Government unveils $190m social investment fund with focus on early intervention
Social investment funding prioritises early support
Finance minister Nicola Willis has announced a $190 million social investment fund to support 'services that deliver measurable improvements in the lives of those who need our help, guided by data and evidence'. The fund is part of a wider $275 million allocation to the newly empowered Social Investment Agency, and was unveiled in a pre-budget speech yesterday, The Post's Luke Malpass reports (paywalled).
Three projects will receive initial funding: an Autism New Zealand programme providing early support to 50 families; an expansion of Emerge Aotearoa's work with at-risk youth; and He Piringa Whare, a data-informed programme to support at-risk Māori. Additional investments will focus on parenting in the early years and preventing children from entering state care, part of the Crown's response to the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse in State Care.
A renamed agency with renewed purpose
The announcement builds on changes made last year, when the Social Wellbeing Agency was rebranded as the Social Investment Agency and repositioned as a central government agency with system-wide oversight, explains RNZ's Russell Palmer in his comprehensive explainer on the past and present of social investment in NZ. Early moves such as reprioritising Oranga Tamariki contracts and overhauling Whānau Ora commissioning have caused some friction – not least with John Tamihere, who has taken the government to court over his agency's lost contracts.
From policing to public services
The agency's CEO is Andrew Coster, whose time as police commissioner was marked by both controversy and reform. Criticised early on by National and Act for being 'soft on crime', he was labelled 'cuddles Coster' by his critics, while former National leader Simon Bridges accused him of being a 'wokester'. The government has since largely changed its tune, with the PM saying Coster had 'delivered bigtime', reports Palmer.
Now, Coster is excited to work at the 'top of the cliff', he tells Newsroom's Laura Walters, and to change a system that is hampered by fragmented funding and an excessive focus on compliance. He believes 'the culture of adding on services, rather than assessing the effectiveness of current services, has led to more money being spent but not always better outcomes being achieved', Walters writes. Says Coster: 'We want to know whether [a service] made a difference, not just that it was delivered.'
A policy redux
Social investment has long been associated with former prime minister Bill English, who promoted the idea of using data to intervene early and reduce the long-term fiscal burden of entrenched disadvantage. His approach was data-driven to the extreme, writes Eileen Joy in the Conversation, including commissioning an actuary firm to calculate the lifetime welfare cost to the state of people on benefits and which type of beneficiary 'is going to cost us the most money'.
While English's model was praised for its logic, it gave no consideration 'to structural factors such as colonisation and poverty', writes Joy, and ultimately delivered few tangible results before being sidelined by the Labour government in 2017. Willis, once a staffer for English, has picked up the baton with a broader framing – emphasising both social and financial returns and apparently seeking to avoid English's ideological rigidity.
Joy says she remains sceptical. 'Given the government's drive to remove any special policy considerations based on … the Treaty of Waitangi, the risk remains that some Māori will again come to be viewed as a 'cost' to the state.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
30 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Hawke's Bay local government elections 2025: 114 candidates and fierce competition ahead
For the rest, you can have your say on who represents your community by voting in the local elections from September 9 to October 11. If you haven't enrolled or need to update your address, you will now need to contact your council's electoral officer, ideally before October 1. The last day to enrol to vote is Friday, October 10. Hastings District Council candidates The most contested race in Hawke's Bay this time around is for the Hastings-Havelock North ward of the Hastings District Council, where 17 candidates will vie for seven seats - too many to list in a single sentence here. Hastings also has the most mayoral candidates at five, followed closely by Wairoa with four. Sandra Hazlehurst is standing down after 15 years on council, the last eight as mayor. Three councillors, Wendy Schollum, Damon Harvey and Marcus Buddo are vying for the mayoralty, along with newcomers Steve Gibson and Darrin Wilson. The two newcomers are also standing in the Hastings-Havelock North seat on council. There are two candidates for the Flaxmere ward's one seat, with Henare O'Keefe making a bid for a return after a term off. He goes up against incumbent councillor Henry Heke. Both are well-known Flaxmere identities. There are three new candidates for the Mohaka ward's one seat, with Deputy Mayor Tania Kerr stepping down. They are Putorino farmer Pagen Goldstone, Derek Nowell-Usticke, who has a background in agriculture and Kirsty Scott-McLean. Zack Makoare and former Hawke's Bay A&P Society general manager Elisha Milmine are vying for the Kahuranaki ward, however, Milmine may win before the campaign starts. Makoare told Hawke's Bay Today his circumstances had changed and he wouldn't be running. There are five candidates for the Takitimu Māori Ward's three vacancies, including incumbents Kellie Jessup and Heather Te Au-Skipworth. The newcomers are Siiam Daniel, who is standing to normalise leadership for Māori for the next generation, Sarah Greening, who also ran in the 2022 elections and describes herself on LinkedIn as a health and safety and human resources officer, and Bevan O'Connor, a lawyer, owner of business VisaMax NZ and advocate for Māori rights. Central Hawke's Bay It was a slow start in Central Hawke's Bay with just six candidates on Thursday morning. But when nominations closed at noon on Friday, the rural district had 20 candidates, including a former mayor, on the ballot sheet. Two candidates are vying for the mayoral chains, incumbent Alex Walker is seeking a fourth term as mayor and Will Foley, farmer and former Hawke's Bay Regional Councillor, his first. CHB's At-Large ward has four candidates for two vacancies. Incumbent deputy mayor Kelly Annand and councillor Gerard Minehan are up against newcomers Stella McDonald, a retiree who has decided she now has time to give back to the community, and Meg Gordon, who says she thinks people are ready for a change and new perspectives. The Ruataniwha ward has a healthy eight candidates for three vacancies. They include incumbent councillor Pip Burne, former mayor and CHB dam backer Tim Gilbertson, freight business owner Todd Chote, who says he wants to help the district grow, and horse trainer Kirsty Lawrence. Aramoana-Ruahine has four candidates with three standing councillors Kate Taylor, Jerry Greer and Brent Muggeridge. They will compete with newcomer, sheep and cattle farmer Simon F.H Collin. Collin, who lives in Flemington, says he now has the time and experience to put in to council. There are three seats. Rautahi Māori Ward has two candidates, Te Ata Kura Huata, who wants to bring a Māori voice to CHB, and Amiria Nepe Apatu, who is currently sitting at the council table as its Pou Whirinaki Advisor. There is one seat available. Napier In Napier, residents will vote for their preferred mayor from three candidates - incumbent Kirsten Wise and two councillors, Nigel Simpson and Richard McGrath. There's plenty of competition for the Ahuriri ward with nine candidates for the three available seats, including three standing councillors, Keith Price, Sally Crown and Juliet Greig. Newcomers include Roger Brownlie, an orchardist and retailer, who says he wants to bring community-focused leadership, and Lyndal Johansson, who works for Sport Hawke's Bay, the New Zealand Transport Agency and as a volunteer. The Napier ward has five candidates for three vacancies, including incumbent councillor Greg Mawson and newcomer Taiatini Lepaio who wants to be the voice for local communities. Taradale has four candidates for three vacancies, with Ronda Chrystal seeking her third term, Graeme Taylor his sixth and semi-retired businessman Terry Cornish, his first. The Te Whanga Māori ward has three candidates for two seats. Whare Isaac-Sharland, who says she has a deep commitment to her people and Kirk Kia-Maia Leonard, who says he's standing for council because it's time for mana whenua (first home people) to be included in the decision making. The third candidate is Shyann Raihania who says the Māori Ward seat is more than representation, it's a strategic tool to drive solutions. Hawke's Bay Regional Council The Hawke's Bay Regional Council has two candidates in its Wairoa Regional Constituency for one vacancy. Councillor Di Roadley is standing again. She is up against Kiri Rangirangi-Hamlin, who believes HBRC must expedite a plan to protect the township of Wairoa from further inundation events. There are six candidates for Ahuriri/Napier with three vacancies. Hayley Browne is seeking a seat after two terms on the Napier City Council and says she wants to work on the big issues, one of which is climate change. Former HBRC councillor Paul Bailey is putting his hand up again. Bailey is well known for his anti-Ruataniwha dam campaign and is an advocate for the local environmental group, Wise Water Use Hawke's Bay. Chair Hinewai Ormsby is restanding, as is political veteran Neil Kirton. Newcomer candidates are Louise Parsons, who was a spokesperson for her Eskdale community after Cyclone Gabrielle, questioning HBRC's decisions and asking for answers, and Syed Khurram Iqbal, who, if elected, plans to redirect HBRC's pollution prosecution funds and provide free nitrate testing for wells. There are two candidates for one vacancy in Ngaruroro, councillor Jerf van Beek and farmer Marcus Ormond. For the Tamatea/Central Hawke's Bay Constituency, there are three candidates for one vacancy. Tim Aitken is a Central Hawke's Bay resident, farmer, and former district councillor. Tony Kuklinski says he stood six years ago because he believed stopbanks needed maintenance and is standing again after HBRC's efforts during Cyclone Gabrielle. Keri Ropiha is also in the running, saying while she supports water storage, she does not support ratepayer funding for water storage without a referendum. There are four candidates in the Heretaunga/Hastings for the three vacancies, two councillors, Jock Mackintosh and Sophie Siers and two newcomers, Conrad Waitoa and Bruce Mackay. Mackay has been involved in water access and security for over a decade and says he has a broader understanding of the diverse values and priorities in the region. Waitoa says he submitted his nomination on opening day because, the time was right to serve with energy, purpose and proven leadership. For Māui ki te Raki Māori there are two candidates for one seat, Shelton White and Michelle McIlroy (nee Lewis). White says he is standing because he is passionate and committed to the region. McIlroy is standing as a strong Māori wāhine voice. 'Toitū te tiriti. Toitū te taiao.' Wairoa In Wairoa, deputy mayor Denise Eaglesome-Karekare is going up against incumbent Craig Little. The two other mayoral candidates are Camdin Gaskin and Kurawari Panere. Two standing councillors, Jeremy Harker and Roz Thomas, are restanding in the General Ward and are joined by seven new nominations vying for just three seats. They are Sara Bird, Amber Forrest, Camden Gaskin, Stuart Harris, Sam Jackman, John Malis and Veronica Grace Tukaki. There are also nine candidates for the Māori ward, including incumbent councillor Benita Cairns, for three seats. The new candidates are: Puti Cook, Marino Harker-Smith, Katarina Kawana, Kurawari Panere, Michelle Tahuri, Alison Tipu, Trevor Teotaia Hirini Waikawa and Esta Makere Wainohu. Full candidate lists NAPIER Mayoralty Richard McGrath (And also council) Nigel Simpson (And also council) Kirsten Wise Ahuriri General Ward Iain Bradley Roger Brownlie Louise Burnside Sally Crown Karl Goodchild Juliet Greig Lyndal Johansson Ben Newport Keith Price Napier Central General Ward Te Kira Lawrence Taiatini Lepaio Greg Mawson Richard McGrath Craig Morley Taradale General Ward Ronda Chrystal Terry Cornish Nigel Simpson Graeme Taylor Te Whanga Māori Ward Whare Isaac-Sharland Kirk Kia-Maia Leonard Shyann Raihania HASTINGS Mayor Marcus Buddo Steve Gibson (And also council) Damon Harvey Wendy Schollum Darrin Wilson (And also council) Mōhaka General Ward Pagen Goldstone Derek Nowell-Usticke Kirsty Scott-McLean Heretaunga General Ward Alwyn Corban Hana Montaperto-Hendry Hastings-Havelock North General Ward Sayeed Ahmed John Bennett Michael Fowler Gareth Freeman Steve Gibson Bernard Hickey Rizwaana Latiff Yvonne Lorkin Lucie-Jane McElwee Simon Nixon Nick Ratcliffe Rion Roben Callum Ross Jacqueline Supra Debbie Ward Kevin Watkins Darrin Wilson Flaxmere General Ward Henry Heke Henare O'Keefe Kahurānaki General Ward Zack Makaore Elisha Milmine Takitimu Māori Ward Siiam Daniel Sarah Greening Kellie Jessup Bevan O'Connor Heather Te-Au Skipworth WAIROA Mayor Denise Eaglesome-Karekare Camden Gaskin (And also council) Craig Little Kurawari Panere (And also council) General Ward Sara Bird, Amber Forrest Camden Gaskin, Jeremy Harker Stuart Harris Sam Jackman John Malis Roz Thomas Veronica Grace Tukaki Māori Ward Benita Cairns Puti Cook Marino Harker-Smith Katarina Kawana Kurawari Panere Michelle Tahuri Alison Tipu Trevor Teotaia Hirini Waikawa Esta Makere Wainohu HAWKE'S BAY REGIONAL COUNCIL Ahuriri/Napier Paul Bailey Hayley Browne Syed Khurram Iqbal Neil Kirton Hinewai Ormsby Louise Parsons Heretaunga/Hastings Bruce Mackay Jock Mackintosh Sophie Siers Conrad Waitoa Māui ki te Raki Michelle McIlroy (nee Lewis) Shelton White, Wairoa Kiri Rangirangi-Hamlin Di Roadley Māui ki te Tonga Thompson Hokianga Ngaruroro Marcus Ormond Jerf van Beek Tamatea/Central Hawke's Bay Tim Aitken Tony Kuklinski Keri Ropiha CENTRAL HAWKE'S BAY Mayor Will Foley Alex Walker At Large Kelly Annand Meg Gordon Stella McDonald Gerard Minehan Ruataniwha Pip Burne Todd Chote Tim Gilbertson Murray Kenderdine Kirsty Lawrence Jenny Nelson-Smith Ben Revell Graham Stubbs Aramoana-Ruahine Simon Collin Jerry Greer Brent Muggeridge Kate Taylor Rautahi Māori Te Ata Kura Huata Amiria Nepe Apatu LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
NZ Herald
an hour ago
- NZ Herald
Foreshore and seabed: Govt to pass marine and coastal areas legislation despite Supreme Court ruling
The Government is pushing forward with controversial legislation that affects Māori customary rights to the foreshore and seabed after a Supreme Court ruling raised questions over whether the Government would consider the legislation necessary.
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Govt forges ahead with foreshore and seabed change
By Craig McCulloch of RNZ The government is forging ahead with plans to change the law governing New Zealand's foreshore and seabed, despite a Supreme Court ruling last year that appeared to undercut the rationale for the change. The proposed legislation stems from a clause in National's coalition deal with NZ First, which promised to revisit the Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act. That commitment was driven by fears that a 2023 Court of Appeal decision could have made it significantly easier for Māori groups to win recognition of customary rights over parts of the coastline. The government introduced a bill to Parliament last year to prevent that, but it hit pause in December after the Supreme Court effectively overturned the earlier ruling. At the time, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith welcomed the development and said ministers would take time to reassess their plans. Today Goldsmith confirmed to RNZ that Cabinet had agreed to press ahead with the law change regardless, and to pass it before October. "Everybody in New Zealand has an interest in what goes on in the coastline, and we're trying our best to get that balance right." Goldsmith said he was not convinced that the Supreme Court ruling had set a high enough test for judging whether customary rights should be granted. "We've had a couple of cases that have been decided since then - which have shown almost 100 percent of the coastline and those areas being granted customary marine title - which confirmed to us that the Supreme Court test still didn't achieve the balance that we think the legislation set out to achieve." Asked whether he expected an upswell of protest, Goldsmith said that had been an earlier concern but: "time will tell". "There's been a wide variety of views, some in favour, some against, but we think this is the right thing to do." The legislation was one of the key objections raised by Ngāpuhi leaders last year when they walked out on a meeting with Prime Minister Christopher Luxon in protest. More than 200 applications for customary marine title are making their way through the courts. Under the amendment bill, any court decisions issued after 25 July 2024 will need to be reconsidered. That would appear to cover seven cases involving various iwi from around the country. "I understand their frustration over that," Goldsmith said. "But we believe it is very important to get this right, because it affects the whole of New Zealand." Goldsmith said the government had set aside about $15 million to cover the additional legal costs. The Marine and Coastal Area Act was originally passed by the National-led government in 2011, replacing the controversial Foreshore and Seabed Act 2004, which had extinguished Māori customary rights in favour of Crown ownership. The 2004 law - introduced by Helen Clark's Labour government - provoked widespread protest and led to the creation of the Māori Party, now known as Te Pāti Māori. National's 2011 replacement declared that no one owned the foreshore and seabed but allowed Māori groups to seek to recognition of their rights - or "Customary Marine Title" - through the courts or in direct negotiations with the Crown. Customary title recognises exclusive Māori rights to parts of the foreshore and seabed, provided certain legal tests are met, including proving continuous and "exclusive" use of the area since 1840 without substantial interruption. The 2023 Court of Appeal ruling, however, declared that groups only needed to show they had enough control over the area that they could keep others from using it, and that situations where the law itself had prevented them from doing so could be ignored. The Supreme Court subsequently overturned that, saying the Court of Appeal had taken an unduly narrow approach in its interpretation.
