Divided US appeals court rejects plea deal for accused Sept 11 attacks mastermind
A U.S. appeals court on Friday refused to allow Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the accused mastermind of the September 11, 2001, attacks, and two of his co-defendants to plead guilty under agreements that would have spared them the death penalty.
The ruling by a 2-1 panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upended an attempt to bring an end to a military prosecution of the three detainees in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, that has been beset by two decades of legal gridlock.
Those plea agreements had been offered last year and accepted by the official who oversees the Pentagon's Guantanamo war court, only to be revoked in August by then-Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin after Republican lawmakers attacked the agreements.
A military judge, though, ruled that Austin lacked authority to revoke the plea deals in a decision that was upheld in December by U.S. Court of Military Commission Review. The judge then scheduled prompt plea hearings.
The D.C. Circuit at the behest of former Democratic President Joe Biden's administration agreed to pause those proceedings while it heard the government's legal challenge, which Republican President Donald Trump's administration continued.
U.S. Circuit Judges Patricia Millett and Neomi Rao, writing for the majority, in Friday's ruling said Austin "indisputably had legal authority to withdraw from the agreements."
"Having properly assumed the convening authority, the Secretary determined that the 'families and the American public deserve the opportunity to see military commission trials carried out," the judges wrote. "The secretary acted within the bounds of his legal authority, and we decline to second-guess his judgment."
Millett was appointed by Democratic President Barack Obama, while Rao is a Trump appointee. U.S. Circuit Judge Robert Wilkins, an Obama appointee, dissented from what he called a "stunning" ruling, saying his colleagues should have deferred to the decisions of military courts interpreting military rules.
A lawyer for Mohammed and one of his co-defendants, Mustafa Ahmed Adam al Hawsawi, did not respond to requests for comment, nor did the Pentagon.
Matthew Engle, an attorney for the third defendant, Walid Muhammad Salih Mubarak bin 'Atash, said he was considering a potential further appeal, including to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Mohammed is the most well-known inmate at the detention facility in Guantanamo Bay, which was set up in 2002 by then-U.S. President George W. Bush to house foreign militant suspects following the September 11, 2001, attacks.
Mohammed is accused of masterminding the plot to fly hijacked commercial passenger aircraft into the World Trade Center in New York City and into the Pentagon. The 9/11 attacks killed nearly 3,000 people. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AsiaOne
2 hours ago
- AsiaOne
Australia will not commit troops in advance to any conflict, minister says, World News
SYDNEY - Australia will not commit troops in advance to any conflict, Defence Industry Minister Pat Conroy said on Sunday (July 13), responding to a report that the Pentagon has pressed its ally to clarify what role it would play if the US and China went to war over Taiwan. Australia prioritises its sovereignty and "we don't discuss hypotheticals", Conroy said in an interview with the Australian Broadcasting Corporation. "The decision to commit Australian troops to a conflict will be made by the government of the day, not in advance but by the government of the day," he said. The Financial Times reported on Saturday that Elbridge Colby, the US under-secretary of defence for policy, has been pushing Australian and Japanese defence officials on what they would do in a Taiwan conflict, although the US does not offer a blank cheque guarantee to defend Taiwan. Colby posted on X that the Department of Defence is implementing President Donald Trump's "America First" agenda of restoring deterrence, which includes "urging allies to step up their defence spending and other efforts related to our collective defence". China claims democratically governed Taiwan as its own and has not ruled out the use of force to bring Taiwan under its control. Taiwan President Lai Ching-te rejects China's sovereignty claims, saying only Taiwan's people can decide their future. Australia's largest war-fighting exercise with the United States, involving 30,000 troops from 19 countries, opens on Sunday on Sydney Harbour. Conroy said Australia was concerned about China's military buildup of nuclear and conventional forces, and wants a balanced Indo-Pacific region where no country dominates. "China is seeking to secure a military base in the region and we are working very hard to be the primary security partner of choice for the region because we don't think that's a particularly optimal thing for Australia," he said, referring to the Pacific Islands. Security is expected to be on the agenda when Prime Minister Anthony Albanese meets China's leaders this week. He arrived in Shanghai on Saturday for a six-day visit. The Talisman Sabre exercise will span 6,500km, from Australia's Indian Ocean territory of Christmas Island to the Coral Sea on Australia's east coast. Conroy said it was possible China's navy would be watching the exercise to collect information, as it had done in the past. The United States is Australia's major security ally. Although Australia does not permit foreign bases, the US military is expanding its rotational presence and fuel stores on Australian bases, which from 2027 will have US Virginia submarines at port in Western Australia. These would play a key role in supporting US forces in any conflict over Taiwan, analysts say. [[nid:720128]]
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Foreign ‘tourists' turn handymen in Malaysia, fleece customers of thousands
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Foreigners entering Malaysia as 'tourists' have scammed unsuspecting customers out of thousands. PETALING JAYA - Renovation scams have taken a new turn, with foreigners who supposedly came to Malaysia as 'tourists' fleecing unsuspecting customers out of thousands of ringgit, some offering fly-by-night handyman and contractor services. What is worse is the shoddy workmanship that wears off within days. This also comes with a hefty price tag, where victims have been charged somewhere between RM6,000 (S$1,800) and RM11,000 for waterproofing and leakage repair works. Mr Kan Tuck Poh, a 48-year-old chef from Iskandar Puteri, Johor, said he came across a waterproofing and repairs advertisement on social media. Mr Kan, who works as a chef in Singapore, said he enlisted the so-called handymen based on the advertisement. 'They did not quote the price before beginning the work. They simply used an adhesive to plug the leakage,' he told The Star. 'After they were done, they quoted RM6,900 as the cost. The warranty supposedly lasted for six years,' he added. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Government looking at enhancing laws around vaping to tackle issue of drug-laced vapes in Singapore Singapore Why the vape scourge in Singapore concerns everyone Singapore I lost my daughter to Kpod addiction: Father of 19-year-old shares heartbreak and lessons Singapore Organised crime groups pushing drug-laced vapes in Asia including Singapore: UN Singapore Prison school to NUS: At 36, former drug abuser finds it's never too late to get a degree Singapore Driver arrested after 66-year-old woman dies in car crash at Geylang pasar malam Singapore Bland and boring? Some hospitals seek help from big names to enhance food menus for patients Asia Patriotism, peace and pain: The politics behind China's World War II narrative Mr Kan said the adhesive only lasted for five days and once it came off, he had trouble getting hold of the two men. They kept coming up with excuses. 'They drove a local car and spoke with a thick foreign accent. I asked them how long they had been here. They said they had only arrived two days earlier and they came here under a tourist visa,' he said. Suspecting it was a scam and after failing to get the duo to fix the leakage, he finally lodged a police report. 'When I asked them to come to the police station to settle the problem, they blocked me,' he said. Mr Kan believes that they were operating nationwide and not just in Johor. In his police report, Mr Kan said he had paid RM2,900 in cash. He had later transferred RM1,000 and S$912 to two Singaporean bank accounts belonging to two foreign nationals. He even said that the handyman had threatened to 'burn down his house' if he lodged a police report. The Star found the Facebook page of the service provider was still active with the last post being on May 25. They claim to offer professional waterproofing and leak repair services. Their promotional literature included short videos of two handymen fixing roofs, bathrooms and other areas, and also included purported customer testimonials. They also claimed to offer free on-site inspection and contact was solely through WhatsApp. Petaling Jaya Malaysian Chinese Association deputy chief Lim Han Boon said he personally visited a renovation site along Jalan Alor and found about 50 foreign nationals working on the project. He said a friend of his, who happened to be one of the workers for the project, had informed him about the situation. 'When I asked how long they had been working here, some of them tried to avoid answering my questions,' he said, noting that they spoke in foreign accents. According to Mr Lim, the site involved renovation work across three floors. Upon inspecting the materials being used, he noted that some appeared to have been sourced from a foreign country. He believes it is possible that the contractor procured the renovation materials directly from a foreign country and shipped them to Malaysia for use. 'Local construction companies have to pay taxes, EPF contributions for their workers and other overheads,' he said. EPF, or E mployees Provident Fund, refers to Malaysia's pension scheme. 'But even after factoring in airfares, accommodation and wages, these foreign workers still cost less than hiring locals.' Mr Lim added that he plans to gather more evidence before submitting the matter to the police and Immigration Department for further action. In 2024, Malaysia's Construction Industry Development Board unveiled a standard construction agreement template that outlines the responsibilities and contractual obligations that all involved parties should adhere to during a renovation project – in an effort to combat renovation scams. It urged homeowners to stay informed about the current prices of construction materials, labour costs and local council regulations affecting renovation work. THE STAR/ASIA NEWS NETWORK
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Australia says China is likely to spy on its military drills with the US
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The comments by a government minister came as Prime Minister Anthony Albanese made a six-day visit to China to bolster recently repaired trade ties. SYDNEY - Australia's government on July 13 said it expects China to spy on major military drills it is conducting with the United States and other allies. It also renewed a charge – denounced by Beijing as a 'false narrative' – that China wants to establish a military base in the South Pacific. The comments by a government minister came as Prime Minister Anthony Albanese made a six-day visit to China to bolster recently repaired trade ties. More than 30,000 military personnel from 19 nations are set to join in the annual Talisman Sabre exercise from July 13 across Australia and Papua New Guinea. 'The Chinese military have observed these exercises since 2017 and it would be very unusual if they didn't do that this time,' said Pat Conroy, Australia's minister for the defence industry and for Pacific Island affairs. 'We'll obviously observe their activities and monitor their presence around Australia,' he told Australian public broadcaster ABC. 'People observe these exercises to collect intelligence around procedures, around the electronic spectrum and the use of communications, and we'll adjust accordingly so that we manage that leakage.' Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Government looking at enhancing laws around vaping to tackle issue of drug-laced vapes in Singapore Singapore Why the vape scourge in Singapore concerns everyone Singapore I lost my daughter to Kpod addiction: Father of 19-year-old shares heartbreak and lessons Singapore Organised crime groups pushing drug-laced vapes in Asia including Singapore: UN Singapore Prison school to NUS: At 36, former drug abuser finds it's never too late to get a degree Singapore Driver arrested after 66-year-old woman dies in car crash at Geylang pasar malam Singapore Bland and boring? Some hospitals seek help from big names to enhance food menus for patients Asia Patriotism, peace and pain: The politics behind China's World War II narrative The strategically important South Pacific region is at the centre of a diplomatic scramble for influence pitting China against its Western rivals. 'We're seeing in my portfolio of the Pacific, China seeking to secure a military base in the region,' said Mr Conroy, who has previously made the same assessment. 'We're working very hard to be the primary security partner of choice for the region, because we don't think that's a particularly optimal thing for Australia.' China inked a secretive security pact with Pacific nation Solomon Islands in 2022. Although the details have never been published, the United States and close ally Australia fear it may be the prelude to some kind of permanent Chinese base. Australia wants 'a balanced region where no one is dominated and no one dominates', Mr Conroy said. China's embassy in Fiji this month insisted claims that it wanted to set up a military base in the region were 'false narratives' driven by 'ulterior motives'. Beijing has spent hundreds of millions of dollars building sports stadiums, presidential palaces, hospitals and roads in Pacific island nations. Kiribati, Solomon Islands and Nauru have in recent years severed longstanding diplomatic links with Taiwan in favour of China. AFP
