Clarence Thomas urges courts to end deferring to ‘experts' on gender-affirming care
Justice Clarence Thomas said Wednesday that courts should not defer to 'self-described experts' on gender-affirming care, suggesting it is a matter of medical uncertainty.
Thomas's concurring opinion came as the Supreme Court upheld in a 6-3 decision Tennessee's ban on puberty blockers and hormone treatments for transgender minors, a ruling that could reverberate through several states that have similar laws.
'This case carries a simple lesson: In politically contentious debates over matters shrouded in scientific uncertainty, courts should not assume that self-described experts are correct,' the justice wrote in a solo concurring opinion.
Tennessee's law, S.B. 1, bars health care providers from prescribing puberty blocking and hormone therapy medications to minors when the intent is to help them transition. Signed in 2023, it also bans gender-transition surgeries for minors, though the justices did not consider that provision.
Medical providers could face $25,000 civil fines for violating the law.
Thomas claimed that 'many prominent medical professionals' have said there is a consensus around how to treat child gender dysphoria, but there is 'mounting evidence to the contrary.' Those experts have dismissed 'grave problems' that undercut the assumption that young children can consent to 'irreversible treatments,' he said.
'They have built their medical recommendations to achieve political ends,' the justice wrote, joining the majority in saying that the court's decision hands power back to Americans and their elected representatives.
The court's decision rejects a challenge brought by former President Biden's administration. It found that Tennessee's law does not amount to sex discrimination requiring a higher level of constitutional scrutiny, dealing a blow to LGBTQ-rights advocates who have claimed as much to try and take down similar laws.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor pushed back against Thomas's perspective in a footnote of her dissenting opinion, joined by Justices Ketanji Brown Jackson in full and Elena Kagan in part.
'Far from signaling that 'self-proclaimed experts' can determine 'the meaning of the Constitution' ante, this reference to the positions of major medical organizations is simply one piece of factual context relevant to the Court's assessment of whether SB1 is substantially related to the achievement of an important government interest,' Sotomayor wrote.
'Indeed, even Justice Thomas seems to recognize that some scientific and medical evidence (at least that which is consistent with his view of the merits) is relevant to the questions this case presents,' she added, citing points where Thomas referenced various peer-reviewed medical journals throughout his opinion.
President Trump's Justice Department walked away from the Biden administration's challenge when he returned to the White House. The new administration urged the Supreme Court to decide the case, nonetheless, given its importance.
Major medical organizations, including the American Medical Association, have said gender-affirming care for transgender adults and minors is medically necessary and often lifesaving, though not every trans person will choose to transition medically or have access to care.
In May, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) broke with major professional medical groups in an unsigned report that declared gender-affirming treatments lack scientific evidence. Susan J. Kressly, president of the American Academy of Pediatrics, said her organization was 'deeply alarmed' by the report, which she said 'misrepresents the current medical consensus and fails to reflect the realities of pediatric care.'
During oral arguments in December, Justices Samuel Alito and Brett Kavanaugh repeatedly referenced European countries that have recently moved to restrict some gender-affirming care for youth.
'If it's evolving like that and changing, and England is pulling back and Sweden is pulling back, it strikes me as a pretty heavy yellow light, if not red light, for this court to come in, the nine of us, and constitutionalize the whole area,' Kavanaugh said at the time.
But opponents of U.S. laws banning transition-related care for trans minors have said prohibitions imposed by Republican-led states go much further than European policies, which limit but do not categorically ban care.
'This is no ordinary medical regulation,' Pratik Shah, head of Supreme Court and appellate practice at Akin Gump, said of Tennessee's law on a call with reporters in December.
Brooke Migdon contributed to this report. Updated at 11:46 a.m. EDT
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
23 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Canada will impose new counter-tariffs against U.S. if it can't make a trade deal in 30 days, Mark Carney says
OTTAWA — Canada will impose a new wave of counter-tariffs if it cannot reach a deal within 30 days to resolve the trade dispute with the Trump administration, says Prime Minister Mark Carney. Speaking in Ottawa on the eve of a key meeting tomorrow between the negotiating teams, Carney announced a suite of new countermeasures, including adjusting existing counter tariffs on U.S. steel and aluminum products on July 21, at the end of that 30-day period. 'In other words, we're going to adjust them to levels consistent with the progress that's made at that point on the broader trading arrangements with the United States,' he said. Carney also announced a Buy Canadian policy for steel and aluminum used in federal procurement. 'Only Canadian producers and producers from trading partners that provide Canada with tariff free reciprocal access through trade agreements, can compete for federal government procurement of steel and aluminum,' he said. Carney wants an immediate end to the so-called 'border emergency' tariffs and the sectoral tariffs on autos, steel and aluminum that U.S. President Donald Trump has hit Canada with. But he said, 'it's a negotiation,' acknowledging there may not be an immediate lift to all of them. 'There is still some room to travel, so to speak, before we get to that point. But we have a deadline in order to achieve that, and if it's in Canada's interest, we'll sign it,' Carney said. With the move, the Carney government is putting more pressure on Canadian and U.S. negotiators to outline the path to a more predictable trade relationship. Carney also announced new tariffs of 100 per cent on foreign imports of steel from 'non-free trade agreement partners to stabilize the domestic market and prevent harmful trade diversion as the result of the U.S. actions that are destabilizing markets.' He said Trump did not ask him to institute the anti-dumping measure, but it has been a call made by steel producers in Canada. Ottawa also signalled that its digital services tax, which Trump calls an unfair trade practice and wants to eliminate, will apply even as Carney's team is in pitched negotiations to reach a deal. Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne told reporters, 'This was voted by Parliament so we're going ahead with the DST. 'But obviously, you know, all of that is something that we're considering as part of broader discussions that you may have, but the DST is in force and it's going to be applied.' Champagne said he and other G7 finance ministers have discussed different regimes of taxation that affect Big Tech at length with the Americans. 'This is not the big thing. The big thing is all the (value-added taxes) and other type of taxes you have around the world,' he said. 'And we had a discussion at the G7 about a few weeks ago, and even in Washington last time, to explain to our American colleagues that, a lot like the VAT they have in Europe and the GST we have in Canada, is neutral, so that it applies to goods … there's no distinction in terms of imports and exports. So we're going to continue to have these discussion and make our case.' Asked if retaining the digital services tax is a red line for Canada in the current trade dispute with the U.S., Champagne said, 'Listen, the tax is in Canada, the tax applies and will apply.' Carney's surprise scheduling of a news conference Thursday afternoon set back a planned news conference by the Canadian Steel Producers Association and the United Steel Workers, who were set to outline their urgent call for immediate action as the 50 per cent steel tariffs Trump imposed are squeezing domestic producers. They have previously called for the full imposition of tit-for-tat counter-tariffs against U.S. steel without any exemptions. During the election campaign, the Carney government authorized exemptions for Canadian imports of U.S. steel and aluminum products — called remissions — that amount to about $8 billion. But most of those exemptions favour importers of American steel, which Canadian steel producers say has given their competitors an advantage.
New York Post
24 minutes ago
- New York Post
Armies of Kremlin and Iran bots aimed at attempting to destroy MAGA: report
Russia and Iran are targeting the Make America Great Again movement and trying to 'destabilize the right from within,' according to a new report. Both rogue states are using tens of thousands of social media bots to amplify untrue voices and opinions 'masquerading as MAGA loyalists,' to cause chaos and confusion and question US leadership, The Post has learned. The bots are automated software applications that mimic human activity on social media. Advertisement They are used to amplify real-life influencers who post untrue 'false flag' narratives designed to discredit President Donald Trump and his conservative stalwarts, according to a bombshell new report from the Network Contagion Research Institute, a politically neutral nonprofit who study extremism on the web. 5 The same foreign playbook that undid the Democratic party is trying to destroy MAGA from within, according to a new NCRI report. REUTERS 'If you talk to Republicans right now, more than 80 percent of them support the war against Iran. But if you go on Twitter you get the sense that there is a civil war raging. Advertisement 'This is exactly the purpose of the psychological operation — to destabilize people's perceptions of institutions that are supposed to protect us,' said an NCRI analyst. The bots make it look like extreme posters have tons more support than they actually have, which helps to persuade other real life viewers that what they are posting is legitimate. The bots use innocuous, average names and have profiles which make them appear as average Americans. NCRI says after domestic attacks, including the Uvalde school shooting, Matthew Crooks assassination attempt on Donald Trump and the murder of two Israeli embassy staffers in Washington DC in May it has noticed an alarming trend of a 'false flag reflex'. Advertisement 'Within minutes of initial reports [the events are recast] as evidence of hidden conspiratorial plots, obscuring the true motives and perpetrators. 'In the days following these crises, Kremlin-affiliated propagandists and Iranian state-linked media are able to rapidly inject narratives that are taken up by MAGA-impostor influencers, who then inject them into MAGA-branded spaces,' the report notes. 5 Noctis Draven, who is a regular consultant for Kremlin media, spread the 'false flag' story about the murder of two Israeli staffers in an attempt to push a conspiracy theory that Israel was behind the deaths. Network Contagion Research Institute 5 Evidence from a Network Contagion Research Institute's report showing bots spreading misinformation calling real events 'false flags' Network Contagion Research Institute Advertisement The group points to Draven Noctis, a real person and US veteran who frequently contributes to Russian state media, and has a potential reach of 2.4 million with more than 180,000 followers on X. 'It's so expensive in the US and Canada that even refugees can't understand how we make it,' he says in a 2024 TikTok post while describing the US as a 'slave system' designed to impoverish its own citizens. 'We are free range humans in an open-air prison of taxes and bulls–t distractions and we think it's completely normal,' he continues. In an earlier post on EurAsia Daily, a Kremlin propaganda outlet, he is shown in military uniform urging Ukrainian soldiers to defect to Russia. The message is written in Cyrillic alphabet, propaganda which is then republished by bots. 5 Jackson Hinkle, a social media influencer, spreads anti-Western conspiracies to his more than three million X followers. Getty Images The 'false flag' narrative surrounding the murder of two Israeli embassy staffers in May – absurdly attempting to claim the man charged with the shooting was, in fact, working on behalf of Israel – was another case in point, the nonprofit says. 'Foreign-linked seeders, such as Noctis, inject crisis narratives within minutes of breaking news. Their content is then mass-republished by clusters of inauthentic accounts, according to the NCRI report. 'Domestic personalities with large but unstable followings – [such as noted trolls like] Jackson Hinkle supply a veneer of grassroots legitimacy, completing an 'asset-adjacency' model in which fringe US influencers ride the same engagement farms that propel Kremlin messaging,' the NCRI report says. Between May 1 and June 10, NCRI recorded 675,000 posts on X referencing 'false flag' and drawing nearly four million interactions, according to the report, adding activity spiked in two sharp bursts: on May 24 after the embassy shooting and on June 3 after the firebombing of a Jewish demonstration in Boulder. Advertisement 5 X user Red Pill Media claims to be based in the US, but was found to originate in Karachi, Pakistan. Eyal Yakoby/ Red Pill Media/ X 'False-flag allegations occupy a privileged corner of Russian hybrid-warfare doctrine: a ready-made, easily adaptable alibi that flips blame, muddies attribution, and buys time for diplomatic misdirection,' the report says. For instance, a tweet from 'Red Pill Media,' which identifies itself as 'exposing Zionist terrorism' and has nearly 81,000 followers on its X account claims to be based in the US, but another user recently revealed that the account belongs to Abdul Abbas in Karachi, Pakistan. Working through firebrand right wing social media influencers, Kremlin-affiliated propagandists also conducted 'a coordinated assault' against Trump, according to the report. Advertisement 'It's a combination of an artificial voice with a real voice,' said an analyst with NCRI. 'It destroyed the Democratic party and now they are going after MAGA.' The network is quick to jump on and twist almost any story in the news cycle, and have recently trained their sights on President Trump, NCRI says. 'The network's goals extend beyond crisis exploitation,' the report says. 'After leveraging the false-flag frame to pose as MAGA loyalists, the same actors pivoted to accuse Donald Trump of pedophilia and to disseminate Iranian state leaks portraying IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) as an Israeli proxy.'
New York Post
36 minutes ago
- New York Post
Breakthrough cure for baldness: 100% of male mice regrew fur with new treatment
It's the bald truth. Researchers at San Carlos Clinical Hospital in Madrid have developed a cure for androgenetic alopecia, commonly known as pattern hair loss. An estimated 80 million Americans — 50 million men and 30 million women — experience some form of alopecia, although it affects women differently than men. Advertisement Researchers at San Carlos Clinical Hospital in Madrid have developed a cure for androgenetic alopecia — commonly known as pattern hair loss. Phimchanok – Men usually go through a receding hairline and bald spots, whereas women get thinner at the part line but rarely go fully bald. In the study — published in the journal Stem Cell Research and Therapy — researchers used a combo of fat‑tissue-derived stem cells and the energy molecule ATP to reverse hair loss in mice, with shocking results. Advertisement All of the male mice grew back their coats. Half had full regrowth, while the other half had intensive regrowth. Among females, a whopping 90% saw intense or complete hair revival. Eduardo López Bran, head of the Dermatology Department at the Hospital Clínico San Carlos, explained that their special method 'stimulates hair regeneration by combining the regenerative capacity of the former with the energy provided by the latter. This synergy favors the recovery of the hair follicle, promoting hair growth.' While the findings will need to be replicated in human trials, the results pave a promising way forward in the fight against hair loss. Advertisement All of the male mice grew back their coats. Among females, a whopping 90% saw intense or complete hair revival. Javier – 'In the future, we will be able to offer new solutions that allow us to meet patients' expectations, allowing them access to new treatments that prioritize their well-being,' Eduardo López Bran said. It's an exciting development in an area where there's plenty of room for growth. Advertisement While hair transplant surgery is on the rise, many people don't realize that it actually often takes several procedures to achieve the desired result. 'An alarming trend is patients who now go to perform a hair transplant by a physician who does not consult the patient about his or her hair loss nor is he actively involved in the surgery,' Texas facial plastic surgeon and hair restoration expert Dr. Samuel Lam previously told The Post. He noted that this troubling practice is 'most rampant' in Turkey — where hair transplant surgery has exploded due to its relative affordability — but it is 'also extremely prevalent in the US, unfortunately.' Meanwhile, some men have been vocal about how post-finasteride syndrome (PFS) — a condition in which someone experiences severe side effects after they stop using finasteride — has completely upended their lives. One woman even recently chronicled how PFS destroyed her husband's sex drive — and ended their marriage. Researchers are racing to find new, safer and more affordable hair loss treatments, inventing non-hormonal pills and gummies and repurposing older drugs to find a sustainable solution.
