Latest news with #ArXiv
CBC
29-04-2025
- Science
- CBC
Scientists skeptical about recent claims that signs of life were possibly detected on exoplanet
The search for life beyond our own planet is something that astronomers have been doing for decades now, with no results. But on April 17, a study was published revealing that a team of astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), led by Nikku Madhusudhan, had discovered gases on an exoplanet called K2-18b that could only be produced by life. Right off the bat, many astronomers were a little skeptical about the claim, saying there wasn't robust evidence to support the findings. "Discoveries like this ... usually takes a long time to confirm, and many times it turned out not true," Yanqin Wu told CBC News on the day it was announced. "That's just the disappointment in real scientific endeavour. Extraordinary claims usually takes a lot of proof and usually are wrong." Now, a new independent analysis of the JWST data has found no evidence of biosignatures, signs that the planet's gases may have a biological origin. Madhusudhan and his colleagues used data collected from JWST of the planet passing in front of its host star, K2-18, and the different molecules that were observed in the spectra. This method is useful for determining which chemicals are in the air of a planet. The study found the presence of two gases — dimethyl sulfide, or DMS, and dimethyl disulfide, or DMDS — which are typically produced on Earth by algae. But Jake Taylor, a planetary scientist who also studies exoplanets using JWST data, used that data and examined it using a different method than the Madhusudhan-led study and was unable to replicate the findings. He published his results on the pre-print site ArXiv. WATCH | Scientists make 'major breakthrough' in search for life outside solar system: Scientists make 'major breakthrough' in search for life outside solar system 12 days ago Duration 1:43 Prof. Nikku Madhusudhan, a Cambridge University astrophysicist, says the discovery of two gases — dimethyl sulfide, or DMS, and dimethyl disulfide, or DMDS — in the atmosphere of a planet will be seen as a 'paradigm shift in our search for life.' Scientists used NASA's James Webb Space Telescope to make the discovery about K2-18 b, a planet found about 124 light-years from Earth. In his method, he used an "agnostic" approach, meaning he didn't look for any sulfur gases that could be signs of life like there are here on Earth. The result was a "flat line" rather than any wiggles in the data, meaning that the dips found in the initial study were statistical noise — random information that can effect study results. Taylor said he was excited about the study and thought it was good in some ways, but "when it came to the atmospheric physics side, I noticed that they didn't give too much detail about their flat-line rejection tests." He explained these tests are "kind of a standard within the field" to do first in order to ensure there isn't noise in the data. He said he did speak with Madhusudhan personally about this last week, who reassured him that the rejection tests had been conducted, though they weren't contained in the study itself. Though he said the current data from JWST didn't provide enough confidence in a biosignature detection, it doesn't mean it couldn't happen with additional data. "It's a good first step in in this sort of endeavour, because this is a spectral range we've never seen before. So just that in itself is pretty cool," Taylor said. "We definitely would need more observations to get a better signal. And who knows, it might pop out, it might be there. It's just right now, the signal-to-noise ratio is not definitive." Asked if there needs to be more rigorous examinations of such claims, Taylor said, "I think there needs to be more discussions about this. I do personally think that there needs to be multiple lines of evidence, and also there needs to be like a model independent confirmation that we see something." Taylor admitted he was a big fan of The X-Files, a sci-fi show that largely focused on finding proof of alien life on Earth. Its most touted catchphrase was "I want to believe." He also noted that planetary scientists looking for signs of life on exoplanets do really want to one day find that robust sign of life, though it's not like we could ever visit the exoplanet to confirm with certainty. "We want to believe," he said. "But we want to do it correctly."
Yahoo
22-02-2025
- Science
- Yahoo
Astronomers discover 'Quipu,' the single largest structure in the known universe
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. Astronomers have discovered what may be the largest-scale structure in the known universe — a group of galaxy clusters and clusters of galaxy clusters that spans roughly 1.3 billion light-years across and contains a mind-boggling 200 quadrillion solar masses. The newfound structure is dubbed Quipu after an Incan system of counting and storing numbers using knots on cords. Like a Quipu cord, the structure is complex, made up of one long filament and multiple side filaments. It spans roughly 1.3 billion light-years (more than 13,000 times the length of the Milky Way), potentially making it the largest object in the universe in terms of length, beating out previous record-holders such as the Laniākea supercluster. The discovery was shared in a new paper posted on the preprint website ArXiv on Jan. 31. (The paper has not yet been published in a peer reviewed journal, but has been accepted by the journal Astronomy and Astrophysics.) "Quipu is actually a prominent structure readily noticeable by eye in a sky map of clusters in the target redshift range, without the help of a detection method," the team wrote in the paper. Related: James Webb Space Telescope smashes its own record to find the earliest galaxies that ever existed The research is part of a long-running effort to map the matter distribution of the universe at different wavelengths of light. Distant structures in the universe show a shift in their wavelengths toward the red part of the electromagnetic spectrum, a phenomenon known as redshift. While objects with a redshift of up to 0.3 have been well-mapped, the researchers focused the new study on redshifts of 0.3 to 0.6. The greater the redshift, the more distant the objects. The structures reported in the new study were all detected between roughly 425 million and 815 million light-years from Earth. Prior studies suggest that even larger structures exist deeper into the cosmos. The current contender for the largest structure in the universe is the Hercules Corona-Borealis Great Wall, a mysterious concentration of matter located roughly 10 billion light-years from Earth, and spanning an estimated 10 billion light-years across. However, the Great Wall's existence remains disputed. Quipu was the largest superstructure the researchers discovered in their datasets, but they also found four more giant structures. The smallest, the Shapley supercluster, was previously known as the largest superstructure ever discovered. It's now been eclipsed by Quipu, plus three others: The Serpens-Corona Borealis superstructure, the Hercules supercluster, and the Sculptor-Pegasus superstructure, which stretches between the two constellations that give it its name. Together, these five superstructures contain 45% of the galaxy clusters, 30% of the galaxies and 25% of the matter in the observable universe, the researchers reported in the paper. In total, they make up 13% of the universe's volume. The researchers also detected the ways that this matter affects the overall environment in the universe. The superstructures affect the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the microwave radiation left over from the Big Bang that's found uniformly across space. The researchers also discovered that the local velocity of these streams of galaxies affects measurements of the universe's overall expansion: Where the superstructures reign, the local expansion of galaxies can distort the measurement of the overall universe's expansion, known as the Hubble constant. Finally, the gravitational pull of so much matter can cause a bending of light known as gravitational lensing, which could distort images of the distant sky. RELATED STORIES —5 fascinating facts about the Big Bang, the theory that defines the history of the universe —The universe is expanding too fast for physics to explain —A cosmic 'CT scan' shows the universe is far more complex than expected Future research could examine how these large-scale structures have affected the evolution of galaxies, the researchers wrote. Though the structures are only temporary — the universe is always expanding, slowly pulling clusters apart — their sheer size makes them important. "In the future cosmic evolution, these superstructures are bound to break up into several collapsing units," the researchers wrote. "They are thus transient configurations. But at present they are special physical entities with characteristic properties and special cosmic environments deserving special attention."
