
This Exhibit Asks Whether Surrealism Would Have Been Better Without Its Leading Men
On October 15, 1924, André Breton published a manifesto that was as notable for its belligerence as its egotism. Striving to define one of the most influential artistic movements of the 20th century, his Surrealist Manifesto laid claim to 'the actual functioning of thought… exempt from any aesthetic or moral concern.' Together with eighteen collaborators – predominantly poets and painters – Breton declared 'the omnipotence of dream' and provided a scheme for trouncing the 'reign of logic' through the practice of 'psychic automatism'.
Leonora Carrington. Darvaux, 1950. Oil on canvas. 80 × 65 cm. Colección particular. © 2025, Estate of Leonora Carrington / VEGAP. Photo: Willem Schalkwijk
Willem Schalkwijk
But Breton was not the only one with designs on surrealism. Earlier in the same month, a poet named Yvan Goll published his own Surrealist Manifesto, backed by a completely different group of artistic confederates, standing for a completely different ideal. 'Reality is the basis of all great art,' he proclaimed. 'Without it there is no life, no substance.'
The terms of disagreement were no mere coincidence. Goll set 'the emanation of life' in opposition to the exaltation of 'the dream and the random play of thought' that he attributed to 'ex-Dadaists' such as Breton. Goll's vision of Surrealism was situated in 'the ground under our feet and the sky over our head'.
Even though Goll was the first to publish a manifesto of Surrealism – and in spite of the care he took to align himself with Guillaume Apollinaire, the poet who coined the term surreal in 1917 – Breton took such a forceful position that he effectively ousted Goll from art history. Breton's victory can partially be attributed to the relative novelty of his project (which transplanted Freud from the clinic to the gallery), in contrast to Goll's vaguer claims to radical change. To an even greater extent, Breton's triumph was achieved with aggressive ambition. (Concurrent with the publication of his manifesto, he and his collaborators established a Bureau for Surrealist Research in Paris. Ostensibly set up to study the 'unconscious activity of the mind', the bureau also issued letters to perceived enemies who called themselves Surrealists without permission, threatening to track them down and beat them to a pulp.)
A century after the publication of Breton's manifesto, the identification of Surrealism with Breton's circle is scarcely questioned, even by the select few who know about his rivalry with Goll. Without challenging these historical facts, a major exhibition at the Fundación MAPFRE in Madrid beguilingly sets out to explore 'Surrealism without Breton'.
It should be stated upfront that 1924. Other Surrealisms is hardly a work of alternative history. The museum does not ask visitors to imagine that Breton had never been born, or to ask what would have happened if Goll had somehow outmaneuvered him. (Consistent with his historical erasure, Goll doesn't rank a single mention in the Fundación MAPFRE's 300-page exhibition catalogue.) Instead the exhibition curator emphasizes much of what Breton ignored or squelched within the realm of psychic automatism. In that sense, 1924 continues the efforts art historians have made since at least the 1980s, notably advanced several years ago in the Metropolitan Museum of Art's Surrealism Beyond Borders. As scholarship becomes more encyclopedic, Surrealism benefits from greater inclusiveness. Approached as a phenomenon instead of a movement, Surrealism can encompass the work of artists who never enrolled in Breton's program (such as Joan Miró), those who were 'excommunicated' (such as Salvador Dalí), and those who were marginalized (such as Remedios Varo).
Remedios Varo. Icon, 1945. Oil, mother-of-pearl inlay and gold leaf on panel. 60 × 70 × 35 cm. Colección MALBA. Museo de Arte Latinoamericano de Buenos Aires 1997.02 © Remedios Varo; VEGAP, Madrid, 2025 Photo: Nicolás Beraza
Nicolás Beraza
There is real merit to this curatorial reconsideration of the artistic activity surrounding André Breton and his Bureau for Surrealist Research. His myopia was at least as deleterious to the liberation of the unconscious mind as his charisma were beneficial. Much is achieved through the simple act of exhibiting the numinous paintings of Varo and those of other women such as Leonora Carrington and Dorothea Tanning, who the misogynist Breton counted as muses rather than artists. Their work rewards the eye and mind to a greater extent than many of the more familiar paintings of more famous Surrealist men.
And yet the invitation to explore Surrealism without Breton has the potential to be more generative than curators have heretofore allowed (even without entering into fantasies that his adversaries beat him up and chased him out of town). During the rivalry of 1924, Goll's ally Paul Dermée justly chastised Breton for 'monopoliz[ing] a movement of literary and artistic renewal that dates from well before his time and that in scope goes far beyond his fidgety little person'. The question that naturally arises is this: What might Surrealists have achieved had Surrealism been more inclusive while the Surrealists were alive?
Breton presented Surrealism as pure and restrictive. Whereas Dada had upset the artistic and sociopolitical status quo with a panoply of absurdist antics, Surrealism was approached as a research and development program that would leverage Dadaist gains to complete the societal revolution that Apollinaire and his fellow agitators started. Logic would be supplanted in favor of a deeper truth revealed through Freudian psychology. For Breton, art was operational. Artists were enlisted to plumb surreality and to popularize it. The inherent orthodoxy of his premise excluded all other alternatives to narrow-minded rationalism and its ethical constraints. Goll's position is far too amorphous to extrapolate what his allies would have attempted (though his inclusion of the arch-Dadaist Tristan Tzara was auspicious).
One reason why Breton's Surrealism ultimately proved so facile on aesthetic and moral grounds is that his methodology amounted to pseudo-science yet lacked the self-awareness to embrace its own phoniness (in contrast, for instance, to the performative irony of Dadaist pataphysics). Another reason is that it was built on the contradictory impulses to liberate the unconscious and to police those whose psyches were freed. Other Surrealisms that were genuinely different might have enriched Breton's project. They might have realized the potential he identified in his Manifesto to an even greater degree than the Surrealist works of women who proved better at pursuing his premises than the men he anointed.
Dorothea Tanning. Birthday, 1942. Oil on canvas 102,2 × 64,8 cm. Philadelphia Museum of Art. 125th Anniversary Acquisition. Adquirido con fondos aportados por C. K. Williams, II, 1999 1999-50-1. © Dorothéa Tanning; VEGAP, Madrid, 2025 ©Philadelphia Museum of Art
Philadelphia Museum of Art
When he sought surreality in 'the ground under our feet and the sky over our head', Yvan Goll provided at least one hint about what might be found there. 'Everything the artist creates has its point of departure in nature,' he wrote in his Manifesto. The strangeness that nature was already revealing as he wrote – from Einstein's General Relativity to the first inklings of quantum reality – has proven at least as unsettling as Freud's ideas about the human mind. The interaction of a Surrealism born out of physical phenomena with one emanating from psychology might have achieved the revolution sought by Breton and by the Dadaists before him.
Otherness is the most potent quality of art as a sociopolitical proposition. Only a fidgety little person would seek to control it.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Netflix's #1 Show 'Sirens' Is Bringing Preppy Back—Here's How to Wear It This Summer
PureWow editors select every item that appears on this page, and some items may be gifted to us. Additionally, PureWow may earn compensation through affiliate links within the story. All prices are accurate upon date of publish. You can learn more about the affiliate process here. You can learn more about that process here. Yahoo Inc. may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below. Read the original article on Purewow. The White Lotus might be over, but there's a new show all about wealth and power that everyone's talking about right now—Sirens. The Netflix series follows sisters Simone and Devon DeWitt, as Simone is drawn into the glamorous world of a wealthy Port Haven family while Devon questions what's really going on. And it's not just the twisty plot that has viewers hooked—the fashion is just as captivating. The looks are totally what you'd expect of a show set on a Nantucket-esque island (the fictional Port Haven)—think perfectly preppy outfits like colorful Lilly Pulitzer dresses ($188) and pieces that easily embody this year's fisherman aesthetic trend like classic Breton tees ($128). Below, find eight styles to make you feel like you stepped right off the set. Want to know which buzzy products are *really* worth buying? Sign up for our shopping newsletter to uncover our favorite finds. Courtesy of Netflix Lily Pulitzer If you adored the bold pink dress Simone (Milly Alcock) donned in episode one, you're gonna want to grab this one that has a super similar style while it's still in stock. The dress is made from a breezy, 100 percent linen fabric that will feel light in the summer heat and it comes in a bunch of different colors and patterns. So when you fall in love with it like other reviewers who call it a "closet staple" have, you can pick it up in a second style. $188 at Lilly PUlitzer Speaking of staples, linen shorts are a must-have for any coastal-inspired wardrobe, and you can grab this pair from for $30 off right now. The stretchy waistband is sure to keep you comfy while you wear them from brunch to the beach and they're machine-washable, too, so you can wear them over and over this sumer. $70; $40 at Tuckernuck From the crochet material to the crisp white trim, this top is preppy perfection. The body of the shirt is lined so you don't have to stress over it being see-through or finding the perfect layer to wear underneath. Not to mention, the boxy fit is ideal to keep you cool and, according to reviewers, it fits true-to-size. $148 at Tuckernuck H&M This breezy sundress *belongs* near the beach, and at just $40, how can you resist? The seashell pattern is totally on-trend, too, (although it does come in two other tropical prints if you prefer) and the ties on the straps will allow you to easily adjust how high or low the neckline sits—could it get any better?! $40 at H&M Gorjana While Simone's exact Nantucket necklace will easily set you back more than $1,000, this bold heart necklace from Gorjana is a fab (and much more attainable) alternative to the necklace Devon (Meghann Fahy) dons throughout the show. But don't worry, shoppers say this one still looks way more expensive than it is. "This is one of my favorite pieces of jewelry from Gorjana!! This necklace looks and feels like a much more expensive piece of jewelry," said one reviewer. Plus, you can easily switch out the heart charm to another design if you want, or add on any extras to mix it up. $153 at Gorjana Vineyard Vines The cotton/modal blend fabric of this printed Vineyard Vines top that could easily be seen on anyone visiting Port Haven is so soft that you'll want to wear it on repeat. It's available in a wide range of sizes from XXS to 3X and comes in both this pretty blue and a pink pattern that I think Simone would just adore. BTW, if you want to make it a whole outfit, you can pair it with this matching smocked skirt made from the same soft, light material. From $128; $52 at Vineyard Vines Free People Michaela/"Kiki" (Julianne Moore) is constantly donning light, flowy sets that look as comfortable as they do elegant, and this linen-blend one from Free People totally feels like something she'd be seen wearing. The straps are adjustable thanks to the tie-back design, and you have a bunch of colors to choose from—so go ahead and get one in your cart while you still can. $88 at Free People Buck Mason You simply can't build a preppy seaside wardrobe without a good Breton tee. I can confirm just how good Buck Mason's cotton shirts are, and this one's bound to be no exception—especially if you take reviewers' words for it. One shared, "This knit is outstanding. [It's] substantial but not bulky and [easily] sheds wrinkles (after I had the sleeves tucked and rolled the entire day). [It] would be great for travel use, work at home, lounge—whatever you need, this will do it." Well, I'm sold. $128 at Buck Mason These 23 'White Lotus'-Inspired Styles Will Have You *So* Ready for a Vacation PureWow's editors and writers have spent more than a decade shopping online, digging through sales and putting our home goods, beauty finds, wellness picks and more through the wringer—all to help you determine which are actually worth your hard-earned cash. From our PureWow100 series (where we rank items on a 100-point scale) to our painstakingly curated lists of fashion, beauty, cooking, home and family picks, you can trust that our recommendations have been thoroughly vetted for function, aesthetics and innovation. Whether you're looking for travel-size hair dryers you can take on-the-go or women's walking shoes that won't hurt your feet, we've got you covered.


USA Today
10 hours ago
- USA Today
'Sadly, largely true': Ex-Newsboys singer speaks on sexual assault allegations
'Sadly, largely true': Ex-Newsboys singer speaks on sexual assault allegations Michael Tait, former lead singer of Christian rock band Newsboys, has admitted to wrongdoing after allegations of sexual assault surfaced. Tait, 59, took to social media on June 10 to share his side of the story, telling fans in a statement titled "My Confession" that a recent report detailing his drug and alcohol abuse and sexual activity are "sadly, largely true." "For some two decades I used and abused cocaine, consumed far too much alcohol, and, at times, touched men in an unwanted sensual way. I am ashamed of my life choices and actions, and make no excuses for them," he wrote. "I will simply call it what God calls it-sin." Tait's admission comes nearly a week after his bandmates released their own statement addressing the allegations highlighted in a years-long investigation by Christian media outlet The Roys Report. Three men, who were all 22 at the time of their encounters, told the outlet that Tait befriended them and later engaged in non-consensual sexual acts with them. Tait made friends with the men while on tour in 2004, 2010 and 2014, according to The Roys Report. "Last night, our hearts were shattered when we read the news alleging drug abuse and inappropriate sexual actions by our former lead singer, Michael Tait," the Nashville-based band shared in a June 5 statement. "While Michael has not addressed these allegations, we are devastated even by the implications." The statement continued: "First and foremost, our hearts are with the victims who have bravely shared their stories. If you are a victim, we urge you to come forward. We absolutely do not condone any form of sexual assault." Who is Michael Tait? Tait was the former lead singer of Australian-formed Christian rock band Newsboys. The four-time Grammy-award winning vocalist replaced original member Peter Furler as the group's new lead vocalist in 2009. Tait officially left the group in January 2025 after 15 years. Before he performed with Newsboys, Tait was a founding member of DC Talks, a Christian rap and rock trio, that released five major studio albums together. Newsboys 'horrified, heartbroken, and angry' by report Tait's bandmates were "horrified, heartbroken, and angry" to learn of the accusations made in the report, writing in the statement that they felt as though they and their families were "deceived for the last fifteen years." "The four of us are husbands and fathers. Between the four of us, we have fourteen children," the band said in the statement. "Our wives and children have made many sacrifices while we have dedicated our lives to playing music together that glorifies God." In the statement, Newsboys members also revealed that Tait confessed to them and management that he had "been living a double-life" when he abruptly left the band in January. Tait, who said he does not blame anyone or anything besides himself, said he left Newsboys earlier this year "to get help." "I was not healthy, physically or spiritually, and tired of leading a double life," Tait wrote. "I spent six weeks at a treatment center in Utah, receiving help that may have saved my life from ultimate destruction. I have been clean and sober since, though I still lots of hard work ahead of me." Read Michael Tait's full statement Contributing: Marcus K. Dowling, The Tennessean, part of the USA TODAY Network
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
Harvey Weinstein Rape Retrial Descends Into Chaos Amid Split Verdicts, Jury Tensions & Threats
A week into jury deliberations on Harvey Weinstein's New York rape retrial, the proceedings appear to be descending into chaos. The jurors just informed Judge Curtis Farber that they have reached a split verdict: guilty on Count 1 of a criminal sexual act in the first degree against Miriam Haley, not guilty of the same charge involving Kaja Sokola and no verdict on Jessica Mann. In this retrial, each count of first-degree criminal sexual act carries a maximum sentence of 25 years. More from Deadline Patricia Clarkson Recalls Harvey Weinstein Telling Her She'd 'Never Work Again' Warner Bros Discovery Hits Back At Russell Simmons' "Unfounded Allegations" In Ex-Mogul's $20M Suit Over 2020 Sexual Assault Documentary - Update Channel 4 Says It Doesn't Use NDAs, But Documents Reveal Company Is Curbing Free Speech Of Aggrieved Ex-Employees Tensions have been running high among the panelists all week, including apparent threats of violence from one juror against another and multiple complaints by jurors to Farber. Earlier today, the foreman of the seven-woman, five-man just told the judge, 'I can't go back in there with the other jurors.' Farber had confirmed hostilities among jurors, including some 'yelling and screaming.' The jury revealed its partial ruling at the request of Farber, who sent the panelists home early today to allow them time away from one another before they resume their deliberations on the last remaining, undecided charge involving Mann. As these near-unprecedented circumstances unfold, Weinstein himself addressed the judge this morning and asked for a mistrial. 'This is my life that's on the line, this is not fair,' said Weinstein, who saw his 23-year sentence from a 2020 conviction dismissed by an appeals court last year. 'I'm not getting a fair trial,' the ailing, 73-year-old added to Judge Farber. As he has before, the judge rejected the request for a mistrial. With Weinstein accused of assaulting numerous well-known actresses and models over the decades, prosecutors in the most benign way say he used his power and influence as an Oscar-winning producer and boss of mini-major Miramax to lure young women into his orbit. Offering what almost always were false promises of work and careers in film and television, they say Weinstein then often violently raped them or forced them into other unwanted sexual encounters. Weinstein, who won a Best Picture Oscar for Shakespeare in Love and also helped produce Pulp Fiction, The English Patient, Good Will Hunting, True Romance and many more films, always has maintained that the sexual relationships were consensual. 'They're all women with broken dreams,' his defense lawyer Arthur Aidala said in closing arguments last week. 'They're all women who wanted to cut the line.' We will update this post as new details emerge. Erik Pedersen contributed to this report. Best of Deadline Sean 'Diddy' Combs Sex-Trafficking Trial Updates: Cassie Ventura's Testimony, $10M Hotel Settlement, Drugs, Violence, & The Feds A Full Timeline Of Blake Lively & Justin Baldoni's 'It Ends With Us' Feud In Court, Online & In The Media Sean "Diddy" Combs: An Updated Timeline Of Charges, Allegations & Consequences The Rap Mogul Faces