Scientists skeptical about recent claims that signs of life were possibly detected on exoplanet
But on April 17, a study was published revealing that a team of astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), led by Nikku Madhusudhan, had discovered gases on an exoplanet called K2-18b that could only be produced by life.
Right off the bat, many astronomers were a little skeptical about the claim, saying there wasn't robust evidence to support the findings.
"Discoveries like this ... usually takes a long time to confirm, and many times it turned out not true," Yanqin Wu told CBC News on the day it was announced. "That's just the disappointment in real scientific endeavour. Extraordinary claims usually takes a lot of proof and usually are wrong."
Now, a new independent analysis of the JWST data has found no evidence of biosignatures, signs that the planet's gases may have a biological origin.
Madhusudhan and his colleagues used data collected from JWST of the planet passing in front of its host star, K2-18, and the different molecules that were observed in the spectra. This method is useful for determining which chemicals are in the air of a planet.
The study found the presence of two gases — dimethyl sulfide, or DMS, and dimethyl disulfide, or DMDS — which are typically produced on Earth by algae.
But Jake Taylor, a planetary scientist who also studies exoplanets using JWST data, used that data and examined it using a different method than the Madhusudhan-led study and was unable to replicate the findings. He published his results on the pre-print site ArXiv.
WATCH | Scientists make 'major breakthrough' in search for life outside solar system:
Scientists make 'major breakthrough' in search for life outside solar system
12 days ago
Duration 1:43
Prof. Nikku Madhusudhan, a Cambridge University astrophysicist, says the discovery of two gases — dimethyl sulfide, or DMS, and dimethyl disulfide, or DMDS — in the atmosphere of a planet will be seen as a 'paradigm shift in our search for life.' Scientists used NASA's James Webb Space Telescope to make the discovery about K2-18 b, a planet found about 124 light-years from Earth.
In his method, he used an "agnostic" approach, meaning he didn't look for any sulfur gases that could be signs of life like there are here on Earth. The result was a "flat line" rather than any wiggles in the data, meaning that the dips found in the initial study were statistical noise — random information that can effect study results.
Taylor said he was excited about the study and thought it was good in some ways, but "when it came to the atmospheric physics side, I noticed that they didn't give too much detail about their flat-line rejection tests."
He explained these tests are "kind of a standard within the field" to do first in order to ensure there isn't noise in the data.
He said he did speak with Madhusudhan personally about this last week, who reassured him that the rejection tests had been conducted, though they weren't contained in the study itself.
Though he said the current data from JWST didn't provide enough confidence in a biosignature detection, it doesn't mean it couldn't happen with additional data.
"It's a good first step in in this sort of endeavour, because this is a spectral range we've never seen before. So just that in itself is pretty cool," Taylor said. "We definitely would need more observations to get a better signal. And who knows, it might pop out, it might be there. It's just right now, the signal-to-noise ratio is not definitive."
Asked if there needs to be more rigorous examinations of such claims, Taylor said, "I think there needs to be more discussions about this. I do personally think that there needs to be multiple lines of evidence, and also there needs to be like a model independent confirmation that we see something."
Taylor admitted he was a big fan of The X-Files, a sci-fi show that largely focused on finding proof of alien life on Earth. Its most touted catchphrase was "I want to believe."
He also noted that planetary scientists looking for signs of life on exoplanets do really want to one day find that robust sign of life, though it's not like we could ever visit the exoplanet to confirm with certainty.
"We want to believe," he said. "But we want to do it correctly."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
3 days ago
Concordia students send Starsailor rocket flying and enter the history books
Students from Concordia University cheered and whistled as the Starsailor rocket lifted off on Cree territory, marking the first of its size to be launched by a student team. At 5:34 a.m. ET, the rocket blasted off in a flash of light, captured in a livestream (new window) posted to YouTube, from a base camp about 250 kilometres north of Mistissini, in northern Quebec. This is insane, said student Shua Kalmanson looking up at the cloud of smoke created by the rocket's separation. The mission is a collaborative effort between the Space Concordia Rocketry Division and members of the local Cree community. Mistissini council member Pamela MacLeod said when she first heard about the student's request to launch the rocket in Mistissini, she though it was strange but interesting. This is, you know, something very different ... never had something like this happen within our territory, she said. And at the same time really looking at it as an opportunity for all our community members, our elders, to see something like this happen within our territory and be part of that. Friday's launch was the team's third attempt after the first two launch dates were cancelled due to unfavourable meteorological conditions. The students hoped Starsailor would enter space, past the Kármán line which is at an altitude of 100 kilometres. But, the rocket separated earlier than expected, potentially stifling its ascent. Concordia professor Hoi Dick Ng said the team will only find out whether the rocket actually made it into space once it retrieves and analyzes the debris. If it travelled far enough, the Starsailor would be the world's first student-built liquid-fuel rocket to reach space, Canada's first space launch in over 25 years, and the first to be achieved by a team of students, according to the university. LISTEN | Daybreak Montreal: Concordia's student built rocket - Starsailor - takes off! (new window) Hannah Halcro, who's been involved with the project since its inception seven years ago, told livestream audiences that despite the setback, everyone is pretty darn happy. We haven't been able to test the structure itself, we can only do simulations and simulations are not reality, so now we know. Over the next couple of days, the recovery team will be working on finding and recovering the rocket with the help of local helicopter pilots. Originally built for a science competition, the rocket was left without a contest after the event was cancelled, due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Nevertheless, the team, made up of 700 members, pressed forward with the goal of making history and launching the biggest student-built rocket. See you in space next time, said Halcro, before turning away from the camera and joining a group of people celebrating in the background. Cassandra Yanez-Leyton (new window) · CBC News · Journalist Cassandra Yanez-Leyton is a journalist for CBC News based in Montreal. You can email her story ideas at With files from Gloria Henriquez, Vanna Blacksmith and CBC Daybreak
5 days ago
Was it a plane? Was it a UFO? Bright light over Quebec captivates stargazers
With eyes turned to the skies, stargazers taking in the Perseid meteor shower on Tuesday night witnessed something out of this world. In a publication on Facebook, the Astrolab du parc national du Mont-Mégantic (new window) in Quebec's Eastern Townships described it as a magnificent and luminous spiral streaking across the sky at around 10:40 p.m. Several people in the Montreal area also witnessed the strange phenomenon and reached out to CBC News describing a bright light enveloped by a fuzzy halo and warning of a UFO sighting. While it was certainly unusual, it wasn't really an unidentified flying object, but more likely the result of a rocket launch, according to the Astrolab. It was in all likelihood the second stage of an Ariane 6 rocket which was igniting its engine in order to de-orbit itself after having released the European satellite Metop-SGA1 in a polar orbit, the Facebook post explained. Astronomers may have discovered 3rd-known interstellar visitor (new window) The European Space Agency confirmed on its website that a weather satellite was launched Tuesday evening at 9:37 p.m. local time, from the European spaceport in Kourou, French Guiana — an overseas department of France located in South America. The new satellite is meant to usher in a new era of weather and climate monitoring from polar orbit. Enlarge image (new window) A bright spiraling light in the sky was confirmed to be part of a spacecraft. Photo: Submitted by Alexis Sanchez According to astrophysicist Robert Lamontagne, the rocket's orbit is what allowed for the spectacle to be visible in Quebec. Most of the time rocket launches are on an equatorial orbit and so will be visible near the equator, he said. In a polar orbit, the rocket has to go around the earth circling each pole of the planet. So the the trajectory of that the rocket made it so that from our latitude it could be seen in Montreal or the south of Quebec, he said. But to witness the phenomena, other factors also need to align, according to Lamontagne, including the time of launch and the altitude reached by the rocket. From our point of view, we were in the dark, the sun was low below the horizon, but the rocket itself was so high that it was still lit by the by the sun, he said. And as the second stage of the rocket re-entered the earth's atmosphere, he said, it was spinning a little bit, there was exhaust gases coming out from it and that's what people saw in the sky. A spokesperson for the Canadian Space Agency told CBC News that many observers captured video of the event, with the agency confirming it was the ESA's Ariane 6 rocket. Annabelle Olivier (new window) · CBC News · Journalist Annabelle Olivier is a digital journalist at CBC Montreal. She previously worked at Global News as an online producer. You can reach her at With files from Gloria Henriquez
CBC
5 days ago
- CBC
Was it a plane? Was it a UFO? Bright light over Quebec skies captivates stargazers
Social Sharing With eyes turned to the skies, stargazers taking in the Perseid meteor shower on Tuesday night witnessed something out of this world. In a publication on Facebook, the Astrolab du parc national du Mont-Mégantic in Quebec's Eastern Townships, described it as "a magnificent and luminous spiral streaking across the sky at around 10:40 p.m." Several people in the Montreal area also witnessed the strange phenomenon and reached out to CBC News describing a bright light enveloped by a fuzzy halo and warning of a UFO sighting. While it was certainly unusual, it wasn't really an unidentified flying object, but more likely the result of a rocket launch, according to the Astrolab. "It was in all likelihood the second stage of an Ariane 6 rocket which was igniting its engine in order to de-orbit itself after having released the European satellite Metop-SGA1 in a polar orbit," the Facebook post explained. The European Space Agency confirmed on its website that a weather satellite was launched Tuesday evening at 9:37 p.m. local time, from the European spaceport in Kourou, French Guiana — an overseas department of France located in South America. The new satellite is meant to usher in "a new era of weather and climate monitoring from polar orbit." According to astrophysicist Robert Lamontagne, the rocket's orbit is what allowed for the spectacle to be visible in Quebec. Most of the time rocket launches are on an equatorial orbit and so will be visible near the equator, he said. In a polar orbit, the rocket has to go around the earth circling each pole of the planet. "So the the trajectory of that the rocket made it so that from our latitude it could be seen in Montreal or the south of Quebec," he said. But to witness the phenomena, other factors also need to align, according to Lamontagne, including the time of launch and the altitude reached by the rocket. "From our point of view, we were in the dark, the sun was low below the horizon, but the rocket itself was so high that it was still lit by the by the sun," he said. And as the second stage of the rocket re-entered the earth's atmosphere, he said, "it was spinning a little bit, there was exhaust gases coming out from it and that's what people saw in the sky."
