logo
Restaurants, Bars Consider Turning Off Music as Licensing Fees Skyrocket

Restaurants, Bars Consider Turning Off Music as Licensing Fees Skyrocket

Mint09-07-2025
(Bloomberg) -- Ever since operetta composer Victor Herbert sued Shanley's restaurant in New York in 1917 to force it to pay for playing his song on a player-piano, songwriters and music publishers have depended on Performing Rights Organizations to make sure they get compensated.
For much of the last century, three organizations dominated the industry, a relatively staid and unglamorous corner of the music scene that remained largely unchanged throughout the eras of radio, records and CDs. But the rise of streaming has led to a surge in revenue and spawned a handful of new organizations looking to cash in. Now there are at least half a dozen PROs in the US, representing different songwriters and publishers, each demanding that bars, restaurants, hotels and other venues pay a fee or risk being sued.
Businesses say the rising licensing costs have become overwhelming, and some question whether it's even worth playing music at all. The House Judiciary Committee last fall asked the Copyright Office to investigate the current system and consider potential reforms. In February, the Office opened an inquiry and received thousands of comments from businesses and songwriters.
'The growing proliferation of PROs and their lack of transparency have made it increasingly difficult to offer music in our establishments,' hundreds of small businesses from across the country wrote to the Copyright Office in a joint letter. 'The issue is not that small businesses are unwilling to pay for music,' they wrote, adding that the current system is unfair and untenable. 'Small businesses can be left feeling like PROs have them over the proverbial barrel.'
Creating a welcoming ambiance in a restaurant or yoga studio isn't as simple as putting on a Spotify playlist. Streaming has unleashed trillions of songs and every one must be licensed and have royalties paid to the songwriter whenever any track is played in public. Violations can cost up to $150,000 per infringement. This booming market for music publishing has led to a windfall for the two major PROs. ASCAP, founded in 1914, and BMI, established in 1939, together represent more than 90% of musical compositions in the US today with talent lists covering Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo, Jay-Z, Lady Gaga and Eminem, to name a few. SESAC, founded in 1931, rounds out the original three and operates on an invite-only basis.
The American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP,) the oldest and, as a nonprofit, the only PRO to publicly share data on its collections and payout, has seen revenue jump to $1.8 billion in 2024 from $935 million in 2010. Broadcast Music Inc. (BMI), in its last public report as a nonprofit in 2022, showed record revenue of $1.6 billion, with 48% of that from digital sources.
This kind of growth hasn't gone unnoticed. In just over the last 12 years, three new PROs have emerged. Legendary music manager Irving Azoff founded Global Music Rights in 2013, offering 'boutique services' and royalty transparency, building a stable of more than 160 high-profile songwriters like Bad Bunny and Bruce Springsteen. AllTrack, founded in 2017, caters to smaller, independent songwriters. Pro Music Rights launched in 2018 and says it represents more than 2.5 million musical works, including AI-created music.
Many songs today are composed by several songwriters, each of whom could be affiliated with a different PRO. Therefore, to legally play those songs, establishments must pay for a license from each PRO. Most PROs offer blanket licensing agreements, meaning that they provide access to their entire repertoires for one fee. And while that gives a particular venue a wide range of musical freedom, it also means bars and restaurants are paying for thousands of songs they may never play or are essentially paying twice, in instances where a song with multiple writers is represented by more than one PRO.
The National Restaurant Association said its members pay an average of $4,500 per year to license music, or 0.5% of the average US small restaurant's total annual sales.
'This may not seem like a large amount, but for an industry that runs on an average pre-tax margin of 3%-5%, this cost is significant, especially since operators don't clearly understand what they get for this particular investment aside from avoiding the very legitimate threat of a business-ending lawsuit,' the association wrote in public comments to the Copyright Office.
The American Hotel & Lodging Association said the mushrooming number of PROs has led to 'significant increases in both financial and administrative burdens.' It gave an example of one 'major global hotel chain' that reported the cost per hotel for PRO license fees rose by about 200% from 2021-2025, with some hotels seeing increases of 400% or more. A large hotel that hosts occasional live music events could be paying a single PRO $5,000 to $20,000 a year. If it's paying all of the major PROs, it could be incurring as much as $80,000 in fees, according to the association.
BMI said its licensing fees have remained 'relatively steady over the years' and are based on objective criteria that apply equally to all similar businesses. Fees for individual bars and restaurants start at just over $1 a day, according to BMI. Other factors that go into licensing fees include the occupancy rate, and the type of music being played — live, DJed or recorded, for example.
In the 1917 Supreme Court case that delivered Herbert his victory over Shanley's, Chief Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes wrote: 'If music did not pay, it would be given up.' He wasn't only referring to the songwriters, but also to the venues themselves and addressing whether music helped generate revenue. The ruling was a win for Herbert personally but also for ASCAP, which he had helped found, and established the royalty payment system that's largely still in use today.
A spokesperson for ASCAP said an increase in fees paid to songwriters by venues is an appropriate and inevitable outcome of a growing market. The organization's musical repertoires have grown exponentially over the years to include tens of millions of works, giving music users more music and more choice, the spokesperson said. ASCAP says about 90 cents of every dollar it collects from licensees is made available for distribution to its members as royalties.
'Licensees are seeking more regulation of PROs because they want to pay songwriters less,' ASCAP Chief Executive Officer Elizabeth Matthews said in a statement to Bloomberg. 'If transparency, efficiency and innovation are the goals, more free market competition among PROs is the answer— not unnecessary government intervention.'
Songwriters depend on PROs for their livelihoods, especially in the streaming era. Many individual songwriters wrote to the Copyright Office in defense of the PRO system, expressing concern that government regulation would only diminish their hard-won earnings.
'Every royalty payment I receive represents not just compensation for my work, but my ability to continue creating music that enhances these very businesses,' wrote Joseph Trapanese, a composer who has created scores for film and TV.
Performance royalties make up about half of total publishing revenue, which is collected by PROs and dispersed to songwriters, according to the National Music Publishers' Association. Last year, only about 5% of songwriters' earnings came from bars, restaurants and other venues, a figure that is 'significantly undervalued,' according to NMPA executive vice president and General Counsel Danielle Aguirre. 'There is a substantial opportunity for growth here,' she said, speaking at the group's annual meeting in June. The organization set a goal to significantly increase that money over the next year, likely by enforcing licensing requirements.
Several establishment owners equated the PRO's efforts to collect fees to a mob-like shakedown, citing aggressive on-site confrontations and threatening letters.
BMI said it spends a lot of time trying to educate business owners on the value that music brings to their establishment, federal copyright law requirements and the importance of maintaining a music license.
Lawsuits are always a last resort, a spokesperson said, which is why BMI spends sometimes years on educational outreach. If those efforts are ignored, however, an in-person visit might occur, and BMI may take legal action.
Despite their differences, songwriters and businesses agree that the current system is opaque and bureaucratic and could serve both sides better.
Businesses complain about the lack of a comprehensive database of songs and the fact that there is no easy system for reporting which songs they've played. Meanwhile, songwriters claim that the sheer volume of music and businesses throughout the US makes it hard to track where and when their work is played and to know whether they've been properly compensated.
'What's really being called to question is, is this system working accurately—is the money that should be finding its way to the songwriters' pockets finding its way in an efficient manner?' said George Howard, a professor at Berklee College of Music. 'And the answer is 'no.' There's no excuse for that with the level of technology we have today.'
BMI and ASCAP joined forces in 2020 to launch Songview, a free digital database showing copyright ownership and administration shares for more than 20 million works. The two PROs are exploring including GMR and SESAC, which would add even more songs to the platform.
Some of the complaints about the PRO licensing system go back decades. Michael Dorf, a producer and founder of the legendary Manhattan music club The Knitting Factory, has faced off with PROs numerous times over his 30-some years as a venue operator. In the 1990s, he signed singer-songwriters who performed at his club to his publishing company and submitted their setlists to the PROs, assuming he and his acts would reap the resulting royalties from their performances.
'We didn't receive one penny,' Dorf, who's also the founder and Chief Executive Officer of City Winery, said in an interview. 'To me, there is a cost of doing business, and we want to have the artists and the songwriters properly paid – we love that. What's simply frustrating is to pay money and know it's not going to the reason why it's being collected.'
Caleb Shreve, a songwriter and producer who's worked with the likes of Jennifer Lopez and is also CEO at Killphonic Rights, a rights collection organization, said he hears music he has produced 'all the time in yoga spots and bars, and I've never seen them on publishing statements.' Many songwriters are convinced the current system favors the biggest artists at the expense of middle-tier and emerging songwriters. Because of the blanket licensing system, BMI and ASCAP don't track individual song use by those licensees and instead rely on proxy data, like what's popular on the radio or through streaming platforms, to divvy up those collected fees.
Sometimes radio hits mimic what's played in an arena, restaurant or bar, but not always.
ASCAP said it tracks trillions of performances every year across all media platforms and only uses sample surveys or proxy data when obtaining actual performance data isn't feasible or is cost prohibitive.
Technology could be a way to solve the current issues without regulation. London-based Audoo is one company leading the way.
Founded by musician Ryan Edwards in 2018 after he heard his music being played in a department store and discovered he wasn't getting paid for it, the growing startup uses proprietary listening devices it places in cafes, gyms and other public venues to recognize and log songs. It uploads the data to the cloud, ensuring every artist — not just the chart toppers — receives compensation for their work.
The company has attracted investment from music icons including Elton John and Adele, and its devices are used by PROs in the UK and Australia. It made its first foray into the US earlier this year, placing listening devices in about 180 establishments around the Denver area in a test run.The collected data underscored that what's played in public places doesn't necessarily mirror what's on the popular playlists or radio and streaming platforms. Edwards likens the idea of using proxies to political polling — directionally helpful but not precise.
Audoo found that 77,000 unique tracks were played around Denver over two months, split among 26,000 artists, according to data viewed by Bloomberg News. On average, only 6.6% of the top-40 songs played in the venues also appeared on Billboard's top radio-play chart.
In markets where Audoo has partnered with venues, Edwards said business owners have been proud to support particular songwriters and the music business writ large.
'All of a sudden it went from a push-and-pull of, 'Why do I owe you money?' to, 'Ok, I can understand music is funding the people who create,'' Edwards said.
(Updates to add context about ASCAP royalty distribution.)
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Why ‘Saiyaara' is all the rage
Why ‘Saiyaara' is all the rage

India Today

time2 hours ago

  • India Today

Why ‘Saiyaara' is all the rage

It took two twenty-something newcomers to cause ripples at the box-office. The Ajay Devgn-led Son of Sardaar 2 pushed its release date. And those awaiting releases in August know they have a force to reckon with in what's about the intense musical romance that audiences cannot get enough of and are reacting to in a rather dramatic fashion? IV drip? Copious tears? All this despite a happy ending. Here are five reasons why director Mohit Suri and writer Sankalp Sadanah have crafter a DON'T STOP THE MUSICSaiyaara's soundtrack has one earworm after another, with the title track particularly hitting all the right loving notes. Rendered by Kashmir's indie artist Faheem Abdullah, this is Gen Z and Alpha's 'Tum Hi Ho' moment, a track which is likely to dominate the airwaves and streaming apps for a few years, like 'Kesariya' did. It has even made it to the Top 10 of Spotify's Top 50 Global Chart, a tremendous achievement for a Hindi film song. That Abdullah's song stands out among those sung by Arijit Singh and Vishal Mishra tells you a lot about the overall strength of the album. 'Barbaad', 'Tum Ho Toh' and 'Humsafar' are also connecting with those familiar with his playbook, this is Mohit Suri doing Mohit Suri things, backing his narrative with emotional songs whose lyrics heal many a broken heart and enable others to express LOVEYes, Saiyaara has that feeling of old wine being repackaged in new bottle. The tropes, the twists, the emotional beats are all too familiar. The Notebook, Aashiqui, Sadma are some of the films that have been referred to. But its stellar box-office showing is proof that audiences are craving for romance of the old-school kind. It's also why the re-release of Sanam Teri Kasam–of all the films–was a surprise hit this sitting in a cinema before the film begins and watching the trailers offers proof of how Saiyaara is so refreshing to behold. It's a simple, straightforward love story about two broken souls with plenty of baggage, unlike the action-heavy, loud dramas that have come to dominate the Hindi cinema landscape of late. There's no scale here to behold, just chemistry between two leads—their fraught journey to be happy together and a narrative that emphasises on unconditional, forever love. No wonder audiences are weeping over lines such as 'Duniya mera naam yaad rakh le lekin woh toh bhool rahi hai na' (The world may remember my name but she's forgetting it) and 'Dimaak bhool jaata hai lekin dil nahin bhoolta' (The head may forget but the heart never does).advertisementINNOVATIVE MARKETINGYash Raj Films (YRF) took a bold move with their marketing strategy wherein they guarded their two new finds from the preying eyes of social media, media and public alike, and continue to do so. That there's so little out there on who Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda are in real life has only piqued the curiosity of the audiences to go to the cinemas to see the two young leads. It reflects in the impressive box-office collections, with Saiyaara expected to surpass the Rs 300 crore mark in the the age of social media, where overexposure is a genuine concern, robbing actors of their sense of mystique, Panday and Padda are anomalies in how their pre-release footprint on the apps is limited. How this impacts the promotional strategies of films from here on remains to be seen, but for a film with newcomers, it clearly has paid rich dividends for TALENT ON THE BLOCKThe factors above matter, but foremost is the undeniable screen presence of the twenty-something youngsters and their ability to hold and command a scene. It's been a while since Bollywood has had newcomers who, in their very first film, have made a solid case that they have the thespian chops to shine on. Panday's Krish Kapoor has the acceptable boy-from-the-wrong-side-of-the-tracks vibe while Padda's Vaani has the angelic, vulnerable get ample moments to shine, with Panday particularly showing his range in the second half as he grapples with the devastating condition of his partner. It's a given that they will be spoiled for choice, but after making the first big impression, the challenge lies in living up to the lofty expectations in the TO THE ROOTSFor YRF, the success of Saiyaara means the banner coming back to the genre that first gave it flight. Long before Anurag Basu, Imtiaz Ali and Mohit Suri, there was Yash Chopra, the filmmaker who presented love in different layers and hues, some even challenging conventions and pushing the envelope on public notions of love (see Silsila and Lamhe).Aditya Chopra, his son, carried forward the legacy, delivering a blockbuster in his very first film Dilwale Dulhania Le Jaayenge. All his remaining films have been in the genre—Mohabbatein, Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi and Befikre. So to see the studio, which of late has made the Spy Universe its mainstay, garner success with a love story will hopefully give impetus to others to embrace romance to India Today Magazine- EndsTrending Reel

Saiyaara Wins Over Gen-Z, Crosses Rs 190 Crore; Title Song Makes It To Spotify's Global Top 5 List
Saiyaara Wins Over Gen-Z, Crosses Rs 190 Crore; Title Song Makes It To Spotify's Global Top 5 List

News18

time5 hours ago

  • News18

Saiyaara Wins Over Gen-Z, Crosses Rs 190 Crore; Title Song Makes It To Spotify's Global Top 5 List

Saiyaara Wins Over Gen-Z, Crosses Rs 190 Crore; Title Song Makes It To Spotify's Global Top 5 List There's no stopping Saiyaara, the breakout sensation from Yash Raj Films that's dominating the box office. Following a spectacular opening week with over Rs 170 crore net earned in India, the Ahaan Panday-Aneet Padda romantic drama has entered its second weekend with impressive momentum. Adding to its success, the film's title track has achieved global recognition, breaking into Spotify's Top 10 Global chart -- an unprecedented feat for a Bollywood song. Watch the video to learn more. news | entertainment news live | latest bollywood news | bollywood | news18 | n18oc_moviesLiked the video? Please press the thumbs up icon and leave a comment. Subscribe to Showsha YouTube channel and never miss a video: Showsha on Instagram: Showsha on Facebook: Showsha on X: Showsha on Snapchat: entertainment and lifestyle news and updates on:

Saiyaara Title Song Is In Spotify's Global Top 5 List. How Ahaan Panday's Wish In The Film Is Coming True In Real Life
Saiyaara Title Song Is In Spotify's Global Top 5 List. How Ahaan Panday's Wish In The Film Is Coming True In Real Life

NDTV

time7 hours ago

  • NDTV

Saiyaara Title Song Is In Spotify's Global Top 5 List. How Ahaan Panday's Wish In The Film Is Coming True In Real Life

New Delhi: Some stories are written. Others, somehow, write themselves. And then there's Saiyaara, a Mohit Suri film that scripted a moment so full of yearning, it was meant to be just that: cinematic. Until life decided to pick up the pen. In a surreal reel-to-real twist, the title track of Saiyaara, the very song Ahaan Panday's character Krish hopes will find the love he lost, has done exactly that. Only this time, not just within the film's universe. The song has now reached everywhere, just as Krish dreamed, and became the first-ever Bollywood song to enter Spotify's Top 50 Global chart, currently holding the No. 5 spot. "Make The Song So Big, Nobody Can Miss It" To understand just how uncanny this is, we need to go back to the film's most heartbreaking scene. In Saiyaara, Krish (played by Ahaan Panday) walks away from a rising music career to look after Vaani (Aneet Padda), the love of his life, after she is diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's. On a quiet vacation meant to help her cope, things take a turn: Vaani begins to forget him, confusing Krish with her ex, Mahesh Iyer. In a deeply moving moment, Krish hides his heartbreak and narrates their own story to her as if it belonged to someone else. He tells her about a "friend" whose girlfriend is forgetting him. In response, Vaani suggests that the friend should create a song, something so powerful and unforgettable that it finds her wherever she is. "Make a song so she never forgets him. Every time she hears it, she should remember he exists," she said. Vaani herself begins writing that song and titles it Saiyaara. But as her condition worsens, Vaani realises she has hurt Krish. She quietly disappears from his life to protect him. For six months, Krish searches. Then, in a spark of memory, he remembers Saiyaara, the song she wrote, and her words. In desperation, he rushes to his music producer friend and pleads, "Promote it. Make it reach every household. Every radio. Every phone. Every corner. Everywhere. So that if she's out there, she hears it." Cut to 2025 - it's happening. A Historic Spotify Milestone The title track, Saiyaara, composed by Tanishk Bagchi along with Faheem Abdullah and Arslan Nizami, has become the first Bollywood song to break into Spotify's Global Top 50. Sung by indie artist Faheem Abdullah, and written and composed by Abdullah and Nizami, both self-made musicians from Kashmir, the track has become a Gen Z romance anthem and a global phenomenon. As of now, Saiyaara is sitting pretty at No. 5, beating international heavyweights like Blackpink's Jump, Lady Gaga's Die With A Smile, Billie Eilish's Birds Of A Feather, and Alex Warren's Eternity. Saiyaara's Box Office Success While Saiyaara the song charts new territory on streaming platforms, Saiyaara the film is breaking records of its own. A Yash Raj Films production helmed by Mohit Suri, the romantic drama starring newcomers Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda has opened to massive box office numbers. According to reports, the film earned Rs 21 crore on its opening day and crossed Rs 100 crore within the first four days. Much of its success is credited to its chart-topping music, which has now completely taken over Spotify India's Top 10 as well. Apart from the main track, the film's album features: Dhun by Mithoon and Arijit Singh, Barbaad (Reprise) by Jubin Nautiyal and Shilpa Rao, Tum Ho Toh by Vishal Mishra, Humsafar by Sachet-Parampara and Saiyaara (Reprise) by Arijit Singh and Shreya Ghoshal A Manifestation That Left The Screen There are chart successes, and then there are cultural moments. What Saiyaara is experiencing right now feels like the latter. In a country where film music has always had the power to shape emotion and memory, Saiyaara is doing something bigger. It's taking the wish of a boy who just wanted to be remembered, and letting the world hear it loud and clear. And somewhere out there, if Vaani was real, she'd probably be hearing it too.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store