like a second chance for me, a second opportunity to showcase my skills,' Finn said during last month league media day in Detroit. 'And having a second chance to be on the football field doing what I love the most.' It didn't take Finn long to find out how fleeting success can be. He lost the starting job after two games and only made one more appearance before opting to leave the Bears. But with so many proven winners and big-name quarterbacks around the league and his starter leaving, Miami coach Chuck Martin waited for Finn to make his decision. Can he help the RedHawks outduel Navarro, the star in Ohio's 38-3 rout of rival Miami in December's title game, Gleason or anyone else? Perhaps. 'I don't know if he was looking to come back to the MAC or even to Miami, I don't think that was the plan,' Martin said. 'You're losing your starter, we had a wide open door for somebody to come in and take the job. It worked out good for him and worked out good for us.' Other top QBs in the league include Akron incumbent Ben Finley, the brother of former NFL quarterback Ryan Finley, and Bowling Green's Drew Pyne, who played previously at Notre Dame, Arizona State and Missouri. Each knows the journey will be challenging. 'It would be a display of dominance,' Navarro said when asked what it would mean if Ohio won consecutive crowns after snapping a nearly six-decade title drought. 'But we know there's a target on us, and we're excited about it.' Hello and goodbye In a college football era where change has become the norm, the MAC has been the most stable conference in the FBS. It couldn't stay that way forever. The league has expanded to 13 teams this season thanks to the return of UMass, which spent the last nine seasons as an independent after playing in the league from 2012-15. This season also marks the final year of Northern Illinois' second MAC stint. The Huskies first played in the MAC from 1975-85 then returned in 1997 and pulled off last season's biggest upset, at Notre Dame. They're headed to the Mountain West next year. New faces The 13-team MAC has five new coaches this season while another — Kent State coach Mark Carney — dropped the interim tag despite a winless 2024. The headliner is easy: Bowling Green coach Eddie George, the 1995 Heisman Trophy winner. 'It was going to take something special (to leave Tennessee State) and this is something special,' George said. 'This team's been knocking at the door the last three years, a game here or there and they're playing for a championship. And then a chance to come back to Ohio? Oh yeah.' The other new coaches are Brian Smith at Ohio, Mike Uremovich at Ball State, Joe Harasymiak at UMass and Mark Drinkall at Central Michigan. The B1G question With Big Ten teams playing nine league games and some schools adapting with new scheduling philosophies, there is some question whether the traditional Big Ten-MAC matchups will continue. Commissioner Jon Steinbrecher is convinced they will. 'It makes an awful lot of sense we continue to play each other,' he said. 'My conversation with Big Ten officials certainly leads me to conclude that (we will).' Nine MAC schools will face Big Ten opponents this season, five on opening weekend. MAC tidbits Kent State has lost an FBS-high 17 straight games and last year became the first 0-12 team since Akron in 2019. … Akron is ineligible for postseason play because of consistently low Academic Progress Rate scores. The Zips are the first football program to face a postseason ban since Idaho in 2014. … Only Buffalo (16), Toledo (13) and Ohio and Central Michigan (10) have more than eight returning starters. … MAC schools have won a league-record 11 bowl games over the past three seasons. Games to watch Aug. 28, Miami at Wisconsin; Aug. 30, Toledo at Kentucky; Sept. 6, West Virginia at Ohio; Sept. 13, Ohio at Ohio State; Sept. 20, Bowling Green at Louisville; Sept. 27, Bowling Green at Ohio; Oct. 4, Miami at Northern Illinois; Oct. 11, Toledo at Bowling Green; Oct. 25, Toledo at Washington State; Nov. 4, Miami at Ohio; Nov. 12, Toledo at Miami; Nov. 19, Miami at Buffalo; Nov. 28, Ohio at Buffalo; Dec. 6, MAC championship game at Detroit. ___ Get poll alerts and updates on the AP Top 25 throughout the season. Sign up here. AP college football: and
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
From quirks to legends: The evolution of AP All-America college football teams over 100 years
A century of Associated Press All-America college football teams features plenty of great teams, great players and a host of of head-scratching quirks, reflecting how the game itself has evolved over 100 years. Let's start with the most important position: quarterback. In 1925, when the first AP All-America team was named, the quarterback position did not loom nearly as large. The forward pass had only been legal since 1906 and the required number of yards for a first down had changed from 5 to 10 yards in 1912. The notion of throwing the ball was still in its infancy. Of the 11 men on the 1925 team, three were listed as 'backs' and one as a 'running back.' It's not clear why Stanford's Ernie Nevers was labeled a running back. For the first 45 years, with two exceptions, quarterbacks were simply listed among the backs. For reasons unknown, Northwestern's Otto Graham (1943) and Michigan's Bob Timberlake (1964) were called QBs but Heisman Trophy winners Roger Staubach of Navy (1963) and Steve Spurrier of Florida (1966) were not. Quarterbacks have been specifically designated as such every year since Notre Dame's Joe Theismann in 1970. Through 1949, the All-America team was made up of 11 players (there were 12 in 1948). A short-lived move to two-platoon football began in 1945 with players no longer required play both offense and defense. The AP began naming 22 All-Americans in 1950. But in 1953, when one-platoon football returned, it was back to 11 All-Americans. In 1964, there were 22 men on the team even though unlimited substitution didn't return until 1965. Position titles were kept general into the 1970s, a holdover from those one-platoon days. Backs could be running backs and quarterbacks but also linebackers and defensive backs. Linemen were just linemen. Ends were positioned at the end of the offensive line and were blockers and receivers, or they could be defensive ends. Specialists weren't recognized until kickers and punters were first honored in 1981, and the first all-purpose player wasn't named until 1991. Notre Dame is the leader Since 1925, there have been 1,952 players named to the AP All-America first team. Notre Dame has had the most with 85, followed by Alabama with 83, Ohio State with 79, Southern California with 77 and Oklahoma with 75. This year's AP All-America team will be released in December. Where they're from The state of Texas has produced a nation-leading 256 AP first-team All-Americans through 2024. The Lone Star State is followed by California with 170, Ohio with 138, Florida with 133 and Pennsylvania with 111. Houston (33) ranks as the No. 1 hometown for first-team picks followed by Dallas (30), Los Angeles (27), Chicago (26) and Miami (25). 3-time All-Americans Twelve players earned AP All-America first-team honors three times, a truly elite group that represents fewer than 1% of the 1,949 All-Americans so far. Five played primarily offense and the other seven were on defense: RBs Felix 'Doc' Blanchard and Glenn Davis of Army, 1944-46; B Doak Walker, TCU, 1947-49; LB Richard Wood, Southern California, 1972-74; LB Jerry Robinson, UCLA, 1976-78; DB Kenny Easley, UCLA, 1978-80; DL Hugh Green, Pittsburgh, 1978-80; WR Anthony Carter, Michigan, 1980-82; RB Herschel Walker, Georgia, 1980-82; OL Bill Fralic, Pittsburgh, 1982-84; RB Marshall Faulk, San Diego State, 1991-93; LB James Laurinaitis, Ohio State, 2006-08. Notable position leaders last 50 years Over the past half-century (1974-2024), some notable bragging rights: — BYU leads the nation with five AP first-team All-America quarterbacks: Marc Wilson (1979), Jim McMahon (1981), Steve Young (1983) and Ty Detmer (1990-91). — Southern California has the most AP All-America running backs with five players honored seven times: Anthony Davis (1974), Ricky Bell (1975-76), Charles White (1978-79), Marcus Allen (1981) and Reggie Bush (2005). — Alabama has the most AP All-America linebackers with 12 players honored 14 times: Cornelius Bennett (1986), Derrick Thomas (1988), Keith McCants (1989), DeMeco Ryans (2005), Rolando McClain (2009), Dont'a Hightower (2011), Mark Barron (2011), C.J. Mosley (2012-13), Reggie Ragland (2015), Reuben Foster (2016), Will Anderson Jr. (2021-22) and Dallas Turner (2023). — Alabama also has the most AP All-America defensive backs with 11 players honored 12 times: Tommy Wilcox (1981), Antonio Langham (1993), Kevin Jackson (1996), Javier Arenas (2009), DeMarcus 'Dee' Milliner (2012), Landon Collins (2014), Minkah Fitzpatrick (2016-17), Deionte Thompson (2018), Patrick Surtain II (2020), Kool-Aid McKinstry (2023) and Terrion Arnold (2023). ___ Get poll alerts and updates on the AP Top 25 throughout the season. Sign up here. AP college football: and
