Peter Dutton's allies speak out on election loss and polling disaster
You can now listen to The Australian's articles.
Peter Dutton's Liberal campaign was so shocked by its historic defeat that the party president demanded the federal director explain its fatally flawed polling in the middle of their own election party, while one of Mr Dutton's top allies kept thousands in the bank after the then-opposition leader told him his seat was safe.
As Sussan Ley works over the weekend to patch up a splintered Coalition and find a strategy to deal with a Labor win so large it could guarantee Anthony Albanese two more terms in office, the Liberal Party has finally laid bare the mistakes that led Mr Dutton to lose his own seat and more than a dozen of his colleagues' on May 3.
Defeated Liberal National Party opposition assistant minister Luke Howarth has revealed Mr Dutton reassured him his outer-Brisbane seat of Petrie was safe, before asking for part of his campaign war chest to be spent trying to win a Labor-held longshot seat and defend Coalition strongholds from the threat of Climate 200-backed Teal candidates. Mr Howarth has also conceded he regrets putting his longtime friend Mr Dutton's face on joint billboards and how-to-vote cards, after he underestimated the then leader's unpopularity in their adjoining electorates.
Another senior Liberal source said the internal polling by Freshwater Strategy was 'way out' and had given Mr Dutton's team, strategists and MPs flawed information throughout the campaign.
'The polling was a huge problem … it was way out,' the senior Liberal told The Australian.
'If we'd have known (the truth) we would have changed course overnight.'
The senior Liberal source also criticised the strength of negative ads produced by Coalition campaign headquarters and director Andrew Hirst, and suggested it was not official opposition policy when Senator Jane Hume announced Canberra-based public servants would be forced to work full-time from the office.
Senator Hume's office rejected that claim and said her speech and the policy announcement had been put through the proper channels, including Mr Dutton's office.
Peter Dutton, centre, Angus Taylor, left, and Jane Hume at Parliament House before the election. Picture: Martin Ollman / NewsWire
But the senior Liberal source said rather than kill Senator Hume's announcement straight away and stoke talk there was a policy split, it was decided it was a 'benign' issue.
According to sources who saw the final Freshwater tracking poll conducted on the Wednesday night before the election, the research showed a swing to the Liberals in some NSW and Victorian marginal seats of about 5 per cent.
Emboldened by that result, Mr Dutton told close allies and MPs, including Mr Howarth, that he could win 10 seats off Labor and force Anthony Albanese into minority government.
Liberal Party president John Olsen. Picture: Nikki Davis-Jones
Liberal Party federal director Andrew Hirst. Picture: Kym Smith
Liberal Party president John Olsen confirmed the flawed polling would be a major target of the 'full and transparent' review of the federal campaign.
On election night in the Liberal Party's campaign war room at Brisbane's the W Hotel, when it became obvious the Freshwater polling failed to predict the scale of Labor's victory, Mr Olsen challenged Coalition campaign director Andrew Hirst to explain what had gone wrong.
Mr Olsen denied the confrontation was 'heated' but said 'we certainly had a conversation on polling, you wouldn't have to be Einstein to work that out'.
Mr Howarth said Mr Dutton was let down by his own office, polling, poor policy development and an inability to counter Labor's devastating personal attacks.
Mr Dutton was reassured by Freshwater twice during the campaign that he was ahead in his own seat of Dickson, which he went on to lose after three-time Labor candidate Ali France secured a 7.76 per cent swing to her.
Mr Howarth said he did not poll his own seat of Petrie, partly because Labor had not announced a candidate until the eve of the campaign but mostly because he was reassured he was safe.
He said Mr Dutton told him to help in neighbouring Lilley, held by Labor Sport Minister Anika Wells, so he raised $1.7m and spent $634,000 in his own seat of Petrie, before tipping $350,000 into Lilley and $400,000 into other seats.
Mr Howarth has hundreds of thousands of dollars left in his campaign war chest but said he did not regret helping his colleagues.
Defeated Queensland LNP MP Bert van Manen. Picture: Jerad Williams
'But the whole polling was wrong … I don't think the leader or his office had any idea what was coming – clearly – because they didn't think he'd lose his own seat. They didn't think I'd lose my seat.'
Freshwater Strategy declined to comment and director Mike Turner is legally prevented from talking because he's still under contract with the party.
It is understood the company did not decide which seats to poll, and that the pollster believes its research consistently and increasingly showed that Labor was the favourite to form government.
Another defeated Queensland LNP MP, Bert van Manen, said there was no indication he would lose his seat of Forde, which he held on just over 4 per cent, but the working-from-home policy hurt his chances.
'Certainly I got no indication from anywhere that there were any risks (to my seat),' Mr van Manen said.
'It's an unusual situation for me because in every campaign I'm in the top five or 10 (marginal) seats in the country and nobody was discussing my seat or Luke (Howarth's) seat this time.'
'Not you guys (in the media), not pollsters, not Labor. From that perspective, it was strange that we got the result that we did. We need to have a good hard look at what went wrong.'
Mr van Manen said the Coalition's policy to cancel working from home arrangements for public servants – which was later reversed – and plans to cut 41,000 Canberra bureaucrats hurt him.
'One hundred per cent I had that feedback directly. Women at the polling booths were concerned … and there's a general view in Queensland … that given what happened during Campbell Newman's tenure, that still resonates when you're talking about public servants.'
Mr Newman's LNP government was defeated after just one term in power, following the sacking of about 14,000 state public servants.
Read related topics: Peter Dutton
Sarah Elks
Senior Reporter
Sarah Elks is a senior reporter for The Australian in its Brisbane bureau, focusing on investigations into politics, business and industry. Sarah has worked for the paper for 15 years, primarily in Brisbane, but also in Sydney, and in Cairns as north Queensland correspondent. She has covered election campaigns, high-profile murder trials, and natural disasters, and was named Queensland Journalist of the Year in 2016 for a series of exclusive stories exposing the failure of Clive Palmer's Queensland Nickel business. Sarah has been nominated for four Walkley awards. Got a tip? elkss@theaustralian.com.au; GPO Box 2145 Brisbane QLD 4001
@sarahelks
Sarah Elks
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
a minute ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Albanese's Palestine decision achieves nothing but division
The announcement by Hamas founder Hassan Yousef that the organisation applauds Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's recognition of a Palestinian state is, not surprisingly, sending shock waves through the Jewish community (' Anger at PM after praise from Hamas ', August 14). All it is likely to achieve is to divide Australians. The recognition of Palestine may well succeed in the UN General Assembly, which has a large Arab block, but it will be vetoed in the Security Council by the United States, as the US Ambassador to the UN has already indicated her government's opposition. So what will it achieve? A boost in political support for governments in Europe, and perhaps Australia, which have Arab minorities in key parliamentary seats – but the war in the Middle East will continue. Vivienne Parsons, Thornleigh Hassan Yousef is currently residing in an Israeli prison. He has applauded Australia's decision to recognise Palestine. Of course, any sensible, intelligent person or media could see that Hamas is manipulating our government's decision, just as we recognise that the Liberals and Nationals manipulate the facts about the economy, renewables, climate change, cost of living – the list is endless. But don't worry, Opposition Leader Sussan Ley is going to 'unrecognise' Palestinian recognition when she's in government, maybe in about 10 years' time – if they're lucky. John Nelson, Mudgee So Australia has emboldened Hamas. Anything bad Hamas now does will be the Australian government's fault. Do the people who say these things hear themselves? Will the Liberal Party ever stand for anything other than dividing Australia over every contentious issue? The Labor government wants a free and secure Israel and a free and secure Palestine. That's not what Hamas wants. We are not on their side. I am waiting to hear Sussan Ley support the actions of the IDF in Gaza. Let's hear it Sussan, loud and clear. Garry Feeney, Kingsgrove I don't care what terrorist group Hamas has to say unless it is to tell us when they are releasing hostages, recognising the state of Israel, laying down their arms, denouncing terrorism and supporting a democratic state of Palestine – in which they will have and take no part. As for Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu, an alleged war criminal, I am willing to pay his airfare to The Hague. No doubt, both of these developments would establish peace. Neil Kenzler, Haberfield Sussan Ley's statement that Anthony Albanese is 'out of his depth' cannot be left unchallenged. It displays an appalling ignorance of diplomacy. Recognising a Palestine state is vital for peace in the Middle East. The move should have been endorsed by her on a non-partisan basis. In this era of instant communications, world leaders would instantly have been aware of her remarks. They will now think that she is saying that Presidents Myriam Debono of Malta, Marcelo de Sousa of Portugal, Emmanuel Macron of France, and Prime Ministers Keir Starmer of the UK, Mark Carney of Canada, and Christopher Luxon of New Zealand, are also, like Albanese, 'out of their depth'. Being new to the job of leader, she may not be aware that you don't insult world leaders in public, especially those who are friends of Australia. This was an appalling gaffe and one hopes that a senior DFAT official immediately brought it to her attention. Perhaps another stint on the backbench would suit her better. Stephen Healion, Wang Wauk I can't take the federal opposition's outrage at Australia's plan to recognise Palestine seriously. Its biases are so blatant and outrageous. Their unquestioning support for Netanyahu and Israel's actions is an outrage. I can't recall any member of the federal opposition expressing outrage at the incursions by Israelis into the West Bank, or Netanyahu's threat to take over Gaza. Nor can I recall hearing any member of the opposition express outrage over the loss of so many innocent Palestinian lives at the hands of Israel. Jill Napier, Phegans Bay The flood of reports, commentary and letters prompted by the Albanese government's decision to recognise Palestine has sadly swept attention away from Israel's brazen assassination of Al Jazeera correspondent Anas al-Sharif, killing four other staffers in the process (' Israel kills Al Jazeera journalist and four colleagues ', August 12). Israel's claim that he was a Hamas operative has as much credibility as its claim there's no starvation in Gaza. The combination of Israel's refusal to allow foreign journalists into Gaza and its elimination of an estimated 186 local media personnel there should have been regular headline news. It's extraordinary that international and national media outlets have not been persistently highlighting this unconscionable attack on the freedom of the press. Failing this outcry, the only sensible approach one can take to Israel's version of events in Gaza is with a large pinch of salt. Tom Knowles, Parkville (Vic) Climate denial costs Perhaps the climate deniers and obstructors within the Liberal and National parties might sit up and take note, as AGL, Australia's largest power generator, announces its plan to invest billions of dollars in grid-scale batteries and hydropower to mitigate the impact of coal plant outages (' Top polluter looks to buy big batteries as fossil fuel costs rise ', August 14). Belief in climate change or not, AGL has seen its profits decrease due to the increasing costs of sourcing fossil fuels, and outages at unreliable coal-fired power plants. As experts have been telling us for decades, renewable energy sources are both cleaner and cheaper, and their cost keeps falling as the technology improves, while fossil fuel prices spiral upwards. Coupled with the unreliability of aged fossil fuel-fired power stations that are approaching decommissioning, the Coalition must accept that their climate war is lost and that decarbonisation and transition to renewables is the only sensible pathway, both economically and environmentally. The longer they obstruct and delay, the more it will cost us all. Alan Marel, North Curl Curl Time to dump AUKUS I wouldn't take any advice from John Bolton, a former national security adviser to Donald Trump (' Speak out about Chinese threat or risk AUKUS subs ', August 14). He was part of the Project for the New American Century, which promoted global leadership through military might. He actively promoted invading Iraq based on a thin tissue of lies, and although supportive of the Vietnam War, like Trump, he made sure that he didn't serve. People like him are not happy unless planning some sort of war, and China seems to be their latest target. They are happy to blatantly lie to get their preferred outcome. AUKUS will not make Australia safer, it will just paint a big target on us should the current batch of right-wing warmongers in the US get their way. Time to drop the whole thing, count our losses and develop unmanned craft suitable for defending Australia – at a fraction of the cost. Graeme Finn, Campsie Bolton and the US need to understand that any Australian support against China will be contingent on the US embodying the values of freedom and democracy. If they continue along their Trumpian path, this is unlikely to be the case. The communism thing is a furphy. China, Russia and US are fascist, regardless of how they choose to define themselves. Boris Feigin, Narwee Boomer bashers For the most part, I agree with Alexandra Smith's assessment of Gareth Ward and her acknowledgement of Kate Dezarnaulds' courage in speaking out against a renowned litigator (' Ward a rapist and bully but beloved by Boomers ', August 14). But in an age when bigotry and racism are rightfully called out and condemned, it seems that ageism, generalising and vilifying the Boomer generation gets a free pass. May I remind the Herald that the Boomer generation led the charge for social reform, fought and marched for feminist issues, fought and marched against racism and for equality, and protested against war. Our music was the music of protest and struggle for social change and equality for race and gender. We were inspired and we were active. Maybe that's the real reason for 'Boomer bashing'. It was a generation not only of hope, but of action for a better and fairer world. Alph Williams, Red Rock Climate change reality It is not difficult to picture the alleged confrontation centred around Wamberal beachfront erosion (' Police probe as beachfront erosion battle turns violent ', August 14). Homeowners, threatened by the inexorable consequences of global warming will, understandably, take measures in a most probably futile attempt to protect their properties. Beach users, seeing the seashore inevitably transitioning from sandy stretches to walls of concrete and rubble, will also be distressed. The accelerating rise in sea levels is an existential threat, not just to Pacific and Torres Strait islanders, but also to vast swathes of the Australian coastline. Unfortunately, governments at all levels can neither permit landowners the freedom to fortify their properties at the expense of their neighbours, nor can they, in view of vast anticipated future infrastructure costs, start contributing any significant funding to preserve private real estate. Climate change is a reality and is already demanding exceedingly difficult decisions. Roger Epps, Armidale Wamberal is just one of a number of beaches on the NSW coast that was identified by the NSW Water Research Laboratory as far back as the 1970s as in danger of major coastal erosion from entirely normal major east coast storm events – nothing to do with climate change – and because land development had been permitted on the foredunes, damage to private property was at some point inevitable. The only proper solution now is to remove all those dwellings and return the land to coastal open space in which the foredune can do what it has done for millennia – erode and rebuild and protect lands further inshore. Using public funds to build seawalls is a complete waste. It would be better used to buy out the owners. Peter Thornton, Killara As a long-time Central Coast resident, I have often walked on Wamberal beach and watched the sea progressively erode the stairs from those exclusive properties, and then the decks. The seas have been harsh. Nature always wins in the end. This council has the lowest per household income in the Greater Sydney region. Our roads are full of potholes from the massive rains. I know what I want my rates to be spent on. Greg Lewin, Tumbi Umbi Crowded house As a resident of the Hills District, I am also concerned at the number of new apartments, 6000 new dwellings up to 40 storeys, being built in the area (' It's a tsunami': Councils angry at plans to fast-track 70,000 homes', August 14). Most of the development is occurring close to Metro stations, which makes sense, until you realise it runs at capacity during peak hours. Standing room only from Norwest to Gadigal station. Current road infrastructure struggles to cope with morning and afternoon peaks, but it's not that different to rest of Sydney. My biggest concern is that none of this new development is being built as affordable housing. The current wait time for social housing in the Hills District and Blacktown is 10 years. There ought to be a requirement that each of these new developments has a percentage of units set aside for social housing, except that will never happen as local residents and developers will cry 'not in my backyard'. Tim Overland, Castle Hill Sidelining the local council and residents and handing all the power to a three-person committee to make a decision that potentially fundamentally alters the quality of life in a neighbourhood is profoundly undemocratic. There has to be a better way. Alan Morris, Eastlakes Transport tolls Your correspondent claims that 'it is far cheaper to fund the rail system than pour money into the road network' (Letters, August 14). Assuming that is true, the difference is that some roads can be funded by private enterprise as toll roads – no government billions needed. Motorists pay it back over decades. The same is not true of the rail network. The only privately funded rail link in NSW, the Airport Line, requires government subsidies for the non-airport stations, and the airport stations have the equivalent of a toll – a $17 access fee per trip. Brendan Jones, Annandale Gun safety I cannot help but question why an AFP officer was carrying a weapon with a round already in the chamber, and perhaps with the safety catch off (' Police gun fired in airport arrest ', August 14). That's just dangerous. To chamber a round required a deliberate action: both hands on the weapon to inject the bullet into the firing position. The fact that an AFP officer was carrying a ready-to-fire weapon raises serious concerns about AFP training standards and the individual's approach to basic firearm safety. Warren Bowden, Fairlight Falafel politics In the interests of neutrality and harmony it was reasonable for the Merivale establishment to ask customers to remove the keffiyeh (' Falafel eatery turned away diners wearing keffiyehs ', August 14) – provided they also asked customers to remove the kippah. Where will it end? Perhaps those wearing jewellery such as a cross pendant (crucifix) will be next. Janet Cook, Waverton Bad taste Memo to Hugh Marks, who cites Masterchef as his inspiration (' New ABC boss wants global hits from the broadcaster ', August 14). The 'premium' aspect of hopeful amateurs being browbeaten by self-centred prigs is cash. The ABC is a public broadcaster. Making money from broadcasting the anguish of brokenhearted aspirants is not your brief. Quality entertainment, without a mean streak, is. Andrew Cohen, Glebe Working week Although I have never been a union member, I can see where the unions are coming from in advocating a four-day week (' Unions to push for a four-day week', August 14). It might not be suitable for all jobs, but I have observed tradies who work well with a four-day week. They work four 10-hour shifts from Monday to Thursday, thus still working a 40-hour week. Productivity is high, with both clients and workers happy. Robyn Lewis, Raglan As a retiree, I have been considering how I can increase my productivity and reduce my working hours (' What's productivity and how could AI affect it?' August 14). Employing AI will not help, as I prefer to exercise my genuine intelligence rather than an artificial substitute. Here is my plan: more time in bed, thus reducing my working week; lunch out four times weekly instead of three; double my output of secretarial emails on strata issues; and write more letters to the Herald. John Flint, St Leonards
ABC News
a minute ago
- ABC News
Queensland chief health officer appointment scrapped for second time
The Queensland government says it wasn't "confident" a doctor was suitable to be the state's chief health officer, despite him being offered the position a second time. Dr Krispin Hajkowicz was appointed to the job in 2021 but resigned shortly after, citing "personal reasons". Sources have confirmed to the ABC that he was recently offered the role again following a lengthy recruitment process. It's understood that a corporate head shot was arranged and a media release regarding the appointment was drafted by Queensland Health. The offer was then rescinded. A spokesperson for Queensland Health said a campaign to recruit for the role was undertaken, "however, no appointment was made". "A renewed campaign to recruit a permanent Chief Health Officer was launched on Friday 8 August." The international recruitment campaign advertises the role as earning up to $431,000 per annum. In a statement, a government spokesperson said the job "is a very forward-facing leadership role". "The government is not confident that the stability and longevity Queenslanders expect in this role has yet been met and the recruitment process is ongoing." Dr Hajkowicz declined to comment on questions from the ABC. Queensland has been without a permanent CHO since December, after Dr John Gerrard stepped down after three years. Dr Hajkowicz's wife, Dr Sarah Martin, made a submission to parliament over the Victoria Park Stadium and planning legislation, before his job offer. It related to laws that exempt 2032 Brisbane Olympic and Paralympic Games infrastructure from major planning rules, to ensure projects aren't held up by potential legal challenges. In her submission, Dr Martin strongly opposed the legislation. "The Crisafulli government's plan to override the rights of the individual Queenslanders to make life easier for politicians and developers is right out of the Joh Bjelke-Petersen playbook. "Exempting this development from public scrutiny and removing the right of Queenslanders to protest via the courts is a very concerning proposition and makes the risk of corruption very likely." She went on to allege that the Bill proposed to remove "the right to protest this development in the courts" and was "out of the fascist playbook". The government said it was not aware of the submission during the recruitment process. Deputy opposition leader Cameron Dick said the government had "questions to answer" over the recruitment.. "I think this whole process stinks," he said. "This is so opaque, lacking in clarity, lacking in transparency, that every Queenslander should be deeply concerned about what the process was. "What has happened, and why has an eminently qualified medical specialist who ticked all the boxes been rubbed out by the LNP for a very important job, particularly as we go through one of the worst flu seasons in recent history?" Mr Dick said the opposition was considering further steps it could take regarding independent investigations into the matter.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
WA gun owners protest regulations as police minister warns of 'total firearm anarchy'
Frustrated WA gun owners have gathered in droves at Parliament House to support a crossbencher's motion to scrap controversial firearms regulations, but opposition from the Greens means it will not pass parliament. Legalise Cannabis MLC Brian Walker tried to use a disallowance motion to force the government to abandon the new laws, which came into effect in March and have been billed "the strictest in the country". But despite more than 1,000 people rallying outside Parliament this morning, the motion faces certain defeat since it has failed to win crucial support from the Greens, with leader Brad Pettitt saying the party could not support "the nuclear option" of scrapping it altogether. The regulations faced a backlash from gun owners and the WA Nationals, who have thrown their support behind the motion, as well as One Nation MLCs. The changes were meant to make it harder to get licences, including by requiring stronger evidence of why firearms are needed. Most people will be limited to 10 firearms under the new laws, although that's reduced to five for hunting licences. "By doing what they're doing to us as gun owners is … it's not really going to make the streets any safer," gun owner Murray Cave said at the protest. "The guns that we've got are all licensed, people know where they are … and we're doing all the right things." Fellow gun owner Debra Taylor echoed similar sentiments. "I'm a farmer, this is about us keeping our tools … to maintain our way of living, it's our heritage, it's our culture," she said. The large crowd resulted in the public gallery of parliament being closed. Other gun owners were unhappy about problems they'd had registering new guns on current licenses, and problems accessing the online portal to register guns. One man was unhappy with how long it took to get a gun licence now, saying he had been waiting for three months. Police Minister Reece Whitby said support for the motion was concerning given "what's on the line". "We're in very dangerous situation. There is massive amounts of misinformation," he said. "You've got the proponent of the disallowance motion in the upper house telling people that everything will be OK, we can go back to the original '73 legislation. That is not true." Mr Whitby told reporters Police Commissioner Col Blanch was "really concerned" about the disallowance motion succeeding, claiming it would lead to "total firearm anarchy". "Every firearm in Western Australia would become prohibited because it's not categorised under the regulations, which be disallowed," Mr Whitby said. But gun owners disagreed, including organiser of the rally, David Finnie who said the new laws were an overreach on law-abiding firearms owners. "Let's be honest there is only one intention here, it is to control us and disarm us," Mr Finnie told the crowd. "They can paint it any way they want." Dr Walker backed up those concerns and said freedoms were being eroded bit by bit. "You think that this firearms act is the only thing, well it's not," he said. "We just got a post and boast bill that we've actually just sent to a committee and that post and boast bill will allow the government to actually at a whim tell the police to arrest you for things that happened five years ago and you put on Facebook." A disallowance motion for the new firearms regulations was first moved in the Legislative Assembly by Nationals Leader Shane Love back in May but failed. While the WA Greens supported the referral of the regulations to a Parliamentary Committee, leader Brad Pettitt said his party would not support today's motion. "This nuclear option that's before the parliament today, of literally blowing it all up before that's even happening [the committee reviewing the regulations] is something that can't be supported," he said. "So we won't be supporting that. We'll be working with the government to make sure it improves the current regulations, not blow the whole lot up." Given the Greens confirmed they won't support the motion, it won't have enough support to get up even with Opposition and some crossbench support. Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas, who previously supported the motion in the lower house, did not make himself available for reporters on the way into parliament this morning about his stance on the issue. The government said the laws are designed to keep the community safe by keeping guns out of the hands of violent offenders. The rally comes after police and consumer authorities on Wednesday warned videos circulating on social media featuring deep fake AI generated police officers condemning the firearm law reforms could lead to community unrest. One video features the AI generated officers removing a gun from a crying elderly farmer, while the other shows an officer falsely stating defence personnel can't hold firearms "unless they can prove they're not crazy". Consumer Protection commissioner Trish Blake said the videos were "intended to build heat and passion in the community". "But it's on based on lies, so and that's where we're worried that someone might be misguided into doing something dumb, responding or actioning something in any way that causes them harm or harm to the community," she said. "It is really concerning because it is misinformation that is causing a lot of heated debate in the community unnecessarily and we really don't want people to be misinformed and we don't want people to be encouraged to take action or do something really dumb based on this."
