Enfield oak tree felled by Toby Carvery 'had 50-year life expectancy'
An ancient oak felled in a north London park by Toby Carvery's owners was classified last year as a "fine specimen" with a life expectancy of at least 50 years, planning documents show.Pub chain Mitchells & Butlers admitted on Tuesday it was responsible for chopping down the 500-year-old tree "to protect our employees and guests as well as the wider general public".An Enfield Council planning document from March 2024 found the tree to be in "moderate good" condition and recommended a "light reduction of the upper crown on north side".The council said it had reported the felling as criminal damage to the Met Police, which is understood to have closed its inquiry, deeming it a civil matter.
The report also stated the pedunculate oak, on the edge of Whitewebbs Park, had high ecological and landscape value.Initially, a source for Mitchells and Butlers (M&B) said on Tuesday that it approved the cutting down of the oak after being told the tree was dead.In an official statement hours later, M&B stated it had received advice from contractors, who said "the split and dead wood posed a serious health and safety risk".It subsequently removed this statement in a further update, but maintained the company "took necessary measures to ensure any legal requirements were met". The BBC has asked M&B for information about the contractor that cut down the tree. The company has not done so and has also declined the BBC's request for an interview.
'Tree worth £1m'
Dr Ed Pine, senior conservation advisor for trees at the Woodland Trust, said of the felling of the oak: "I couldn't quite believe it, to be honest. "I've been working for trees in various capacities now as an arborist, as an academic for close to 14 years and in all that time I don't think I've seen a tree felling as shocking as this."It comes just two days after a report from the charity Tree Council and researchers Forest Research that warns trees are only indirectly protected, with some "significant legal gaps".It recommends the development of a "robust and effective system" to ensure they are safeguarded.
The Enfield oak was worth £1m, according to tree valuer Russell Miller who made his estimate using the Capital Asset Value for Amenity Trees (CAVAT) system.Mr Miller said it was "much older and much more valuable than the Sycamore Gap" cut down in Northumberland in 2023.He added: "This tree is designated... as an irreplaceable habitat because it's got decay features and habitats within it that you cannot replace within hundreds of years."In addition to the sorts of species that people are familiar with, like bats and owls that live in these trees, you've got thousands of species of invertebrate."You've got lots of different niches for lots of different species inside the tree, and that's why they're so special."
A spokesperson for M&B said: "The tree was cut back after we were advised that it caused a serious health and safety risk."Upon further inspection, our specialist arboriculture contractors made the assessment that the split and dead wood posed a serious health and safety risk and advised that the tree was unsafe and should be removed."We are grateful to our expert contractors for warning us of this hazard so swiftly, allowing us to act before anyone was harmed."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
4 hours ago
- Wales Online
Two die as car plunges off cliff into sea at popular UK beauty spot
Two die as car plunges off cliff into sea at popular UK beauty spot It was reported a man was pulled from the sea by a lifeboat after a car plunged from a cliff at the Isle of Wight The car was driving along Alum Bay New Road, police said (Image: Getty ) Two people tragically lost their lives after a car plummeted into the sea at a popular tourist location on the Isle of Wight, police have confirmed. The incident unfolded on Friday evening at Alum Bay, close to The Needles — one of Britain's renowned natural wonders. The grey vehicle is said to have veered off Alum Bay New Road, tumbling 300 feet down the cliff and coming to rest in the waters below. Police released a statement on Friday, June 6, stating: "We're currently at the scene of a serious incident in Totland. "We were called at 7.21pm this evening (Friday, June 6) after a car, which was being driven along Alum Bay New Road, left the road, came off the cliff top and came to rest in the water below." At that time, reports indicated that a man had been retrieved from the water, the Express. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here In a statement issued on Sunday, June 8, the force said: "Formal identification has yet to take place, but their next of kin have been notified." The enquiry, carried out on behalf of the coroner, continues, with officers examining a property situated on Arctic Road, Cowes. Article continues below The Needles Landmark Attraction was temporarily closed (Image: GETTY ) Emergency services, including the police, coastguard, firefighters, and paramedics, were dispatched to the scene, and the nearby Needles Landmark Attraction was temporarily shut down by the police while emergency teams responded. Despite the incident, the Round the Island Race, one of the world's largest yacht races attracting over 1,200 boats and around 10,000 sailors, proceeded as planned yesterday with the route passing through the bay. Each year, according to the BBC, about half a million people visit Alum Bay and the surrounding cliffs. The iconic chalk stacks of The Needles were named as one of the Seven Natural Wonders of the UK. They are a row of three stacks of chalk that rise almost 100ft out fo the sea on the west of the island. Article continues below The Needles Lighthouse stands at the western end. At the attraction visitors can take boat trips, a chairlift, aswell as experience glass-blowing.
The National
5 hours ago
- The National
Farage's proposal is just the latest undermining of the Barnett system
This, according to senior criminologists and ex-police officers, is not just a failure of admin, it's the result of austerity-era cuts that stripped police forces of capacity, dismantled the state-run Forensic Science Service in 2012, and left fragmented, underfunded systems to cope with ballooning evidence demands. Austerity didn't just weaken institutions; it disassembled infrastructure. READ MORE: Nigel Farage could cut the Barnett Formula. Here's what devolution experts think of that While these failings may seem like an English and Welsh concern, they tell a broader UK-wide story. Because when public services are cut in England, the Barnett formula translates those cuts into reduced budget allocations for Holyrood, too. Scotland has long borne the dual burden of being denied full fiscal autonomy while also seeing its devolved budget squeezed by decisions made for entirely different priorities south of the Border. Cuts to police, criminal courts, housing, public health, and local government in England have systematically eroded the spending floor on which Scottish services rest. So when justice collapses in England, it affects Scotland financially – even if the governance is separate. And now, against this backdrop of UK-wide budgetary degradation, Nigel Farage has called for the scrapping of the Barnett formula entirely. It's a move that's politically convenient, historically illiterate, and economically reckless. But more than anything, it's a distillation of what's already happening by stealth. Successive UK governments have undermined the foundations of the Barnett system – and devolution itself – for more than a decade. READ MORE: Furious Anas Sarwar clashes with BBC journalist over Labour policies It's obvious to every Scot that Farage's view relies on a mischaracterisation of Barnett as a subsidy, when in fact it simply ensures Scotland receives a proportional share of changes to spending in England for devolved services. It doesn't calculate entitlement or need, it mirrors policy shifts at Westminster. If England increases education or health spending, Scotland sees a relative uplift. If England cuts deeply, Scotland's budget falls, even if demand remains or rises. This has led to an absurd and punitive dynamic where Scotland loses funding not by its own decisions, but because England spends less. And when Scotland chooses to maintain higher standards in public services, it must do so from a proportionately smaller pot. Perversely, it doesn't stop there, though. Since the 2016 Brexit vote, Westminster has begun bypassing devolved governments directly. Funds like the Levelling Up Fund and Shared Prosperity Fund are allocated by UK ministers to local authorities, often bypassing Holyrood entirely. Promises made in The Vow on the eve of the 2014 independence referendum to deliver near-federal powers and respect Scottish decision-making have unravelled. READ MORE: SNP must turn support for independence into 'real political action' The Internal Market Act has overridden devolved laws under the banner of market 'consistency'. Powers that returned from Brussels in areas like food standards, procurement, and agriculture were supposed to go to Holyrood, but in many cases they were retained by Westminster. The Sewel Convention, once a safeguard of devolved consent, has been treated as optional. Farage's proposal to scrap Barnett isn't an outlier, it's the natural conclusion of a decade-long pattern: cut services in England, shrink the Barnett allocation, bypass devolved institutions, and then blame the devolved nations for 'taking more than their share'. There's no consideration of fairness, or implementation of a needs-based analysis, it's a strategy of erosion; one that gouges out the Union from the centre while draping itself in the flag. The failures of justice in England, catastrophic as they are, expose a deeper injustice: the systematic unravelling of the constitutional promises made to Scotland. Ron Lumiere via email
Scottish Sun
6 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
British ‘service person' arrested on suspicion of ‘raping' woman near army training camp in Kenya
A UK-Kenya defence cooperation agreement allows thousands of Brit soldiers to train in Kenya every year ARMY 'RAPE' British 'service person' arrested on suspicion of 'raping' woman near army training camp in Kenya Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A BRITISH "service person" has reportedly been arrested on suspicion of raping a woman near an army training camp in Kenya. The alleged rape happened last month, with the man arrested after a group of soldiers visited a bar in the area near the town of Nanyuki, BBC reports. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The incident occurred close to the British Army Training Unit Kenya (Batuk) 2 A Brit 'service person' has reportedly been arrested on suspicion of raping a woman near an army training camp in Kenya Credit: Getty Military cops have questioned the bar owner and security guards who were working the night of the incident that occurred close to the British Army Training Unit Kenya (Batuk), The Sunday Times reports. According to the paper, the bar owner said: "They [soldiers] like this place and when I meet some of them in the supermarkets, they tell me they have been banned from coming here. "Sometimes they get too drunk and I drop them at the gate for free." An investigation is being carried out by the UK military police from the Defence Serious Crime Unit. read more news HOLIDAY TRAGEDY Brit tourist, 21, found dead on street in popular Algarve resort The UK Ministry of Defence confirmed in a statement that a "service person" had been arrested in Kenya. A MoD spokesperson said in a statement: "We can confirm the arrest of a Service person in Kenya. "As the matter is the subject of an ongoing investigation by the Defence Serious Crime Command, we will not comment further." A UK-Kenya defence cooperation agreement allows thousands of Brit soldiers to train in the East African country every year. About 200 UK troops are based there permanently to train Kenyan soldiers. Some Kenyan people have complained for a long time about the soldiers behaviour alongside the atmosphere around their training camp near the town of Nanyuki. There was an outcry over the 2012 death of 21-year-old Agnes Wanjiru, who was last seen alive leaving a bar with British troops near their training camp. Bloodcurdling moment ruthless soldier cocks his gun & presses it against woman's temple during restaurant brawl Her body was tragically later found in a septic tank. Wanjirus family has campaigned for years for the suspected perpetrator, a serving British soldier at the time, to be charged. In April, UK Defense Secretary John Healey met with Wanjirus grieving family in Kenya and vowed to help the family secure the justice they deserve. The British Army has launched an inquiry into allegations of unacceptable behavior by UK personnel in Kenya. The MoD said in a statement that all British personnel in the country "have clear direction about how to behave, on and off duty, must complete mandatory training and attend compulsory briefings on conduct." It added: "We will have zero tolerance for unacceptable behaviour."
