Judge orders LA prosecutors to explain why Menendez brothers' conviction shouldn't be re-examined
LOS ANGELES — A judge has ordered Los Angeles prosecutors to explain why Erik and Lyle Menendez's murder convictions should not be re-examined in light of new evidence supporting their claims of sexual abuse by their father.
The July 7 order by LA County Superior Court Judge William Ryan was in response to a habeas corpus petition filed by the Menendez brothers in May 2023 seeking a review of their 1996 convictions for the killings of their parents based on new evidence.
The brothers were convicted of murdering their father, Jose Menendez — a powerful record executive — and their mother, Kitty Menendez, in their Beverly Hills home in 1989. While defense attorneys argued the brothers acted out of self-defense after years of sexual abuse by their father, prosecutors said the brothers killed their parents for a multimillion-dollar inheritance.
Their first trials resulted in hung juries. At the second trial for both brothers, the judge excluded a substantial amount of evidence, including testimony from several family members who witnessed or heard about the abuse. The brothers were convicted and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
In May, a judge reduced their sentences to 50 years to life in response to a resentencing petition, making them eligible for parole. They will appear before the state parole board in August.
The new evidence included a newly discovered letter from Erik Menendez to his cousin Andy Cano in which he describes being abused by his father, and a declaration from Menudo boy band member Roy Rossello that he was raped by Jose Menendez in the 1980s.
While prosecutors argued that the evidence was untimely and inadmissible, Ryan sided with the Menendez brothers, saying they had provided sufficient proof of why the evidence could have changed the outcome of their convictions.
The Los Angeles County District Attorney's office now has 30 days to explain why the brothers should not be granted habeas corpus relief.
There are several possible outcomes if the judge grants relief, including reduced sentences, a new trial, or even release from prison.
Jaimie Ding, The Associated Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Atlanta stylist's social media restored after she says Meta mistakenly flagged her name for terrorist organization connection
Isis Aguilar, who has been in the hair industry for five years, said her name — which is also used by a terrorist organization — was the likely trigger for the shutdown. (WXIA via CNN Newsource) ATLANTA (WXIA) - An Atlanta hairstylist said she nearly lost her livelihood when Meta abruptly shut down her social media accounts, citing rules against 'dangerous individuals and organizations.' Isis Aguilar, who has been in the hair industry for five years, said her name — which is also used by a terrorist organization — was the likely trigger for the shutdown. Social media, she explained, is her primary way of booking clients and promoting her salon. 'I was just really overwhelmed, because that's how I make my living,' Aguilar said. 'My gut reaction was, 'Oh my God, my name is causing a problem again.' Common sense tells you it's still a beautiful name, but it's associated with a terrorist organization.' Last Thursday, without warning, Aguilar's business and personal accounts vanished. Meta cited a violation of its community standards on dangerous individuals and organizations. She said the move left her with no way to contact her clients and no means to appeal directly to a representative. 'It feels hopeless because there's no phone number to call, there's not a rep. They don't give you a warning,' she said. After days of unsuccessful appeals, Aguilar reached out to 11Alive's Angelina Salcedo. Hours after we contacted Meta, Aguilar's accounts were reinstated. 'Oh, my God, how did you do that?' she exclaimed on camera when she saw her pages restored. 'It almost got taken away from me. It's crazy. Thank you so, so much.' Meta later told 11Alive the account deactivation was a mistake. The company did not respond to questions about whether Aguilar had been targeted or reported. Aguilar said the experience left her feeling small against 'huge' tech companies. 'You do feel little, and that your voice isn't heard,' she said. 'But today, it finally was.' By Angelina Salcedo.
Globe and Mail
2 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. Advocates for Families After Fatal Car Crashes
Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. ( is addressing the legal and emotional toll that follows fatal car accidents by guiding families with the support of a Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorney. In Pennsylvania, wrongful death claims provide a legal path for surviving family members to recover compensation and seek justice when a loved one is lost due to another driver's negligence. A Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorney can help families understand their rights and secure financial stability after an unexpected tragedy. The laws in Pennsylvania are clear that when a fatal car accident is caused by reckless or negligent driving, a wrongful death claim may be pursued. According to the article, common forms of negligence include drunk driving, distracted driving, speeding, unsafe lane changes, and driver fatigue. A Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorney plays a critical role in identifying whether negligence occurred and what legal action can be taken. Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. emphasizes the importance of timely legal action, given that Pennsylvania law enforces a two-year statute of limitations from the date of death. Attorney Lawrence M. Kelly of Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. brings decades of litigation experience to wrongful death cases. As a Board-Certified Civil Trial Advocate and President of the Pennsylvania Association for Justice, his leadership and dedication are well documented. Attorney Kelly has been recognized among the Top 50: Pittsburgh Super Lawyers from 2019 to 2024 and has been selected for inclusion in Pennsylvania Super Lawyers since 2006. These acknowledgments reflect his record of handling serious cases on behalf of grieving families. For those who need a Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorney, Attorney Kelly stands as a consistent advocate. Joseph A. George, also with Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C., is known for his compassion and strong representation in wrongful death matters. His membership in the Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association and the American Association for Justice supports his long-standing dedication to helping those facing loss. As another seasoned Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorney, Attorney George helps families understand the steps involved in filing a wrongful death claim, especially when navigating emotional and financial challenges. Wrongful death lawsuits must be filed by the personal representative of the deceased's estate. This individual may be named in the will or appointed by the court. If no action is taken within six months of death, Pennsylvania law allows any eligible family member, such as a spouse, child, or parent, to file a claim. Compensation is then distributed to the legally recognized beneficiaries, typically including spouses, children (biological or adopted), and parents. Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorneys like Lawrence M. Kelly and Joseph A. George guide families through this process with clarity and support. Economic and emotional damages are both considered in a wrongful death case. Families may recover funeral expenses, medical costs, lost income, and damages for grief and lost companionship. When applicable, a separate survival action may be filed to recover for the deceased's pain and suffering from the time of injury until death. The article explains, 'It is critical to understand that proceeds from a wrongful death action are paid directly to the beneficiaries and are protected from the deceased's creditors and inheritance taxes.' This distinction is essential in planning how to handle compensation and safeguard the estate. To build a strong case, families must demonstrate fault on the part of the other driver. This often involves collecting police reports, eyewitness testimony, physical evidence, black box data, cell phone records, and video footage. Attorneys work to secure and preserve these elements quickly, as evidence can be lost or destroyed in the days and weeks following an accident. Vehicle black boxes, dashcam footage, and physical crash site indicators may be essential in proving that the driver's negligence caused the fatal crash. Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. emphasizes acting quickly after a fatal accident to protect a family's legal rights. Insurance companies often begin investigations immediately, and key evidence can be lost if steps are not taken promptly. By reaching out to a Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorney shortly after the accident, families improve their chances of a successful claim and reduce the risk of missed opportunities for compensation. Fatal car accidents leave behind emotional and financial scars that can impact families for years. A wrongful death claim offers one avenue for seeking accountability and financial support. The legal team at Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C., led by attorneys Lawrence M. Kelly and Joseph A. George, works to provide clear legal guidance during these difficult times. Their role as Western Pennsylvania wrongful death attorneys is to help families move forward while honoring the memory of their loved one. Families affected by a fatal car accident are encouraged to contact Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. for a free consultation. Legal support can make a meaningful difference in securing justice and restoring financial stability. The firm's commitment to Western Pennsylvania communities continues to support families navigating the aftermath of wrongful deaths due to car accidents. About Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C.: Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George P.C. is a Pennsylvania law firm with a strong focus on helping families affected by serious injury and wrongful death. With decades of courtroom experience and a deep understanding of state laws, the firm provides legal representation to those seeking justice after catastrophic events. The attorneys at LGKG are committed to supporting their clients and achieving meaningful results. Embeds: Youtube Video: GMB: Email and website Email: lmkelly@ Website:
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Man arrested in murder of 11-year-old Trudy Appleby, who disappeared in 1996 in Moline, Illinois
Trudy Appleby was last seen on Aug. 21, 1996 near her home in Moline. (National Center for Missing and Exploited Children/WBBM via CNN Newsource) Warning: The following story contains graphic details. Illinois (WBBM) - Nearly 30 years after an 11-year-old girl disappeared in her hometown in western Illinois, a man has been charged with her murder. Trudy Appleby was last seen on Aug. 21, 1996 near her home in Moline. Moline Police Chief Darren Gault said witnesses saw her getting into a gray vehicle with an unidentified man. That day, she had asked to go swimming with a friend, but her father had said no, and Gault said phone records indicate she went ahead anyway, then disappeared On Wednesday, a Henry County grand jury indicted 50-year-old Jamison Fisher on three counts of first-degree murder and one count of concealment of a homicidal death, according to Henry County State's Attorney Catherine Runty. Fisher is accused of kidnapping and strangling Trudy, and concealing her death. Trudy's body has yet to be found. Police and prosecutors said Fisher does not face kidnapping charges because the statute of limitations has expired. Gault said Fisher was already in custody in Iowa on unrelated charges when he was arrested after the indictment. He will remain in jail in Iowa pending court proceedings in Illinois. Jamison Fisher Fisher is accused of kidnapping and strangling Trudy, and concealing her death. (Scott County, Iowa/WBBM via CNN Newsource) 'Today is not about celebration, it's about a resolution, it's about accountability, and most importantly, it's about Trudy Appleby. This arrest does not erase the pain, but it does bring us one step closer to closure. We hope it offers a measure of peace to her family and to all of those who have walked this journey with them,' Gault said. Moline police first identified Fisher as a person of interest in the case in 2020, along with another man who has since died. Gault said Fisher was a family friend and associate of a third suspect, who died in 2014. Gault said Trudy's family had mixed emotions when they learned of Fisher's arrest. 'This doesn't bring Trudy back, but it's a relief, and they've certainly earned it,' he said. By Todd Feurer.
