NYCFC, Red Bulls set to renew rivalry for first time since postseason showdown

New York Post

17-05-2025

While revenge isn't top of mind for New York City FC's Justin Haak, the chance to play a rival always gets the juices flowing for the midfielder.
In this case, it's the New York Red Bulls.
Saturday will be the latest installment of the Hudson River Derby, which received a serious infusion of excitement last year when the two clubs met in the postseason for the first time.
Advertisement
The Red Bulls came away with the win at the time en route to their first MLS Cup Finals appearance since 2008.
3 Justin Haak fights for possession during NYCFC's game on May 14, 2025.
Imagn Images
'I don't think it's revenge, because if we win this game, it's not going to get us through the playoffs last year, because that's already over,' Haak told The Post. 'It's a new game. There's going to be some new players, different players on the field, but every single time we play them, we definitely want to win. And there's always more emotion in these games.'
The match at Citi Field will be the first taste of the rivalry for new NYCFC head coach Pascal Jansen since he took over in January.
Advertisement
Speaking with reporters from NYCFC's practice facility in Rockland County, Jansen echoed similar sentiments about the 'extra' emotions that come with a derby match, but said he wanted the club to lean into some of the memories from past games.
'Thinking back and bringing up memories from games played in the past always helps — because, like you described, emotions are there, and we have to learn from those moments to be better prepared going into the next game,' he said.
Both teams are headed into the Hudson River Derby — ironically the same weekend as the city's two MLB teams square off in The Bronx — with an identical 5-5-3 (18 points) record, and each club is clinging to one of the final two playoff positions in the Eastern Conference.
Advertisement
3 Justin Haak looks to move the ball during NYCFC's game on May 4, 2025.
Imagn Images
The match presents the sides with a chance not only to get a victory after each failed to win Wednesday, but also to springboard forward as the regular season hits its stride.
'It's a big chance to get that kind of elevation into the season,' Red Bulls defender Noah Eile told The Post by Phone. 'If you could get a good result there, then we get a real big push, especially in such a big game for the whole club. I think that's a great point to make that winning here can have a big impact on the rest of the season.'
While the Red Bulls have been good at home, they've struggled to find wins on the road, currently 0-4-2 away from Sports Illustrated Stadium.
Advertisement
3 Noah Eile looks to pass during the Red Bulls' game on May 14, 2025.
Imagn Images
New York City FC, on the other hand, has felt quite comfortable at home this year, posting a 4-2-0 record at Yankee Stadium and Citi Field combined, but are struggling to put the ball in the net.
NYCFC has not scored in their past three matches, which include a loss in the U.S. Open Cup and two prior regular-season games.
'I think as a team, we're doing well to create chances,' Haak said. 'We had a few opportunities. I would say maybe it's just a little bit unlucky now, and guys are maybe thinking a little bit too much in front of the goal when you have a run like this.
'But with the players we have, we have absolutely no doubt that the goals are going to come.'