logo
My Life With Uncle Vanya, the Self-Pitying Sad Sack We Can't Quit

My Life With Uncle Vanya, the Self-Pitying Sad Sack We Can't Quit

New York Times28-04-2025

Why can't we ever get enough of Uncle Vanya?
What is it about Anton Chekhov's incessantly complaining, self-pitying sad sack that makes him return anew to the theater more than any other dramatic protagonist maybe short of Hamlet, that other great melancholy inaction hero?
The question has grown more pressing in the last two years, since there have been four new revivals of 'Uncle Vanya' in New York alone and another starring Hugh Bonneville that finished an acclaimed run at Shakespeare Theater in Washington earlier this month.
Last year, the playwright Jon Robin Baitz argued that the play was in vogue partly because it was a 'study of post-Covid paralysis.' But 'Uncle Vanya' is always in fashion. I have seen 15 different versions in the last three decades, and I have come to believe that its enduring popularity is because of its flexibility.
The old argument about whether 'Uncle Vanya' — which follows a series of emotional disasters that occur on a Russian country estate run by Vanya and his niece, Sonya — is a comedy or a tragedy misses the point. There's no one right way to perform it. I've seen it done funny and gloomy, cerebral and physical, small scale and broadly theatrical. What's most remarkable about the play is how it can sustain so many different approaches and still move audiences.
Look at the actors who have played the title character in the past year. There's a world of difference between Andrew Scott, the star of the series 'Ripley,' and the comedian Steve Carell; between the defeated, passive man played by the Tony-winning theater director David Cromer and the aggressively cranky Bob Laine from the Brooklyn adaptation by the 'Dimes Square' playwright Matthew Gasda.
'Uncle Vanya' is to ambitious middle-aged actors what 'King Lear' is to older ones: a challenge and a mark of credibility. It's common practice to reimagine the plays of Shakespeare, shifting them into a different place and time. Chekhov's work can just as easily be transported from 19th-century Russia to a contemporary West Virginia or Ireland without strain. Its nimbleness has become especially apparent to me over the years. 'Uncle Vanya' ages well because it changes with age.
The most unsettling moment in three decades of watching this play was during the first act of a whispery 2023 production in a downtown Manhattan loft lit by candlelight. As Vanya, Cromer, who directed two shows currently on Broadway, 'Dead Outlaw' and 'Good Night, and Good Luck,' was bemoaning how he has wasted his life. I'd seen this speech many times, but this one hit differently. Because while he wailed about his lost years, I realized, Oh, no, I am the same age as Vanya.
I am tempted to go on a long tangent about how 47 in Russia more than a century ago was much older than it is now. But instead, a confession: The first time I met Vanya was when I was a teenager and he seemed like an extremely old and clownish bore. Now that I am his age, he comes off more sympathetic. Funny how that happens.
His obsession with lost chances, the way he transforms thwarted ambition into simmering resentments that emerge as smirking mockery, his delusion about the writer he could have been — I recognize parts of myself here. When Vanya moans, 'I could have been a Dostoyevsky,' it used to seem absurd. Now I get it.
The Vanya of my mind's eye, the face that pops to mind when he's evoked, is Wallace Shawn, who starred in the film version, 'Vanya on 42nd St.' It began with a superb cast featuring Larry Pine and Julianne Moore coming to work in street clothes, a fourth wall-busting gesture that has become fashionable if not clichéd. You see it in the Bonneville 'Uncle Vanya' as well as to a lesser degree in the revival with Scott, who begins by turning on the lights, making a cup of tea and adjusting the set. In contrast to those revivals, Shawn's Vanya had an unusual gravitas, a mature weariness and slow burn, his gripes more potent because you could tell he was holding back.
The drama critic Kenneth Tynan called Vanya one 'of the least playable heroes in dramatic literature' because he is so hard to take seriously. But if we don't take him seriously, Tynan argued, the play falls apart. It's the kind of categorical statement that critics and scholars, not to mention artists, often make about Chekhov. My mother's college acting teacher insisted that Vanya must be played as suffering from hemorrhoids (a conviction unsupported by the script).
But consider the miraculous work being done by Scott, playing all the roles through quick-changing physicality. He plays Vanya as a man stuck in arrested development, walking onstage in sunglasses, larking around with a plastic device that plays comic sounds like wolf whistles or a recorded laugh track. He is easy to see as ridiculous (as is this show, which includes a smoldering sex scene between a man and a door). Yet the production, powered by the charisma and Scott's bold choices, holds together.
The plot of 'Uncle Vanya' is spurred by a visit from Sonya's father, the ex-husband of Vanya's sister, and Yelena, his bored second wife, whose beauty distracts all the men around her.
I've attended the last few productions of 'Uncle Vanya' with my teenage daughter, and seeing the play through her eyes clarified how Vanya need not be central to a production. The play can be relatable to young audiences and old, women as well as men. The title itself, 'Uncle Vanya,' invites you to consider young Sonya's perspective. She quietly harbored a crush on the environmentalist Doctor Astrov for six years, until finally Yelena offers to act as an intermediary to learn his true feelings for her.
People have long complained that nothing happens in 'Uncle Vanya' — Tolstoy told an actor, 'it doesn't go anywhere' — but the high-stakes romantic move by Sonya and Yelena is not just a nerve-racking story line. It's a central narrative of middle-school recess.
In a revelatory performance in a Sydney Theater production in 2012, a dancing and pratfalling Cate Blanchett proved that 'Uncle Vanya' could be as lively and funny as it is morose — and made a case that Yelena was its catalytic main character.
But in the new spate of modern productions, 'Uncle Vanya' seems like Sonya's play. She has the standard pathologies of the Instagram era: hyper alert to her physical flaws; deathly insecure; and holding on to the time she overheard someone gossiping about her.
Her relationship with Vanya also underlines another element of the play: Vanya as father figure. He has rubbed off on her, and not in the best ways. Sonya can be competitive about who is more unhappy.
The most memorable performances from this play have been from actresses playing this role. In my favorite production of 'Uncle Vanya' — the recent National Theater revival starring Tony Jones — Amie Lou Wood (Chelsea on the recent season of 'The White Lotus) delivered a heartbreaking, lustful performance that emphasizes the line about the unattractiveness of her teeth. Melanie Field, in the Washington production, contorts her face into a grotesque mask of pain upon describing herself as 'plain.'
For the recent loft production in downtown Manhattan, Marin Ireland portrayed the most fully imagined Sonya I've seen. She makes you feel the pain of embarrassment, but also the excitement of plotting with Yelena, the conspiratorial high of a fleeting friendship. The optimism on her face makes you see that this play is not only about people constantly annoying each other, but also trying and failing to connect.
Seeing all these different versions of 'Uncle Vanya' makes clear that another reason artists and audiences keep returning to the play is it's as full of hope (doomed as it might be) as it is of frustration. This can be hard to see, because characters are constantly describing their misery, and quite flamboyantly. After all, one well-received modern adaptation is titled 'Life Sucks.'
From a certain view, Sonya and Vanya end the play in a place not unlike where they were at the start, minus a few illusions. The world presented here is bleak and unforgiving in ways that will be altogether familiar to an audience today, in ways that are personal, social and even environmental.
Sonya's resilient final speech — 'What can we do? We must live our lives.' — offers a narrow path forward, in work and the afterlife. But one doesn't need either to find solace in this famous last vignette. Vanya and Sonia have each other. In almost all the versions, she seems to keep going because of him. Sonia's last line, spoken next to Vanya, is imagining a better future: 'We shall rest.' The key word is 'we.'
It's worth recalling that the first time Chekhov tried this play, it was called 'The Wood Demon,' and he had the Vanya character kill himself. (It flopped.) When he reworked it, he let him live. Vanya made some moves toward killing himself, like stealing a bottle of morphine, but Sonia found him out and forced him to give it back.
It's one of the most important edits in the history of theater. Dying by suicide would not only have been darker (there goes the debate about comedy versus tragedy), but also less open to interpretation. Death is nothing if not conclusive. This play is about something more understandable to the living: failure.
Vanya tries and fails to get the girl, the career and the revenge he craves. He's so ineffectual that he can't even kill himself. It's pathetic and wonderful, depending how you look at it.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Eddington' Trailer: Joaquin Phoenix Gets Into Standoff With Pedro Pascal In A24's Covid-Era Western From Filmmaker Ari Aster
‘Eddington' Trailer: Joaquin Phoenix Gets Into Standoff With Pedro Pascal In A24's Covid-Era Western From Filmmaker Ari Aster

Yahoo

time21 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

‘Eddington' Trailer: Joaquin Phoenix Gets Into Standoff With Pedro Pascal In A24's Covid-Era Western From Filmmaker Ari Aster

A24 has unveiled the first full-length trailer for Eddington, its latest film from Hereditary helmer Ari Aster, which is slated to hit theaters July 18 after premiering at the Cannes Film Festival. Starring Joaquin Phoenix and Pedro Pascal, the genre-bender is set during the Covid-19 pandemic, watching as a standoff between a small-town sheriff (Phoenix) and mayor (Pascal) sparks a powder keg as neighbor is pitted against neighbor in Eddington, N.M. More from Deadline Everything We Know About Ari Aster's 'Eddington' So Far Pedro Pascal Says That With 'Eddington' Ari Aster Wrote A Movie That's 'All Our Worst Fears' In Post-Covid Political Era Emily Mortimer Taps Alison Oliver & Yura Borisov To Lead 'Dennis,' Her Feature Directorial Debut For A24 & Fruit Tree For Aster, Eddington marked a reunion with Phoenix on the heels of his last film, the dark A24 comedy Beau Is Afraid. He directed from his own script, with Luke Grimes, Deirdre O'Connell, Micheal Ward, Austin Butler, and Emma Stone rounding out the cast. Eddington drew a nearly seven-minute standing ovation in its launch at Cannes, where Deadline's Damon Wise praised Aster for being 'willing to go there' with his satire of modern-day America and all its challenges — 'a slice of history that we have yet to see properly shown on film, even though it happened only five years ago.' The film is financed and produced by A24. Aster produced alongside Lars Knudsen under their Square Peg Banner. Watch the trailer for Eddington at the link above. [youtube Best of Deadline Sean 'Diddy' Combs Sex-Trafficking Trial Updates: Cassie Ventura's Testimony, $10M Hotel Settlement, Drugs, Violence, & The Feds A Full Timeline Of Blake Lively & Justin Baldoni's 'It Ends With Us' Feud In Court, Online & In The Media Where To Watch All The 'John Wick' Movies: Streamers That Have All Four Films

The Best '70s Ski Outfits From the POWDER Archives
The Best '70s Ski Outfits From the POWDER Archives

Yahoo

time31 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

The Best '70s Ski Outfits From the POWDER Archives

As you might remember (or as your parents might remind you), things were a bit different in the 1970s. Global politics were in upheaval, society was opening its mind to new norms, and ski bumming was entering its first golden age. Those were also the years when this publication, first helmed by founders Jake and Dave Moe, began chronicling the deeper side of ski culture. At the time, ski culture had started to evolve into the free-spirited and expression-driven form it still has today, in part driven by the pages of the first volumes of POWDER Magazine. Powder skiing represented the ultimate freedom, and in true 1970s fashion, the skiers of the time took their expression of it to extreme lengths. Speaking of fashion, this was the era of true drip: from tight-fitting one-piece ski suits to oversized knit sweaters, most everything featured loud colors, patterns, and revealing necklines. Check out the Best 70s Ski Outfits from the POWDER archives below. This piece is part of POWDER's Summer of Ski Nostalgia content series. Stay tuned in daily for more nostalgic articles, and keep an eye out for the upcoming Summer of Ski Nostalgia badge to identify future content. You can also view all of POWDER's summer nostalgia content here. These were the days before Gore-Tex and other waterproof/breathable fabrics, with skiers instead opting for wool sweaters and the odd stretchy ski suit. These things were warm, bordering on sweaty, but they undoubtedly oozed style. A 1977 gear editorial section highlighting the year's finest insulated wares for skiers. Many iconic ski brands really found their stride in the 1970s. Look at how far things have come in these ads from Bogner, Rossignol, and Gerry Clothing. Apparel ads from the 70s were just built different. The wool sweater, still an icon of ski fashion today, provided the vibes during the 70s. Personally, these are WAY too hot for me to wear anywhere but inside a cozy mountain hut, but to each their own, I suppose. Eyewear was also on point, with many skiers still opting for large-framed sunglasses instead of full-on goggles. Fashion over function, especially on sunny days. For anyone who has worn goggles of this era, you'll remember that fogging was a pretty real issue. Marketing copy has always been a hot topic of discussion for brands. How can you make things eye-catching without being too weird? That clearly didn't matter to apparel manufacturers back then. Marlboro jackets? Budweiser sweaters? Nothing was sacred back then. While backcountry skiing really entered its golden age during the COVID pandemic, skiers have been walking up mountains and enjoying soft turns on the way down for many years. Take a look at the style and equipment (or lack thereof) employed during the 1970s from places like Vail to Courchevel. Long before technical outerwear, skiers were enjoying hard-earned turns deep in the backcountry. This piece is part of POWDER's Summer of Ski Nostalgia content series. Stay tuned in daily for more nostalgic articles, and keep an eye out for the upcoming Summer of Ski Nostalgia badge to identify future content. You can also view all of POWDER's summer nostalgia content Best '70s Ski Outfits From the POWDER Archives first appeared on Powder on Jun 4, 2025

Ari Aster's ‘Eddington' Sharply Divides Cannes: Star Pedro Pascal Defends a Western About ‘Our Worst Fears' Amid Lockdown
Ari Aster's ‘Eddington' Sharply Divides Cannes: Star Pedro Pascal Defends a Western About ‘Our Worst Fears' Amid Lockdown

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Ari Aster's ‘Eddington' Sharply Divides Cannes: Star Pedro Pascal Defends a Western About ‘Our Worst Fears' Amid Lockdown

When writer/director Ari Aster stood up for the ovation after the Cannes premiere of his divisive 2020-set Western 'Eddington' (July 16, A24), he said, 'I feel very privileged to be here. This is a dream come true. Thank you so much for having me. And, I don't know, sorry?' Indeed, festival attendees have been fiercely divided by his 145-minute portrait of a fictional New Mexico town wracked by COVID, BLM, ACAB, you-name-it-2020-buzz-concept during the darkest season of American lives in recent memory. Joaquin Phoenix (Aster's 'Beau Is Afraid') plays a conservative sheriff who decides to run against his Gavin Newsom-esque, pro-masks-and-testing adversary, Ted Garcia (Pedro Pascal), in the local mayoral election. More from IndieWire The Cannes 2025 Films So Far Most Likely to End Up in the Oscar Race 'Imago' Review: Chechen Documentary Explores a Filmmaker's Conflicted Return to His Roots Meanwhile, at home, Phoenix's character Joe Cross is in a quarantine bubble with his hysteria-addled wife Louise (Emma Stone) and her far-right conspiracy-obsessed mother Dawn (Deirdre O'Connell), the type for whom hydroxychloroquine was presumably a panacea. But Joe's campaign is all anti-masks, anti-vax, with the threat of cult leader Vernon Jefferson Peak (Austin Butler) also posing a challenge to his political and personal life. The film has sparked massive debates up and down the Croisette since premiering Friday night, with the starriest red carpet thus far and a press conference Saturday afternoon featuring Aster with his actors Phoenix, Pascal (in a sleeveless top), Stone (in a pixie haircut, her hair growing back presumably after shaving it off for Yorgos Lanthimos' upcoming 'Bugonia'), and Michael Ward, who plays Phoenix's next-in-command. IndieWire has talked to people who loved or hated the film, with rarely any opinion in between and certainly never without a strong response of some kind from anyone — whether out of boredom or raptures over Aster's in-your-face replay of our worst COVID-times memories. 'Eddington' could be a tough sell for audiences unwilling to be submersed again in summer 2020 and all the chaos and anxieties it erupted. Other pundits I've spoken to defend 'Eddington' as a necessary social satire that mocks and derides the panic of that year, while encapsulating it all into one movie as never before. IndieWire critic David Ehrlich wrote in his rave review that 'few other filmmakers would have the chutzpah required' to pull this movie off, 'and we should probably all be grateful that none of them have tried.' 'It's very scary to participate in a movie that speaks to issues like this,' Pascal said at the press conference. 'It's far too intimidating a question for me to address. I'm not informed enough. I want people to be safe and protective. I want very much to be on the right side of history.' 'Eddington' indeed takes shots at both sides of the aisle, roasting liberal posturing in the form of social justice youth like Sarah (Amélie Hoeferle), who posts TikToks about James Baldwin and rants about having any position at all on 'stolen land.' Phoenix's sheriff character, meanwhile, could only be wrought from the era of Trump, as he rails against mask mandates and is suspicious of the George Floyd-inspired protests shaking up his community. At one point, he swaggers into a grocery store with the pompousness of Western's most classic, gun-on-the-hip cowboys. Pascal added, 'I felt like [Aster] wrote something that was all our worst fears as that lockdown experience was already a fracturing society. This was building toward an untethered sense of reality. There is a point of not going back. I was overwhelmed by that fear, and it's wonderful that it was confirmed by Ari.' Aster, whose latest feature is a hairpin departure from the genre thrills and chills of films like 'Hereditary' and 'Midsommar' and is far from the spirit of intrusive-thought-induced weirdness of 'Beau Is Afraid,' added, 'I wrote this movie in a state of fear and anxiety. I wanted to try and pull back and show what it feels like to live in a world where nobody can agree on what is real anymore.' 'Eddington' is his first feature to premiere at Cannes. 'I feel like we're on a dangerous road, and we're living in an experiment that hasn't gone well,' Aster said (via Deadline) about his MAGA- and liberal-skewering Western. 'I feel there is no way out of it… Mass liberal democracies always had this fundamental agreement we agree what we're arguing about, that system was coming from power. So it's not like suddenly there's this bad power out there. It's always been there, but right now it's chaos.' Stone, who connected with Aster amid his 2024 'Beau Is Afraid,' said that her research into the conspiracy theories that turn her character against her husband even ended up modifying her personal social media algorithms (via Variety). 'The only additional thing that scared me a little bit in the algorithm system was looking into some of the things that are in this film that haven't been in my algorithm, unfortunately, added them to my algorithm,' she said. 'Because once you start Googling it, you start seeing more and more things. So it's a real rabbit hole, very quickly. Unfortunately, I'm still getting fed some crazy shit.' 'Eddington' is still the most conversation-starting Competition premiere at Cannes, with critics split over its social message and pacing (it's currently at 63 on Metacritic, where you can find reviews all over the map). How A24 will market this movie — only one teaser has been released so far, showing Phoenix doom-scrolling through familiar images of the deepest COVID era — is an intriguing question in the lead-up to its July theatrical release. Alex Garland's 'Civil War,' another post-COVID story of national conflict, did well for A24 last year, grossing more than $127 million by tapping into a fascination factor over a divided United States. Who will 'Eddington' appeal to? Either way, it's pitting Cannes audiences against each other — Screen Daily called it a 'wan satire,' while Variety deemed it 'brazenly provocative' — and will no doubt continue to stoke debate into the summer. Best of IndieWire Guillermo del Toro's Favorite Movies: 56 Films the Director Wants You to See 'Song of the South': 14 Things to Know About Disney's Most Controversial Movie The 55 Best LGBTQ Movies and TV Shows Streaming on Netflix Right Now

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store