logo
PHC seeks replies in oath challenge

PHC seeks replies in oath challenge

Express Tribune2 days ago
The Peshawar High Court (PHC) has issued notices to the federal government, the Attorney General of Pakistan, the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP), and other parties in response to constitutional petitions filed by Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur and Provincial Assembly Speaker Babar Saleem Swati. The petitioners have challenged the Chief Justice of the Peshawar High Court's directive, which authorized the Governor to administer oaths to members elected on reserved seats outside the assembly premises. The court has sought written replies from all respondents by August 5.
A two-member bench comprising Justice Ejaz Anwar and Justice Faheem Wali presided over the hearing. During proceedings, the judges raised serious constitutional questions and expressed skepticism over the maintainability of the petitions, especially that of the Chief Minister. Justice Ejaz Anwar remarked that the matter primarily concerns the Speaker of the Assembly and not the Chief Minister, stating, "The Speaker is the affected party here. The Chief Minister is not an aggrieved person." Justice Faheem Wali also questioned Gandapur's legal standing, asking, "In what capacity has the Chief Minister filed this petition? He already fulfilled his role."
The hearing saw the presence of K-P Advocate General Shah Faisal Utmankhel, Additional Attorney General Sanaullah, Speaker's counsel Waqar Khan, and other legal representatives. Justice Ejaz Anwar, while addressing the Advocate General, noted that had the oath not been administered, the members would not have been able to vote in the Senate elections. "The fact that they voted shows the oath was essential," he observed.
Speaker Swati and CM Gandapur, through their respective counsels, contended that the oath-taking held at Governor House was unconstitutional. They argued that Article 65 of the Constitution clearly stipulates that members must take oath within the Assembly, and that the Speaker had not refused to administer the oath - the session was simply adjourned due to a lack of quorum.
The petitions further claim that Article 255(2), which allows for alternative oath-taking arrangements in case of impossibility, was misapplied. "There was no refusal from the Speaker or the Chief Minister. A session had already been convened. Therefore, the conditions for invoking Article 255(2) were not met," the petitioners argued. They maintained that the Chief Justice's administrative directive instructing the Governor to administer the oath was a constitutional overreach.
The oath-taking ceremony, held at the Governor House on a Sunday, followed a request made to the Chief Justice by newly elected members on reserved seats. In their letter, they expressed concerns over being denied the opportunity to vote in the upcoming Senate elections. Acting on this letter, the Registrar of the High Court issued an official directive, authorizing the Governor to administer the oath under Article 255(2)".
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Imran Khan's sons meet Trump aide to launch US campaign for father's release
Imran Khan's sons meet Trump aide to launch US campaign for father's release

Business Recorder

time11 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

Imran Khan's sons meet Trump aide to launch US campaign for father's release

Sulaiman Khan (28) and Kasim Khan (26), sons of jailed former Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan, have met with U.S. special presidential envoy Richard Grenell in California to kick off a campaign to garner international support for their father's release. The brothers made a bold public debut in May, highlighting their father's imprisonment since August 2023 at Pakistan's Adiala Jail. Serving a sentence related to a £190 million corruption conviction, Imran Khan is also facing ongoing trials under the Anti‑Terrorism Act linked to the May 9, 2023, protests. In a photo shared on X, Richard Grenell stood alongside the Khans and U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom Vice Chairman Dr Asif Mahmood. Grenell issued a rallying message: 'Stay strong… millions around the world are sick of political prosecutions. You are not alone.' Mahmood expressed admiration for the brothers' determination and praised Grenell's support, calling it a stand for justice and principle . In a previous May interview, Sulaiman and Kasim revealed they had 'exhausted' legal and diplomatic channels, alleging their father was held in 'complete isolation' in a cell likened to those used for death row inmates, without access to lawyers or doctors . They appealed directly to high‑profile figures, especially former U.S. President Donald Trump, to generate global pressure in support of Imran Khan's basic human rights . The siblings are now focusing on a campaign to confront what they describe as a suppressive wave against dissent in Pakistan. Their U.S. launch is expected to coincide with a planned protest movement in Pakistan scheduled for early August, marking the second year since Imran Khan's arrest. Although Pakistani officials have not formally reacted, Barrister Aqeel Malik, the Minister of State for Law and Justice, noted that Article 16 of Pakistan's constitution does not extend to foreigners, and that violating visa rules could lead to consequences. Meanwhile, political voices within the ruling PML‑N are split over whether the Khans should be allowed to return to Pakistan.

Finance minister lauds CCP's for ‘reducing pending court cases'
Finance minister lauds CCP's for ‘reducing pending court cases'

Business Recorder

time16 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

Finance minister lauds CCP's for ‘reducing pending court cases'

Federal Minister for Finance Muhammad Aurangzeb expressed satisfaction over the performance of the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP), saying the commission's had brought significant improvements, particularly in reducing the number of pending court cases. Addressing the Senate, the finance minister requested the chairman Senate Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue, to invite Dr Kabir Sidhu, Chairman CCP, for a detailed briefing to appreciate the true extant of reforms undertaken by the commission. He informed the house that over the past two years, the CCP's new management actively pursued litigation in various courts, which resulted in reducing the backlog of cases from 577 to approximately 300. Responding to a motion moved by Senator Mohsin Aziz, the minister emphasised that a transparent and robust regulatory framework is essential in a market-based economy to foster competition and ensure accountability. In this context, he highlighted CCP's recent performance as crucial and deserving of support. He shared that the CCP issued 11 major orders in the past year alone, imposing fines exceeding Rs1 billion. Of this amount, approximately Rs120 million has already been recovered. The inquiry process has been expedited, the issuance of show-cause notices has become more efficient, and the overall hearing mechanism has improved to ensure timely action against violators. The minister further stated that CCP's Cartels Department completed 20 inquiries during the current fiscal year, while the Office of Fair Trade finalised 13 investigations related to misleading advertisements and deceptive marketing. These investigations have led to the issuance of show-cause notices and the initiation of formal hearings, he said. He also informed the Senate about the establishment of a dedicated Market Intelligence Unit within the CCP, which proactively monitors market distortions, price manipulation, and other potential violations of competition law. The minister said that the unit has so far identified 170 potential violations across sectors such as banking, e-commerce, telecom, and real estate, with 28 inquiries already initiated. CCP tells Aurangzeb: 23 major actions taken against cartels and cos Highlighting the CCP's role in facilitating investment, he said that the commission Mergers Department approved 69 transactions during the current year, resulting completion of transactions worth $30 million in foreign direct investment (FDI). Moreover, the Exemptions Department granted 83 exemptions, helping to ease business operations. He added that a Centre of Excellence has also been established within the Commission to conduct research and data-driven analysis of various market sectors.

Proposed amendment on LGs: NA Secretariat asked to issue reminder to all parliamentary party leaders
Proposed amendment on LGs: NA Secretariat asked to issue reminder to all parliamentary party leaders

Business Recorder

time21 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

Proposed amendment on LGs: NA Secretariat asked to issue reminder to all parliamentary party leaders

ISLAMABAD: A parliamentary body on Tuesday directed the National Assembly Secretariat to issue a reminder to all parliamentary party leaders to submit their opinion on the proposed constitutional amendment aimed at strengthening local governments. The Senate Standing Committee on Law and Justice, which met with MNA Chaudhry Mahmood Bashir Virk in the chair, discussed 'The Constitution (Amendment) Bill, 2025' (Article 140-A) moved by MNA Muhammad Jawed Hanif Khan, seeking to make local government institutions more viable and effective in line with the aspirations of the people of Pakistan. The parliamentary body observed that, in compliance with its previous directions, letters were issued to the provincial governments as well as to the parliamentary leaders of all political parties, seeking their views regarding the proposed amendment in Article 140-A. However, the committee has so far not received a response of any parliamentary leader in this regard. The committee directed the secretariat to issue a reminder to all parliamentary leaders to submit their opinions as soon as possible to proceed further in the matter. The meeting also considered 'The Qanun-e-Shahadat (Amendment) Bill, 2025' moved by MNA Shazia Marri. During detailed deliberations, the mover informed the committee that, in light of the discussions held during the previous meeting, the proposed bill had been redrafted. The revised draft of the bill was placed before the parliamentary body for consideration, she said. The members of the committee observed that, since the bill now contained substantive amendments, it was not feasible to deliberate upon the revised draft without prior examination. Therefore, the committee decided to defer consideration of the bill till its next meeting to allow members sufficient time for a thorough review. The committee also considered the 'Constitution (Amendment) Bill, 2024' (Article 25) moved by MNA Nafeesa Shah and 'The Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Bill, 2024' (Section 54-A) moved by MNA Sofia Saeed Shah but due to the non-availability of the movers, the committee decided to defer consideration of both bills to its next meeting, with the observation that no further deferment shall be granted. The committee decided that, in case of continued absence of the movers, the bills shall be taken up and decided upon in absentia. MNAs Zahra Wadood Fatemi, Kiran Haider, Syed Ibrar Ali Shah, Syed Naveed Qamar, Syed Hafeezuddin, Hassan Sabir, Ali Muhammad Khan, Umair Khan Niazi, Changaze Ahmec Khan, Sardar Muhammad Latif Khan Khosa, Aliya Kamran, Shazia Marri, Jawed Hanif Khan, and senior officials of Ministry of Law and Justice attended the meeting. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store