Why We Should Be Suspicious Of The Wuthering Heights Criticism
First, she was criticised for casting Margot Robbie, 35, as Catherine Earnshaw, who (spoiler alert) dies by the time she is 18. Then she was called out for casting Jacob Elordi, a white actor, in the racially ambiguous role of Heathcliff. And then 'first look' pictures of Wuthering Heights found their way onto social media and the whole production was written off for its numerous historically inaccuracies.
Now, despite the film not coming out until 13 February 2026, scathing reviews of the test screenings have put Fennell's adaptation back in the headlines. One viewer at the first test screening in Dallas labelled the film 'aggressively provocative' and said it had parallels with the 'stylised depravity' of her last project, Saltburn.
Paul Rhys, Jacob Elordi, Emerald Fennell, Barry Keoghan, Carey Mulligan and Archie Madekwe at the LA premiere of Saltburn. (Photo by)
Another viewer called it 'sexually explicit' and 'tonally abrasive'. One attendee described scenes of 'purposefully discomforting masturbation', a sexual bondage encounter involving horse reins and shots of 'suggestive textures', such as egg yolks, bread dough and slug trails. Apparently, the film even opens with a man being hanged who proceeds to 'ejaculate mid-execution'.
For anyone who has seen Fennell's films – where vengeful rape victims are murdered and conniving university students drink semen from the bath drains and have sex with empty graves – none of this will be remotely surprising.
What is surprising, though, is that we are hearing about all of this six months before the film hits cinemas. Whether you work in the entertainment industry or not, it is fairly unprecedented for reviews of screen testings not to be under strict embargoes, especially for a film with such a demonstrable marketing budget and high profile cast and crew.
There is a reason why reviews tend to drop the week before or day of a film being released. They are, to all intents and purposes, a way of helping people decide whether to tune in. Nowadays they are also used to create 'buzz' and help the film cut through in online discourse.
Given Fennell's penchant for raucous debate – she certainly seems to be an advocate of 'all publicity is good publicity' – it's hard to imagine that these scabrous reviews are not part of the film's wider marketing strategy.
When have we ever heard what a single viewer in Dallas thinks of a test screening before? Or read that a film blogger thinks her interpretation adds 'something bold and unexpected' to Bronte's story? It is far from usual protocol. And Fennell knows what she's doing.
I'll be the first to admit I only watched Saltburn to see what all the fuss was about (and to validate my preconceived opinion that I would hate it). Perhaps this talk of ejaculation-ridden executions and 'suggestive' egg yolks is pathing the way for the same thing to happen again.
In a post- Don't Worry Darling world – where the alleged BTS scandals between director Olivia Wilde and her co-stars (most notably her rumoured affair with Harry Styles) turned the film into international talking point – all business savvy studios know a good fell won't always sell itself anymore.
We saw it happen last summer during the press run of It Ends With Us . The feud between co-stars Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively far outshone the film itself and snowballed into a toxic legal battle that is still ongoing. Far more people now know about It Ends With Us than they ever would have before – even if, in this instance, it was not intentional.
In a world where audiences are constantly overwhelmed by choice and reluctant to spend in cinemas without knowing what they're paying for, the louder the chatter about a film is online, the more likely they are to watch it.
If that's what Fennell is playing into, then hats (or bonnets) off to her. Wuthering Heights might still be six months away, but part of me wants to find out what all the fuss is about already.
Nikki Peach is a writer at Grazia UK, working across entertainment, TV and news. She has also written for the i, i-D and the New Statesman Media Group and covers all things pop culture for Grazia (treating high and lowbrow with equal respect).
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
Audiences are left shocked by Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi's 'aggressively provocative' Wuthering Heights movie with 'BDSM sex scene'
Emerald Fennell's upcoming Wuthering Heights adaptation has been called 'aggressively provocative' and will feature a BDSM-inspired sex scene. The upcoming adaptation of Emily Bronte's classic novel sees Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi portray doomed lovers Catherine and Heathcliff. But those expecting a faithful adaptation of the beloved work may be in for a rude awakening as Fennell's upcoming film is said to lean into the 'stylised depravity' she has become known for after directing Saltburn. According to World of Reel, Fennell's Wuthering Heights received a mixed reaction at its first test screening in Dallas, Texas this month. The feature opens with a public hanging that sees the condemned man 'ejaculate mid-execution'. Emerald Fennell's upcoming Wuthering Heights adaptation has been called 'aggressively provocative' and will feature a BDSM-inspired sex scene His agony sends the crowd into an 'orgiastic frenzy' and a nun reportedly fondles 'the corpse's visible erection'. The film is also said to feature 'intimate, clinical and purposefully discomforting' masturbation scenes and a BDSM-inspired sex scene involving horse reins. The camera is also said to linger on 'suggestive' imagery including 'egg yolks running through fingers' and 'dough being kneaded with quiet aggression'. The publication does note that Margot and Jacob both deliver 'committed performances' and have 'great chemistry'. Fennell has made a name for herself as the director of Promising Young Woman and the black comedy Saltburn which saw a character drinking another's dirty bathwater. Along with her directing and writing career, she has also acted, noteably playing Queen Camilla in The Crown. Wuthering Heights was published by Emily Brontë in 1847 under the pseudonym Ellis Bell, one year before her death. It follows the story of an orphan, Heathcliff, who is taken in by the Earnshaw family, and he later grows close to their daughter and his foster sister, Cathy. The first known adaptation was from A. V. Bramble in 1920, with Laurence Olivier and Merle Oberon's 1939 version being nominated for the Academy Award for Best Picture. Born in 1818 in West Yorkshire, Emily was the fifth of six children, and spent most of her short life in the moorland village of Haworth, where her Irish father Patrick was curate. But life dealt Emily a series of terrible blows as she lost her mother when she was three, then two older sisters when she was seven. Following her trauma, the novelist retreated into a fantasy world, writing stories and poetry with her siblings. The writer poured her suffering and passion into Wuthering Heights, a wrenching love story as raw as the Yorkshire Moors on which it's set.
Metro
4 days ago
- Metro
Controversial book adaptation shocks viewers with BDSM sex
Emerald Fennell's controversial adaptation of Wuthering Heights has been met with shock and labelled 'aggressively provocative' by initial audiences. Fennell's 2023 dark comedy Saltburn, starring Barry Keoghan and Jacob Elordi, caused quite the stir when it was released a couple of years ago. The film featured darkly erotic scenes and was praised for its severe sexual content and nudity, as well as its frequent depiction of violence and gore. Because of this huge success, the announcement that Fennell would be directing an adaptation of Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights was met with excitement – and concern from literary fans. The casting of Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie respectively as Heathcliff and Cathy, raised major eyebrows, and now it's been reported that an initial first screening of the unfinished film has left many shocked by the content of the period piece. World of Reel revealed that the adaptation included -among other shocking scenes – a nun fondling a corpse, BDSM, and sexualised slugs and egg yolks. Attendees have reported that the film includes 'hyper-sexualised imagery' with a 'grotesque' scene that sees a public hanging end with the condemned man ejaculating during the execution. This is followed up with some blasphemous necrophia from a nun who 'fondles the corpse's visible erection'. There are 'several masturbation scenes' that are 'purposefully discomforting' and a 'BDSM-tinged encounter' involving a woman being strapped into some horse reins. There are also some rather sexy textures, including 'egg yolks running through fingers', sliding slugs, and a bit of dirty dough kneading. Test screenings can often lead to major edits to the film, and with Fennell's film not set to be released until February 2026, who knows if any of this will make it to the final cut! The film has faced criticism for casting Elordi, yet another white actor to play Heathcliff, a famously non-white role that was written by Brontë. On one page of the original novel, Heathcliff is described as a 'dark-skinned gipsy in aspect', while another refers to his 'dusky fingers'. Characters debate his appearance to be of a 'Lascar' – a dated description meaning a sailor from India or Southeast Asia – or 'an American or Spanish castaway'. Casting director Kharmel Cochrane worked on the film and is one of the biggest names in her field in the UK, having previously worked on the likes of Nosferatu, Saltburn, Bob Marley: One Love. While at the Sands International Film Festival of St Andrews, she told Metro that she is very much aware of the abuse directed at her after her casting choices for the film. 'I have really had to hold back on Instagram after a glass of wine, because I think someone was like, 'The casting director should be shot',' she said. More Trending 'There's definitely going to be some English Lit fans that are not going to be happy.' She then added: 'Wait until you see the set design, because it's even more shocking. And there may or may not be a dog collar in it.' 'You can read anything into a book and make it your interpretation. And it's really easy to sit online and say things, but just wait until you've watched it, and then you can say – maybe not that I deserve to be shot – but you can say what you want!' Cochrane suggests. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: Michael Bay leaves Will Smith Netflix film over 'creative differences' MORE: I know Freakier Friday is an unnecessary sequel – but it makes good choices MORE: Scarlett Johansson's 'terrible' English accent in new film leaves fans unimpressed
Graziadaily
4 days ago
- Graziadaily
Why We Should Be Suspicious Of The Wuthering Heights Criticism
There aren't many directors who manage to stir up rage, controversy and divide opinion quite like Emerald Fennell. Before she could even say the word 'Heights', the Promising Young Woman director's adaptation of Emily Bronte's 1847 novel has had the internet up in arms. First, she was criticised for casting Margot Robbie, 35, as Catherine Earnshaw, who (spoiler alert) dies by the time she is 18. Then she was called out for casting Jacob Elordi, a white actor, in the racially ambiguous role of Heathcliff. And then 'first look' pictures of Wuthering Heights found their way onto social media and the whole production was written off for its numerous historically inaccuracies. Now, despite the film not coming out until 13 February 2026, scathing reviews of the test screenings have put Fennell's adaptation back in the headlines. One viewer at the first test screening in Dallas labelled the film 'aggressively provocative' and said it had parallels with the 'stylised depravity' of her last project, Saltburn. Paul Rhys, Jacob Elordi, Emerald Fennell, Barry Keoghan, Carey Mulligan and Archie Madekwe at the LA premiere of Saltburn. (Photo by) Another viewer called it 'sexually explicit' and 'tonally abrasive'. One attendee described scenes of 'purposefully discomforting masturbation', a sexual bondage encounter involving horse reins and shots of 'suggestive textures', such as egg yolks, bread dough and slug trails. Apparently, the film even opens with a man being hanged who proceeds to 'ejaculate mid-execution'. For anyone who has seen Fennell's films – where vengeful rape victims are murdered and conniving university students drink semen from the bath drains and have sex with empty graves – none of this will be remotely surprising. What is surprising, though, is that we are hearing about all of this six months before the film hits cinemas. Whether you work in the entertainment industry or not, it is fairly unprecedented for reviews of screen testings not to be under strict embargoes, especially for a film with such a demonstrable marketing budget and high profile cast and crew. There is a reason why reviews tend to drop the week before or day of a film being released. They are, to all intents and purposes, a way of helping people decide whether to tune in. Nowadays they are also used to create 'buzz' and help the film cut through in online discourse. Given Fennell's penchant for raucous debate – she certainly seems to be an advocate of 'all publicity is good publicity' – it's hard to imagine that these scabrous reviews are not part of the film's wider marketing strategy. When have we ever heard what a single viewer in Dallas thinks of a test screening before? Or read that a film blogger thinks her interpretation adds 'something bold and unexpected' to Bronte's story? It is far from usual protocol. And Fennell knows what she's doing. I'll be the first to admit I only watched Saltburn to see what all the fuss was about (and to validate my preconceived opinion that I would hate it). Perhaps this talk of ejaculation-ridden executions and 'suggestive' egg yolks is pathing the way for the same thing to happen again. In a post- Don't Worry Darling world – where the alleged BTS scandals between director Olivia Wilde and her co-stars (most notably her rumoured affair with Harry Styles) turned the film into international talking point – all business savvy studios know a good fell won't always sell itself anymore. We saw it happen last summer during the press run of It Ends With Us . The feud between co-stars Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively far outshone the film itself and snowballed into a toxic legal battle that is still ongoing. Far more people now know about It Ends With Us than they ever would have before – even if, in this instance, it was not intentional. In a world where audiences are constantly overwhelmed by choice and reluctant to spend in cinemas without knowing what they're paying for, the louder the chatter about a film is online, the more likely they are to watch it. If that's what Fennell is playing into, then hats (or bonnets) off to her. Wuthering Heights might still be six months away, but part of me wants to find out what all the fuss is about already. Nikki Peach is a writer at Grazia UK, working across entertainment, TV and news. She has also written for the i, i-D and the New Statesman Media Group and covers all things pop culture for Grazia (treating high and lowbrow with equal respect).
