logo
Taxes, negotiations and dealing with a bully

Taxes, negotiations and dealing with a bully

Opinion
In the current perilous and mercurial moment, it was undoubtedly the right thing to do. But the practical reality of the matter doesn't make it any less viscerally unpleasant.
The decision last Sunday by Prime Minister Mark Carney to rescind the digital services tax might be, as he attempted to ensure Canadians, a small element of a larger negotiating strategy, but for those who have grown sick and tired of the petulant tirades and deplorable tactics of U.S. President Donald Trump, it felt more like backing down in the face of a bully's threats.
The DST, which was introduced by the then-Trudeau-led Liberals in 2020 and was set to take effect June 30, would have imposed a three per cent tax on tech giants with Canadian revenues in excess of $20 million per year.
Adrian Wyld / The Canadian Press
Prime Minister Mark Carney
The primary targets, of course, were U.S.-based firms such as Meta (Facebook, Instagram), Amazon, Google, X Corp. (formerly Twitter) and others, which have siphoned off billions in revenue from this country's retail, commercial and media sectors without contributing anything to the Canadian economy.
Other nations, including France, the United Kingdom, Spain and Italy, have imposed their own versions of a DST, and the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) continues its long and often-stalled effort to create an international framework for regulating and taxing global tech companies.
But Trump, who since being re-elected has fabricated numerous rationales for imposing tariffs and other penalties on Canada, last week described the DST as 'a direct and blatant attack' on the U.S. and declared he would cease all trade negotiations until Canada 'straighten(s) out their act.'
Given that Carney has invested considerable time and political capital into repairing Canada-U.S. relations that had turned toxic largely because of the U.S. president's deep dislike for former prime minister Justin Trudeau, it isn't surprising that the decision was made to shelve the DST, at least temporarily. Carney's priority is to restart talks aimed at reaching a trade deal that addresses the punitive tariffs that have been capriciously applied since Trump's return to the White House.
Weekday Mornings
A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day.
'It's part of a bigger negotiation,' Carney said of the DST withdrawal. 'It's something that we expected in the broader sense that would be part of a final deal.' Trade talks between Canada and the U.S. resumed Monday, with the previously agreed-upon deadline of July 21 still being the target for reaching an agreement.
Whether the last-minute cancellation of the digital tax truly was a tactical move or simply amounts to an act of sheepish acquiescence, it's difficult for Canadians to view it as anything but loathsome. We're all taught, from childhood, that we should never give in to a bully, because doing so will only embolden the tormentor to attack again, demand more and extract as much as can be gained for as long as the bullying tactics continue to work.
In addition to the direct costs of seeking to appease, there's also an emotional toll that comes with letting a bully get away with it, a sickening feeling deep in the pit of one's stomach at the idea the bad guys are winning, yet again, and that maybe the arc of history does not — as former president Barack Obama and others have professed — bend toward justice.
For now, all we have is our trust that Carney really is playing a long game, and that Canadians will be rewarded for their patience in this moment of profound frustration.
Giving in to a bully is deeply unpleasant; now, it's up to the PM to prove to us all it was worth it.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Toronto Mayor Chow to lead trade mission to Ireland, United Kingdom
Toronto Mayor Chow to lead trade mission to Ireland, United Kingdom

CTV News

time30 minutes ago

  • CTV News

Toronto Mayor Chow to lead trade mission to Ireland, United Kingdom

Toronto Mayor Olivia Chow speaks during a panel at the Federation of Canadian Municipalities conference, in Ottawa, Friday, May 30, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld Toronto Mayor Olivia Chow is planning to put a spotlight on the city's film and screen industry during her upcoming trade mission to the United Kingdom and Ireland. Chow announced on Saturday that, along with members of Toronto's film and television industry, she will be travelling to Dublin and London from July 6 to 12 and meeting with production companies and broadcasters. 'At a time of historic uncertainty, reliable trade partners have never been more important,' said Mayor Olivia Chow in a statement. 'This trade mission is about supporting more economic opportunities for Toronto workers and businesses, including export diversification and foreign direct investment attraction.' According to a news release from the city, the mayor is hoping to increase Canadian content through co-production treaties with the two countries during her visit. In Dublin, the mayor will meet with the Ireland-Canada Business Association, Enterprise Ireland executives and explore funding partnership opportunities through Horizon Europe and CeADAR, Ireland's Centre for AI, the release said. Meanwhile, in London, Chow is scheduled to participate in a roundtable with the UK-Canada Chamber of Commerce to promote trade opportunities in Toronto. The mayor will also have bilateral meetings with Dublin Lord Mayor Ray McAdam and London Mayor Sir Sadiq Khan. 'The mission will also provide opportunities for city-to-city knowledge exchange about solutions to common urban policy challenges, including housing and transportation,' the city said. Leading a trade mission to increase export and investment opportunities is one of the items in Mayor Chow's economic action plan in response to U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs.

Lorne Gunter: Carney taking lessons from Trump and it's bad for Canada's bottom line
Lorne Gunter: Carney taking lessons from Trump and it's bad for Canada's bottom line

Calgary Herald

time33 minutes ago

  • Calgary Herald

Lorne Gunter: Carney taking lessons from Trump and it's bad for Canada's bottom line

As much as U.S. President Donald Trump loves to exercise power by executive order, rather than leaving lawmaking up to the U.S. Congress, it is becoming increasingly obvious that Canada's very own Prime Minister Mark Carney loves governing by the Canadian equivalent – the order-in-council. Article content Consider for a minute Carney's refusal to have Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne bring down a budget until November or December. Rather than a budget and enabling legislation to authorize nearly half a trillion dollars in spending, Carney prefers to rule (and spend) by cabinet decree. Article content Article content Article content Before April's election, parliamentary budget officer Yves Giroux estimated the federal deficit for the current fiscal year would be just about $47 billion. That's bad enough, but a significant decrease from the $62-billion deficit that the Liberals had to admit to before Christmas for last year. Article content But as Giroux pointed out at the time, his sum was only 'a baseline.' His number was only what the deficit would be before any of the political promises the winning party carried through on. Article content Since the Liberals were re-elected, Giroux has estimated for reporters that the Carney government's campaign goodies would raise the 2025-26 deficit to between $60 billion and $70 billion 'in the absence of spending cuts elsewhere.' That, of course, is as bad or worse than last year's Liberal amount. Article content Mark Carney intends for his government to spend more money than Justin Trudeau's, and without a budget or proper accountability to Parliament. Article content Article content But even Giroux's latest guestimate doesn't include measures the Carney Liberals have taken since the end of May without recourse to the House of Commons or a budget. Article content Article content Enter Toronto's C.D. Howe Institute. Article content The non-partisan think tank calculates that with measures announced by the Liberals since the election (right up to the cancellation of the digital services tax last weekend), the deficit this year will be $92 billion in the current fiscal year, $75 billion next year, $73 billion the year after that and $71 billion in 2028-29. Article content That's a total of $311 billion in extra public debt in just four years. It took the Trudeau government 10 years to add $600 billion. That's a rate of extra debt about 20 per cent faster than the rate built up by Justin Trudeau and his cabinets. Article content You may take comfort in the fact that Carney is a former central banker and international financier. I don't. Canada already has a higher-than-average debt-to-GDP ratio for a developed nation. Carney's orgy of spending will only make it worse.

Windsor's Best Western workers stage ‘unity picket' in Ingersoll
Windsor's Best Western workers stage ‘unity picket' in Ingersoll

CTV News

timean hour ago

  • CTV News

Windsor's Best Western workers stage ‘unity picket' in Ingersoll

Tammy Smith, the chairperson for unionized workers at the Best Western in Windsor, said members remain 'upbeat' five weeks into a strike. Seen in Ingersoll, Ont. on July 5, 2025. (Brent Lale/CTV News London) Striking workers from the Best Western Plus Windsor Waterfront travelled to Ingersoll on Saturday to picket outside another property owned by the employer. Unifor Local 195 members held an information picket outside Elm Hurst Inn and Spa, which is owned by Shmuel Farhi of Farhi Holdings Corporation, the same owner of the Best Western. The two sides have been in a stalemate since workers walked off the job on June 1, largely due to differences over wages. 'We just want to educate the public what Farhi has been doing all along,' said Emile Nabbout, president of Local 195. Nabbout described the picket as a 'sign of solidarity' with Unifor members in the Ingersoll area. 'This is a unity, trying to call on Farhi, the owner of Farhi Holdings, to come to the table and bargain a fair deal for our employees who have been on the picket line for almost five weeks,' Nabbout said. Windsor workers picket in Ingersoll Best Western Members from Unifor Local 195 travelled to Ingersoll, Ont. to strike outside the Elm Hurst Inn & Spa, which is owned by Farhi Holdings Corporation, the mutual owner of the Best Western. Seen in Ingersoll, Ont. on July 5, 2025. (Brent Lale/CTV News London) CTV News reached Farhi by phone on Saturday afternoon, but he declined to comment. The union has said the majority of members make about $18.02 per hour, and the company is acting out of 'greed' by not raising wages. Tammy Smith, who works at the Best Western, said union members were invited by those in the Ingersoll area. 'It was the people in this area that said, welcome to this beautiful property here in [Ingersoll] that is owned by Farhi Holdings, and let's just let people know what's going on in Windsor,' Smith said. Striking workers include staff from the front desk, maintenance, and housekeeping. Current wages make it difficult for workers to make ends meet, Smith said. 'I'm not saying that $20 an hour they're going to make their bills, but it's a little bit easier for these people to get ahead,' Smith noted. Smith said workers were dealt a 'slap in the face' by the company when their demands were not taken seriously. Despite about five weeks of job action, she added there remains an 'upbeat' demeanour among workers. 'We take the jobs really, really seriously. And we feel like this is just an utter disrespect to send us out to the streets instead of staying at the negotiating table and bargaining with us,' Smith said. Commenting about the Ingersoll picket, Ironwood Management Corp., who manages Best Western for Farhi, said: 'The move by the union to start attacking the guests of other Farhi owned businesses is disappointing. People are intelligent enough to tell the difference between legitimate labour disputes and meaningless Union rhetoric. Unifor is only risking their own embarrassment by trying to convince anyone that the Employer has been anything but fair with its employees.' Workers previously rejected an offer after the employer forced the vote, calling it their 'final offer,' at the time. -With files from CTV News London's Brent Lale.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store