How tax rules our politics (and lives)
Far be it from me to argue about tax with a man who founded a think tank called Tax Policy Associates and who advises the Scottish Government (among others) on tax issues, but his first point hardly needs proving to anyone. Ever since we learnt the story of Robin Hood, we've known tax as a fifth element in our lives.
As for Einstein, well, having listened ahead to all five episodes of Untaxing, I am tempted to agree with the physicist. Neidle's series makes our tax systems seem arcane, opaque, fantastical, occasionally deranged, often frustrating and always baffling. Despite that – or perhaps because of it – it's a terrific series, filled with anecdote and insight, that will leave you with the feeling you should pay far more attention to tax beyond your payslip, the Budget and the adventures of Little John et al.
Monday's opener was all about a napkin – 'the napkin that changed the world' – and revealed both Neidle's ability to zero in on quirks of history that prove to be seismic and how ideology and politicking give tax a bad name. The napkin was on a restaurant table in Washington DC in 1974, and scribbling on it was a young economist named Arthur Laffer. Watching him doodle a graph, with ever-widening eyes, were White House officials Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld. What the doodle 'proved' was that if you raise taxes too much, revenues will actually go down.
Though disputed, the 'Laffer Curve' is still popular today – it is regularly cited by, among others, Liz Truss, while in 2019 Donald Trump awarded Laffer the Presidential Medal of Freedom, referencing the famous napkin. The napkin is a Shroud of Turin for those who seek low taxation, but tax ideology works both ways.
Recently, the Scottish Government raised the top rate of income tax to 48 per cent, which some believe will scare off higher earners and lead to less revenue. And what did Neidle and his colleagues at the Scottish Government's Tax Advisory Group have to say about this? 'Nothing,' said Neidle. 'Because they didn't ask us. It was pure politics.' More tax theory drawn up on the back of napkins.
Yesterday delved into the murky story of the Beatles' inventive but ultimately flawed efforts to avoid income tax (surely Eleanor Rigby would have benefited from some of their revenues?), a tale that ultimately ended in Michael Jackson selling the rights to Lennon & McCartney's songs to pay his own tax bill.
Today's episode is on Jaffa Cakes, tomorrow's on a porn-star lawyer who played a part in the downfall of Rangers Football Club. Neidle cherrypicks the minutiae expertly. The overall impression is of the British tax system as a towering, teetering, rickety old building, with extension built upon extension, and all sorts of oddities lurking in the basement. Five 15-minute episodes isn't nearly enough – I hope Radio 4 have Neidle back soon.
Also managing to be riveting on an ostensibly dry economic subject was Invisible Hands (Radio 4), which is looking at the birth of the free market. That it's so compelling is no surprise, given that the man behind it is David Dimbleby, who shares Neidle's ability to extrapolate world-changing ideas from the smallest of moments. This first episode, for instance, found the origins of the free market in the downing of a Hurricane fighter plane in August 1940, the Egg Marketing Board and a copy of the Reader's Digest.
Jo Barratt's production had the swing and sway (and the background music) of a juicy true-crime podcast, with Dimbleby gamely showing he could mix it with the young pups of podcasting. Here, it's all about storytelling. 'It turns out it's a much stranger story than you can imagine,' began Dimbleby, as the music grew more insistent. It's shameless, but I was hooked.
And when that Reader's Digest came along, Dimbleby introduced it like this: 'A magazine that would change the course of Antony Fisher's life… and the history of this country – forever.' He even gave us the little details – in that edition, alongside the all-important article The Road to Serfdom by Friedrich Hayek, were pieces on 'strange animal friendships, the beard of Joseph Palmer and shepherds of the underground', a list of subjects that would fit quite pleasingly into Radio 4's schedules.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Entrepreneur
12 minutes ago
- Entrepreneur
Why Most Businesses Overcomplicate Their Marketing Strategy
Your marketing strategy is probably overcomplicated. Here's how to simplify it and actually see results. Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own. Let's be real: Most founders don't need more marketing tactics. There is a ton of content out there about how to handle your marketing — so much that it's overwhelming. Marketing also accounts for a large part of business budgets, adding up to nearly 10% of the cost for the average business. It's easy to chase trends, try to be on every platform, run ads without understanding ROI and slap together messaging that changes every other week. When you do that, it just leads to more confusion for your audience and usually, a waste of money. Overcomplicated marketing strategies generally come from a good place — founders want to grow. But in trying to do everything, they end up doing nothing well. Let's talk about why this happens and how to simplify your marketing so it actually works. Related: 5 Common Marketing Mistakes You Need to Look Out For Why we overcomplicate things in the first place There are a few common culprits that drive marketing overwhelm. The most common thing I see in small business owners is a sense of "shiny object" syndrome. When a business owner sees a new tactic pop up on Instagram or their peer swears by a niche funnel, too often, they just start rebuilding their whole strategy around it. Even more importantly, too many business owners get into this situation and then have no data tracking set up. Trying new things is good, but how will you know if it worked or not? Gut feeling is definitely not enough when it comes to determining your marketing spend, and if you are too busy throwing too many things at the wall, you likely aren't setting up proper tracking, so those experiments aren't telling you much in the end. If any of that sounds familiar, you're not alone. Let's break down what a simpler, more effective marketing strategy might look like. Simple marketing strategies often outperform complex ones The best marketing strategies are clear, consistent and rooted in your actual business goals. They don't try to do everything, and instead focus on doing the right things well, consistently and with proper tracking. To start, define your one core message. You should be able to clearly articulate what you do, who it's for and why it matters. If you can't say it in a sentence, your audience won't get it either. Next, establish a consistent cadence that is realistic for you. Whether it's weekly emails, biweekly blogs or daily Instagram stories, consistency beats perfection every time. Resist the temptation to set too ambitious of a goal, if you realistically might not meet it. Setting a realistic goal sets up a habit, and that can build much more easily from there. Finally, establish a feedback loop. Your marketing should be a living system. You put out a message, you watch how it performs, and you adjust accordingly. For whatever you are trying, establish a KPI that defines if it is working, and monitor it. Be willing to cut when it's not working, and double down when it is. Most importantly, simple marketing is sustainable. This sets up the foundation for you to continue to grow. Related: 3 Reasons Your Marketing is Failing (And How to Fix It) How to use data to guide your strategy If you feel that you aren't sure how to track the impact of your marketing, you are in the majority — more than 85% of businesses don't track the impact of marketing on an ongoing basis. You don't need a fancy dashboard or expensive analytics software to do this. You just need to start with a few key questions: Where are your leads coming from? Look at your clients who came in as prospects in the last 30-90 days, and break them down by where they came from. If you aren't sure, this is a chance to pause and add more lead tracking into your marketing tech before moving on to the next point. What percentage of those leads turn into paying clients? Do the same exercise as the above, but only with those who bought. How much did you spend on each of these channels? This includes any labor spend working on your marketing, tech costs, ad spend, event entrance costs and more. Do your best to break that down by lead channel. What's the lifetime value of a client? Look at your clients from the last six months or so and their average spend. This is the value of the client to your business. These numbers will tell you more than any guru's playbook ever could. One of the most common trends to look at is where you're investing time and money versus where you're getting leads. For example, if you're pouring time into Instagram but your conversions are all coming from referral emails, that's a signal to double down on email and consider refreshing or cutting back on your Instagram strategy. The second thing to consider is the lifetime value of your clients as compared to the cost of a lead. If you're getting leads from paid ads but they are costing you two times as much as their lifetime value, it's very likely you need a paid ads refresh. Once you have this kind of clarity, you can market smarter, not harder. Related: Your Marketing Strategy Needs an Overhaul — This Approach Is What Separates Successful Campaigns From the Rest Growth comes from focus, not frenzy That's it. You don't need a 42-step funnel or three different types of lead magnets to make this work. You just need a clear offer, a consistent cadence and a feedback loop. It's easy to think more marketing equals more growth, but if that "more" isn't strategic, it's likely not serving you.
Bloomberg
44 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Chicago Public Schools Struggle to Make the Math Work
Students in Chicago are soaking up the last few days of summer before classes start again on Monday. And the heat is on for education leaders, in the city and nationwide, writes Chicago-based municipal finance reporter Shruti Date Singh, as budget pressures are everywhere. Plus: Boxes are in a slump, Twitter's pre-Elon Musk CEO has a new startup, and capital is flowing into the Middle East. If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Austin expected to approve $6B+ budget, triggering property tax rate election
AUSTIN (KXAN) — After hours of public comment and debate Wednesday, Austin City Council is likely to approve its budget for next fiscal year, including setting a tax rate, on Thursday. All but one member of the dais has indicated they support a property tax rate high enough to trigger an election in November (TRE). PREVIOUS: Austin mayor 'disappointed' with cost of some tax rate election proposals 'Nobody enjoys paying more taxes, but we do enjoy our parks—we do need to drive on our roads. There are crucial, essential things a city has to do, and the cost of doing those things has risen,' Austin City Council Member Ryan Alter said. How much will the city ask for in a tax rate election? Some Austin city council members and the mayor indicated Wednesday they were not comfortable going above 5 pennies in the below scenario. Previously, the council was considering anywhere from the city manager's proposed base budget to 8 pennies. As the graph indicates, at 5 cents, a tax rate election would mean the average homeowner's property tax bill goes up by $302.14 annually, $197.92 of that from the TRE. That does not include rates. What would you get for it? City council members so far seem to almost unanimously agree that more money is needed to fully fund the Homeless Strategy Office's $101 million plan, for parks, public safety and some social services. Staff brought forward a base tax rate election proposal Wednesday, which included some funding for the Homeless Strategy Office's (HSO) plan, the housing trust fund, Emergency Medical Services programs, funding for parks, public health, sidewalks and funding for overtime at the Austin Fire Department. 'I wanted to make sure that we have the appropriate overtime for our fire department. I am not in favor of changing our staffing models,' Austin City Council Member Paige Ellis told KXAN of her priorities. She brought forward an amendment on that issue. Austin firefighters push back against proposed budget's staffing requirement changes That base proposal was amended Wednesday, and council members will continue to add to it or take away from it on Thursday. Some amendments included reinstating funding for police oversight, fully funding the homelessness plan and adding additional funding for a homeless navigation center. 'Addressing the needs from public safety, whether that's EMS needs or fire needs, looking at things including library funding, the list goes on and on,' Austin City Council Member Ryan Alter said of early amendments made. Austin's homeless strategy office identifies $101 million needed for new strategies to address issues Austin City Council Member Marc Duchen said Wednesday, while he thinks these are important services, he does not support a tax rate election as high as 5 cents and will be voting against items that raise the property tax rate. Previous coverage Aug. 14: Austin budget discussions underway, property tax election all but certain Aug. 12: Get up to speed with the latest tax rate election proposals Aug. 8: Austin mayor 'disappointed' with some tax rate election proposals Aug. 5: Austin leaders lay out initial tax rate election proposals Aug 1: Texas cities, counties may face new limits on raising property taxes July 15: Austin leaders concerned budget cuts too much from community needs July 12: Austin City Manager TC Broadnax releases proposed $6B+ budget What is a tax rate election? Because of a 2019 state law, taxing entities cannot raise the property tax rate more than 3.5% from the year prior without triggering a TRE. After City Manager TC Broadnax released his proposed budget, which sat at that 3.5% voter approval rate and would not trigger an election, council members and the mayor started proposing alternatives that cut less services but also add to your property tax bill. That increase in the property tax rate would ultimately trigger a tax rate election in November. The body started discussion on Wednesday, and while the vote is expected to happen Thursday, it may take until Friday to officially vote on the budget and tax rate. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
