'Free Speech Doesn't Extend...': Allahabad HC Slams Rahul Gandhi Over Remarks On Army
Rejecting Gandhi's plea, Justice Vidyarthi said the right to free speech does not include the freedom to make statements which are defamatory to the Indian Army
The Allahabad High Court on Wednesday made a strong observation against Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi for his alleged derogatory remarks against the Indian Army.
A single-judge bench of Justice Subhash Vidyarthi was hearing a plea filed by the Congress leader against a summoning order issued by a Lucknow court in connection with his alleged derogatory remarks against the Indian Army during the Bharat Jodo Yatra in 2022.
Rejecting Gandhi's plea, Justice Vidyarthi said the right to free speech does not include the freedom to make statements which are defamatory to any person or defamatory to the Indian Army, the Bar & Bench reported.
During the hearing on Thursday, the Allahabad High Court dismissed Rahul Gandhi's petition. However, the detailed order was released on Wednesday.
Gandhi had challenged the summoning order and the complaint arguing that it was motivated and lodged in a mala fide manner.
During the Bharat Jodo Yatra on December 16, 2022, Gandhi said 'Chinese soldiers are beating up Indian Army personnel in Arunachal Pradesh."
'People will ask about Bharat Jodo Yatra, here and there, Ashok Gahlot and Sachin Pilot
and whatnot. But they will not ask a single question about China capturing 2000 square kilometers of Indian territory, killing 20 Indian soldiers and thrashing our soldiers in Arunachal Pradesh," he had said.
In his plea filed in a court in Lucknow, complainant Udai Shanker Srivastava alleged that during the December 2022 Yatra, Gandhi made several derogatory remarks about the Indian Army in the context of the conflict with Chinese soldiers. The lower court then summoned Gandhi as an accused for facing trial.
Gandhi's advocate Pranshu Agarwal had argued that the allegations appeared to be fabricated just by reading the complaint. It was also argued that Gandhi is not a resident of Lucknow, so before summoning him on this complaint, the lower court should have investigated the veracity of the allegations and he should have been summoned only if the allegations were prima facie found to be fit for trial.
(With PTI inputs)
First Published:
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
11 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Southeast Asia Needs to Step Up Defense Spending
'Trust me, it's paradise.' That's how Leonardo DiCaprio's character describes Southeast Asia in the 2000 cult classic 'The Beach.' The region is a wonderland of white-sand beaches, tropical landscapes, vibrant cities and delicious street food. But there's trouble in paradise. China is menacing Southeast Asia, making the region dangerous for its inhabitants. China's Xi Jinping sees the area—home to 700 million people across 11 countries—as his backyard, belonging in the 'Sinosphere' of influence. He has been flexing his muscles to make this clear. In April, Chinese coast guard officials took control of Sandy Cay, a disputed reef in the South China Sea claimed by the Philippines. This was the latest in a series of similar seizures. For more than a decade, Mr. Xi has been asserting territorial claims over reefs and islands across Southeast Asian waters. His goal is to turn them into outposts of Chinese military power. Take the Paracel Islands off the coast of Vietnam, on which China has built 20 outposts, complete with fighter jets, cruise missiles and radar systems. Or take the Spratly Islands west of the Philippines, where China has seven outposts. Nuclear-capable bombers have reportedly been spotted flying overhead. China also puts pressure on Southeast Asia in subtler ways. It has waged disinformation campaigns across the region, pushing pro-Beijing narratives and seeking to sway elections. The Philippines in particular has been called a 'petri dish' for Chinese disinformation. Southeast Asian nations aren't doing much to protect themselves from China. With the exception of Singapore, they invest little in defense. Indonesia, the world's fourth most populous country with 280 million people, spends only 0.7% of its gross domestic product on defense. Malaysia spends 0.9%. Vietnam and the Philippines, which bear the brunt of Chinese aggression, muster only 1.7% and 1.4% respectively. By contrast, North Atlantic Treaty Organization member states recently pledged to cough up 5% of GDP on defense. That includes countries such as Greece and Albania. Southeast Asian countries have no excuse not to follow suit. They need to spend more on defense—and soon. Southeast Asian nations must show China that they aren't pushovers. What if the Chinese navy tomorrow tried to disrupt shipping routes in the Strait of Malacca, a narrow waterway wedged between Indonesia and Malaysia through which some 30% of annual global trade passes? Asian nations couldn't count on the U.S. to intervene if China disrupted this trade route or otherwise overstretched its hand in the region. Neither Indonesia nor Malaysia would be able to defend against Chinese predations. If Southeast Asian countries had bigger military budgets, however, it would establish deterrence and make Mr. Xi second-guess his plans. Former Singaporean Defense Minister Ng Eng Hen recently pointed out that the new world order is 'based on size and influence, based on power.' The only way to safeguard sovereignty in such a world is to become mighty. 'Strong fences, and I would add, defenses, make good neighbors,' said Mr. Ng. Spending on defense would also boost Southeast Asian economies. Some nations in the region—including Vietnam, Malaysia, Indonesia and the Philippines—lack a strong domestic economic foundation, are especially vulnerable to President Trump's tariffs, and rely heavily on exports and foreign investment. Higher military spending would be a game changer for such economies. As has been the case with other countries, building a strong security sector would drive innovation and entrepreneurship. Before long, the benefits would spill over into the wider economy. As Palantir CEO Alex Karp argues in 'The Technological Republic' (2025), Silicon Valley's early growth was largely fueled by investments from the U.S. military. A bigger defense sector in Southeast Asia would also be a boon for the U.S. American firms could benefit from lucrative arms contracts. The U.S. government could strengthen alliances in a critical region, meaning more leverage over China. And American tourists could continue to visit this paradise for decades. Mr. Scheers is a defense analyst from Malaysia. Mr. Zenou is a historian specializing in the Cold War.
The Hindu
11 minutes ago
- The Hindu
For urban lung space
It is refreshing to learn from time to time that civic bodies across cities are taking steps to nurture urban parks by renovating existing spaces, especially those affected by metro and other projects, and developing new ones. Parks, which are compact green spaces, have been consistently playing a vital role in societies from time immemorial. During the different periods of Indian history, groves and gardens were set apart by rulers for public enjoyment. Mark Antony successfully whipped up the emotions of the Roman mob soon after the assassination of Julius Caesar when he announced dramatically that Caesar had 'left you all his walks, his private arbours and new-planted orchards on this side of Tiber'. However, the concept of public parks in Indian urban areas, as we know it, was introduced only during the colonial period on the lines of parks in the West. The People's Park (1859-61), for example, was one of the oldest parks established in Chennai. Considered the 'lungs' of a city, parks are indispensable in metropolitan areas. Peace park Talking of the status of a typical public park today, it is disappointing that its sparse vegetation fails to invest the city with nostalgic rural charm. Though one must not expect placid calm in public parks situated amid the din and bustle of a city, a fairly peaceful place is necessary for citizens. The scene in a park varies with the hours of the day. In the mornings, one can see the superannuated gentility taking the morning constitutional. A few people trudge stertorously around the park as if it is a ritual. Parks become very noisy in the evenings with children playing all around. The balloon vendor produces the usual irritable noise to attract them. Vendors selling groundnuts and ice cream ply a brisk trade. Soon the place gets littered with fruit rinds and bits of paper. Most of the parks have only a minimum supervision by a part-time guard. Lack of cleanliness is a common issue. The growth of grass goes unchecked giving rise to mosquito menace. As the night falls, everything is quiet again in the parks. Early in the morning, one finds some men who have chosen the park for their nocturnal sojourn, unwillingly rising from the cement benches, cursing the sun that disturbed their night-long slumber. Winding down For the common person who does not have the advantage of a beach near his home, a park is the only place where he hopes to find relaxation and respite. In the country as a whole, there is a significant shortage of public parks and green spaces due to rapid urbanisation. It is important to regulate encroachment on lands earmarked for parks and also ensure that parks are evenly distributed over a city. Regular maintenance of public parks will doubtless go a long way in contributing to public health and environmental well-being. Local administrations must allocate adequate funds in their annual budgets for this purpose. They should remember that a park is not a luxury, but a necessity. On the lighter side, I recall an incident related to a park of my school days. My classmate Mani used to be marked absent for a number of days. When he had lost his term days, his class teacher referred the matter to his parents. They were told that the boy was regularly leaving for the school with his books and tiffin box and returning home in the evening. On investigation, it transpired that the boy spent the school hours playing hide and seek with street children in the park adjacent to our school. He used to have his lunch and his siesta under the umbrageous banyan trees in the park and leave for home on hearing the school bell. The parents acted quickly to correct the boy's behaviour. His mother accompanied him to the school, waited for the whole day in the park and ensured that the boy attended the classes. When I met Mani after a long time, I enquired about his profession. 'I graduated with a degree in botany, and I am now the supervisor of public gardens and parks in the city,' he said proudly. ramaraon2014@
Time of India
25 minutes ago
- Time of India
Protests in Jalgaon after statue desecration
Nashik: Residents of a Jalgaon village, within Pahur police station's jurisdiction, took to the streets on Aug 15 after a statue of a prominent Indian politician was found desecrated in the market area at 7.30 am on Friday. Protests were also staged by a political party in front of the Jalgaon district collector's office, demanding strict action against those involved in the desecration. Additional SP Kavita Nerkar said, acting on a tip-off, a 50-year-old man from the same village where the incident took place was arrested by the Pahur police and charged under sections 298 (injuring or defiling a place of worship), 299 (deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings), and 196 (promoting enmity and hatred between different groups based on religion, race), among other sections of the BNS. Police officers said the suspect was produced before a court on Friday, which remanded him to three-day police custody. The police are investigating whether more people were involved in the act. The incident came to light at 7.30 am on Friday. Soon after the news spread, people in the village went to the police station and demanded strict action. As the situation became tense, the police deployed a strong bandobast in the village to avoid any untoward incidents. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 1 Reason to Read The 5 Books American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends For Turning Your Life... Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo The protestors also demanded that CCTV cameras be installed. The Jalgaon police, under the guidance of SP Maheswar Reddy, appealed to the people to maintain peace and refrain from making any posts on social media. Protestors on Saturday morning emphasised the need for strict action against the suspects involved and demanded CCTV cameras near the statues of all national figures to prevent such incidents in the future. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
