logo
'Feed them at home?' That one line has dog lovers fuming and why

'Feed them at home?' That one line has dog lovers fuming and why

India Today21-07-2025
A simple question - "Why don't you feed them at home?" - posed by the Supreme Court during a recent hearing has reignited an already simmering debate: Should stray dogs be fed in public spaces, or does this practice create more chaos than compassion?For dog lovers and feeders, the remark stings. While this was just an observation and not a ruling, many fear that such statements coming from the country's highest court could further deepen the existing fault lines between the animal lovers and those who perceive the strays as a menace.Feeding isn't the problem. The system isadvertisementHarshitha Reddy, organiser of PETEX India, says the real issue is not people feeding dogs, but the systemic failure in neutering and vaccinating them. 'There's a widespread misunderstanding that feeding strays leads to their population growing. That's just not true. What's actually fuelling the increase is the lack of active spaying and neutering by civic bodies,' she says.
She points out that even in cities like Bengaluru, civic authorities have gone so far as to allocate budgets, Rs 2.88 crore in this case, for feeding strays, recognising the need for compassion alongside control.So why does feeding strays continue to be such a flashpoint?'Because for someone who's not familiar with dog behaviour, it's easy to be swayed by fear,' Reddy says. 'One attack video can override the dozens of peaceful interactions that go unnoticed.'She adds that the media and civic authorities both have a role in spreading awareness about what to do, what not to do, and why sterilisation is key. 'This isn't just an animal issue. It's a civic issue. NGOs are willing to help, but they need consistent support. The load can't be carried by animal lovers alone.'A remark, a ripple effectMeet Ashar, legal advisor and director of Cruelty Response at PETA India, stresses that the Supreme Court's recent 'feed them at home' statement wasn't part of any binding judgment. 'It was an oral remark, not a direction, not an order,' he clarifies.He worries, however, about the unintended impact. 'Even an offhand comment can embolden those who are already hostile towards animals. It gives them a sense of validation, 'See, even the Supreme Court said it.' That's dangerous.'But Ashar is also hopeful. 'The same Supreme Court has, on record, protected the rights of feeders. In 2022, it stayed a Bombay High Court order that penalised public feeding, clearly stating that adoption doesn't mean strays must be taken home. Feeding them in designated spots is the settled position.'He points to amendments made in the Animal Birth Control Rules, 2023, which inserted Rule 20, officially recognising the role of feeders in helping sterilise and vaccinate dogs. 'Feeding helps humanise the dogs. Only when they're friendly can they be safely caught, neutered, and vaccinated. That's how we control population and keep rabies in check.'Beyond dog vs humanAt the heart of the issue lies a deeper question: Are we framing the debate fairly?After speaking to numerous people who have a fear of dogs, their anxiety often stems from just one thing: they may bite us, harm us, or even maul us.Every time there's a video of a dog mauling a man or child, or worse, killing someone, the debate reignites: Do these strays even deserve a place in society?And to be honest, their concerns are, to some extent, valid.But what we often forget to ask is whether the behaviour was a repercussion—was it triggered by something the victim did, or perhaps rooted in past trauma? Because, believe it or not, animals have their fair share of trauma too.'Every time there's an attack, we speak about dangerous dogs. But we rarely talk about how dogs are treated, abused, run over, left to starve,' Reddy points out. 'There's a double standard there.'advertisementAshar echoes that sentiment. 'Imagine going hungry, being kicked, and then being expected to stay friendly. No living being reacts well to mistreatment.'Both of them agree that solving this issue requires collective effort. Not just dog lovers. Not just haters. But civic bodies, RWAs, NGOs, the media, and most importantly, the public.What next?On July 23, when the matter is taken up again in court, the petitioner's lawyer will have the opportunity to present the other side of the story. A chance to shift the conversation from "Who's feeding whom?" to "How can we manage this humanely and effectively?"Because at the end of the day, this isn't about dogs vs humans. It's about coexistence, and the kind of society we want to build.- EndsTrending Reel
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Union min Pradhan lays foundation of infra projects in CU Punjab
Union min Pradhan lays foundation of infra projects in CU Punjab

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Union min Pradhan lays foundation of infra projects in CU Punjab

Bathinda: Union minister of education on Tuesday virtually laid the foundation stone of infrastructure projects worth Rs 200.99 crore at the Central University of Punjab (CU Punjab), Bathinda. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The ceremony was part of a nationwide initiative to launch infrastructure projects at centrally funded higher education institutions under the ministry of education. During the day, the minister virtually laid the foundation stone for the academic block, a 600-seater boys' hostel, a 400-seater girls' hostel, a 100-seater international students' hostel, and the vice-chancellor's residence. Several of these buildings are designed in compliance with GRIHA-IV norms, incorporating green, energy-efficient, and sustainable features such as sensor-based lighting, solar energy systems, aseismic structures, zero-waste water systems, and full accessibility for differently-abled persons. Pradhan lauded the proactive role of higher education institutions in implementing NEP 2020, particularly in advancing multidisciplinary education, digital inclusion, skill development, and inclusive learning. He highlighted the notable improvements in rural learning outcomes through initiatives like the NIPUN Bharat Mission and emphasised that this progress is the result of collective efforts by educators, students, institutions, and state govts. Vice-chancellor Prof Raghavendra P Tiwari emphasised that these developments would propel CU Punjab towards becoming a world-class institution with state-of-the-art facilities for teaching, research, and student well-being. MSID: 122975566 413 |

Areas near Hubballi airport lack drinking water for 20 years
Areas near Hubballi airport lack drinking water for 20 years

Time of India

time3 hours ago

  • Time of India

Areas near Hubballi airport lack drinking water for 20 years

Hubballi: Jagadish Nagar and Ram Nagar, located next to Hubballi Airport in Ward No. 32, continue to suffer from a lack of drinking water supply for the past 15-20 years. While most HDMC wards received 24x7 water supply or have ongoing work, these two areas remain excluded. Despite repeated appeals by residents for pipeline connections, there is no response from authorities. Locals expressed frustration over being left out of essential urban infrastructure. According to a source, these areas are located at HDMC Ward No. 32. A total of 612 houses were built here under the Ashraya scheme. However, due to lack of amenities, many of the owners locked their houses and are living elsewhere. 120 poor families are living here because they cannot afford to shift to another area. Rajeshwari Sutar, a resident of Ashraya Yojane, said that in recent years, villages have also been improving. Concrete roads, piped water supply to every house, street lights, sanitation, and other basic amenities are seen in villages. She said that every year during the rainy season, it was impossible to even walk on roads here. "If the roads here are also asphalted or concreted, it will facilitate commuters. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like See the AI App Making Headlines Across the UK — Book Your Spot Kapital Wolf Undo There are no medical facilities and Asha workers are not visiting. Govts that spend hundreds of crores of rupees to upgrade the airport to international standards have no will to provide basic facilities like drinking water," she said. Shankarappa Harijan, corporator of HDMC Ward No. 32, said he requested HDMC seeking 24x7 drinking water supply. The drinking water is being supplied from Neerasagar to around 13 to 15 wards. Till Tarihal industries area, the pipeline was installed. Now the water is supplied from the tanker once a week, he said. Shivakumar Gokavi, Ashraya committee member, said that around Rs 10 crore grant was announced in the budget to provide basic amenities. The grant should be provided soon, he urged. Manjunath Daivajna, assistant executive engineer, KUIDFC, said that continuously the drinking water is being supplied through a tanker as per request. The 24x7 drinking water project is not included. In the second phase, some areas will be included for 24x7 drinking water, he said.

On Camera, Elephant Chases Workers Near Coffee Estate In Karnataka
On Camera, Elephant Chases Workers Near Coffee Estate In Karnataka

NDTV

time4 hours ago

  • NDTV

On Camera, Elephant Chases Workers Near Coffee Estate In Karnataka

Over 15 estate workers narrowly escaped a wild elephant that charged at them near a coffee estate in Pollibetta, Kodagu (Coorg), on Monday morning. The incident was caught on camera. The footage, dated July 28, shows a group of workers breaking into a frantic run. Moments later, an elephant is seen charging down the same road. The workers manage to flee into a gated compound just in time, with the elephant following closely behind. The elephant approached the compound gate, appearing to push it open. But it stopped, turned around, and disappeared into the surrounding bushes. Though no injuries were reported, the close call has left estate workers too fearful to return. Many have stayed away since the incident and are demanding swift action from authorities to ensure their safety. Forest officials have announced plans to conduct a drive on Wednesday to steer the elephant back into its natural habitat. Kodagu, known for its dense forests and coffee plantations, has witnessed a rise in human-elephant conflicts in recent years due to habitat loss and shrinking corridors for wildlife movement. Located in the Western Ghats, these lands once supported elephant corridors, but over the past two decades, forest cover has declined by about 18 per cent, with nearly 46 per cent lost in dry deciduous areas, forcing elephants into nearby human-dominated zones. At least 44 people have died in wild elephant attacks in Kodagu between 2019 and 2024, reported The Kodagu Express. Hotspots include Madikeri taluk, the Nagarahole Tiger Reserve periphery, and Virajpet. With around 2,000 elephants living in Kodagu (nearly a third of Karnataka's entire elephant population), encounters have become more frequent and intense. To address the crisis, the Karnataka government has sanctioned Rs 40 crore for immediate mitigation. Measures include trenching, railway barricades, solar fencing, and elephant-proof trenches in high-risk areas like Virajpet. A major component of this plan is the proposed relocation of 185 conflict-prone elephants, especially from southern Kodagu and the Kutta border zone. The state is also investing in science-driven solutions. A Rs 4.7 crore partnership between the Forest Department and the Indian Institute of Science (IISc) aims to study elephant behaviour, track movements via satellite, and develop predictive models to prevent future conflict. The five-year study will also focus on mapping historical migration corridors and understanding the health and stress levels of these elephants.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store