Steve Martin: Green hydrogen can't solve WA's impending energy woes
When the Premier announced a new Energy Minister in March, we were optimistic Amber-Jade Sanderson would bring a fresh and practical approach and a practical and responsible view to the energy debate.
For far too long the State Government has been talking big about the upcoming energy transition but delivering mighty small.
In an
opinion piece in The West
this month, Ms Sanderson said her 'job is supporting our heavy industry to decarbonise to meet national emissions targets'.That is only one part of her job and not her first and most important responsibility.
Her first job is to keep the lights on and power running to all the houses, businesses and heavy industries that need it, and to do it at a cost that householders, businesses, and industries can afford.
The Government's lack of a clear and coherent energy plan means they are on their way to failing their first responsibility.
Fortunately for all West Australians, the Energy Minister admitted that gas was needed as a transition fuel.
It was good to see Premier Roger Cook also support gas as an export commodity that can reduce emissions overseas and in turn resist a 2030 State target.
The bad part was the reinforcement of the Government position that they are relying on green hydrogen to save their bacon.
As reported by The West in May, a competitive target price for green hydrogen would be $2 per kilogram, but a trial running in WA, partially funded by taxpayers, is producing the hydrogen at $24.50 a kilo.
With a price 10 times the competitive rate, it is no wonder green hydrogen projects are being abandoned at a rapid rate.
In the State Government's other trial of green hydrogen in Denham last year, it turned out it took 379,503 kWh of wind energy to be converted into 1,422kg of hydrogen, which was then converted back into a tiny 16,044 kWh of electricity being returned to the grid.
In other words, a paltry 4 per cent of the energy used to make green hydrogen made it into the grid as electricity. They would have been 96 per cent better off just transmitting the power straight from wind turbines into the grid.
If the Labor Party is relying on green hydrogen to save the day, I suggest we all start cutting and storing firewood and buying matches.
The State Government's current energy plan simply won't work. It is underfunded, and about to run out of time.
There is not enough generation, distribution, or storage in the current Government plan to fulfil its first and primary obligation of providing enough affordable energy for homes and businesses.
The real danger is energy prices are about to rise and rise dramatically.
WA has been somewhat insulated from power price rises compared to the eastern States, but we are about to start catching up.
Businesses are the Government's first targets, with new contracts in Synergy's contestable markets seeing price increases of 25 to 45 per cent on total power bills.
This is the first sign that the system is broken and not being fixed.
Households have been protected from this pain, so far, but you shouldn't expect that will last.
The mismanagement of the power system in this State means taxpayers are subsidising
it to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars every year.
While being hit with regular ongoing price increases, households have been hidden from the real pain of major price increases. But that cannot last, especially if green hydrogen is the proposed solution to the problem.
The State Government needs to find real, practical energy solutions, otherwise families will start to feel the pain that businesses have been suffering the last few years.
Steve Martin is the shadow energy minister
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
5 hours ago
- West Australian
Steve Martin: Green hydrogen can't solve WA's impending energy woes
When the Premier announced a new Energy Minister in March, we were optimistic Amber-Jade Sanderson would bring a fresh and practical approach and a practical and responsible view to the energy debate. For far too long the State Government has been talking big about the upcoming energy transition but delivering mighty small. In an opinion piece in The West this month, Ms Sanderson said her 'job is supporting our heavy industry to decarbonise to meet national emissions targets'.That is only one part of her job and not her first and most important responsibility. Her first job is to keep the lights on and power running to all the houses, businesses and heavy industries that need it, and to do it at a cost that householders, businesses, and industries can afford. The Government's lack of a clear and coherent energy plan means they are on their way to failing their first responsibility. Fortunately for all West Australians, the Energy Minister admitted that gas was needed as a transition fuel. It was good to see Premier Roger Cook also support gas as an export commodity that can reduce emissions overseas and in turn resist a 2030 State target. The bad part was the reinforcement of the Government position that they are relying on green hydrogen to save their bacon. As reported by The West in May, a competitive target price for green hydrogen would be $2 per kilogram, but a trial running in WA, partially funded by taxpayers, is producing the hydrogen at $24.50 a kilo. With a price 10 times the competitive rate, it is no wonder green hydrogen projects are being abandoned at a rapid rate. In the State Government's other trial of green hydrogen in Denham last year, it turned out it took 379,503 kWh of wind energy to be converted into 1,422kg of hydrogen, which was then converted back into a tiny 16,044 kWh of electricity being returned to the grid. In other words, a paltry 4 per cent of the energy used to make green hydrogen made it into the grid as electricity. They would have been 96 per cent better off just transmitting the power straight from wind turbines into the grid. If the Labor Party is relying on green hydrogen to save the day, I suggest we all start cutting and storing firewood and buying matches. The State Government's current energy plan simply won't work. It is underfunded, and about to run out of time. There is not enough generation, distribution, or storage in the current Government plan to fulfil its first and primary obligation of providing enough affordable energy for homes and businesses. The real danger is energy prices are about to rise and rise dramatically. WA has been somewhat insulated from power price rises compared to the eastern States, but we are about to start catching up. Businesses are the Government's first targets, with new contracts in Synergy's contestable markets seeing price increases of 25 to 45 per cent on total power bills. This is the first sign that the system is broken and not being fixed. Households have been protected from this pain, so far, but you shouldn't expect that will last. The mismanagement of the power system in this State means taxpayers are subsidising it to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars every year. While being hit with regular ongoing price increases, households have been hidden from the real pain of major price increases. But that cannot last, especially if green hydrogen is the proposed solution to the problem. The State Government needs to find real, practical energy solutions, otherwise families will start to feel the pain that businesses have been suffering the last few years. Steve Martin is the shadow energy minister
West Australian
a day ago
- West Australian
Editorial: There are simply not enough people to do all the jobs WA's economy needs to fill
It's a staggering list — 62 professions in WA have been experiencing a skills shortage for at least the past four years. The Jobs and Skills Australia figures reflect what businesses for some time have been saying — and what many West Australians have been experiencing: there are simply not enough people to do all the jobs our economy needs doing. WA's underemployment rate — a measure of people who are working but would like more hours — has consistently been among the lowest of all States for several years, despite us having the strongest population growth for the past two years. Premier Roger Cook has rightly been concerned. Having written to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese outlining 10 key priorities for WA, he's urged his Federal counterparts to excuse WA from broad-brush national rules clamping down on international migration, particularly affecting students. Though critics of migration like to blame it for myriad issues, the simple fact of the matter is WA has not experienced the same problems as Eastern States. International education is a $3.6 billion contributor to the State's economy, but some providers are on their knees, with enrolments plunging after visa fees surged. The result for ordinary West Australians? Fewer people doing the jobs we need done, particularly in the hospitality sector, but fewer people studying in WA and potentially staying, adding to the State's rich culture and making valuable contributions. Aged care is another critical sector facing worker shortages, and with an ageing population, demand is set to keep climbing. Australia — particularly WA — does not have enough people working to service its population. As StudyWest chief executive Derryn Belford has told The Sunday Times: 'If we didn't have international students there are whole sectors that would have no workers.' Western Australia desperately needs the Federal Government to exempt it from blanket national rules restricting international student numbers — and more support on migration caps. It's a blatant impediment to our economy, restricting employers and in turn a handbrake on consumers. Yes, the State is experiencing a housing shortage. But it's not been caused by international students. The State Government has pushed the construction of dedicated student housing, particularly in the CBD, and these go some way to help. And for skilled workers, many companies have shown ingenious solutions to accommodating staff — particularly in regional areas. Construction alone expects to need up to 10,000 more workers every year. If our borders are not opened, where are they to come from? Housing Industry Association WA executive director Michael McGowan expects about three-quarters of the new workforce would need to come through apprenticeships. The rest need to be skilled migrants who can start immediately. By carving our State out of a blunt national rule, the Government would prove it actually 'gets' WA and allow our State to keep moving forward.
West Australian
a day ago
- West Australian
BEN HARVEY: Why Rita Saffioti's the human punchline
Rita Saffioti, you are weak as p***. The writing was on the wall that bare-knuckle boxing was politically poisonous but you didn't have the guts to use your power as Sports Minister to veto it. Instead, you let the Combat Sports Commission do your dirty work by putting a last-minute kybosh on the Bare Knuckle Boxing Championship event. You were the only person who wanted this thing to happen, Rita. For weeks you failed to read the room, insisting community concern was a storm in a teacup that would blow over when West Australians realised just how much fun it was watching two people bash each other the way nature intended. You knew best. Perhaps it was because eight years ago you stared down those opposed to cage fighting. Perhaps it was because, having represented the good burghers of West Swan for so long, you know a thing or two about punch-ups. You refused to intervene even when it emerged that a former bikie who went to jail for bashing a police informant was being considered for the card. His opponent? A British reality TV 'star' called Aaron Chalmers who, presumably, decided that having his head punched in was worth it because it gave him the requisite brain damage for another season on Geordie Shore. 'The advice to me is that with very strict protocols and criteria that the event, if the organiser were to meet that, that it could be conducted in WA,' you said. In making it clear you were a woman not for turning you made the entire Cabinet look like hapless idiots. Why buy tickets to Cirque du Soleil when you can watch Meredith Hammat contorting herself while dodging questions about how a health minister could endorse what the Australian Medical Association was calling a blood sport. If it was up to the AMA the most dangerous sport in WA would be Ring a Ring o' Roses (perhaps accompanied by someone playing the lute) so we don't want to be led by the nose by medicos, but still. Your government, which adhered slavishly to medical advice during COVID, was very quick to discount the opinion of doctors on this one. I hope you apologised to Meredith for making her look such a fool. You owe Paul Papalia a beer as well. He didn't hesitate in going over the top for you, making out that bare-knuckle boxing was something the Famous Five might indulge in, refreshing themselves with lashings of ginger beer between bouts. At least Paul sounded like he believed what he was saying. Perhaps his performance was compelling because he was a navy clearance diver before politics. Let's face it, anyone who swims towards the bomb has a unique appreciation of risk. Rita, so terrified are ministers of your wrath in Budget expenditure review committee meetings, they would have built a Thunderdome in your honour. Two men enter, one man leaves, they would have chanted, had you asked. You took advantage of their pathetic weakness and insisted they back your absurd rationale that the Combat Sports Commission could never be questioned. It's not the bloody Roman Senate, Rita; it's sports administration. 'I can't stop one and then not stop others,' you said, hinting that your ministerial override risked the fall of the Westminster system. It was only when the July 19 card was confirmed that you appeared to have realised there might be a political problem. It turns out there is something as bad as a former bikie who bashed a police informant being the star of the show. Alex 'Godly Strong' is a 140kg, 195cm meat-axe who went to prison for bashing a drug dealer during an aggravated home invasion. It was a bridge too far. Labor had ceded the moral high ground to Basil Zempilas and was enjoying what must have been a novel view. Everyone knew the wound needed to be cauterised. But still you refused to act. And now you're asking us to believe that at the last minute the Combat Sports Commission 'independently' arrived at the conclusion that this show could not go on. The same commission whose chair, Bob Kucera, had been so enthusiastic about this event he was practically humming Eye of the Tiger. This was a contest between 'superb athletes', Bob told us a couple of weeks ago. Strict medical conditions had to be met before anyone could step in the ring, he said. And it was best to have these kind of events held out in the open, otherwise bare-knuckle fighting might go underground, the former cop warned ominously. Bob even managed to keep a straight face when he said that last one. I was waiting for him to gush, 'I would like to thank the Academy' at the end of each interview. He was so convincing the promoters started selling tickets to the fight! Bob had your back, Rita. And you hung him out to dry. You made him look like a stooge. Does anyone believe that there was no political pressure here? That nobody in the executive arm of government had a quiet word to the commission about the need to somehow get the shit back in the horse? That there were no phone calls asking that the commission take one for the team? Bull****. I can't imagine what the atmosphere was like in the State Solicitor's Office when the commission knocked back the event application. Did someone at least give them the heads-up that we were about to pick a legal fight with Conor McGregor, the man who owns Bare Knuckle Fighting Championship? Rita, do you have any idea how wealthy this bloke is? He earnt $US130 million in one fight against Floyd Mayweather, for the love of God. The only people richer than Conor are his lawyers. We were worried about Clive Palmer's lawsuit bankrupting us; wait for this costs order! Rita, I know that you didn't initiate this mess. That was your predecessor, David Templeman. David should never have recognised bare-knuckle fighting as a sport when the application was made prior to the last State election. He should have understood the politics but was probably distracted by the excitement of delivering his last end-of-year serenade to the Legislative Assembly. You, on the other hand, Rita, should have known better. You're no political fool. There's no excuse for allowing this public policy absurdity to run for so long.
