
'Feed them at home?' That one line has dog lovers fuming and why
She points out that even in cities like Bengaluru, civic authorities have gone so far as to allocate budgets, Rs 2.88 crore in this case, for feeding strays, recognising the need for compassion alongside control.So why does feeding strays continue to be such a flashpoint?'Because for someone who's not familiar with dog behaviour, it's easy to be swayed by fear,' Reddy says. 'One attack video can override the dozens of peaceful interactions that go unnoticed.'She adds that the media and civic authorities both have a role in spreading awareness about what to do, what not to do, and why sterilisation is key. 'This isn't just an animal issue. It's a civic issue. NGOs are willing to help, but they need consistent support. The load can't be carried by animal lovers alone.'A remark, a ripple effectMeet Ashar, legal advisor and director of Cruelty Response at PETA India, stresses that the Supreme Court's recent 'feed them at home' statement wasn't part of any binding judgment. 'It was an oral remark, not a direction, not an order,' he clarifies.He worries, however, about the unintended impact. 'Even an offhand comment can embolden those who are already hostile towards animals. It gives them a sense of validation, 'See, even the Supreme Court said it.' That's dangerous.'But Ashar is also hopeful. 'The same Supreme Court has, on record, protected the rights of feeders. In 2022, it stayed a Bombay High Court order that penalised public feeding, clearly stating that adoption doesn't mean strays must be taken home. Feeding them in designated spots is the settled position.'He points to amendments made in the Animal Birth Control Rules, 2023, which inserted Rule 20, officially recognising the role of feeders in helping sterilise and vaccinate dogs. 'Feeding helps humanise the dogs. Only when they're friendly can they be safely caught, neutered, and vaccinated. That's how we control population and keep rabies in check.'Beyond dog vs humanAt the heart of the issue lies a deeper question: Are we framing the debate fairly?After speaking to numerous people who have a fear of dogs, their anxiety often stems from just one thing: they may bite us, harm us, or even maul us.Every time there's a video of a dog mauling a man or child, or worse, killing someone, the debate reignites: Do these strays even deserve a place in society?And to be honest, their concerns are, to some extent, valid.But what we often forget to ask is whether the behaviour was a repercussion—was it triggered by something the victim did, or perhaps rooted in past trauma? Because, believe it or not, animals have their fair share of trauma too.'Every time there's an attack, we speak about dangerous dogs. But we rarely talk about how dogs are treated, abused, run over, left to starve,' Reddy points out. 'There's a double standard there.'advertisementAshar echoes that sentiment. 'Imagine going hungry, being kicked, and then being expected to stay friendly. No living being reacts well to mistreatment.'Both of them agree that solving this issue requires collective effort. Not just dog lovers. Not just haters. But civic bodies, RWAs, NGOs, the media, and most importantly, the public.What next?On July 23, when the matter is taken up again in court, the petitioner's lawyer will have the opportunity to present the other side of the story. A chance to shift the conversation from "Who's feeding whom?" to "How can we manage this humanely and effectively?"Because at the end of the day, this isn't about dogs vs humans. It's about coexistence, and the kind of society we want to build.- EndsTrending Reel

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


News18
40 minutes ago
- News18
‘God, Should've Taken Me': Mother's Anguish After Losing Both Kids In Rajasthan School Collapse
Last Updated: A school collapse in Jhalawar, Rajasthan killed seven children, including siblings Meena and Kanha. Families received the bodies Saturday. Five staff were suspended. The grief-stricken mother of the two children who died in the school building collapse in Rajasthan's Jhalawar wished that God had taken her life instead of her kids. In just a day, the world of many families was turned upside down after seven children lost their lives in the Jhalawar school building collapse on Friday. For this mother, the tragedy has been especially devastating, having lost both her son and daughter in the incident, leaving her feeling like she's 'lost everything." The youngest of those who died was only six years old. 'I've lost everything. I had only two children, a boy and a girl, and both are gone. My home is empty. There's no one left to play in the courtyard. I wish God had taken me instead and spared my children," news agency PTI quoted her as saying. The deceased children were identified as 12-year-olds Payal, Priyanka, Kundan and Kartik, along with eight-year-old Harish. The brother and sister duo were 12-year-old Meena and her brother, six-year-old Kanha, who was the youngest kid to be killed in the tragedy. On Saturday morning, the bodies of the seven children were handed to their families outside SRG Hospital and Medical College in Jhalawar, where anguished wails from grieving mothers filled the air, evoking deep sorrow in all who witnessed the scene. Some parents clung desperately to their children's lifeless bodies, while others sat in stunned silence, struggling to process the loss. The children were cremated soon after, with five bodies being laid to rest together and two receiving individual funeral pyres. The tragic school building collapse in Rajasthan's Jhalawar district, which killed seven children and injured another 28, has raised serious questions about the condition of rural school infrastructure in the state and the systemic neglect that turned a place of learning into a site of mourning. A grieving mother who lost her child in the tragedy questioned the responsibility of the teachers who were present at the school when the incident occurred. 'The teachers went outside, leaving the children behind. What were they doing outside?" she charged. Five school staff members were suspended, and a high-level investigation was launched into the incident. Rajasthan's School Education Minister, Madan Dilawar, announced a Rs 10 lakh compensation for the families of the children who lost their lives. Jhalawar District Collector Ajay Singh consoled the grieving families on Saturday. Later, talking to reporters, he said appropriate action would be taken against those guilty. 'Five school staffers have been suspended, and a probe committee has been constituted. If needed, an FIR will be registered. If suspension has to turn to expulsion, that will be done," Hindustan Times quoted Singh as saying. The collector stated that clear guidelines are in place for repairing the school building, and the district administration is taking steps to prevent such incidents from happening in the future. 'District education officials have been directed not to let students enter schools if the condition of the building is not good," Singh said, adding that if they had received any complaint, they would have repaired the building, and this tragedy might have been prevented 'If we had received any complaint, we would have got the building repaired and the incident could have been averted," he said. view comments Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


Indian Express
41 minutes ago
- Indian Express
IP University Admission: Apply for environment management programmes by July 30
The Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University (GGSIPU) Delhi is inviting applications for admission to its three environment management programmes for the academic session 2025-26. The programmes include MSc (Environment Management), MSc (Applied Geoinformatics) and BSc (Environment Management). Interested candidates can check the details and apply on at the university websites – and Eligible candidates can apply online based on the Common University Entrance Test (CUET) scores by July 30. The university has clarified that admissions will be made based on CUET scores after the merit list of national-level tests or university-conducted entrance exams for affiliated programmes is exhausted. Candidates applying through CUET scores need to pay a combined application and counseling fee of Rs 2,500. Those already admitted through national-level tests or university-conducted entrance exams are not eligible to apply through CUET scores. The programmes are offered at the University School of Environment Management, located in the Dwarka campus. The two postgraduate programmes have 30 seats each, and the undergraduate programme has 60 seats. According to Prof. Varun Joshi, Dean of the school, the demand for these programmes is increasing globally, given the emphasis on environment management and the application of latest technologies. This year, GGSIPU has introduced an orphan children quota, in addition to the existing Single Girl Child quota. The Single Girl Child Quota was introduced last year. The quota will be effective from the academic session 2025-26. Under the new quota, one additional seat will be reserved in each university schools and programmes, and the selected students will be eligible for a 100 per cent fee waiver under the university's EWS scheme. IPU has launched an admission chatbot service. The admission chatbot service seeks to provide instant answers to queries related to admissions in various programmes for the new session. The link to the new service is available on the University's main website — Using this service, prospective applicants can get immediate answers to their queries related to admissions in various programmes for the new session, a statement issued by the university said.


Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Jhalawar school collapse shatters parents' worlds; Grieving mother cries, 'Wish God had taken me instead'
A heartbreaking silence has fallen over a small house in Rajasthan's Jhalawar district, a house where two siblings once played, laughed, and dreamed. Now, only grief remains. The brother and sister were among seven children who died when a government school building in Piplod village collapsed on Friday morning. The collapse has not only shattered several families, but also cast a harsh spotlight on the crumbling state of school infrastructure in rural Rajasthan. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Artificial Intelligence Data Science others MCA Operations Management Technology Management CXO PGDM Others Leadership healthcare Degree Product Management Data Science MBA Healthcare Public Policy Data Analytics Cybersecurity Digital Marketing Design Thinking Finance Project Management Skills you'll gain: Duration: 7 Months S P Jain Institute of Management and Research CERT-SPJIMR Exec Cert Prog in AI for Biz India Starts on undefined Get Details As per a PTI report, the mother of the siblings, speaking through tears, said, 'I had only two children, a boy and a girl. Now both are gone. My house is empty. There's no one left to play in the courtyard. I wish God had taken me instead.' by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Blood cancer is taking our curious baby away from us! Donate For Health Donate Now Undo Her anguish is just one of many heartbreaking stories that have emerged from the tragedy. On Saturday morning, the air outside the mortuary at SRG Hospital was filled with cries of grieving parents. Some held the bodies of their children, wrapped in white sheets, refusing to let go. Others sat silently, still unable to grasp the suddenness of their loss. Live Events In a powerful gesture of shared grief, five of the children were cremated together on a single pyre. The remaining two were laid to rest separately. A mother who lost her child questioned the school's staff: 'Why were the teachers outside? Why did they leave the children alone?' Her words reflected the anger and confusion that many parents now feel. The children who lost their lives have been identified as Payal (12), Priyanka (12), Kundan (12), Harish (8), Kartik, and siblings Meena (12) and Kanha (6). Most were students of Classes 6 and 7. The youngest was just six years old. The state government has taken some immediate steps. Five school staff members have been suspended, and a high-level probe has been ordered. Rajasthan's School Education Minister also announced a compensation of Rs 10 lakh for the families of each child who died. District Collector Ajay Singh visited the families and assured them of full support. Speaking to reporters, he said, 'If needed, an FIR will be filed. The suspension of staff could lead to full dismissal. We are not taking this lightly.' Singh added that the administration would ensure a new school building is constructed and that financial assistance would reach families within 10 days. However, serious concerns remain. Singh admitted that no prior warning or complaint was received about the unsafe condition of the school building. 'Had we known, we would have repaired it. This tragedy could have been avoided,' he said. Reacting to a viral video showing rushed patchwork on the road outside SRG Hospital ahead of the minister's visit, Singh said he was not aware of it but would look into it. The collapse happened just as the children had gathered for morning prayers. Over 35 students were buried under the debris. Locals and school staff scrambled to rescue them. In total, 28 children were injured. The scene was one of chaos and heartbreak. Concrete slabs, stones and dust covered the ground as anxious parents, teachers and villagers dug through the rubble. The sorrow quickly turned into anger. Protests broke out at Guradi Circle and outside SRG Hospital. Locals blocked roads and demanded answers. Congress leader Naresh Meena joined the protest briefly before being detained by police. Tensions escalated when protestors clashed with police. Stones were thrown, and a policeman was injured. Authorities used mild force to disperse the crowd. Inputs from PTI