Chairman of Sheku Bayoh Inquiry decides against recusing himself
Mr Bayoh, 31, a father-of-two, died after he was restrained by around six police officers who were called to Hayfield Road in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on May 3 2015.
After considering the matter, Lord Bracadale has refused the application for his recusal.
In a decision published on Wednesday, he said: 'Having reviewed the facts, the fair-minded and informed observer would conclude that there was no real possibility that I was biased.'
He said such an observer would note that 'although the meetings with the families of Sheku Bayoh were private, they were not kept secret'.
The application for recusal of the chairman and assessors was lodged on behalf of the Scottish Police Federation, Pc Craig Walker and Nicole Short.
A spokeswoman for the inquiry said: 'The inquiry held a procedure and conduct hearing on June 12.
'After careful consideration of written and oral submissions from core participants, Lord Bracadale has decided not to recuse himself or terminate the appointments of the assessors.
'Having regard to the relevant legal test, he has determined there is no apparent bias.
'Taking into account various considerations in respect of the handling of the inquiry, he has determined having meetings with the families was not unfair.
'There is much important work for the inquiry still to do, not least proceeding with closing submissions and moving towards the writing of the final report. The team is working at pace and will announce next steps in due course.'
The inquiry has been examining the circumstances of Mr Bayoh's death, and whether race was a factor.
In a statement issued on behalf of the Bayoh family, lawyer Aamer Anwar said: 'Lord Bracadale, following an application by the Scottish Police Federation, PCs Craig Walker and Nicole Short to recuse himself and to terminate the appointments of the assessors Raju Bhatt and Michael Fuller, has refused to do so – he has delivered a humiliating and devastating indictment not just on the Federation but also the Solicitor General and Police Scotland.
'Despite their desperate claims, the chair Lord Bracadale has done nothing wrong, he is a judge with over 50 years' legal experience, respected for his impartiality and integrity.
'It comes as no surprise that both the Police Federation and Solicitor General failed to grasp that this inquiry's duty under the Human Rights Act is to conduct a thorough investigation into the death of Sheku Bayoh, having at the inquiry's heart the Bayoh family.
'There is nothing wrong with the chair treating a bereaved family with compassion and respect.'
Scotland's Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes said: 'I note the detailed and extensive consideration that has informed Lord Bracadale's decision and hope all parties involved can progress the important work of the inquiry as soon as possible.
'The Scottish Government remains committed to establishing the facts surrounding the circumstances leading to Mr Bayoh's death.
'However, as it is vital all public inquiries operate independently of government, it would be inappropriate of me to comment any further.'
A spokesperson for the Scottish Police Federation said: 'Any fair-minded observer would be concerned when it is revealed that there have been five meetings with a core participant family, without the knowledge of the other core participants.
'The inquiry's legal team asserted that no evidence was discussed at these meetings, it subsequently transpired that was not the case.
'Lord Bracadale has never asked for a meeting with former Pc Nicole Short, who was assaulted in May 2015 in the line of duty and who has been unable to return to work as a result of her injuries.
'Police officers will continue to call for a fair and transparent hearing, based on the evidence alone.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
4 hours ago
- The National
Body of man recovered from water in Perth after major search
Emergency services were called to a report of three men in the water in Perth at about 7.45pm on Thursday. Two men were traced and were checked over by the Scottish Ambulance Service. Searches continued at Moncrieffe Island in the area on Friday, and police confirmed the body of a man was found shortly after 7pm. Police said enquiries are ongoing to establish the identity of the man. READ MORE: Tributes pour in following death of Scottish comedian Gary Little A Police Scotland spokesperson said: "The body of a man has been recovered following searches in the water it the Moncreiffe Island area of Perth. "Emergency services remain in attendance and enquiries are ongoing to establish the identity of the man." Police, mountain rescue, the air support unit and Scottish Fire and Rescue Service were among those involved in the search. Tay Street has been closed in both directions, from Marshall Place to Canal Street, for motorists and pedestrians.
The National
5 hours ago
- The National
Ian Blackford's decision signals the rise of a new generation
FORMER SNP Westminster leader Ian Blackford, who announced in June 2023 that he did not intend to stand for reelection to his Ross, Skye, and Lochaber seat at the 2024 Westminster General Election following his replacement as Westminster leader by Aberdeen South MP Stephen Flynn in December 2022, recently raised some eyebrows by announcing that he was giving "careful consideration" to making a return to frontline politics and standing as a candidate in next year's Holyrood election. He said that he had had calls from supporters urging him to stand in the constituency of Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch after its current MSP – Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes – announced she will be standing down. But in a post on social media on Thursday evening, Blackford said that while he was "grateful" for these calls, he had "reflected carefully" and decided after all that he is not going to stand. However, he clarified that he was not ruling out a return to frontline politics in the future. He wrote: "With Kate Forbes having announced she would not be contesting the seat of Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch at the Scottish Parliament in 2026, I have received many promptings to potentially represent the SNP in the election next year. "I am very grateful to all those who have encouraged me to step forward for the 2026 election. I was particularly minded that many of those prompting me were those I have campaigned with for many years – people I have the highest respect for and who I hold very dearly. "It was out of a deep respect to all of these people that, although I had previously stated that I would not stand for the Scottish Parliament, I decided to give due consideration to those requests." Blackford went on to say that he was "honoured" to have been asked to stand and that "I do not take lightly the responsibility that they all encouraged me to take on". He added: "Having reflected carefully I have concluded that I will not present my name as a potential candidate for the 2026 election." "I do believe that I am still of an age that I can serve my party and my country. "I joined the SNP as a teenager in the 1970's and I see the journey to independence as being very much unfinished business. I will support the SNP and its leader, my old friend and colleague John Swinney, to the full. "My firm judgement is that the UK is not far off another financial crisis that would be cataclysmic. In short – Britain is broken.' Blackford went on to call on his SNP colleagues to explore "how we can make Scotland a safe haven" through independence. "Working with others I do want to participate in that debate on our future and perhaps, in the time ahead, there may be future opportunities to return to front line politics. "On this occasion though – after careful consideration – I will not be putting my name forward for next year's Scottish parliament elections. "The opportunity and the privilege of seeking to represent this Highland's seat at the Scottish Parliament will fall to another and we are fortunate to have a range of capable candidates in the SNP. "Whomever my party chooses, they will have my full support in what I am confident will be a successful election for the SNP under the leadership of John Swinney." Blackford's decision not to stand again signals an important milestone in the history of the SNP, and the rise of a new generation of younger politicians who grew up in the era of devolution and who have always known the existence of a Scottish Parliament. This generation of people in their 30s take it for granted that Scotland should become an independent country. It is already the settled will of this generation of Scots, and as they gradually replace older generations in the electorate, people who are far more doubtful and fearful of independence, a desire for independence will gradually become the settled will of the people of Scotland as a whole. This is a generation which needs a different approach to Scottish independence. Unlike previous generations, millennials and Gen Z do not need to be persuaded of the viability of an independent Scotland, they need to be persuaded of a plausible route to get there. That's going to take a younger generation of politicians who are prepared to be more confrontational in the face of Westminster's constitutional roadblocks. Talking of constitutional roadblocks... Talking of constitutional roadblocks, or possibly constitutional road bollocks, Scottish Tory MSP Craig Hoy, a man who has never allowed the inconvenient fact that the Conservatives have not won an election in Scotland in his lifetime get in the way of his petulant entitlement, has written to the Permanent Secretary to the Scottish Government, Joe Griffin. He has demanded that former first minister Nicola Sturgeon be investigated for what Hoy insists was a breach of the ministerial code by asking the UK Supreme Court whether her government could hold the independence referendum which it had received a mandate to hold from the people of Scotland in the May 2021 Holyrood election, which Hoy's party fought on opposition to another independence referendum and which it lost badly. In his letter, Hoy, who clearly has a problem accepting the verdict of the Scottish electorate, highlighted two parts of the code in a bid to back up his dubious argument, which the parts which state that ministers 'must not use public resources for party political purposes' and should 'ensure their decisions are informed by appropriate analysis of the legal considerations and that the legal implications of any course of action are considered at the earliest opportunity.' But the Scottish Government has said the reference to the Supreme Court was 'entirely appropriate'. A spokesperson said: 'The reference of this question to the Supreme Court was entirely appropriate and intended to achieve legal clarity over whether the Scottish Parliament had the legislative powers to hold an independence referendum, in light of majority support within the Parliament for a referendum. It did that.'
The National
5 hours ago
- The National
Inside the Scottish media row at Nicola Sturgeon's book launch
But when it came to facing the Scottish press following her book launch on Thursday, she and her team left a sour taste in the mouths of many journalists. I was among a pack of print journalists who turned up as instructed to a room inside the Edinburgh Futures Institute. When I arrived, I was told to 'hover with intent' by a press officer as the broadcast journalists would be questioning the former first minister first, followed by a print huddle. I was happy to wait, though I did feel confused as normally the print journalists would listen in to the broadcast interviews for any news lines that would later come out anyway. READ MORE: Robin McAlpine: Why I won't be reading Nicola Sturgeon's book As others joined me outside room 2.35, one of the journalists from The Sun emerged from the room to say we could go in. Happy days. But as we all sat next to our broadcast colleagues, print journalists were then asked to leave the room, which sparked a bit of a row. One by one reporters began to make their case this was the way we always did things, and Sturgeon had witnessed it many times before. One broadcast journalist stuck up for us and explained we were not about to get in the way or interject in their interviews, we would just be staying quiet and listening in before getting our turn to ask questions, which is standard procedure. She was more than happy to accommodate it and no one else argued. So, no issues right? But we were told repeatedly this was the way it had to be, while being given little explanation as to why. The main argument seemed to be that Sturgeon was short on time. Surely though we would be saving time if we listened into the broadcast questions, so as not to repeat them? No? No. The press officer duly left huffing and puffing before Sturgeon herself emerged to announce this would now be a 'combined huddle' of broadcast and print, and she would only have time to take the odd question from print after broadcasters. READ MORE: Scottish Government hits back at Tory MSP over Nicola Sturgeon memoir claims In more than three years of working for The National, I had never come across such an arrangement, because it simply doesn't work, particularly when there is a clock to contend with. With bulky camera equipment set up, it is very difficult for print journalists to catch the attention of the interviewee as they struggle for space, so the result was that two or three print journalists got a question in, despite several more being present. I should add that the broadcast journalists were also promised one-to-one time with Sturgeon but did not receive it after she turned up late. In the end, all the papers and broadcasters in Scotland got a grand total of 14 minutes with Sturgeon, who seemed ready to leave before she arrived. She gave very short answers to questions and kept wanting to move on, saying things like 'next question'. It felt like she was telling us she didn't want to be there and we were wasting her time. So, when you're watching clips of Sturgeon this week from STV or Sky News or LBC, now you know what really happened the other side of the cameras.
