Education Secretary Linda McMahon struggles with basic math when trying to add up proposed budget cuts
Sitting before the appropriations subcommittee that focuses on education, McMahon nodded her head along as Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana mistakenly claimed that the U.S. spends '$1,580,000' on federal grant programs, known as TRIO and GEAR UP, per year and that after 10 years, that adds up to be 'over a trillion dollars.'
The U.S. actually spends $1.58 billion per year on the programs, which does not add up to more than a trillion after 10 years. But, McMahon did not correct Kennedy's math error.
However, Reed, the senator from Rhode Island, did.
'I'm not a great mathematician, but I think you were talking about a trillion dollars? I believe $1.5 billion times 10 is $15 billion, that's a little bit off from a trillion dollars,' Reed said.
McMahon responded, 'I think the budget cuts $1.2 billion for TRIO.'
'Well, $1.2 billion that would be $12 billion, not a trillion dollars,' Reed replied.
'Ok,' McMahon said.
The math blunder was part of McMahon's testimony about President Donald Trump's 2026 budget proposal, which includes sweeping cuts to the Department of Education – drastically impacting education grants such as TRIO or GEAR UP.
The Independent has asked the Department of Education for comment.
TRIO, a federal program comprised of various grants, are some of the Education Department's largest investments aimed at assisting low-income or first-generation college students or individuals with disabilities to advance through the academic pipeline. In 2024, the Education Department provided $1.191 billion for the program.
GEAR UP, a federal grant program, assists low-income students preparing to enter postsecondary education. In 2024, the Education Department provided $388 million for the program.
But under Trump's proposed 'skinny budget,' essentially all of the TRIO and GEAR UP grants would be eliminated. It's part of his efforts to shutter the Education Department.
During the hearing, Senator Susan Collins of Maine aired concerns about the cuts to TRIO, saying she had 'seen the lives of countless first-generation and low-income students, not only in Maine, but across the country… changed by the TRIO program.'
Education advocacy groups such as the Council for Opportunity in Education and the Institute for College Access & Success have condemned the proposed budget, saying it would negatively impact millions of students – particularly those of low-income households.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
30 minutes ago
- CBS News
Trump administration could block student loan relief for some workers in public service
The Trump administration is proposing a new rule that would bar people with outstanding college loans from relief on that debt if their employers were found to be "undermining national security and American values through illegal means." The proposed rule, announced Monday by the Department of Education, would restrict people from participating in the federal Public Student Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program if the organization they work for is found to be engaging in certain illegal activities. "President Trump has given the Department a historic mandate to restore the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program to its original purpose — supporting public servants who strengthen their communities and serve the public good, not benefiting businesses engaged in illegal activity that harm Americans," Under Secretary of Education Nicholas Kent said in a statement. The loan program, which was launched in 2007 under President George W. Bush, is aimed at helping public employees such as teachers and police officers shed student loan debt. The proposed rule lists some examples of what sorts of activities would be considered illegal, potentially resulting in an organization's workers being excluded from the public service loan program. Those include assessments that an organization is aiding and abetting terrorism, violations of immigration laws, and what the rule describes as the "chemical and surgical castration or mutilation of children." If an individual with outstanding student loans works for an employer deemed ineligible for the PSLF, the person could still participate in the program but would have to switch to an eligible employer, according to the proposed rule. President Trump spurred the new rulemaking process in March by issuing an executive order that directed the Secretary of Education to revise the public service loan forgiveness program. The Education Department is soliciting public comments on the proposed rule until September 17. The White House and the Education Department didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. The Department of Education said the proposed regulations are necessary to preserve the original intent of the Public Student Loan Forgiveness program, which is to reward public service. The agency also said it wants to protect Americans to ensure their tax dollars do not support organizations engaged in "unlawful activity." "The proposed rules would halt PSLF benefits to employees of organizations that are undermining national security and American values through illegal means, and therefore not providing a public service," the Education Department said in a statement. Critics of the draft regulation said it would allow Education Department officials to improperly exclude some public servants from loan relief under the federal program. The Student Borrower Protection Center, an advocacy group, said in a July blog post that the rule would give the Education Department broad authority to restrict funding to groups whose work conflicts with the Trump administration's agenda. "To be clear, if implemented this proposal would allow the secretary [of education] to disqualify from PSLF any employees of school systems that accurately teach the U.S.' history of slavery, of health care providers who offer gender-affirming care and of legal aid organizations that represent individuals against unlawful deportations," Winston Berkman-Breen, legal director of the Student Borrower Protection Center, said in a June 30 public hearing on the proposal. Introduced as part of the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007, the public service loan program cancels outstanding debt for borrowers who make 120 monthly payments, or 10 years worth of payments. Currently, the program provides benefits to all government employers and all qualifying 501(c)(3) employers.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Higher ed reallocations: Utah's college presidents present strategic reinvestment plans to lawmakers
Tuesday marked a key moment in the state's historic and often divisive strategic reinvestment effort for Utah's higher education institutions. For the first time, the leaders of the state's eight degree-granting colleges and universities formally presented their respective reallocation plans for the next three years to lawmakers. The Legislature's Higher Education Appropriations Subcommittee got the first shot at examining each institution's plans. After listening to Tuesday's presentations from each of the school presidents, the appropriation subcommittee, by majority vote, accepted their respective reallocation proposals. The eight strategic reinvestment plans are now in the hands of the Legislature's Executive Appropriations Committee for final approval, which will vote in the coming weeks. There's much on the line. If each of the school's strategic reinvest plans gets a thumbs-up from the committee, they can reclaim the 10% of their annual budget that was cut during the recent legislative session. The eight strategic reinvestment plans each received prior approval from the Utah Board of Higher Education. Utah Commissioner of Higher Education Geoffrey Landward, who addressed the subcommittee at Tuesday's school presentations, saluted the institution presidents and their teams for the 'exceptional amount of work … that they put into producing these plans and executing on these plans." 'As well as having to go through a process that required a careful scrutiny of the programs that they offer — and making some very difficult decisions.' Rep. Karen Peterson, R-Clinton, who co-sponsored House Bill 265 — the so-called 'Strategic Reinvestment Bill' — said that Tuesday's subcommittee meeting has been 'a long time coming.' 'We've been talking about higher education and the importance and value of higher education in our state — not just for our students, but for our communities, for our families, for our industries and for keeping our state strong. 'Higher education is the most important economic driver we have in our state, and we need to continue to keep our higher education system strong to keep our state strong.' Difficult decisions demanded by HB265 The 'growing pains' exacted by HB265 are being felt by institutions — and by individuals. People have lost, or will lose, jobs. Meanwhile, instructional programs and courses are being eliminated so funds can be reallocated to programs deemed more valuable. 'This process was not easy on our college campuses … there were real impacts for individuals,' said Peterson. Sen. Kathleen Riebe, D-Cottonwood Heights, has been a vocal critic of HB265 since its inception. The longtime educator made clear Tuesday that she remains opposed to the state-mandated higher education reallocations and cuts. She pushed back on suggestions that the reallocation legislation is 'a massive success.' 'I have not really gotten a lot of great emails about (how this) is working,' said Riebe. 'I have had a lot of emails from professors that say it's not working — that their programs have been cut, that they have lost their tenure and that they feel like it's arbitrary and capricious in the ways things have happened.' Responding to Riebe, Landward acknowledged that the reallocation process 'is not without its pain points — and that there are real impacts on individuals that work at our institutions.' But the commissioner added that Utah's education leaders are required to justify every tax dollar sent to higher education. So it's appropriate, he said, to scrutinize each program being funded at a public Utah college — and then make data-driven decisions about if it's providing sufficient returns and worth preserving. There are valid criticisms regarding the institutions' reallocation decisions, Landward acknowledged. 'But making the wrong choice, based on the data in front of us, is different from making an arbitrary choice based on no data,' he said. 'And I am confident in the fact that all of our institutional presidents … made decisions based on the best information they had in front of them, and not arbitrarily.' Riebe argued that there is danger in making the sort of 'occupational optimization' pivots being prioritized by HB265. She pointed to efforts in recent years to educate more people in computer coding — a job skill that's now being claimed by artificial intelligence. 'I think the changes we are making are shortsighted,' she said. 'And I think that the humanities and social services are taking a brunt that they shouldn't be taking.' She added that such educational shifts could undermine efforts to remedy societal challenges such as loneliness and suicide. Peterson countered that one of the largest 'reinvestments' happening across Utah colleges is in health care. Highlights of each school's strategic reinvestment plan The state's flagship institution of higher learning has the largest HB265 reallocation burden: more than $19.5 million. The University of Utah's reinvestment plan includes reallocation investments in engineering; advancing responsible AI and biotechnology; boosting programs that address the critical nursing shortage; and strengthening general education by focusing on civic responsibility and building durable skills such as critical thinking and conflict resolution. The university's disinvestments will come, in part, by implementing improved efficiencies in administration and administrative support areas and terminating the lease on the school's St. George Center. Meanwhile, scores of courses and programs at the University of Utah are being sunset across a variety of colleges — including programs in educational psychology, bioengineering, modern dance, Middle East studies, sociology/criminology and neurobiology. Ninety-nine positions at the University of Utah are being eliminated — while 129 are being created as part of the reallocation effort. The state's sole land-grant university, USU is required by HB265 to reallocate approximately $12.6 million. School leaders are concentrating their changes on three broad categories: technologies and careers for the future (i.e., addressing critical needs in engineering, artificial intelligence, computing, and analytics); health and well-being workforce; and improving student access, success and outcomes. Proposed reallocations include new faculty positions in AI and data science, a new school of computing, a new chemical engineering program and the expansion of the school's aviation program. In health care, USU is looking to expand mental health and well-being programs and its nursing program — while creating a new College of Health and Human Sciences and a new doctor of physical therapy program. Investments are also planned in student success support programming and USU's online enterprise. Seventy new positions are being created. USU's proposed plan does include significant personnel costs. Approximately 120 full-time equivalent positions are slated for elimination — including positions in school administration, staff and faculty. (Note: Full-time equivalent positions do not represent, number-to-number, full-time employees.) Several USU programs, degrees and certificates are slated to be discontinued — including bachelor's degrees in American studies, agriculture communication and deaf education; master's degrees in financial economics and fitness promotion; and an associate's degree in theatre offered at the school's Price, Utah, campus. The state's largest community college, SLCC is required by HB265 to reallocate approximately $5.2 million. SLCC is focusing on three 'major outcomes' in support of the bill's goals to align funding to evolving student and workforce needs: 1. Reinvesting in workforce and high-demand transfer programs — including over $2 million reinvested in technical programs, almost $1 million in the Gail Miller Business School and $586,000 in the School of Health Sciences. 2. Reducing administrative overhead costs to reinvest in instruction programs by, in part, eliminating five administrator positions and through consolidation. 3. Centering student outcomes in the decision-making process — prompting almost $600,000 in additional reductions that went beyond HB265's budget reduction requirements. SLCC's proposal would result in decreasing the number of instructional offerings from 195 to 147 total certificate and degree programs, while also consolidating the School of Arts, Communication and Media. The changes are expected to impact 50 full-time and part-time employees. Fifteen are vacant positions — 35 are slated for layoffs. Many employees impacted by layoffs will have opportunities to transfer to another position at the school — or pursue a retirement option, according to the school. The Ephraim-based community college is required by HB265 to reallocate $1.7 million over the next three years. Strategic reinvestment plan highlights include expanding the school's prison education program, the elementary education program, the respiratory therapy program — and the creation of several new programs, including pre-architecture and drafting, strategic communication and public relations, commercial driver's license, and rural entrepreneurship. Meanwhile, several academic programs/courses are slated for disinvestment — including French, Italian and media studies. There will be 11 jobs eliminated — including positions in information technology and student affairs. However, there were no involuntary separations or forced layoffs. One vice president position was eliminated at Snow. Located in St. George, Utah Tech University is required by HB265 to reallocate $2.5 million over the course of its implementation. UT's plan aims to meet workforce demands, while increasing enrollment — including adding 17 faculty and instructional staff positions in high-demand areas such as business, engineering, psychology, health sciences and digital media programs. The school also plans to add an associate dean for arts. Reductions are being made, in part, by eliminating several staff, faculty and administrative positions — including the school's executive director of strategic partnerships, one Spanish education and one theater directing faculty member; and one school dean and five administrative support positions. The direction of HB265, said president Shane Smeed, helps UT 'strengthen and accelerate UT's pursuit of polytechnic mission and value.' Cedar City's SUU is required to reallocate $3.1 million. The school's plan focuses primarily on Utah's workforce needs and identifying emerging student opportunities. Multiple faculty positions, for example, are being added to the school's business, STEM, health care and innovative tech programs. Several new positions are also being created to enhance student support as they prepare for careers. Meanwhile, 25 positions are being eliminated in several fields — including chemistry, biology, history and math. Twenty-four academic programs are being eliminated. Majors slated for elimination include philosophy, French, French education and art history. The arts administration (face-to-face) and athletic training master's programs are also being cut. Several associate degree programs — including many which were already slated for eventual elimination — are also being dropped. Also, SUU's College of Engineering & Computational Sciences will be combined with the College of Natural Sciences. The Ogden-based institution, which has experienced record growth in recent years, is required by HB265 to reallocate approximately $6.7 million. Forty-nine positions are being cut: 11 administrative positions, 10 staff positions and 28 salaried faculty — with most of the faculty cuts coming from the College of Social and Behavioral Sciences and the Lindquist College of Arts & Humanities. Several administrative slots are also being reduced — including the school's assistant vice president for regional partnerships and the executive director for Academic Support Centers and Programs. Meanwhile, dozens of majors, certificates and minors are being eliminated — including majors in applied physics, dance education, geography, and computer science teaching. Areas of reinvestment at WSU include: innovation, AI and emerging technologies; health professions and behavioral health; energy, aerospace and defense; digital economy, social media and forensics; creative industries and digital content; course fee replacement; academic advising; recruitment/enrollment; classroom technology; open education resources WSU also plans to establish a new associate dean position within the Dumke College of Health Professions, specifically focused on nursing. In harmony with HB265, WSU will also be providing a few three-year bachelor's degree programs. The state's largest university, UVU is required by the state to reallocate approximately $8.9 million. UVU had been implementing efficiency-focused decisions long before HB265 — reducing, in recent years, a number of academic schools/colleges and discontinuing the English Language Learning Program. And last October, the school implemented a campus-wide hiring freeze to manage budgets. Still, this year's legislative actions are taking a toll at the Orem institution. Fifty positions are being eliminated. Several of those jobs were already vacant. Meanwhile, several specific academic programs are slated for cuts — including a specialized associate's degree in business; certificates in woodworking/cabinetry and administrative information support; and a nursing education master's degree. Expenditures are also being reduced in UVU's Academic Affairs departments — including the Innovation Academy and Program Assessment budgets. Other highlighted areas of UVU's reinvestment plan include: Expanding resources for emerging occupations such as AI. Increasing engineering-related initiatives in mechanical engineering, computer science and IT. Expanding health and wellness opportunities in occupational therapy and behavioral health. And further investing in general education to develop critical thinking, communication and durable skills. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
New Hartford superintendent addresses school board for the 1st time
HARTFORD, Conn. (WTNH) — A new leader is at the helm of the Hartford Public Schools. Dr. Andraé Townsel addressed the Hartford community for the first time as superintendent during a school board meeting Tuesday. 'Ladies and gentlemen, I've hit the ground running,' he said at the board meeting. It's been an eventful start so far for Dr. Townsel, who has spent the last three weeks exploring Hartford and learning about the community. 'I'm learning as much as I possibly can, because the reality is young people do not get their time back,' Dr. Townsel said. 'So, I have to learn as quickly as possible' Dr. Townsel said he will soon release a 100-day plan as he gets ready to take over a school district that has recently dealt with budget issues and low staffing. RELATED: Community describes qualities wanted for new Hartford superintendent 'You know what? We do have some vacancies, but we're working every single day to fill that,' Dr. Townsel said. 'We are going to be fine once school starts, we have our people locked and loaded.' Dr. Townsel said he plans to visit all 39 of Hartford's public schools during the first few weeks of the school year. Some community members say there will be a lot for him to investigate. 'We need a superintendent that is going to fight for our kids, not just give in to the powers that are out there,' Carol Gale, president of the Hartford Federation of Teachers said. Gale spoke about areas in need of attention to the school board during the Tuesday meeting, including special education, opportunity gaps and the district's relationship with labor unions. She said the root of many of the school district's problems is lack of staff retention. 'It has to do with raising the culture and climate in this district,' Gale said. 'It comes from treating people professionally, respecting people, valuing staff.' One displaced teacher is Mike Soucy, who said that a lack of money has forced him to teach at different schools within the district. He believes Dr. Townsel might be the perfect man for the job, but he must see action in his plan. 'I just want to know that he is committed to the city,' Soucy said. 'If he's committed to the city, then I'll be 100%. I'll be extremely hopeful and that little doubt that's in me can go away.' A native of Detroit, Michigan, Dr. Townsel was previously the school superintendent in Calvert County, Maryland, where he helped to improve the school district's ranking for fourth-best in the state. He was approved unanimously by the Hartford Board of Education after a nationwide search that began in the spring. RELATED: Hartford Public Schools announces new superintendent Dr. Townsel's first school year as superintendent will officially kick off on Tuesday, Aug. 26, when all Hartford students are back in session. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
